Marvel's The Defenders Review: 5 Ups And 7 Downs
The Defenders have assembled at last, but were they better off staying apart?
The Defenders have assembled at last.
Four years in the making, and four series into the Netflix Marvel Universe, four heroes come together to save New York from a mysterious threat.
It's a project that deserves applauding just for its ambition, as it tries to replicate the success of The Avengers on the small screen, and one with a lot of quality behind it too: Jessica Jones, Daredevil, and Luke Cage were all, to varying degrees, good-to-great, and Iron Fist's failings could be better hidden away.
Put Sigourney Weaver into the mix as the Big Bad, and it's all looking rosy for the team-up event. The results, however, aren't quite as expected. It's not an outright bad show, and there are some genuinely excellent moments, but the series does become less than the sum of its parts.
Even with fewer episodes it can't avoid some problems that have plagued this universe, and creating a few unique ones as well, but fans of these characters should still find plenty to enjoy as Marvel's small screen heroes defend their city.
Warning: this review contains spoilers for all eight episodes of The Defenders.
Ups...
5. There Are Some Great Character Moments Between The Heroes
One of the things the series gets right is the dynamics between its four heroes. It takes a while to bring them together, but once it gets Jessica Jones, Matt Murdock, Luke Cage, and Danny Rand in a room, sparks begin to fly.
Some of the best moments of the series come when these 'heroes' are just conversing, whether it's arguing about what to do next, striking up new friendships, re-kindling old ones, or Jessica ripping the piss out of absolutely everyone, this is where we see the real strength of the team.
They all play off each other really well, with the show seeding Heroes for Hire, allowing Jessica and Luke to reconnect in a way that feels organic despite them being thrown back together, while Jessica and Matt in particular shine as a pair, and there's a lot of charisma to go around and fun to be had with putting these characters together.
4. It Does A Good Job Of Setting Up The Next Phase
While this is The Defenders, it's also a halfway point for each of the individual heroes, a brief stop before we get to the next seasons of the various solo shows.
To that end, it does a great job of laying the groundwork for the future. This is especially the case in the last 15 minutes or so, which puts a lot of nice bows on everything, giving a number of mini-endings, but the characters should all be taking something from this that carries over into their respective shows.
Jessica is ready to setup shop again, Danny has matured, Luke grew more into his role as Harlem's protector, and Matt, well, he almost died and is ready to be born again.
Even outside of the heroes, we had Colleen Wing and Misty Knight (sans arm) striking up a bond, clearly setting out the future for a Daughters of the Dragon team-up further down the line, and there's a lot to be excited about looking to the coming slate.
3. It Makes Danny Better
Heading into The Defenders, Iron Fist was the big question mark. His solo series had been the worst of the bunch, and Finn Jones was a big reason for that. Would he drag the other 75% down, or would they lift his quarter up?
Thankfully, it mostly turned out to be the latter. Danny Rand isn't suddenly a great hero, but he's a hell of a lot better in The Defenders than his own show.
Part of this is the show utilising him as the butt of so many jokes, which - even though it was done before Iron Fist arrived - feels like a satisfying way of dealing with that series. But it's also a Danny who has matured and is more responsible, and if anyone needed this team-up it was him.
It'll be interesting to see how it all translates back to Iron Fist Season 2, when he has to do all the heavy lifting himself, but he makes for a solid member of this team. He gets humbled, he has to learn from his mistakes, and, while Jones still isn't great, he becomes more likable as a result.
2. Matt's Arc
It's no great shock that the most developed character in The Defenders is Matt Murdock, since he's had far more screen time than any of his fellow heroes. It's also no great shock that Charlie Cox is once again superb, but both are points worth celebrating.
Matt was in a dark place after the events of Season 2, and The Defenders - which takes place a few months later - does excellent work in picking up those threads and continuing to pull at them.
We start with a depressed Matt who is out of the vigilante game, to a man who gets dragged back into the fight, and eventually steps up to be the leader this team and, more importantly, his city needs him to be, finding a level of acceptance in who he is.
Cox's little tics as the blind lawyer continue to be a marvel to watch, while he expertly sells the inner turmoil over doing what's right and his love for Elektra. He gets meaningful time with both of his key supporting players, is the best in the action sequences, and by the end it leaves you desperate for Daredevil Season 3.
1. Jessica Jones
It has been far too long since Krysten Ritter's Jessica Jones graced our screens, and my word it is good to have her back.
Jessica Jones is, for my money, the best series of all these Netflix Marvel shows, and a lot of that comes down to Ritter's performance, which she builds on perfectly here.
Throughout all eight episodes Jessica constantly delivers the best lines, calling anyone and everyone out on their bullsh*t and how ridiculous it all is, but without ever just being used as comic relief.
She herself as a strong arc, since she starts the series no longer wanting to do P.I. work and still struggling with her past, and the show does a great job of just laying little bits at a time of her becoming a more fully fledged hero who can see the bigger picture.
It nicely rebuilds her relationship with Luke and starts a fresh one with Daredevil (which takes goes to a new level when she talks about his father), and she's a lot more than just a snarky badass (though she definitely is that too, and it is a joy to watch). There's no one more entertaining in the series than Ritter, and like with Daredevil, it leaves you yearning for her solo show to return.
Downs...
7. It's Too Slow
The Defenders being just eight episodes should've been a good thing. It should've meant a lean series that didn't suffer the same pacing issues many 13 episode Netflix series do.
Unfortunately, even with a shortened run, the show runs (or walks) into these problems. The series takes way too long to get going, as we don't have the heroes team-up until the end of the third episode, by which point a lot of time has been wasted.
It doesn't stomp on the gas from that point either, but instead prefers to mostly just cruise towards the finale, keeping both the Defenders and the Hand sitting around until it's time to make a big move.
The approach could work if the setup behind it was better, or the story more worthy of investing time in, but sadly it's not, and a lot of just comes off as being slow-moving and, at times, fairly dull.
6. Underwhelming Action
The Netflix Marvel Universe has become known, among other things, for its action sequences. These are shows that bring us plenty of superhero fight scenes, whether good or bad, and it was a reasonable assumption that The Defenders - what with four heroes and just eight episodes - would follow suit.
Unfortunately, the action is pretty thin on the ground. The series opens with a badly lit fight, we get the first Defenders fight at the end of episode 3, and a few more scrapes along the way after that.
There aren't enough action sequences, but even with the ones we do get there's nothing to really make them stand out or electrify us in the way Daredevil's have done previously. The hallway set pieces, which were once so exciting, now just feel like they're in there because they have to be, and the rest is pretty underwhelming too (so maybe it's actually a good thing there's not more of it).
5. Some Of The Direction Is Terrible
One of the big problems with the action scenes we do get - apart from the choreography - is the lighting. There's some awful direction and camera work in there that makes them incredibly difficult to follow, and at certain points the action is so dark it's incomprehensible (I wondered if this was just me, but it seems to be a problem a number of colleagues have had).
It doesn't just apply to the fight sequences either. At the end of episode 7, when the big reveal is made that it's a dragon skeleton down below Midland Circle (because that makes total sense), the impact is severely lessened when you can't really make out what the thing is.
The show does make some interesting visual choices, most notably and commendably the unique backlighting for each hero. But much of it is so badly lit and shot that it's hard to watch at certain points.
4. Elektra
While Matt Murdock is brilliant in this, the woman he loves, Elektra, is not.
There's something more interesting about her in the early stages, as she's an amnesiac weapon of superhero destruction used by the Hand, with an odd relationship between her and Alexandra, and just enough of the old Elektra shining through.
The more we see of her, though, the less interesting she becomes. She increasingly dominates part of the story, especially in being the one to deliver the double murder twists, but there's no pay off to that.
We don't really get to understand what's going on in her head, or why she killed Alexandra. She could've had this planned with Stick all along, or maybe there was a different, compelling reason for taking over, but we don't get to see any of that. Instead it boils down to 'I'm not actually this empty vessel, I do remember and I'm gonna be kinda evil just 'cause'.
3. It Lacks A Great Individual Villain
Sigourney Weaver's Alexandra is another character who starts off quite strongly, but again ultimately falls by the wayside.
There's an interesting air of mystique to the character at first, and Weaver brings a real presence to the screen, but it gradually fades away before she herself is killed off.
She spends as much time squabbling with her fellow fingers as she does taking the fight to the Defenders, and there's not enough done to mark her out as the biggest and baddest threat any of these heroes have faced yet.
One of the reasons Daredevil Season 1, Jessica Jones, and the first half of Luke Cage worked so well was each had an incredibly compelling, complex villain. A show shouldn't just be as good as its Big Bad, but we've seen how much it helps in this universe, and it's very much lacking here, with no one stepping into her void once she is killed off either.
2. The Hand
If there is one fatal flaw made in Netflix's Marvel Universe, then it's investing so much into the Hand.
First in Daredevil Season 2, then Iron Fist, and now here, the shadowy, ridiculously-named organisation has had New York in its clutches, and not once has it been an entertaining aspect of any of them.
In theory, the Hand should work: they're a ninja death cult, for f**k's sake. But their fights have been terribly inconsistent in how easy or difficult they are to deal with, their power structure constantly changing and featuring characters it's hard to invest in at all (Madame Gao is the only one who comes close to succeeding, and apparently she's developed Force powers now), and their motivations a complete muddle to the point where they're just a complete bore (again, ninja death cult).
If there's one excellent point to come out of The Defenders, it's that this universe moving forward should be Hand-free.
1. It Never Justifies Its Existence
A lot of this stems from the problems with the Hand, but The Defenders never fully manages to justify its existence. Whereas The Avengers was a coming together after years of setup and felt like a necessary team, this just feels like they had the idea to do The Defenders a few years ago, which allowed them to make four other shows, and now we've got to do this.
Because the Hand never feels like a major threat, no matter how much they say they are, it's hard to buy that what's at stake requires these four street-level heroes to band together. Certainly in at least Jessica Jones and Daredevil Season 1, the stakes felt higher, the risk greater, and the storytelling much more satisfying as a result. The Defenders isn't a bad series, but it's a very average one that could and should have been a lot more.
There are some great character moments that come from this team-up, but there's little else that feels like it couldn't have been achieved in each solo series, and it's telling that upon ending the excitement isn't for where The Defenders might go next, but each of these individuals.
What did you think of The Defenders? Share your thoughts down in the comments.