Hannibal: 10 Things We Won't Get To See

This was their design... or it could have been.

mads mikkelsen
whatculture.com

Hannibal is that rare thing: a television adaptation of a long familiar cinematic property that betters the original. It’s smarter, more stylish and sophisticated than the previous film adaptations of Thomas Harris’ novels, with a singular vision throughout – that of Bryan Fuller, the showrunning executive producer of the series.

For those not in the know, the show follows the introduction of Will Graham, the sensitive, unstable FBI profiler of the Red Dragon novel, to his new shrink Dr. Hannibal Lecter, a renowned forensic psychiatrist and also the Chesapeake Ripper, one of the serial killers that Graham is hunting.

Critically acclaimed from the beginning, Hannibal never reached a large fanbase. Intellectual, elliptical and arty at one and the same time as being the most brutal and gory programme ever broadcast on network television; perhaps it was only ever destined to attract a niche market. Whatever the reason, Hannibal was cancelled by NBC on 22nd of June 2015, three episodes into the third season. At the time of writing, efforts to find a new home for the show on platforms like Amazon or Netflix have met with failure.

Hannibal’s status as the third iteration of Lecter’s story means that much of the central narrative is familiar to viewers, just given a new spin by Fuller and company. If season three is really the swansong for this remarkable project, then what storylines and set pieces will we miss out on? Let’s see… and here be spoilers, so don’t say we didn’t warn you.

10. The Fate Of Freddie Lounds

Hannibal Freddie Lounds
NBC

Although Hannibal follows the same narrative arc as Thomas Harris’ original novels, it plays fast and loose with some of the stories already familiar to fans of the franchise in order to tell the story the way Fuller wanted it told. One of the changes made was to cast Lara Jean Chorostecki to play the role of Freddy Lounds, the exploitative tabloid reporter of the novel Red Dragon. Every other interpretation had been male, scuzzy and sleazy, whereas Chorostecki, fashionable and elegant, brought a coldly manipulative kind of sleaze to the part far more in keeping with the show’s aesthetic.

When the second half of season three begins to follow the Red Dragon storyline, it’ll actually be the fourth time the story has been told, not the third: Red Dragon has previously been adapted for the big screen as both Michael Mann’s seminal Manhunter, and Brett Ratner’s rather less successful Red Dragon. In all three previous versions, the obnoxious Lounds falls foul of The Tooth Fairy, the serial killer antagonist, and is kidnapped, has his lips bitten off and is set on fire while strapped – or glued – to a wheelchair.

In Fuller’s adaptation, we’ve already seen the iconic image of the flaming chair: in season two, Will Graham fakes the death of ‘Fredricka’ Lounds in order to allay Lecter’s suspicions. It’s unlikely that Fuller is going to repeat the feat in season three when the Red Dragon storylines filter into the narrative. Does that mean a whole new fate for the most irritating hack in popular fiction today?

One theory is that Fuller was saving Freddie for Lecter’s larder. After all, she’s the very definition of the rudeness that Lecter despises the most… perhaps immolation is too good for her. If Lounds isn’t killed by the Tooth Fairy, would we have seen her become one of Hannibal’s inventive, artistic crime scene exhibitions in season four? We’ll never know.


9. The Charmed Life Of Dr. Chilton

Chilton Hannibal
NBC

Ahhh, Chilton: another Frederick, and the other most obnoxious character in the show. Bryan Fuller has already gone on record as saying that he loves Raúl Esparza’s smarmy portrayal of the worst psychiatrist in the entire world, and is deeply invested having horrible, horrible things happen to him.

If you’re reading this and you’re not up to speed with season three – well, firstly you were warned about spoilers, and secondly you’re probably asking yourself why anyone would talk about Frederick Chilton in the present tense, let alone the hypothetical future tense, because Frederick Chilton is dead, right? In season one, he was surgically gutted and pieced back together missing a few non-vital organs, and in season two he was framed for Lecter’s crimes and shot in the face by one of Lecter’s brainwashed victims. He’s kicked the bucket. He’s shuffled off this mortal coil, run down the curtain and joined the choir invisible. He is an ex-Chilton.

Well, you can’t keep a good douchebag down: and like the cockroach he is, Chilton’s still kicking, albeit sans an eye and most of his teeth. Fuller assures us that more is to come for the man in season three, and such is his unctuous horrendousness as a human being that you can’t help but feel he still deserves it. If only there were a season four to continue the Chilton-lovefest. Raúl Esparza is a genius. 


8. Lecter’s Bloody Escape Artistry

Hannibal Lecter Silence Of The Lambs
Orion Pictures

One of the absolute highlights of The Silence Of The Lambs was Hannibal Lecter’s escape to go on the run, picking the lock of his handcuffs and killing the guards. Taking a guard’s clothes, he then cuts off the man’s face and carefully lays it out over his own. The heavily armed S.W.A.T. team find one dead guard and one living guard, covered in blood and supposedly unconscious, and immediately call for paramedics to take him for urgent treatment while they search the building for Lecter, thereby giving him his escape route.

It’s a stroke of genius, only made possible by the fact that Lecter is moved to a makeshift imprisonment in Tennessee: the killer called ‘Buffalo Bill’ has kidnapped the daughter of a US Senator by mistake, and when he learns this Lecter refuses to give the information he has to anyone but the Senator, and is transported to her location. Lecter has no idea where he will be held or what opportunities he will be presented with, so one has to assume that his practically foolproof escape plan is an almost completely spontaneous invention.

We’ll never get to see the Mads Mikkelsen iteration of this escape from captivity. Would they have retained the iconic ‘skin mask’ set piece? Or would Fuller have had his show live up to its reputation for grand guignol theatre by making his version even more horrific?


7. Hannibal Won’t Be Rising Anytime Soon

Hannibal Rising
MGM

Thomas Harris’ novel Hannibal Rising is a prequel detailing the history of the character from childhood to young adulthood, as he experiences the loss of his parents and his sister – the latter of which opens the door to his psychopathic urges. The book was adapted into a film starring Gaspard Ulliel as the young Lecter, following the same story. Neither were particularly well received – the movie in particular was panned, and bombed at the box office.

Aspects of this back story – including mention of Lecter’s sister Mischa – have surfaced in season three of Hannibal already, but what with there being only two episodes to go in Florence and the remainder of the Mason Verger storyline to play out, followed by the Red Dragon storyline in the final half of the season, it’s unlikely we’ll get to see any of the grim story of revenge told in Hannibal Rising, or witness the birth of Lecter’s cannibalistic modus operandi.

Many would say that, considering the poor reception that the novel and film received, the less this part of the franchise is referenced in the far superior television show, the better. They might also point out that too much explanation removes some of the mystique from the character. There’s something to be said for that, just as there’s something to be said for unexpected revelations adding poignancy to a characterisation: and if anyone could have taken the clumsy sow’s ear of Hannibal Rising and turned it into a narrative silk purse, it’s Fuller and his team.


6. Jame Gumb And Buffalo Bill

Buffalo Bill
Orion Pictures

The Silence Of The Lambs is still the seminal chapter in the Hannibal Lecter story, the multiple Oscar-winning movie that began and defined the franchise. It’s entirely possible that Bryan Fuller might never have obtained the rights to those iconic characters, and even before Hannibal’s cancellation, the rumour was that he had other plans for season four.

But then Fuller just had to drop hints at the Saturn Awards last month about how excited he was about the possibility of working on the Jame Gumb character: the serial killer known as ‘Buffalo Bill’, the antagonist of The Silence Of The Lambs. In that conversation, he dropped hints that his interpretation of the wannabe-transsexual serial killer would have been radically different from anything we’ve seen before.

It’s highly unlikely anyone will ever get to see it now, of course… but the character could certainly do with a new spin. The original iteration of the character as a grotesque doesn’t sit well with our modern understanding of and sympathy for issues relating to gender dysphoria… ‘Buffalo Bill’ may not have ever been intended to represent a true transsexual, but that’s something that was never properly delved into in either the novel or the film of The Silence Of The Lambs. 


5. When The Lambs Stop Screaming

Jodie Foster Silence Of The Lambs
Orion Pictures

This is, of course, the big one – the cancellation of the show is likely to mean that we’ll never see Bryan Fuller’s interpretation of Clarice Starling on Hannibal.

There were issues in obtaining the rights to the characters in The Silence Of The Lambs regardless of NBC’s decision to cancel Hannibal, and Fuller has made it clear that any season four probably wouldn’t have followed that storyline. However, no comprehensive adaptation of this material would ever be complete without touching on the storyline that turned Dr. Hannibal Lecter into a household name, and Clarice Starling is canonically as vital to Lecter’s character as Will Graham has proven to be in Fuller’s version of the story.

Of course, Jodie Foster’s portrayal of Clarice is iconic, irreplaceable, as Julianne Moore found when essaying the character in the Hannibal movie. Having said that, everyone thought the same thing about Sir Anthony Hopkins as Lecter himself, and Mads Mikkelsen has confounded and surprised all who scoffed at the idea of a new, different Lecter.

That, in turn, leads to the traditional geekery of the fantasy casting session: who would you have had play Bryan Fuller’s version of Clarice Starling? How would she have differed from the classic take given by Jodie Foster? Feel free to spitball ideas in the comments if you like… it’s a moot point now.


4. Quid Pro Quo, Clarice

Silence Of The Lambs
Orion Pictures

And of course, the cancellation of Hannibal and the lost possibility of a Bryan Fuller interpretation of The Silence Of The Lambs and Clarice Starling means we won’t get to see Fuller and company have a go at reinterpreting the interaction between Clarice and Dr. Lecter that Foster and Hopkins made so iconic in Jonathan Demme’s 1991 film.

To date, Hannibal has revolved around the relationship between Will Graham and Lecter, a relationship invented for the purposes of the television series: there was no such friendship in either Red Dragon or either of the cinematic adaptations of the novel. It’s a mesmerising game of cat and mouse… only in this case, the cat is pretending to be a mouse, and the mouse is starting to believe that he may have been a cat all along.

Giving viewers a genuine look at a new portrayal of the Lecter/Starling dynamic would necessitate making the Lecter/Graham relationship take a back seat. That might ruffle the feathers of ‘Fannibals’ whose cravings run towards shipping Will & Hannibal eloping together. However, their quibbles might have been assuaged if…


3. Three’s A Crowd

hannibal will graham
NBC

… we had finally, for the first time ever, seen Will Graham and Clarice Starling meet and interact.

For many, this is the lost storyline that rankles the most. Clarice may be the most iconic protagonist to face off against Lecter, but Will is the man who caught him – and with Hannibal, audiences have been privy to an expansion of that fairly binary ‘cops n’ robbers’ relationship. Lecter may have gotten into Will’s head and had a good rummage around, but judging by the events of season three so far, Will’s left his mark on Hannibal’s psyche too.

How would Will react upon seeing Starling interacting with Lecter? Would there be a professional rivalry? A personal one? Graham isn’t a social animal, and doesn’t suffer fools gladly… and Clarice would, by necessity, be stepping onto his turf with Lecter. Meanwhile, the entirely new dynamic that Clarice would have with Lecter might well be threatened by the lurking presence of Will Graham in the background.

It’s a little like just beginning a new romantic entanglement, only to have the ex hovering around in the periphery. Will and Hannibal are complicated enough. What happens when you throw Clarice into the mix?


2. Clannibal

Clarice Starling Hannibal
Orion Pictures / Sony Pictures Television

But let’s not forget that the OG pairing in this franchise isn’t Will/Hannibal, but Clarice/Lecter. After all, Lecter is fascinated by her, for many reasons. The films make it clear that Clarice respects Lecter’s mind and even understands him to a degree… but is focused purely on his remaining in captivity. She may get him, but she doesn’t want to get with him.

Most of you reading this will probably be aware that Thomas Harris’ book Hannibal has a fairly controversial ending: where the film adaptation has Lecter’s advances rebuffed and Clarice intent on recapturing him, the book has Lecter attempting to brainwash Starling (using a cocktail of psychotropic drugs and some fairly unethical behavioural modification therapy) into believing that she is his sister Mischa, somehow come back to life. When Clarice proves too strong willed for this spot of weirdness to take, the pair become an item – sealing the deal with a spot of light cannibalism together.

The major objection to this pointless nonsense has always been that this was wholly out of character for Clarice, a highly ambitious but thoroughly moral woman whose main attraction for Lecter was her straightforward instincts and unselfconscious strength of character: one would imagine that’s why the film deviated from the book so abruptly at this point. However, in a hypothetical Hannibal season five where Bryan Fuller’s interpretation of Clarice Starling met his interpretation of Hannibal Lecter, who’s to say what could happen?

Mads Mikkelsen’s Lecter is far more lugubriously charming than the reptilian, high camp Lecter essayed by Anthony Hopkins, after all. He’s also younger, sexier, a dandy with a vicious physicality to him, and a past master at the art of psychological seduction: part of the USP of the Hannibal television show is presenting us with a Hannibal The Cannibal who manipulates people into doing things they would never have dreamed they would, and thinking that it was their idea all along.

Hopkins’ Hannibal Lecter is a theatrical monster, a murderous ham. Mikkelsen’s Hannibal is the very Devil himself. A Clarice/Hannibal (Clannibal?) pairing doesn’t make any sense in the film version of Hannibal, and they were wise not to take that path with the story’s climax. In Hannibal the television series… it could actually have worked.


1. A Definitive And Original Ending

hannibal tv meal
NBC

Finally, one of many things that Fuller mentioned was planned in his proposed overarching narrative for the Hannibal television series was an ending. No, not the ending to The Silence Of The Lambs where an escaped Lecter begins to stalk Frederick Chilton, telling Clarice that he’s about to have an old friend for dinner. No, not the ending to Hannibal the book, that saw Clarice and Hannibal Lecter eloping to Buenos Aires together, or the ending to Hannibal the film, that saw Lecter escape once again, minus a hand this time.

No, Fuller more than hinted that his preferred way of rounding out the story of Hannibal Lecter was to complete his interpretation of the Harris-sourced material… and then deliver one final season of wholly original material, concluding the epic in his own style, finally constrained by nothing except his own understanding of the character and of the idiosyncratic storytelling that had taken him to that point.

There’s no indication anywhere of what that ending might have looked like: the fates of any of the major characters, or even a simple binary, ‘does he live or die at the end’ answer. Nonetheless, fans of the series that prize Fuller’s interpretation over and above the inconsistent, iffy versions available in print and on DVD to date may well consider that his take had the potential to be the definitive version of the story, even above the one presented in the novels.

High praise, indeed… but we’ll probably never know how that hypothetical final season would have played out, and who would have remained alive to tell the tale.

What’s the biggest missed opportunity you can think of in Hannibal being butchered in its prime like this? Tell us all about it in the comments…


Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.