Legion: 9 Ways It's A Totally Unique Comic Book TV Show
The first TV team-up between Fox and Marvel is unlike any superhero show we've seen before.
Superhero TV is in great health right now, and there are plenty of differences to be found in each series: the fun, comic-y lightness of The Flash and Supergirl; the conflicted darkness of Arrow; the more grounded nature and mature themes of Netflix's Marvel shows.
However, for all their variations, they have recognisable core elements: heroes, powers, crimefighting. Legion, the new TV series that marks the first collaboration between Marvel and Fox (but airing on FX), stands apart from these.
Telling the story of David Haller, a schizophrenic mutant who has been in and out of care all his life (and is, in the comics at least, the son of Charles Xavier), it is unlike anything else we've seen from the comic book realm (and that stretches to non-superhero fare like The Walking Dead and Preacher).
The first episode is stunning, and the quality doesn't dip too much over the next couple of episodes. Noah Hawley, creator of the incredible Fargo TV series, once again proves his genius here, and has delivered a series that is, in many ways (which we'll explore in spoiler-free fashion), a completely unique take on a well-worn genre.
9. It's Not About Heroes
As mentioned in the introduction, one of the connective threads between the various superhero shows on television - for all their differences, and regardless of whether it's Marvel or DC - is the fact that, at the centre, these people are heroes. Some are more reluctant than others, but the general premise is on fighting crime and cleaning up the city.
Legion offers no such familiarity. Although David (expertly played by Dan Stevens, who is capable of switching gears without any notice) is ostensibly the hero of the piece, and we're invited to root for him in that regard, there's no following the heroic formula here.
There's no grandstanding, no taking matters into his own hands, no hero complex, no being the hero we deserve and/or need right now; just a man, with many issues, but who is seemingly a good person at heart.
8. Nor Is It Really About Superpowers
Much like it's not about heroes, Legion isn't really too focused on the other part of the word 'superhero' either.
Sure, we know that David is a mutant, and potentially a very powerful one. But that's not the whole story that Noah Hawley is interested in telling.
We've seen through Fargo that he takes ordinary people and places them in extraordinary circumstances, and while David is far from being considered 'ordinary' there is a similar approach taken here.
It's not so much the superpower aspect that's of most interest, but rather the humanity of the characters we see on screen, their relationships, romances, mental health, and the world they live in, but with the more superpowered elements thrown in for good measure.
Other shows - most noticeably Jessica Jones and Luke Cage - have done great work in being superhero shows that are about more than that, but the powers are still at the core in a way they aren't for Legion.
7. A Lack Of Action
One of the hallmarks of any comic book show is its action, from big set-pieces to frenzied fight scenes to tightly co-ordinated stunt work.
Legion, for a lot of the time, veers away from this. It's not about beating up the bad guys, but instead takes a deep dive into the psyche of its lead character, which means that we're much more likely to get a long conversation than we are a big fight sequence.
Despite this, you never really feel like the series needs the action to bump things along. Whereas on some superhero shows you're left waiting for it to spark into life, Legion is constantly alive, always buzzing.
On the odd occasions when it does dip into action, it still presents it in a different way, utilising the range of powers at its disposable that other shows don't really have.
6. The Sound Editing Is Insane
I mentioned in the previous entry that Legion is always buzzing, and that is true in more ways than one.
While the series is incredibly alive and active, there's also going to be a buzzing in your ears while you're watching it.
The sound editing and mixing isn't done in a way that makes each one clear and distinct, but rather the various noises we hear throughout the show - the soundtrack, which kicks off with The Who's Happy Jack; the dialogue; the voices in David's head; the other amplified sounds of the surrounding - are blended together to dizzying, disorientating effect, in a way that really helps you understand what's going on inside David's head.
Most shows of this ilk don't play around too much with sound - Luke Cage being the obvious exception, and that was more to do with the soundtrack - and certainly don't deliver anything like this.
5. And The Visuals Are Even Crazier
Hawley had only directed one episode of TV before Legion - an early episode of Fargo's second season. And while that was assured, it's nothing compared to the absolute stunner he delivers in the Legion premiere.
That episode in particular - not that it changes too much in the next two, which come from the dependable hands of Michael Uppendahl (Mad Men, Fargo, American Horror Story) - is a complete trip, unlike not only anything seen in comic book TV terms, but pretty much anywhere on television.
The closest recent comparison would be a movie, Doctor Strange, which similarly employed trippy, world bending techniques (albeit on a much larger scale). Legion turns the world upside down and inside out, slows it down and speeds it up.
From the bright colour palette to the kaleidoscopic camera work, the show is visually arresting, with a kinetic energy and a penchant for framing and symmetry that would make Wes Anderson proud.
Crucially, it never feels like its too much or overly indulgent, but rather - like with the sound - an effective way of showing us the world as David sees it.
4. You'd Barely Even Realise It's An X-Men Series
A lot has been written about Legion being an X-Men TV series, from the pondering of whether we might got an appearance from Charles Xavier to the endless headlines questioning and theorising about how it may or may not fit into the X-Men cinematic universe (easy answer: it doesn't).
And yet, for all the focus on it in the build-up, watching the series you'd hardly be aware that it is supposedly an X-Men TV show, save for stray mentions of the word "mutant" and that little 'x' in the title.
There's no civil rights allegory here, no team needing to be led, no Charles Xavier's School for Gifted Youngsters. If David Haller is searching for something, it probably won't take him to Professor X. Other shows can shove the references to the movies and comics down your throat (a lot of the time it works to be fair, sometimes it doesn't), but Legion is just happy blazing its own path.
3. Questioning What Is Real
Is this real? Or is it in my head?
It's a question that Steven's David asks repeatedly, but he may as well be filling in for the audience when he does so, because we're not given any strong indication either way about the true nature of what it is we're watching.
The show endlessly flicks between the real life and David's fantasy, or at least our/his notions of which is which, as well as flitting between the past and present, cutting from scene-to-scene, location-to-location in such a manner that we don't truly know what is going on anymore.
Indeed, it's all a matter of perception anyway, and the only reality that matters is that which David believes in. It's a far cry from the grounded reality (contextual reality, anyway) of other comic book series, and something that could prove equally frustrating and exciting as it progresses.
2. It's Not Afraid To Get VERY Weird
Even just based on the early stages of the first season, Legion has already established itself as one of the weirdest live-action shows on TV, comic book inspired or otherwise.
Hawley has shown a mastery of this sort of territory on Fargo, and he gets free reign here, from the trippiness of the visuals to the reality-questioning narrative, the unconventional love story to the characters and their names (at one point we sit and watch the drool coming from a patient's mouth; there are characters called Kerry and Cary Loudermilk - pronounced the same way, but seemingly unrelated).
The show is unconventional, bizarre, and yet makes its weird elements all work together in beautiful fashion.
1. The Examination Of Mental Health
Other comic book shows have dealt with mental health issues before, most notably Jessica Jones, which tackled abuse, depression, and PTSD.
Not to downplay those elements of Jones, which work brilliantly, but Legion takes it to another level, with a serious examination of mental health. This is in many ways what the show is about, rather than having a character with those being elements of them.
The show is genuinely interested in exploring these avenues, posing both big questions about mental illness and exhibiting concern for the characters and what they may be dealing with.
It tackles elements such as medication and care, and the stigma that still exists around mental health, in a grounded way, as well as the more reality-warping explorations of what's going on inside David's head.
Share your own thoughts on Legion down in the comments.