Marvel's The Punisher: Ranking Every Major Character From Worst To Best

Rating the weapons in The Punisher's arsenal.

The Punisher Characters
Netflix

After the total misfire that was Iron Fist and the enjoyable but muddled The Defenders, the pressure was on The Punisher to put Marvel's Netflix subfranchise back on track.

Thankfully, the series - starring Jon Bernthal's ultra-violent vigilante - actually did just that. It had some issues, sure, but, all in all, it was arguably the best of these shows since Jessica Jones season 1, thanks to its terrific central character, strong themes of grief and loss and thrilling, gore-filled action.

Like the best Marvel-Netflix series, another big part of why it worked so well was its cast. These shows are often criticised for being too slow, but the gradual pacing allows the characters room to move and grow. Even a show about a loner like Frank Castle is driven by its great character dynamics. That said, some of the cast didn't shift their weight as much as they could have done.

Counting the adult characters who appeared in over half the episodes (along with one big exception who couldn't be leave out), there were 10 main characters in The Punisher.

10. Bill Rawlins

William Rawlins Punisher Netflix
Netflix

In contrast to the usually underwhelming villains of the MCU, Marvel's Netflixverse has spoiled us with one amazing adversary after the other. Daredevil had Wilson Fisk, Jessica Jones had Kilgrave, Luke Cage had Cottonmouth, Iron Fist had... Well, let's forget Iron Fist.

Unfortunately, while there is a great villain in The Punisher (more on that later), the big bad of the season is a bit of a let-down. Top CIA boss Bill Rawlins AKA Agent Orange might be at the top of Frank Castle's hitlist but he's a pretty two-dimensional antagonist, especially when compared with the rest of the well-rounded cast.

This isn't any fault of Paul Schulze, though, who does the best with what he is given and plays Rawlins in a suitably detestable and psychotic manner. In many ways, it's a shame that the series decided to rehash the whole 'conspiracy from Frank's past' thing that already took up too much time in Daredevil season 2.

As such, Rawlins suffered as a character by being the face of this plotline.


9. Sam Stein

The Punisher Sam Stein Madani
Netflix

As well as layered villains, another thing the Marvel-Netflix series often provide is a shocking death halfway through the season. While not as jaw-dropping as Cottonmouth's demise in Luke Cage or Sigourney Weaver's exit from The Defenders, it was still a surprise when Dinah Madani's partner Sam Stein was murdered by Billy Russo in episode 8.

But hey, maybe we should have seen it coming. Sam wasn't an essential cog in the machine and therefore dispensable, though his role as light comic relief and Dinah's conscience and common sense was welcome. The two Homeland agents' friendly chemistry was enjoyable and Michael Nathanson did a good job with the part.

Overall, though, Sam served his purpose in the first half of the season and his death was a nice twist to raise the stakes for the remaining few episodes, in particular for Madani's personal storyline. R.I.P. Sam.


8. Lewis Wilson

The Punisher Lewis Curt
Netflix

Given the fact that it stars a gun-toting vigilante, The Punisher had to say something about society's current problems with gun control. While Frank's war on crime went largely untouched by this, the show addressed this discussion through the subplot involving Lewis Wilson, a damaged veteran who becomes a terrorist.

It's engrossing to see Lewis' descent unfold, and Daniel Webber gives a strong performance in the role. However, this plotline never properly aligns with the rest of the show, meaning Lewis is prevented from having the same impact as the rest of the cast. More also could have been done with the parallels between Frank and Lewis, but the show is too quick to paint them with the hero/villain brush.

Still, Lewis was a worthwhile character, whose storyline stopped the season from sagging in the middle like some of the Marvel-Netflix shows have done before.


7. Curtis Hoyle

The Punisher Curtis
Netflix

Frank Castle is a difficult character to write for. In a comic book, the fact that he's a solitary kind of fella works, but on screen a character needs friends to talk with and confide in. Enter Curtis Hoyle, a close buddy of Frank's from his military days and one of the few people who knows he's alive.

Though it seems slightly out of character for Frank, particularly the version from Daredevil, to go to a friend for help, Curtis is a nice addition to The Punisher's cast. He acts as the representative of Frank's better angels and also shines a light on a different kind of veteran from Frank and Lewis.

Unlike them, Curtis' leftover trauma from the army is physical, as he lost his leg in a bomb blast. Yet, though it's difficult some days, he turns his depression around to coach other veterans through the difficult period of adjusting back into society.

The only trouble with Curtis' character is that he becomes a bit of a 'damsel-in-distress' for Frank to save. Overall, though, he's a likeable guy who thankfully survived the season (just about).


6. Sarah Lieberman

The Punisher David Sarah Lieberman
Netflix

The addition of the Lieberman family was a brilliant move as it generated some really interesting character drama on several different fronts. Firstly, it offered Frank the opportunity to gain a surrogate family to watch out for, while also bringing his pain back to the surface. For Micro, it meant that he had to sit and watch Frank practically move in on his loved ones, while he was laying low for their own safety.

While she was mostly an adjunct to those characters' arcs, then, Sarah Lieberman was a strong character in her own right, as well. In contrast to Frank's wife Maria, who only appears in rose-tinted flashbacks, Sarah is depicted as a three-dimensional person, a good mother who is struggling to hold it together for her kids in the wake of her husbands' 'death.'

Jaime Ray Newman was terrific in the role and her complicated chemistry with Jon Bernthal was spot-on (probably due to the fact that the pair had previously played husband and wife in 2006's Eastwick).


5. Karen Page

The Punisher Karen Page
Netflix

Karen Page and Frank Castle made quite a connection in Daredevil season 2, so Deborah Ann Woll's character had to crossover to The Punisher, as well. Sadly, she's only in 4 of the 13 episodes, but the New York Bulletin's top reporter still made a big impression.

For one thing, Karen acted as basically The Punisher's only tether to the wider Defendersverse. Besides, a couple of other Daredevil characters like Mitchell Ellison and Sergeant Mahoney.

The highlight, though, was her relationship with Frank developing to the next level. While Frank is still grieving for his late wife and Karen still has complicated feelings for Matt (well, we assume - the lawyer doesn't get a mention), the pair do share a brief but passionate kiss upon their last meeting in the show.

Hopefully we'll see this romance explored even more in season 2. Matt and Karen are probably Daredevil's endgame couple, but Frank and Karen might actually be a more interesting match.


4. Dinah Madani

The punisher Madani
Netflix

As I said earlier, the central conspiracy storyline of The Punisher was fairly underwhelming, which sadly means that a lot of the Homeland Security stuff led by Dinah Madani was still not as good as it could have been, either. However, the character herself was a strong one, with Amber Revah Rose rising above the sometimes overly-familiar writing to make Dinah a worthy co-protagonist for the show.

In effect, Dinah had a similar character arc to Luke Cage's Misty Knight, in that she is an officer of the law whose end goals happen to align with a vigilante. However, the dynamic between Frank and Dinah remains frosty throughout, and therefore more interesting - they're just situational allies rather than categorically on the same side.

All in all, Dinah is another in the gratefully long line of tough, capable but still well-rounded and flawed women in the Marvel-Netflix shows. It should be interesting to see how Frank and Dinah cross paths again in season 2.


3. David Lieberman

Punisher Netflix Micro
Netflix

There's a reason Micro has only appeared in one out of three movies featuring the Punisher so far - Frank's not really the kind of hero who works well with others at all, let alone the sort to have a sidekick. The Netflix show nails it perfectly, though, by having Micro and Punisher start as uneasy allies brought together by circumstance, with a genuine friendship growing out of that.

In contrast to the sleazier character from the comics, the show's version of David Lieberman is a good guy through and through and his non-violent methods provide a nice contrast to Frank.

The motivation to get back home to his family is a neat one that ensures we sympathize with him. Much like with Daredevil's Foggy, a lesser show would cast Micro as comic relief but The Punisher makes him a dramatic foil for Frank's character.

Ebon Moss-Bachrach excels in the part, making Micro a relatable everyman forced into a horrible situation. You might not always be on Frank's side, but it's impossible not to root for David.


2. Billy Russo

The Punisher Billy Russo
Netflix

When Ben Barnes was cast as Billy Russo, Marvel comics fans knew one thing - that the character would become Jigsaw, the Punisher's nemesis with the mangled face, at some point.

Cleverly, then, the show plays with our expectations and transforms the supervillain into a totally unrecognisable character - a charming old buddy of Frank's who's apparently a good guy. Of course, the rug is pulled halfway through the season and the truth comes out that Billy is working for Agent Orange.

Once this is out of the bag, Barnes - who previously proved he could play a b*stard in Westworld - gives a great performance as Russo's true cruel nature comes to the fore. Thanks to the added connection to Frank, Russo's a stronger character than the comics version. When the climactic moment comes and Frank rams his face into a mirror, it's simultaneously horrifying and satisfying to see the birth of the supervillain.

The only problem is that he's subservient to Agent Orange, but this should be fixed for season 2, when Jigsaw emerges to get his revenge on the Punisher.


1. Frank Castle

The Punisher Jon Bernthal
Netflix

This might seem like an obvious pick for the top spot - the show is called The Punisher, after all. However, the heroes of previous Marvel-Netflix shows haven't always been the best character on display (need I remind you of Iron Fist again?). In this case, though, Frank Castle is far and away the best thing about his own series.

A great deal of that is due to Jon Bernthal. As mentioned earlier, the current climate could make it tough to feel anything for Frank, but Bernthal manages to make us care thanks to the nuance he imbues his performance with, which allows us to see an unexpected amount of humanity beneath the Punisher's armour. The Defenders shows are stuffed with terrific actors, but Bernthal's performance in this season is one of the finest of the bunch.

The writing also serves Frank well as he even goes on a kind of journey of self-discovery across the run, ending it by talking through his problems at a support group. Hopefully he hasn't worked through all his issues, though, so that we can see him don the skull motif again in a follow-up season.


Contributor
Contributor

Spewing words on the internet daily. You can also read my stuff at StarburstMagazine.Com, WeGotThisCovered and TheQuiz.Com.