How I Met Your Mother: 10 Best Episodes

It's over now, but there's been plenty of cracking episodes down the years...

It is hard to believe it now but How I Met Your Mother teetered between renewal and cancellation in its first two seasons. On Monday it wrapped up its ninth and final season and it did so as primetime's third highest rated comedy. While the very title of the show placed the focus on the story of how Josh Radnor's Ted Mosby met the mother of his children, it soon became clear that the focus was more on the lives and friendship of Ted and his friends. It was in that element that the show excelled and found its audience of diehard fans, all thanks to its incredibly likeable cast. Alyson Hannigan and Neil Patrick Harris were no strangers to television after their previous successes in Buffy and Doogie Howser, M.D. respectively, with Hannigan also coming off the back of the American Pie series. They were rounded out with relative unknowns Cobie Smulders and Jason Segel who have both launched into big Hollywood roles since making their name in the CBS sitcom. Now that the series has reached its long awaited conclusion, it is the perfect time to take a look back at the greatest episodes of its nine year run. Thanks to the controversial nature of both the finale itself and its implications on developments throughout the series history, the episode and the events of it are not being factored into this list. As you might expect, spoilers are contained within, so if you still haven't seen the show to its ending consider yourself warned.

10. The Time Travelers (Season 8, Episode 20)

The set-up is a bit surreal for a sitcom but after turning down Barney's invitation to Robots Versus Wrestlers Ted is told by Barney that he will regret this decision in 20 years. Then the bizarreness begins. Various versions of Ted and Barney, and at one point "coat-check girl", all telling him why he should (or in some cases shouldn't) go to Robots Versus Wrestlers. The three different timed versions of the duo end up singing an a cappella version of Billy Joel's 'The Longest Time'. At the same time Marshall and Robin have a big disagreement about naming rights to a cocktail after Marshall orders his "Minnesota Tidal Wave" at MacLaren's only to find Carl calling it "the Robin Scherbatsky". An annoyed Marshall challenges Robin to a dance-off, and after the two prank each other, Lily agrees to allow it. Ted returns to Barney in the booth, who tells him that the whole cocktail dance-off incident happened five years ago and Ted is actually sat all alone with a single ticket as he prepares to go to the event alone. As Future Ted ponders over what other things he would've done that night instead, including imagining himself introducing himself to The Mother 45 days before they actually meet, the episode takes a melancholy turn and that is where a lot of the strength of this well crafted episode lies. Trivia Fact: The menu Barney holds when arguing with Robin about their caterer is for Gourmet M.D., the catering company of Neil Patrick Harris's real life partner David Burtka (who himself plays Scooter in the series).

9. Come On! (Season 1, Episode 22)

The finale of HIMYM's first season is all about Ted's "final" attempt to get Robin. While viewers may have grown frustrated with Ted's nine year refusal to move on from her will know that this wasn't the last attempt, it is the most ambitious. In typical Ted fashion it was a grand romantic gesture, as he got a quartet in Robin's apartment playing blue instruments as a callback to their first date in the Blue Horn. However her answer to his heartfelt confession is one of indecision. Ted refuses to give up, creating rain in order to prevent her camping trip with co-anchor Sandy Rivers. It is only then that he gets what he desired and kisses her in the rain. It has been slightly dampened by future seasons but this is Ted at his most romantic and to see him get a rare pay-off in his love life is a great moment. The foreshadowing of the episode is also its strength, as Barney is severely opposed to Ted continuing to try to get Robin (it is later revealed that he has feelings for her). An even bigger foreshadowing comes in the ending's emotional swerve, as Future Ted speaks about how "in one night everything changed." Little did viewers know just how much had changed, as the jubilant Ted got back to the apartment to find Marshall sat on the front porch with Lily's engagement ring in his hand. The seemingly unbreakable couple were split by Lily suddenly running away to San Francisco just weeks before they were due to be married. Trivia Fact: Neil Patrick Harris cried at the end of the episode upon watching it for the first time.

8. Pilot (Season 1, Episode 1)

Immediately setting up the unique formatting of the show with Future Ted (voiced by Bob Saget) in 2030 beginning to tell his children the story of how he met their mother, it was clear that this was a different take to the usual sitcom set-up. The pilot then proceeds to tell the story of how Ted, who is searching for "the one", met Robin whom he immediately fell for. She seems a perfect match for him and after a successful first date and a romantic gesture of stealing the blue horn from the restaurant, he prematurely proclaims his love for her. A move like that would seemingly blow his chances but yet when he leaves without kissing her he wonders if he had missed "the signal" (it would be revealed eight years later that he had) and HIMYM had set up their Ross and Rachel. Only for Future Ted to rule out the cliché by telling his children that it was the story of how met their Aunt Robin. As well as the great introduction to Ted and Robin the show introduced the immediately loveable couple of Marshall (who is preparing to propose) and his college sweetheart Lily, and the show's breakout character, serial womaniser Barney Stinson. With so many of the show's catchphrases, signature character traits and recurring minor characters established within the space of half an hour in many ways it felt like viewers were being dropped into an existing show rather than being introduced to the characters for the first time. Trivia Fact: Jennifer Love Hewitt turned down the role of Robin Scherbatsky, before relative unknown Cobie Smulders was cast. Bays and Thomas are thankful for the outcome as "when Ted's seeing her for the first time, America's seeing her for the first time."

7. The Platinum Rule (Season 3, Episode 11)

One of HIMYM's finest examples of its time jumping exploits. As Ted prepares to go on a date with Stella, the doctor who is to remove his "tramp stamp" tattoo, the gang try to persuade him that it is a bad idea. The fact that Stella (who doesn't appear in the episode but is revealed in later episodes to be Scrubs' Sarah Chalke) ends up in a lengthy relationship with Ted that ends in disaster as he is left at the alter for her ex, only adds to the importance of the message his friends are trying to give him via another one of Barney's theories: The Platinum Rule - never, ever, ever "love" thy neighbour. They illustrate their point by relaying to Ted the eight stages of why relationships with someone you see on a regular basis never work out, through each of their own individual experiences. Barney was the first with Wendy the Waitress in 2005, before he tried to stop Marshall and Lily repeating with their neighbours in '06 and finally Robin in '07 with co-anchor Curt Irons. The three stories are all funny for their separate reasons that all fit their character perfectly with Robin giving in because of hockey, Marshall and Lily innocently going along with their clingy neighbours activities and Barney's over-the-top paranoia of believing that Wendy wants to kill him after they break up. The fact that Barney completely overreacted, and therefore almost disproves the entire theory, is called out by everyone but as usual it doesn't deter him from what he views as the truth. Trivia Fact: This was the final episode before the 2007-08 Writer's Guild of America Strike that stopped production for 100 days.

6. The Final Page (Season 8, Episodes 11 & 12)

A two-part episode that is best known for the twist that Barney's inexplicable relationship with Patrice (as well as some previous season 8 moments) had all been part of an elaborate play to win back Robin and propose to her. Robin naturally feels manipulated and lied to, saying she could never be with a man like that. Until Barney tells her to turn the page which has the final step of 'The Robin' play: "Hope she says yes." This leads to the proposal, which she accepts ending both her inability to commit and Barney's womanising ways. The journey taken to get to that point is just as strong, as Barney spends nearly the entirety of part one jinxed (complete with an explanation of why Barney takes them so seriously). Once alone Barney tricks Ted into breaking the jinx by bringing out a wedding ring. He proceeds to tell Ted how he is going to propose to Patrice on the roof of the WWN building the next night, knowing that Ted will not be able to keep it a secret from Robin. During Barney's silence, the first part of the episode centred around the idea of a mental "pit" the gang each found themselves in because of the show's running theme of an inability to move on, only this time it was from grudges. The 'Silence of the Lambs' inspired idea provided both comedy and drama, with the trip to Wesleyan College for Ted to confront his professor and Marshall and Lily bumping into their obsessed college friend Daryl (played by Seth Green) while Robin tackled her own issues with Patrice when planning to fire her out of jealousy. With Marshall and Lily gone home to baby Marvin, Ted makes the ultimate sacrifice by sending Robin to Barney, he is left celebrating the achievement of his dream at the opening of the new GNB building all alone. Ted has had a lot of moments of feeling alone in the show's history but this has to be the most bittersweet. Trivia Fact: Carter Bays revealed that the influence for the "long con" for Barney to win Robin was inspired by the final run of episodes in the fourth season of Breaking Bad.

5. How Your Mother Met Me (Season 9, Episode 16)

HIMYM fans had been crying out for more of Cristin Milioti as The Mother during season 9, and to celebrate the 200th episode of the series they got exactly that. The Mother-centric episode, complete with her own version of the title sequence, was a charming insight into the titular character that the audience knew little about and showed all viewers what a wonderful choice Milioti was to play one of television's most awaited reveals. The episode took an immediately sombre tone as on her 21st birthday The Mother received the news that her boyfriend Max had died. Believing that he was "the one" much of the episode thereafter focused on her trying to move on in a perfect parallel of Ted's own struggles with Robin, but with a twist. She did eventually find the strength to move on in the present day as her boyfriend Louis proposes to her at the Farhampton Inn. Instead of giving him an answer she goes outside to make a moving speech to Max about knowing she needs to find a way to move on and declines the proposal. This leads to Curtis finally being able to tackle his worries for the single Ted by placing her in the room next to his, where she goes on to display Milioti's Broadway talents with a ukelele rendition of La Vie En Rose. It isn't just the emotional story of The Mother's struggle to move on that gives this milestone episode such strength, the supporting cast that comprise her friend group are surprisingly well realised characters to say that most of them are introduced solely for the one episode. The return of Cindy helped the case, but Kelly, Louis and Darren were all well-realised characters to help explain The Mother's history. The endless references and showing The Mother's involvement in existing scenes made sure that Bays and Thomas showed viewers how The Mother was always close by, and furthermore explained just how Ted had so many near misses in meeting her. It was also revealed that she was the first exception to Mitch's Naked Man "2 out of 3 rule" and her presence in Ted's wrong classroom on his first day as a teacher. Trivia Fact: By showing that The Mother's 21st birthday was during the events of 'Pilot', where Ted states he was 27, the episode reveals that there is a 6 year age gap between the two.

4. Slap Bet (Season 2, Episode 9)

Who could ever forget the debut of Robin Sparkles? After endless debate between Marshall and Barney over Robin's hatred of malls, Bays and Thomas pulled the rug from underneath viewers as the truth was revealed. And no-one expected what was coming. As a teenager Robin had been a pop sensation under the name Robin Sparkles with her hit 'Let's Go To The Mall'. Channelling the very cheesiest of 80's bubblegum pop music for the music video, it was an instant fan favourite. This episode also introduced another important recurring feature to the HIMYM lore: the slap bet. Marshall and Barney's differing opinions over Robin's secret (Marshall sided with wedding, Barney with porn) in a slap bet. Thanks to premature slaps in declarations of victory the eventual resulting punishment is a choice for Barney: be slapped ten times immediately or five times at any future point. Barney chooses the five but Marshall points out that he must live in constant fear of being slapped at any time, beginning another of the shows longest running gags that spawned the likes of the excellent 'Slapsgiving' episode. Trivia Fact: Originally titled 'Robin Sparkles,' the episode name was changed to preserve the surprise reveal.

3. The End of the Aisle (Season 9, Episode 22)

As the show enters the final half hour of Robin and Barney's wedding, viewers finally catch up to the panic of both the bride and groom as glimpsed in the finales of previous seasons. Barney's panic is actually about getting his vows right, while it is Robin who is having doubts thanks to one more moment of thinking Ted is the logical option. Thankfully Ted shuts down her concerns and tries to show her that Barney is perfect for her. But it is only when Ted is nowhere to be found that Robin's mind is made up, as Barney confesses to her he only needs one vow, to always be honest. The wedding finally happens and Robin becomes Mrs Stinson. Meanwhile Marshall and Lily make an impromptu unofficial vow renewal, acknowledging that wedding vows don't account for people evolving and growing as personalities and so breaking the original ones is natural and unimportant. It is Barney's witnessing of this that inspires him into the honesty vow as he once again shows his admiration for the couple and how he aspires to be as good a couple as them. Ted's story was focused around how he needs to step back and remove himself from the Robin scenario for both the sake of their relationship and his own mind, something which he had originally had in mind when deciding to move to Chicago but he failed to truly stick to. The episode puts Ted in complete position ready to meet The Mother in the finale, with nothing else on his mind, and if you don't factor in the final two minutes of the finale this episode was the perfect precursor to it. Trivia Fact: The score entitled 'The Robin' plays during the episode, it first debuted in The Final Page - Part 2.

2. Symphony of Illumination (Season 7, Episode 12)

In a formatting twist the episode opens with Future Robin talking to her children, revealing that Barney is their father. This follows the cliffhanger set up by the previous episode 'The Rebound Girl' where Robin reveals to Barney that she is pregnant. She rules out the possibility of Kevin, who she was dating, because they haven't slept together but the more shocking news was Barney's excitement at the prospect of becoming a father. The two see a doctor who informs them that Robin is not in fact pregnant, something that comes as a relief to both of them after Barney had seen an old friend whose life had been destroyed by fatherhood. The doctor's news wasn't finished there though as Robin's mood did a 180 with the heartbreaking news that she cannot have children. Deciding to hide it from her friends because their reactions don't help her, she pretends to be upset about not being able to compete in the Canadian pole vault team. Each of the group react in the exact way she worried they would, and she eventually confides that even though she never wanted to be "a pole vaulter" it hurts to know that it will never be an option if she changes her mind. It is revealed that the entire storytelling to her children had been imagined, as she sits alone on a bench in Central Park drinking eggnog and the usually emotionally anchored Robin is a completely broken mess. Cue Ted, who despite not harbouring romantic interests for her at this time would still do anything he could to make her smile and show her that she "is never alone." He sets up a lights show for her at their apartment to try and cheer her up without needing to know what the problem really was. The emotional rollercoaster that Cobie Smulder's excellent performance takes the viewer on during the half hour is enough to earn such a high placement in the history of the show. Trivia Fact: This is the first time an episode was told from a point of view other than Ted's, which would be repeated by The Mother in the 200th episode and by Marshall in 'Bedtime Stories'.

1. Bad News (Season 6, Episode 13)

Lily and Marshall spent the whole episode worrying about receiving bad news about their fertility checks. Everything turns out okay for the couple as they are both confirmed to be fertile and can continue attempting to have a baby. Marshall waits outside MacLaren's to tell Lily the good news but Marshall and the viewer are blind-sided by the episode title delivering on its threat instead. Lily tells Marshall that his dad has died of a heart attack. The closing scene is hands down one of televisions greatest and saddest death scenes despite it being for a non-regular character who dies off -creen. The performances from Segel and Hannigan are faultless, filled with the kind of raw emotion that makes it seem so real. Marshall's "I'm not ready for this" is heartbreaking for the double meaning of it, as the ever-optimist is shaken by his father's death and also gets his first doubts about fatherhood. Marshall does get to have a tender final time seeing his father with his parents telling him that they will love him no matter what the outcome of the fertility tests are and that there are other options to have children if needs be. The episode is also well known for its use of ordinary objects as a countdown to the bad news, ending with the expired parking meter after the news is told. There is also some good comedy running throughout the episode alongside the tragic drama, including finally discovering Barney's real doppelgänger and Barney meeting him himself while Robin has troubles when she discovers that the lead anchor at her new job is old colleague Sandy Rivers. Trivia Fact: In order to keep the ending a secret Segel and Hannigan were led to believe that the news would be that Lily is pregnant until just before shooting the scene. There was only one take shot. Agree? Disagree? Sound off in the comments what your favourite episodes of How I Met Your Mother were.

Contributor
Contributor

Founder of ForTheRecordNews.com; he is a long time fan of wrestling, television, film, sports and video games from North Yorkshire.