It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia: 10 Best Recurring Jokes

Which of Paddy's recurring gags gets you laughing?

Frank Reynolds Man Cheetah Rum Ham
FX

The mark of a great sitcom is when you can keep returning to similar jokes and get a laugh every time. Each comedy show that tries to make a stamp on the market needs to have a specific set of gags that it returns to in order to give it identity and reward loyal fans who remember them.

That is something that Always Sunny achieves in abundance. It is home to a plethora of ridiculous recurring jokes based on language, character traits, or ideas that get a tonne of laughs whenever they appear.

Throughout the show's 14 seasons, the characters have gone through so much, and they've come out of it all the better - or worse, realistically speaking.

They've picked up a certain amount of habits and ideas that make their way into the show regularly, and this helps to form some of the best running gags in comedy TV history. The following ten entries are the best examples of this.

Honourable mentions include: Dee's nervous gagging, Charlie's affinity for inedible foods, Uncle Jack's "Tiny" hands, Guigino's and specific recurring roles like The Lawyer and The Waiter.

10. Charlie's Characters

The Nightman Cometh
FX

Charlie Kelly is an easy fan-favourite for the show, and one of the best things to come from the squeaky-voiced janitor is his plethora of weird characters. The main ones being The Nightman, The Dayman and Green Man.

Firstly, Green Man is always a funny thing to see, as Charlie's green morph suit, which he uses as a sports mascot, has led to some great moments, such as Charlie fighting the Philly Fanatic and Cricket using it to gate-crash the gang's Superbowl adventure. It's a great recurring joke that only appears every so often.

However, the Day and Night man characters take this even further, as they don't seem to be roles he made up, but rather deep emotional presences in Charlie's psyche.

It's abundantly clear that Charlie is dealing with some traumatic emotional problems. Those always seem to manifest as The Nightman, a character who the gang clearly see as a person who assaulted him, as the lyrics of his song makes clear. While the reality of these characters is horrible, it's also hilarious as their constant mention shows how close Charlie always is to cracking.

Plus, who could ever forget "The Nightman Cometh"? Best musical episode ever.


9. Frank Doesn't Have Donkey Brains

It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia Frank Reynolds
FX

So, it looks like Charlie isn't the only one dealing with some psychological troubles.

Frank Reynolds is a perplexing man, as his loaded bank account means you'd expect him to live a life of luxury, but he instead chooses to live in squalor, sharing a bed with his best friend and eating cat food just to get to sleep. It's clear that Frank is dealing with a lot of stuff, but he seems happy; so long as you don't call him "donkey brained."

This is a joke that's turned up many times in the show, most notably in "Reynolds vs Reynolds: The Cereal Defence" when Frank provided a certificate to certify that he did not have "donkey brains". This allegedly came after he was sent to a "nit-wit" school and wanted his mother to get him proof that he was no longer mentally unstable.

Of course, Frank is always oblivious to how ridiculous he sounds, and anytime he brings up his "donkey brains" - or lack thereof - it gets a big laugh. But, more than that, this recurring joke even became a fundamental piece of Frank's backstory, as we later found out in the episode "Psycho Pete Returns" that he did spend a lot of time in a mental health ward.

By his own words, you could easily say that he had "donkey brains" in his youth.


8. Charlie Work

It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia Charlie
FX

You might think that your job is a bit of a grind, but compared to Charlie Kelly's, it's probably a walk in the park. This poor man's life is a constant struggle, as not only does he live in horrible conditions, but he also gets mocked by his friends, is shunned by society and has to do "Charlie work".

This umbrella term constitutes any job in the bar that's deemed gross. You've got your classic rat bashing, playing with electrical equipment, and toilet cleaning, but there's also syphoning gas, taking out hornet's nests and much more. No wonder he huffs so many chemicals.

Charlie is so comfortable getting down and dirty, and that's what makes "Charlie work" so funny. All of the other gang members are terrified at the prospect of even doing one day of it, meaning that it's a constant source of laughs and conflict.

It even led to the phenomenal episode of the same name, which saw Charlie manage an entire airline miles chicken scam whilst passing a health inspection, showing how vital "Charlie work" is.

Fans can only hope that they eventually get a "Charlie Day" like Mac and Dee Day, where the rest of the gang finally get their hands dirty with some "Charlie work".


7. Their Poor Movie Making Skills

It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia Charlie Mac Fight Milk
FX

It's likely that everyone remembers their first time using windows movie maker, but even those juvenile projects probably have more skill going into them than the gang's attempts to make movies.

One of the funniest things about the owners of Paddy's pub is their obsession with schemes and plots. Almost every episode revolves around them coming up with some idea they think will grant them success, and it always comes to bite them in the back. One key aspect of this is how excited they get about making commercials and movies.

There are loads of examples of their terrible product films, such as; the Fight Milk advert, Dee's Invigaron demonstration, the Chardee MacDennis board game trailer, and more.

No matter what they are advertising, their films are always full of awkward cuts where they skip over each other, poor visuals and a lack of coherent writing. But, it's always primed for a big laugh.

With how poorly edited and performed these films are, it's a miracle that their Lethal Weapon sequels came out so well. Although, they were wrong for entirely different reasons.


6. Dee's Characters

Always Sunny Dee Day
FX

If you thought Charlie was the only character with an arsenal of wild characters, then you haven't seen anything yet.

Deandra Reynolds is a person who constantly seeks the approval of her peers, and this is where most of her comedy comes from. Seeing the unlucky butt of the gang's jokes try desperately to make people like her and falling flat on her face is a consistently reliable way for the writers to get a rise out of the audience.

One of her most attention-grabbing antics is the host of colourful characters she has created, all of which are horrendously inappropriate. The likes of Taiwan Tammy, Crazy Paddy, Martina Martinez and Mr Covington all appeal to stereotype, making her performances entirely cringe-inducing.

What's worst about them is that she goes so far with the costumes, particularly for Taiwan Tammy and Martina Martinez, for which she sports some incredibly outdated make-up methods to look "authentic".

Seeing these characters pop up is always a delight, as Dee's ignorance to their offensiveness and lack of self-awareness makes them a punchline in themselves.


5. Nightcrawlers

Charlie Kelly Always Sunny Nightcrawlers
FX

Always Sunny is an inherently nihilistic show that pokes fun at sentiment all the time, which is what makes the "Gruesome Twosome" of Frank and Charlie such a fun exception. These two live in an absolutely disgusting apartment, and even share a bed, yet they are so connected to each other and seem to have a fantastic relationship. One great signifier of this is their special game, Nightcrawlers.

What is Nightcrawlers? We may never fully know. All that we do know is that it's a game Frank and Charlie play where they crawl around on the floor pretending to be worms collecting minerals. What else are they supposed to do on a Friday night?

The disgust that the rest of the gang hold towards this game - without fully knowing what it is - makes it all the better, as they are fully aware of the weirdness these two share, so love to jab at it.

However, the viewers know better, as while "The Gruesome Twosome" are weird, they have a lot of fun, and thus it's always rewarding to see them reference the game they love to play together - even if it is a little strange.


4. Charlie's Illiteracy

It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia Charlie
FX

It's safe to say that Charlie is a genius in his own right. The man might not have much control over his life, but he's very skilled at what he does. There are not many other gang members who can play multiple instruments, multitask a health inspection with a scam and survive so long in the sewers. With that being said, by conventional standards, he's far from being a genius.

It's made clear early that Charlie has no understanding of the written word and a "tenuous grasp on the English language in general" - as stated by The Lawyer. This has come up very consistently in the show, as Charlie's struggles to read have been a thorn in the side of the gang on multiple occasions.

For example, he accidentally left the closed sign on at the bar, has created terrible maps of the vent systems, and even accidentally entered the gang into a dance marathon with Paddy's Pub as the grand prize. This particular mistake led to the classic line, "your illiteracy has screwed us again".

Fans can only hope that Charlie learns to read one day, for his sake. But, for now, it's hilarious to see how his illiteracy causes havoc.


3. Dennis' Erotic Life

It's Always Sunny Dennis
FX

Dennis Reynolds started as the "cool guy" in Always Sunny. He was always hooking up with chicks, impressing people and acting vain; but that man is long gone now. A great example of how far he has fallen is the ever-evolving creepiness in his erotic lifestyle.

The sex life of Dennis Reynolds is - weirdly - one of the most interesting things about the show, as his constantly domineering and creepy behaviour is always eye-catching. This was brought to the forefront of the series in the episode "The D.E.N.N.I.S System", where he walked the gang through his six-step plan of seduction. But his flair for manipulation was only just getting started.

He's also resorted to using tapes, video cameras and even elaborate sex rooms (as seen in The Gang Escapes) for his sinful ways, and hearing stories of his "conquests" - as he calls them - is always an amusing yet disturbing joke.

And, of course, it would be impossible not to mention "the implication", which has reared its ugly head plenty of times throughout the show and never fails to get viewers rolling in fits of laughter whilst rolling their eyes too.


2. Rum-Ham

Frank Reynolds Man Cheetah Rum Ham
FX
"Rum Ham! I'm sorry Rum Ham!"

Never were more emotional words said in an episode of Always Sunny. Well, that's not entirely true, but the heartbreak that Frank Reynolds experienced after losing his precious rum-soaked ham at sea in "The Gang Goes to the Jersey Shore" was certainly memorable.

After this episode - when the rum-ham made its first appearance - the alcoholic meat became a massive motif for the fanbase, as they loved the concept of Frank's unconventional alcohol. This led to the meat becoming a recurring joke that doesn't show itself too often but always gets a significant reaction when it does.

From its first appearance, rum-ham has come along in two further episodes and even found its way into the mobile game. Despite its lack of screen time, it's easily one of the best-remembered gags in the series and has gone on to become synonymous with the show, meaning that it doesn't have to show up in every other episode to get a laugh.

The horrible delicacy has even found its way into real life, with viewers working to make their own version of the beverage/dish to very mixed results.


1. Dee's A Bird

It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia
FX

Dee is a hilarious character, but she is also a somewhat talented person and a decent friend on occasion. Still, above all else - Dee is a great big flightless bird.

Calling Dee a bird is such a strange gag, as it's never made any sense yet never fails to capture a laugh. The joke originated in the episode "The Gang Gives Back" when Mac mocked Dee for wearing a yellow jumpsuit, comparing her to Big Bird. From there, the joke evolved and turned into something that constantly gives Dee grief.

She is always getting insults hurled at her, and this is one that's tossed around a lot, with her barely being able to go a few episodes without being compared to a bird.

The best implementation of the running gag had to be in "Who Got Dee Pregnant?", where each time the gang remembered the drunken Halloween night, they pictured her becoming more and more like a bird until she just ended up being an ostrich.

Of course, Bird isn't the only word beginning with a b that they constantly call her, but the other one's best left to your imagination.


Contributor

Michael is my name, overanalysing comedy is my game! Anime, wrestling, TV, movies and video games all live in my head rent free!