Green Arrow's 10 Greatest Failures
The Emerald Archer has failed more than just his city during his crusades against all that is evil.
With his unique sense of humor in the face of overwhelming odds, a quiver full of bizarre trick arrows, and the ability to endure suffering and pain across the multiverse, the hero known as Green Arrow has delighted audiences around the world for well over 80 years.
The Emerald Archer has slowly become more popular over the years, thanks in no small part to the character's TV universe-spawning show Arrow, and his prior appearances in the hit CW show Smallville.
Star City's protector has become just as popular in mainstream media as Marvel counterpart Hawkeye and has earned his place in the multiverse as a hero and self-proclaimed social justice warrior, fighting for the little guy both as the hero Green Arrow and as the multi-billionaire philanthropist Oliver Queen.
Yet even with a seemingly endless reserve of resources and several powerful teammates by his side, the Emerald Archer's career as a crime fighter has no shortage of devastating failures.
From completely failing the people closest to him, dying from somewhat stupid reasons, or just getting completely destroyed while fighting against the diverse members of his rogue gallery, these entries are just a few of the robin hood-inspired heroes' most devastating failures.
10. Broken By Komodo - The Kill Machine
Komodo, aka Simon Lacroix, was a man who dragged himself from poverty into a respectable position at Queen Industries. Lacroix's determination and perseverance impressed Queen Industries CEO Robert Queen so much that Robert actually viewed Lacroix as a better son to him than Oliver was.
During "The Kill Machine". Lacroix returned to Star City with a plan to completely destroy the Green Arrow and prove that he is not only worthy of Queen Industries but Star City as well. He ended up taking all of Oliver Queen's fortune for himself and framing the Emerald Archer for murdering then CEO of Queen Industries, Walter Emerson.
As if that wasn't bad enough, Lacroix then made sure Oliver witnessed one of his safehouses explode, with two of his closest friends inside.
When Lacroix finally confronted Olie face to face, he revealed that he was well aware of nearly all of his secret stashes, including the ones that held many of Oliver's famous trick arrows.
Komodo proved himself to be an even better archer than Oliver was, and at the end of their first fight, the Green Arrow was trapped by a cement arrow and nearly beaten to death by the villain.
9. Abandoned Speedy To His Addiction - Snowbirds Don't Fly
Comic books don't tend to shy away from real-world problems. Many embrace issues across the board that we normal humans have to deal with on our own.
For the Green Arrow, a massive issue came in the form of his partner and protege, Speedy, who ended up forming a heroin addiction. Speedy even sold several of Oliver's own arrows to junkies in order to score more of the highly dangerous and addictive drug.
Those arrows ended up being used on Star City's protector, severely wounding him, and all because Oliver went on a cross-country road trip with his best pal in spandex, the Green Lantern.
By leaving Speedy alone and unsupervised, Oliver allowed his partner and young ward to become an addict. This specific story put the character of the Green Arrow back on the map, showing that the hero and his writers were willing to deal with all kinds of hard-hitting issues that affect people across the world.
However, this story is also one of Ollie's greatest failures as a mentor, friend, father figure, and hero to those in need.
8. Accidentally Created Racist Police Drones - The Nightbirds
Green Arrow has always declared itself as a comic series that focuses on many sociopolitical issues with an extreme left-wing view of the world. This is represented in Oliver, whose personal politics have been mostly left-leaning ever since the '70s.
So of course, it was inevitable that a storyline about white police officers committing extremely prejudiced actions against marginalized communities, especially African Americans, was going to come up.
In the storyline known as "The Nightbirds," the hooded hero returned to the city of Seattle where he learned that people from lower-income parts of the city were mysteriously vanishing at an alarming rate.
In order to help protect the people of Seattle, Oliver Queen helps finance the Seattle police force in creating an army of police drones that can sense the "crime threat" in someone before they actually commit a crime.
But during the creation of these drones, it turned out that the man who created their original algorithm, Aaron Zimm, was actually a white supremacist, so the drones ended up "predicting" that a lot of African American men were going to commit crimes.
Olie eventually destroyed all the drones and brutally murdered the two men responsible for their drones' racially biased massacres. However, he still helped fund the drones which led to the deaths of dozens of black men.
Though he intended well, the Robin Hood-inspired hero still failed those innocent men in the worst way imaginable for a supposed hero.
7. Agreed To Wipe Doctor Light's Memory - Heading Into The Light
Identity Crisis was an extremely divisive DC comic event that tried to shake up the core of what it meant to be a superhero. Essentially the plot breaks down into a simple choice several Justice League members made in regards to the villain Doctor Light. He had learned the identities of the Justice League, as well as their loved ones, and threatened unspeakable acts if he ever escaped.
This forced the heroes to use magic in order to wipe the memory of Doctor Light and several members of the Secret Society of Super-Villains. They also wiped Batman's memory, who was incredibly against the abuse of magic to wipe someone's memory and alter their personality.
The consequences for wiping Light's mind came to a head in the post-Identity Crisis story, "Heading Into the Light." During this, Doctor Light regained his memories and targeted Green Arrow, beating him up and taking the hero hostage in order to draw in not only Speedy but his new teammates the Teen Titans.
The conflict grew so large that every single hero who had ever been a Titan appeared to save Oliver. However, other than Cyborg, they were all brutally defeated by Doctor Light's powers, and Ollie could only sit there and watch as an action he took led to others not even involved in Identity Crisis getting severely hurt.
6. Chose To Die Rather Than Be Disarmed - Run Of The Arrow
Death is never the end of comic characters, but it nevertheless is an impactful moment for readers, creators, and characters anytime a hero goes down fighting the good fight. For Green Arrow, however, one of his earliest deaths in the comics was less than glorious.
During the storyline "Run of the Arrow" Oliver decides to go undercover inside an eco-terrorism cell. As usual, the billionaire playboy fell in love with the leader of the group and realized too late that they designed a bacteria that eats all plastics, including the plaster used for constructing buildings.
The terrorists were set to take off in a plane towards their first target, Metropolis. A firefight ensues, wounding Oliver who placed his hand inside the trigger mechanism.
This turns out to be a huge mistake, and the world's greatest archer becomes trapped. Bleeding out and losing consciousness, Olie seems a goner until Superman burst through the door and quickly assesses the situation. It becomes quite clear that a decision needs to be made.
Either Superman cuts his arm off and saves him, or blows up the plane with the archer still inside. Both plans save the city, but Ollie felt that there was no way his arm could possibly be replaced after removal, so he chooses self-sacrifice and goes up in flames with the airplane.
His death is rather selfish overall, as he hurts those closest to him by believing his skill as an archer was more important than his life.
5. Allowed Harley Quinn To Escape - Injustice: Year One
The comics of the Injustice universe focus on the years immediately following the tragic murder of Lois Lane by a drugged Superman, cataloging every attempt by Batman's resistance to prevent the complete global takeover by the Man of Steel.
In the first year of the Injustice storyline, almost immediately after the Joker's murder, Oliver Queen tracks down and arrests Harley Quinn, who was able to escape since all attention was on her clown prince. Harley's arrest is difficult, but eventually, she is taken to Arkham Asylum for both her and Oliver's safety.
Yet right as Ollie brings Harley into the Asylum, several other heroes are there fighting over whether or not Superman should be allowed to mercilessly slaughter every single inmate. The self-proclaimed social justice warrior leaves Harley alone with a single guard to try and diffuse the situation. Harley, of course, immediately escapes from her cuffs and decides to spring all of her crazy criminal compatriots.
During the ensuing chaos, Nightwing is accidentally killed by Robin and most of Arkhams patients escape to cause even more mayhem for Superman and the innocents of Gotham.
So in a very indirect way, Green Arrow caused Nightwing's death, and the escape of nearly every Arkham Asylum patient simply because he couldn't lock Harley in a cell before offering his opinions. Something even Batman remarks to the emerald archer during that storyline.
4. Failed To Prevent Star City's Destruction And Lian's Death - Cry For Justice
In the Justice League story "Cry for Justice" several Justice League members leave the League due to disagreements on how to best deal with all the supervillains they battle in a seemingly endless cycle. Shortly after members leave the Leauge, the villain known as Prometheus launches a deadly attack.
When captured, Prometheus unveils his final plan, to detonate devices across the globe that will send the beloved cities of League members into a sort of time void where the innocent civilians will live but be lost to their heroes forever. His only demand is to be released.
The heroes obviously refuse at first, until the first device goes off. Green Arrow's own Star City is targeted first, but the device malfunctions. Instead of sending the city to the time void, the city is leveled. Oliver returns to the ruins, finding the body of Red Arrow's daughter Lian crushed under a building. Prometheus is let go and the devices deactivated.
Prometheus is quickly hunted down and murdered by the enraged archer, with an arrow between the eyes. Red Arrow blames Olie for being too slow to save his daughter and the two separate. Black Canary leaves as well because of the hooded archer's cold-blooded murder of Prometheus.
In the end, no one truly won. A city was destroyed, lives ended, all because Star City's "protector" totally, completely, and irreparably failed his city.
3. Lets Felicity Get Shot - Arrow 'Dark Waters'
The Arrow TV show on the CW brought about a new age of television and did for DC heroes then what Disney+ does now for Marvel's own gallery of heroes.
While the show took a lot of liberties with the Green Arrow mythology, one thing that stayed consistent with Oliver both on TV and in the comic books was his ability to fail those closest to him. In Arrow, Ollie meets a woman named Felicity Smoak, who joins his team as tech support, as well as the group's moral compass.
Eventually the two fall in love, going through several peaks and valleys in their relationship. A major valley formed in the relationship on the day Oliver proposed to Felicity, as on the ride home they were ambushed by heavily armed soldiers hired by that season's main antagonist Damien Darhk.
Ollie initially shields Felicity from the absolute hailstorm of bullets going through their limo. But literally right as he goes to the driver's seat to try and get them to safety, Felicity is hit by a bullet that permanently paralyzes her.
She eventually makes a device that helps her walk again, but the entire ordeal is quite traumatizing for Felicity and the Green Arrow, putting an incredible amount of strain on their relationship, and showing that Star City's hero can fail even when acting as a human shield for those he cares deepest about.
2. Shot Jonathan Kent Accidentally - Injustice: Year One
When Batman first formed his insurgency in the Injustice universe, he was originally against bringing Green Arrow into the fold.
After a lot of arguing, Bruce eventually allowed Oliver to come with them on a mission to infiltrate Superman's Fortress of Solitude and recover super-powered pills that allow any human to stand up to the deranged Kryptonian in a fistfight.
Of course, the mission goes horribly wrong. When they break into the fortress they discover Superman's human parents, the Kents, hiding inside. However, before they can turn around and leave, the Man of Steel breaks into the fortress and attacks Batman's group.
Oliver tried to distract Superman by firing arrows at him knowing they won't even scratch his cape. What he didn't expect was for an arrow to bounce off Superman and fly right into Jonathan Kent's shoulder, injuring him. This obviously enraged the Man of Steel who then proceeded to pulverize the Emerald Archer to death.
While it truly was an accident, Ollie endangered innocent humans while trying to distract Superman, and was only just able to save a pill to complete the mission before his death.
This death of the Green Arrow is slightly better than some of his other deaths, but it was still all because the highly trained archer wasn't aware of his surroundings when taking on a man faster than a speeding bullet.
1. Had An Affair While Dating Black Canary - Straight Shooter
Oliver Queen has a lot in common with billionaire playboy Bruce Wayne, especially the "playboy" aspect. At times the Green Arrow was quite the scuzzball when it came to the fairer sex.
In the "Straight Shooter" storyline, Oliver teamed up with Jefferson Pierce, Black Lightning, to finance his niece Joanna on her path to becoming a lawyer.
Ollie and Joanna end up hooking up while they fought against an evil conglomerate in Star City. Almost immediately after the affair, the pair drift apart when Oliver reveals he's dating someone else. That someone else being Black Canary.
The world's greatest archer blames the entire affair on Joanna for some unknown reason, and even tells Black Canary not to come to the city since he feels so bad about the whole "cheating on her" thing.
Oliver's promiscuity continues even after this story and got so bad the writers had to change his sexuality to be polyamorous so that he could still have Black Canary and cheat on her without having any of that pesky guilt getting in his way.
This could easily be described as the Green Arrow's greatest failure. The worst part is that this wasn't because of some criminal plot or ultimate betrayal, this was just a fundamental failure of one man to stay truthful to the one woman in the multiverse who truly loved him, no matter what he did.