Marvel's Daredevil Season 3: Ranking Every Character From Worst To Best

Not every character was a bullseye.

Daredevil Season 3
Netflix

It's been a tough time for Marvel-Netflix fans of late, what with the cancellation of both Iron Fist and Luke Cage, but at least we've had Daredevil season 3 to lift our spirits. It's widely agreed that it's one of the best seasons of this corner of the MCU we've had to date. Part of that is to do with its surprisingly tight, well-paced storyline, but it's also due to how character-led the season is.

As is obvious from the retro choice of costume for its hero, Season 3 goes back to the stylings of Season 1 which means we get not only a lot of focus on Matt Murdock and his friends Foggy Nelson and Karen Page but also their eternal nemesis Wilson Fisk, as he gets himself out of jail and resumes his quest to take over Hell's Kitchen. We also have some new additions, too - like Special Agent Ray Nadeem and Sister Maggie.

The majority of the ensemble work very well, though as ever there are a couple that don't have the impact they should. There's only one character who can top the list, though, but you'll have to keep reading to find out who that is.

14. Julie Barnes

Daredevil Julie
Netflix

Julie Barnes is the unfortunate object of Dex's obsessions. Though he says he didn't have romantic feelings for her, he had chosen her as his "north star" and so had been stalking her for years since they worked together at a suicide hotline. The monster that he is, Fisk manipulates Julie back into Dex's life and then murders her in order to mold Dex into his pet assassin.

First of all, Julie's bottom placement here isn't a negative reflection on actress Holly Cinnamon, who does a good job of portraying perhaps the most innocent and just plain nice person in the entire season. However, the way the character is treated is atrocious.

She's little more than a plot device and she's written out with the most literal example of the "women in refrigerator" trope seen in a long while. Not cool, Marvel. Try better next time.


13. Blake Tower

Daredevil Blake Tower
Netflix

Blake Tower has been the local District Attorney since Daredevil season 2, also popping up in both seasons of Luke Cage. While we know underneath it all he's a good guy, his role has always been an antagonistic one - representing the frustrating loopholes of the law that confound our heroes' plans to put the bad guys away for good.

Again, that's exactly the role he fills in season 3. He plays right into Fisk's hands by agreeing to his deal with the FBI and dismisses Foggy's cries to realise the truth for far too long.

Eventually, he does come around and is instrumental in helping Nelson, Murdock & Page take the Kingpin down. However, if we're meant to feel anything for the character, or get the sense that he's changed over a redemptive arc, it falls flat as Tower always comes across as a bit of a jerk.


12. Marci Stahl

Daredevil Marci
Netflix

In the beginning of season 3, Marci is in a serious relationship with Foggy and, apart from his grieving over the loss of Matt Murdock, they appear to have got their life together. Once Fisk's power grows once again, though, Foggy becomes at risk and Marci conceives of a plan for him to run for DA in order to make him as public a target as possible.

Marci and Foggy's relationship is a lot of fun as they are such different people - "Foggy Bear" is a sweet, caring guy while she's incredibly blunt and a little scary. In some ways, it's nice to see a softer side to her, then, but mostly it feels like the sassy edges that made her an entertaining addition to season 1 have been sanded off here. Still, it was nice to have her around more than in season 2.


11. Mitchell Ellison

Daredevil Mitchell Ellison
Netflix

Mitchell Ellison is the steadfast editor at the New York Bulletin - J. Jonah Jameson's more even-tempered, approachable cousin, if you will. Much like Tower, he often acts as an obstacle to our heroes, particularly Karen, as they try to get to the bottom of the truth. Actor Geoffrey Cantor always makes clear the moral centre of the man, though, so he never feels like a nuisance to have around.

Season 3 portrays Ellison at his most human, as we see him at home with his wife and attempting to set Karen up on a date.

It's tough to watch him shun Karen later on when he discovers she's withholding the identity of Daredevil, but seeing what he's been through and his nature as a journalist it's a fair enough reaction. Thankfully, he lived through his attack by Pointdexter when it looked like the show was setting him up for a martyr's death.


10. Brett Mahoney

Daredevil Brett Mahoney
Netflix

Brett Mahoney's role on Daredevil has always been very simple - he's Nelson & Murdock's Commissioner Gordon, their ally on the police force that they can trust to uphold the law and aid their investigations. We never know too much about him as a three-dimensional person but he's a likable presence who fills his role well.

Detective Mahoney doesn't play a part in season 3 until later on when he turns out to be our heroes' ace in the hole when they need an honest officer to combat the corrupted FBI - he even hides the Nadeem family away at his mother's house.

As always, Mahoney's a welcome face and his repartee with Foggy, in particular, is enjoyable to watch. He doesn't have any sort of character arc across the season, though, so it's hard to rank him any higher.


9. Father Lantom

Daredevil Father Lantom Dead
Netflix

As Matt is such a conflicted Catholic, Father Lantom has been an important part of Daredevil as he acts as Murdock's voice of reason and effectively his therapist. In the first two seasons, he was very much a wise, pure soul but what makes his role in season 3 interesting is that we get to see the human, flawed side of Lantom.

It comes out in episode 8 that Lantom has been keeping a huge secret from Matt his entire life - one that may have contributed to his life-long sense of loneliness.

This could turn us against Lantom but Peter McRobbie ensures that the character comes across as repentant and regretful. As such, it still comes as a sad blow when Bullseye murders him in episode 11, in a shock twist on Karen's death in the comics. R.I.P. Father Lantom.


8. Vanessa Fisk

Daredevil Vanessa Fisk
Netflix

Vanessa might only appear in the last two episodes of the season, but her presence can be felt the whole way through as Wilson Fisk's main motivation this year is to get his lady love back by his side. As Fisk becomes more obsessed with this, we're left to wonder if perhaps things won't work out when she eventually returns.

Interestingly, though, Vanessa turns out to be more like Fisk than we realised - when she becomes involved in his organisation, she's the one to order Ray Nadeem's death. Well, I guess you'd have to be a sociopath yourself to be in love with someone like the Kingpin.

By the time that Daredevil crashes Fisk and Vanessa's wedding in the finale, you're rooting for him to take down not only the man himself but the woman that facilitates him and arguably even makes his crimes worse.


7. Sister Maggie

Daredevil Season 3
Netflix

Season 3 introduced Sister Maggie, the head nun at the St. Agnes Orphanage where Matt grew up and where he goes to recover from his near-death experience in The Defenders. Fans of the comics knew where this character was headed - late in the season, Maggie was revealed to be Matt's mother, having left his father and joined the order in her youth.

While many of us saw this twist coming, though, the character's arc was still pretty well done - much like Lantom before her, Maggie acts as Matt's moral compass but their relationship is much more layered than his and the priest's as he and Maggie have that estranged parent/son angle.

By the end of the season, Matt seems to have come to terms with what his mother kept from him. Hopefully, having a parent around will help him become a healthier person in season 4.


6. Ray Nadeem

Daredevil Season 3
Netflix

Honestly, Ray Nadeem is a pretty frustrating and arguably even unlikeable character for the first half of Daredevil season 3. As we the audience know he's being so easily manipulated by Fisk, it's hard to muster any sympathy for the hole he is digging himself into. Plus, giving a great deal of screentime to a new character so unconnected to our heroes seemed like a bad idea.

However, the season really manages to turn our opinions on Nadeem around in its second half, as Nadeem bravely realises that things have gone too far and he needs to correct them, even at the cost of his own relationships, career - and eventually his life.

Jay Ali is terrific in these later episodes and the tragic story of Nadeem, a good man compromised and corrupted by the evil of Fisk, in some ways becomes the heart of the season.


5. Foggy Nelson

Daredevil Foggy
Netflix

Some fans have had problems with the way Foggy has been portrayed as "whiny" or "clingy" towards Matt in past seasons, personally though that seems like a natural reaction to finding out your best pal risks his life every night as a vigilante. Season 3, however, slightly recalibrates Foggy's character to make him much more charming and endearing.

After spending the first few episodes mourning Matt's loss, Foggy's main role in the season is to be a source of optimism - he always believes that they can beat Fisk with the power of the law. He's painted as the nicest character on the show so clearly that this viewer briefly wondered if he was going to be killed instead of Karen (thankfully I was wrong).

What didn't work so well was his bid to run for DA which ultimately went nowhere. However, at least the season ends with Nelson & Murdock (& Page) back in business, which is what we all really wanted.


4. Ben "Dex" Pointdexter

Daredevil Season 3
Netflix

If there's one thing Daredevil fans have been waiting for the show to tackle it's Bullseye. While Kingpin might be the Man Without Fear's overall nemesis, Bullseye is his equal in combat. In season 3, the series finally delivers an MCU version of the villain - and it doesn't go how viewers expected. For the better.

In contrast to the comics, we get to see the character's origins. Wilson Bethel plays Benjamin Pointdexter as a complex, very troubled individual - and when Fisk manipulates his carefully-controlled life, his psyche fractures and he well and truly goes off the deep end. How easily this apparently highly-trained FBI agent falls under the thumb of a criminal could have felt ridiculous, but Bethel ensures Dex remains believable though also suitably larger-than-life.

By the end of the season, the character looks set to become the supervillain as we know him, with a slightly OTT final shot forming his logo in his eye. Netflix better give us a season 4 so we can see him back in action.


3. Karen Page

Daredevil Season 3
Netflix

Fans were prepared for season 3 to tackle the classic comic book storyline Born Again, which meant we knew what to expect of Karen: basically, she was going to hit rock bottom, likely also meeting the same fate that occurred in Guardian Devil (another influence on this run). In a smart move, though, showrunner Erik Oleson kept those comics' focus on Karen but created its own storyline that bolstered her character instead of reducing her to a damsel-in-distress.

The highlight of the season for Karen is obviously episode 10, which reveals her tragic past across two thirds of the episode. It's a clever bit of wrong-footing as it sets us up for her death which never happens. Thankfully so, as Deborah Ann Woll gives her greatest performance as Karen so far this season. Just watch how good she is in that scene where Karen reveals all to Fisk.

It would be a great loss to Daredevil's ensemble if she was written out. She's honestly one of the most complex, fascinating female characters in the whole of the MCU.


2. Matt Murdock

Daredevil Season 3
Netflix

One of season 3's strokes of genius is following Born Again and putting Matt Murdock back in his Man in Black suit instead of his Daredevil costume. Strangely, the character's best point up to now was his season 1 story arc, before he was properly ol' Hornhead. For one, fans have always been divided by the appearance of the suit but that period also saw Matt at his rawest and most interesting.

And that Matt is back with a vengeance in season 3. What's surprising is just how much of a jerk he's portrayed as - treating his friends like dirt and turning against every type of faith he had (religion, the law, other people ETC). However, he has a pleasing redemptive arc across the 13 episodes so we end up with a brighter, more balanced Matt by the end of it.

Once again, Charlie Cox proves he is the perfect Daredevil and every bit as definitive a portrayal of his character as, say, Chris Evans as Cap. Even so, someone else still robs him of the top spot...


1. Wilson Fisk

Daredevil Season 3
Netflix

Season 3 might as well change the name of the show to Kingpin as it 100% belongs to Vincent D'Onofrio as Wilson Fisk. He was already more like an anti-hero in season 1 but we spend so much time with him across this run that he's virtually a co-protagonist.

The best thing for fans is that season 3 finally delivers the Fisk from the comics - suited in white, more powerful than ever and finally going by the codename Kingpin. It's chilling to witness as the truth of how far up the system his reach goes is revealed and his neverending cruelty and malevolence makes it easy to side with Matt Murdock when he believes that Fisk needs to die.

That said, D'onofrio still manages to do the impossible and imbue this monster with some humanity, mostly through his genuine love for Vanessa and rare moments of mercy (e.g. letting the Holocaust survivor live). Portraying a character as both utterly detestable but still multi-layered is tricky but the writers and the actors manage it this season.

Sorry, Thanos, but Kingpin is still the finest villain in this franchise.

Who are you favourite characters from Daredevil season 3? Join the conversation in the comments!


In this post: 
Daredevil
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Spewing words on the internet daily. You can also read my stuff at StarburstMagazine.Com, WeGotThisCovered and TheQuiz.Com.