Legion: Ranking Every Main Character From Worst To Best
It seems that not all mutants are created equal.
This past February, the television airwaves were blessed by the debut of FX's new X-Men Spin-off show, Legion. There's no other way to say it, this is a brilliant show for many, many different reasons.
Among these reasons, however, is the show's cast. The characters we are treated to in Legion are nothing if not fiercely unique; the traditional safe and marketable superheroes have been put aside in favor of this proverbial Island of Misfit Toys. They are not heroes, but rather a group who are just doing all they can to survive in a bizarre, ever-hostile world. Not to mention the fact that their casting was on point.
For right now, we'll be focusing on season one's main cast. And while just about all of the show's primary characters are enjoyable to some degree, with each playing a vital role in the narrative, there are certainly some who have been given a better showing than others.
8. Melanie Bird
Among the otherwise incredible, engaging characters that Legion has to offer, there is one weak link in the bunch: Melanie Bird.
Bird is the leader of Summerland in name, and name alone. A figurehead, if you will. She lacks all of the qualities of a strong, wise leader. Everything she says is rendered irrelevant by her subordinates, and there seems to be no sense of conviction about her. Apart from one, admittedly interesting moment of wisdom as she helps David learn to control his powers, that quality is all but absent as well. Professor X, she is not.
Moreover, she's just not terribly interesting. And between the other, far more gripping characters that Legion has to offer, it's very hard to find any mental energy to give to her.
The reason for this boils down to the fact that the show is simply not about her; and her involvement in the story is all but a formality. She's there to occasionally deal out some (albeit useful) exposition, while the other characters take care of more interesting matters.
She has the potential to be a great character, and Jean Smart is a phenomenal actress. However, as it stands, there is simply not enough room for her in the story that is currently being told. With any luck, she'll be given more depth and more to do in season two. After all, her role as the head of this safe haven for mutants has a world of potential behind it.
7. Kerry Loudermilk
With the one negative entry out of the way, we are now on the up and up.
Kerry Loudermilk is a girl who shares a body, as it were, with a scientist at Summerland by the name of Cary Loudermilk. In short, their relationship is as follows: Cary takes care of the technical stuff, whereas Kerry's expertise lies in bonafide action. This is for a good reason too, as she is shown to be exceptionally skilled at hand-to-hand combat.
She is a character who is defined by her childlike sense of wonder. And if you think that that would be tiresome, you would be absolutely wrong. Due in large part to actress Amber Midthunder's sheer commitment to the roll, Kerry's overexcited attitude towards fighting works perfectly. Moreover, there is an interesting dynamic between her personality and her love of fighting that acts as the character's flaw, as she will run headlong into a fight without first devising a proper plan. During the battle at the lighthouse, we see that this can be a major detriment, as her pure skill can only take her so far.
We also get a taste of her side of the codependency that goes along with her and Cary's relationship, if only for a few fleeting moments. This leads us to Kerry's one major drawback, which is a need of more screentime. As of right now, she's more or less a flat character, but there is lots of potential just around the corner.
6. Syd Barrett
Sydney Barrett, better known as Syd, is an interesting character to say the least. The very first thing that is established when we meet her is that she doesn't like to be touched. Shortly thereafter, it becomes apparent as to why: as her power is being able to switch bodies with anyone she comes in contact with. And as the series progresses, it seems to be a power that does a bit more harm than good, which creates an interesting conflict as to whether it is a gift or a curse.
In addition, Syd is shown to be both an incredibly smart and incredibly caring person. She all but steals the show in the first episode with her enthralling criticism of the way the psych ward is run, as well as exhibiting genuine care for David and the others on a number of different levels.
Overall, she is an exceptionally great character and is integral to the show's structure. However, the reason she ranks so relatively low has to do with the way she's acted.
Make no mistake, Rachel Keller is a very talented actress who definitely has her moments of brilliance in the show. However, she is also prone to emoting awkwardly at times. There are occasions where her delivery just feels off. It isn't enough to ruin the character, and certainly isn't enough to take anything away from what truly is a spectacular show; but it is definitely noticeable.
5. Cary Loudermilk
As stated before, Cary and Kerry have a rather bizarre relationship due to the fact that they share a body. However, as it stands, Cary's side of the equation is the more fleshed out of the two, for a variety of reasons.
First and foremost, Cary is the host; meaning that Kerry essentially lives inside of him, only taking on her separate physical form when duty calls. One key thing to note about this is that while the two are as one, Kerry does not age and Cary ages normally. As a result of this, Cary has become something of a father figure for Kerry; due to the fact that he is a middle-aged man, whereas her body and mind are still that of a twenty-something (hence her childlike behavior.)
It is because of this dynamic that Cary lives his life brutally aware of not only his own mortality, but that of his doppelgänger, as it were. In fact, we see just how much he cares for Kerry when he tends to the wounded girl after she is injured, merging with her to take on her pain as his own.
In addition, Cary is very entertaining just on his own. Whereas the others seem to adhere to set behavior, he is a bit of a moving target. He can be funny, serious, sarcastic or sincere, depending on the situation. It's because of this that he is oddly comforting, and a member of the group they couldn't live without.
4. Amy Haller
David's older sister, Amy, is introduced early on as a bubbly, quaint person who is doing all she can to help her brother work through his (alleged) psychiatric problems, while doing her best to maintain a life of her own. She had some funny moments in Chapter 1 and was undoubtedly a good bit of fun during what screentime she had.
However, it's only after she was kidnapped and tortured by Division 3 that we began to see that there was far more to her than meets the eye. We discover that she has known since childhood that David was adopted and, to a degree, about his powers. Yet, she remained silent out of fear as things progressed and David's life hit a downward spiral that ultimately landed him in a psych ward.
She feels an immeasurable amount of guilt, which is made clear when everyone ends up back at the institution via the astral plane. In this dreamscape, Amy is one of the nurses and regularly subjects David and his friends to verbal and physical abuse. This peek into her psyche shows that she feels just as responsible for what David went through as those who directly put him through it. This arc materialized at a brilliantly gradual pace, and turned a character who initially appeared to be all but flat into one of the most subtly dynamic of the entire show. Amy is a prime example of how incredibly effective subtext can be.
3. Ptonomy Wallace
Plain and simple, Ptonomy Wallace is a well-written character, who is a joy to have around. If David, Syd, and the Loudermilks are the heart and soul of our team of protagonists, then Ptonomy is the all-important backbone. He may not always be at the forefront, but when he is, it's brilliant; and even when he isn't, he is still very entertaining.
He is cynical and sarcastic in the best possible way, and carries himself with a certain confidence and conviction that some of the other characters lack. He's the type of person that when he speaks, people listen; because they know that he knows full well what he's talking about and what he's doing. As a result, he seems to be the much-needed voice of reason for the group at times.
Moreover, his memory exploration power is not only incredibly unique, but also integral to the plot. Without Ptnonomy, much of the narrative falls apart, as it is through his expert control of his abilities that he is able to help piece together the secrets of David's past.
The only drawback in regards to Ptonomy is that while it's clear he plays a crucial role in the story, we don't really know a whole lot about him as of yet. A backstory was alluded to, but has not yet been explored. Meaning that he is another character who would gain from more development in season two or beyond.
2. David Haller
We now come to Legion's titular character, which is a responsibility that he more than lives up to.
When it comes to making a television show there is a certain way that the protagonist needs to be treated, and Legion got it absolutely right. David Haller is the main character of Legion, and they make sure that you never once forget that.
In the first season alone, we have seen an incredible amount of depth and growth with this character. The story of this man's life and struggle are illustrated in vivid detail, as we see first-hand the amount of torment his great power has caused him, practically since birth. Frankly, across the entire X-Men universe, David's story is arguably the single best of a mutant coming to terms with his powers we've ever gotten.
Moreover, David's personality has an incredible amount of depth. He's snarky, funny and charming, but also wears a very thin mask of sanity as a result of the aforementioned years of psychological torture. And this is something we see him grow to be able to control better following his omnipresent journey of self-discovery. We're only one season in and he's already such a complete character.
The cherry on top of all of this is a near-flawless performance by Dan Stevens, who masks his English accent perfectly, was no slouch in preparing for the role, and clearly very much enjoys playing David.
1. Lenny Busker
There's only one character in Legion who could possibly hope to outshine its main protagonist, and that is its main antagonist.
Lenny Busker is the preferred form of Amahl Farouk, aka the Shadow King, and there's simply no two ways about it: she is absolutely brilliant, and then some.
Lenny is so relentlessly sinister and manipulative that you want to hate her because of how merciless she is, but you can't bring yourself to do it because she's also so charismatic and beyond clever. Not to mention the fact that her rise to villainous prominence was as perfectly methodical as she is. She starts of slow, acting as a heavy-handed devil's advocate of sorts for David.
As time goes on, she slowly wraps him around her finger before finally making her true, sadistic self known. Plus, she's also an incredibly competent villain, as she toys with the rest of the gang's psyches at one point as if they were nothing more than idle playthings, and does it all with a smile on her face.
The absolute best thing about Lenny, however, is her actress. Whereas Dan Stevens' portrayal of David is near-flawless Aubrey Plaza's performance as Lenny is absolutely flawless. She meshes with the character to an uncanny degree, and as a result turns in what is undoubtedly the best performance of the entire show. The only word you can use to describe it is 'wow'.
If Plaza does not receive an award for this performance, it would frankly be an injustice.
How would you rank the Legion characters? Let us know down in the comments.