How Every Doctor Who Got Cast

Some Doctors wrote a heartfelt letter – others auditioned in Steven Moffat's kitchen.

Doctor Who William Hartnell Ncuti Gatwa
Silver Screen Collection/Getty Images/BBC Studios

Russell T Davies recently referred to the role of the Doctor as "the Crown Jewels" of UK television, and heavy is the head that wears that crown.

Only 14 actors have played the Doctor's 15 primary incarnations between 1963 and 2024, and careful consideration is always paid to who will inherit the TARDIS.

Casting director Andy Pryor has been instrumental in casting all of the modern Doctors, and therefore has a unique perspective on what goes into finding the next Time Lord. In an interview with Digital Spy, Pryor described some of the things he looks for in a potential Doctor:

"We've always wanted really good actors rather than people who are just known for one thing."

This is something that's true of every actor who's played the Doctor. Versatility is key to a great Doctor, which is why established character actors like William Hartnell and Patrick Troughton were cast in Doctor Who's earliest days.

The process of how every Doctor Who got cast has changed over the years, given the shifting landscape of television. Some were offered the role outright, others had to audition, and one had to... perform in Steven Moffat's kitchen?

Well that's alright then!

15. William Hartnell

Doctor Who First Doctor William Hartnell
BBC Studios

William Hartnell had been acting for over 30 years by the time he was offered the role of the First Doctor. A role in the 1944 war movie The Way Ahead secured him a fairly consistent career playing tough men, from army generals to hard-boiled detectives and sinister crooks.

In 1957, Hartnell was cast as Sergeant Major Percy Bullimore in sitcom The Army Game, and became a household name. When The Army Game ended in 1961, Hartnell fell back into guest spots in other TV shows, and a movie role that would change his life.

The Army Game William Hartnell
ITV Studios

Lindsay Anderson – a key figure in the British New Wave of cinema – cast Hartnell as the elderly rugby scout "Dad" Johnson in 1963's This Sporting Life. Hartnell gives an astonishing performance here, displaying a tender interest in Richard Harris' Frank which appears to go beyond rugby.

It was Hartnell's performance as Johnson that caught the attention of Doctor Who's first producer, Verity Lambert. The First Doctor was imagined as an older man, and Hartnell's ability to play tough characters with a soft centre made him perfect for the role.


14. Patrick Troughton

Doctor Who Patrick Troughton Second Doctor
BBC Studios

Patrick Troughton was an incredibly gifted character actor in film and television, and had clocked up some impressive credits in the years before Doctor Who.

A fascinating tidbit about his career is that he was the first actor to play Robin Hood on television, doing so in the BBC's 1953 serial of the same name. Doctor Who's producers believed that an actor of Troughton's versatility was a good fit to replace William Hartnell, and though he was initially unsure, he ultimately signed on the dotted line.

Arguably, Troughton had the toughest role of any lead actor in the history of Doctor Who. Not only did he have to sell the concept of regeneration, he had to be markedly different to William Hartnell, while staying true to the heart of the character.

Thankfully however, some of his more outlandish suggestions for the Second Doctor – including a turban and darker skin – were shot down by the production team.

Troughton blazed a trail for future incarnations, so it's understandable that Hartnell apparently noted that he was "the only man in England who can take over."


13. Jon Pertwee

Doctor Who Third Doctor Jon Pertwee
BBC Studios

A former Naval intelligence officer, Jon Pertwee served alongside James Bond creator Ian Fleming, perhaps influencing his own 007-inspired take on the Doctor. When the Second World War ended, Pertwee embarked on a prolific career on stage and screen.

He was encouraged to enquire about playing the Doctor when it became clear that Patrick Troughton would be leaving. Producer Peter Bryant duly placed Pertwee's name on the list, right behind Oliver! star Ron Moody.

Ron Moody The Twelve Chairs
UMC Pictures

When Moody turned down the role – which was reportedly the single biggest regret of his career – Pertwee was a shoo-in for the Third Doctor.

Before Doctor Who, Pertwee was primarily known for playing comedy roles, appearing in multiple Carry On movies, and the beloved radio sitcom The Navy Lark. Mindful of this reputation, Pertwee was keen to play the Doctor as a more serious and heroic figure.

This is largely why the Third Doctor is more straight in his first season, but quickly softens, allowing Pertwee to lean into his talents as a comedian and raconteur.


12. Tom Baker

Doctor Who the Fourth Doctor Tom Baker
BBC Studios

The story of how Tom Baker became the Fourth Doctor is the stuff of legend.

In the early 1970s, Baker's career appeared to be in the ascendant after he was cast in movies like Nicholas and Alexandra, and The Canterbury Tales. Unfortunately, the roles dried up by 1974, and Baker found work on a building site.

Meanwhile, Barry Letts and Terrance Dicks were casting the actor who would replace Jon Pertwee as the Doctor. They had considered actors like Bernard Cribbins (can you imagine!), Graham Crowden, and Fulton Mackay – all of whom, incidentally, have appeared in Doctor Who in other roles.

That was until BBC Head of Serials Bill Slater received a letter from Tom Baker, whom he'd previously worked with. Slater passed the details on to Letts and Dicks, suggesting that they go see Tom's latest movie, The Golden Voyage of Sinbad.

Letts and Dicks were both captivated by Baker's performance as the sorcerer Koura, and offered the out-of-work actor the role of a lifetime.

Baker recalls his last day on the building site in his autobiography in suitably quirky fashion:

"That lunchtime I shook hands and swore eternal friendship with everyone, and full of tears and good resolution, I tottered off. I never saw them again. I was Doctor Who now. I was an alien."

And the rest is history.


11. Peter Davison

Peter Davison Doctor Who
BBC

In 1981, Doctor Who producer John Nathan-Turner was grappling with how to replace Tom Baker. It was the biggest challenge for the show since his predecessors had to seek out potential candidates for the Second Doctor.

JNT approached Richard Griffiths (these days best known as Uncle Vernon in Harry Potter) about the role, but he wasn't available.

An actor who was available, despite simultaneously appearing in two sitcoms (Holding the Fort and Sink or Swim) was Peter Davison.

JNT had worked with Davison before on All Creatures Great and Small, the show that had made Davison a household name. Davison's profile and his youthful appearance were deemed a winning combination by JNT, who quickly offered the role to the initially reluctant star.

Davison worried about being too young to play the Doctor, and was also concerned about becoming typecast. He needn't have worried of course, as he would go on to become the most successful actor to have played the Doctor in the classic era. So much so that he's still working today, in shows like The Gold, Gentleman Jack, and Good Omens.


10. Colin Baker

Doctor Who Colin Baker Sixth Doctor
BBC Studios

On the advice of Patrick Troughton, Peter Davison made the decision to leave Doctor Who after three years. As with the transition between Tom Baker and Peter Davison, John Nathan-Turner was keen to cast someone who would provide a sharp contrast with their predecessor.

Colin Baker, therefore, could not be more different from Peter Davison. Where Davison had generally played sympathetic everyman characters, Baker had carved out a career playing villains in acclaimed dramas like The Brothers and The Roads to Freedom.

Not to mention his antagonistic role as Maxil in the Fifth Doctor serial Arc of Infinity.

Doctor Who Colin Baker Arc of Infinity
BBC Studios

It was Baker's strong performance as Maxil that ultimately led to his casting as the Sixth Doctor, despite his concerns that Doctor Who generally didn't recast guest stars as the lead.

Colin's fears proved to be unfounded however when John Nathan-Turner offered him the role. JNT and Baker had become acquaintances in the months following Arc of Infinity, and the producer increasingly believed that he would make a great Doctor.

If only the BBC had agreed with JNT's assessment at the time.


9. Sylvester McCoy

Doctor Who Sylvester McCoy Paradise Towers
BBC Studios

Sylvester McCoy had previously thrown his hat into the ring for the Sixth Doctor, having been unaware that John Nathan-Turner had already cast Colin Baker.

Fast-forward a couple of years and the BBC has fired Colin Baker, and John Nathan-Turner is looking for a new Doctor. Again. Sylvester McCoy – via his agent – puts himself forward for the role, following a recommendation to JNT by BBC producer Clive Doig.

After seeing McCoy perform in The Pied Piper on stage, JNT was convinced that he was the right man to play a Troughton-esque Seventh Doctor. McCoy had a knack for physical comedy, perfected during his years in the anarchic theatre group, the Ken Campbell Roadshow.

However, BBC One Controller Jonathan Powell wasn't convinced that McCoy could lead a TV show, and nixed the casting. Undeterred, JNT assembled a number of actors, McCoy among them, to record screen tests opposite one Janet Fielding, who had played Tegan opposite the Fifth Doctor.

Viewing the tapes, Powell conceded that McCoy was the strongest performer, and so he was officially cast as the Seventh Doctor.


8. Paul McGann

Doctor Who TV Movie Paul McGann TARDIS
BBC Studios

Looking at the history of the 1996 TV Movie, it feels like there wasn't a single actor in the UK who wasn't considered for the role of the Eighth Doctor.

And not just UK actors either – Americans like Jurassic Park's Jeff Goldblum and Twin Peaks' Kyle MacLachlan were also potential candidates.

Paul McGann eventually emerged as the frontrunner for the role, due to the BBC's desire to have a British actor as the lead. McGann taped his audition for the TV Movie in September 1994, but even that wasn't enough to secure the role.

Fox wanted a big name like Sting (yep, seriously, Sting) to play the Doctor, but the BBC and producer Philip Segal vetoed this wild casting suggestion. Eventually, Segal offered to cast a big name as the Master, if Fox agreed to Paul McGann's casting as the Doctor.

Peter Capaldi later revealed that he turned down the chance to audition for the TV Movie, believing that he would have to "jump through hoops for something I'd never get."

He's an astute man, that Peter Capaldi.


7. Christopher Eccleston

Doctor Who Ninth Doctor Christopher Eccleston
BBC Studios

Ah, Christopher Eccleston and Russell T Davies, where did it all go wrong?

In 2003, it was announced that RTD would be reviving Doctor Who for a brand-new series. Also in 2003, RTD and Christopher Eccleston collaborated on the ITV drama The Second Coming, which depicted the return of the son of God.

When he discovered RTD was reviving Doctor Who, Eccleston expressed his interest in the title role. Speaking about this during promotion for his first and only series, Eccleston stated that he was excited to do something for a younger audience.

Eccleston was also a suggestion made by executive producer Mal Young. However, before he received Eccleston's interest, RTD never believed that the actor – best known for gritty and challenging work – would ever do Doctor Who.

Which is presumably why more "obvious" names like Hugh Grant and Bill Nighy were pursued by the team prior to Eccleston's casting being announced.

It was a game-changing bit of casting that signalled Doctor Who wasn't just going to be phoning it in, and helped ensure the show's overnight success back in 2005.


6. David Tennant

Doctor Who David Tennant Tenth Doctor
BBC Studios

David Tennant has always cited Doctor Who as one of the key influences on his decision to become an actor. In fact, Tennant had played multiple roles in Big Finish audio dramas in the years before he was cast as Doctor number Ten.

Alongside these audio dramas, Tennant's TV career was taking off with a breakthrough role in 2004's Blackpool, opposite "the next Doctor" David Morrissey. Tennant also got the chance to work with Russell T Davies on the 2005 show Casanova, which is what led to his casting as the Tenth Doctor.

Casanova David Tennant
BBC Studios

When Christopher Eccleston decided not to return for Doctor Who Series 2, RTD had to find a replacement fairly quickly. So it was a good job that he'd literally just worked with an incredibly talented actor, who had also been dreaming of playing the Doctor since he was a little kid in Paisley.

Not wishing for their new lead to leave as quickly as Eccleston had, the BBC signed Tennant for multiple series. Not that he would've minded, the man can't keep away!


5. Matt Smith

Doctor Who Matt Smith Eleventh Doctor
BBC Studios

When Steven Moffat took over Doctor Who in 2010, he was keen to cast an older Doctor to differentiate the character from David Tennant. A reverse Peter Davison manoeuvre, if you will.

Instead, he cast the youngest actor to ever play the Doctor.

Matt Smith had previously auditioned for the role of Watson in Moffat and Mark Gatiss' Sherlock, but was turned down because he was more of a Holmes figure than a Watson. Smith proved this when he turned up to audition for the Doctor and completely won over Moffat, convincing him that this young actor could still embody the Doctor's centuries-worth of experiences.

It's said that Steven Moffat and his producers had their hearts set on one particular actor before Matt Smith walked into the room, leading to much speculation over the years.

Peep Show's Paterson Joseph and Voyage of the Damned's Russell Tovey also auditioned for the role of the Eleventh Doctor, eventually losing out to Smith.

It's even been rumoured that Chiwetel Ejiofor was offered the part, but turned it down. It's certainly a tantalising "what-if", though who can deny that Smith was utterly perfect casting.


4. Peter Capaldi

Doctor Who Heaven Sent Peter Capaldi
BBC Studios

Steven Moffat had apparently considered casting Peter Capaldi as the Eleventh Doctor back in 2009, but it never came to be. Four years later, Moffat revisited this notion, and offered Capaldi the role after a private audition at Moffat's home. 

It's widely believed that Capaldi was always the first choice for the role, which was why he auditioned in Moffat's kitchen, rather than in a more official setting.

However, other options were being explored for the unlikely possibility that lifelong Doctor Who fan Capaldi would turn down this most coveted of characters.

Actor Ben Daniels revealed that he had been asked about succeeding Matt Smith as the Twelfth Doctor. Meanwhile, bookies slashed the odds on James Bond actor Rory Kinnear being cast as the Doctor, believing that it was a dead cert.

While these potential candidates had been rumoured and leaked to the press ahead of the big swanky primetime reveal in August 2013, Peter Capaldi was always at the top of the list.


3. Jodie Whittaker

Doctor Who Jodie Whittaker
BBC Studios

The short version of how Jodie Whittaker was cast as the Thirteenth Doctor is that she had worked with Chris Chibnall on Broadchurch. But it's a bit more complicated than that.

Doctor Who was never on Whittaker's mind, even when Chibnall contacted her for a meeting. She assumed it was to discuss the final season of Broadchurch, and was surprised when Doctor Who was brought up!

The actress was then put through months of auditions, reading specially-designed script pages to test whether she could handle the Doctor's many sides. She recorded a self-tape where she pretended to defuse a device – a typical Doctor scenario – and successfully bagged the role.

Several other mystery actresses also auditioned. Rumours emerged prior to Peter Capaldi's final series that he would be replaced with Tilda Swinton or Phoebe Waller-Bridge, which obviously never came to pass.

Whatever the truth of those rumours was, Chibnall has stated that he was always going to cast a female Doctor, and that Jodie Whittaker was always his number one choice.


2. David Tennant (Again)

Doctor Who David Tennant Fourteenth Doctor
BBC Studios

The story of how the COVID-19 pandemic inadvertently led to David Tennant being cast as the Fourteenth Doctor is a fascinating one.

The chain of events is as follows. Former Doctor Who Magazine writer Emily Cook organised tweetalongs to several popular Doctor Who episodes, to keep fans entertained during lockdown.

After a tweetalong for The Runaway Bride in December 2020, Catherine Tate texted Russell T Davies and indicated she'd be down to do more Doctor Who. RTD loved the idea, and upon learning that David Tennant was also up for it, he informed the BBC.

With the future of the show uncertain and no clear plan in place for Chibnall and Whittaker's successors, the promise of new episodes with Tennant and Tate must've been music to the Beeb's ears. RTD soon agreed to return as showrunner, bringing with him a bold vision for the show that is currently unfolding before our eyes.

The return of David Tennant as an older, weather-beaten incarnation of the Doctor was the perfect way to reinvigorate wider public interest in the show during Doctor Who's 60th anniversary year.


1. Ncuti Gatwa

Ncuti Gatwa Fifteenth Doctor An Adventure in Space and Time
BBC Studios

Ncuti Gatwa was already becoming a huge star when he auditioned for the role of the Fifteenth Doctor.

Rising to fame playing Eric Effiong in Netflix's Sex Education, Gatwa had also snagged a small role in 2023's blockbuster hit Barbie.

Barbie Ryan Gosling
Warner Bros. Pictures

This led to him making a cameo during the I'm Just Ken performance at the 2024 Oscars, in what is surely one of the most iconic moments for a Doctor actor.

Casting director Andy Pryor told Digital Spy that Gatwa "blew everyone away" during his audition. Pryor also revealed that the auditions took place over a couple of days, and that there were other actors they would happily have cast.

Elsewhere, Russell T Davies revealed to the Radio Times that Ncuti Gatwa was the last actor to audition for the role, and that the showrunner had already cast someone else in his head:

"I thought someone else was a guaranteed hit and then in [Ncuti] came, and that person will never know."

Cue decades of speculation over who RTD would've cast if Ncuti Gatwa had turned left and never auditioned for Doctor Who!


Watch Next


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Citizen of the Universe, Film Programmer, Writer, Podcaster, Doctor Who fan and a gentleman to boot. As passionate about Chinese social-realist epics as I am about dumb popcorn movies.