New Girl: Every Main Character, Ranked
Apartment 4D's finest.
When you think about the very best that the US sitcom genre has to offer, it's easy for your mind to automatically go to the likes of Friends, The Office, and Brooklyn Nine-Nine. However, though it doesn't get nearly the same level of respect as these other shows, New Girl absolutely deserves to be in this conversation.
Based around a group of friends and their new roommate in L.A, the show struck a wonderful balance of goofy humour and genuine heart, and is an utter joy to watch. No matter how many times you've sat through it before, a rewatch of New Girl is never a bad idea.
One of the biggest reasons for this success is, of course, the characters. It's one thing to have strong writing and a compelling plot, but how these characters are portrayed on the screen, and their relationships with each other, are what make New Girl both as good as it is, and as unique.
For the most part, every main character throughout the series has been incredibly well received and loved. However, some are always going to be more popular than others, and one in particular, fell a little short of the rest...
9. Reagan
Needless to say, this list will cover the topic of Jess Day much closer to the top. She was the heart and soul of the show, she was the new girl for which it was titled, and was loved by everyone. Why then, when Zooey Deschanel left at the beginning of season five to go on maternity leave, was she replaced with a character who couldn't have been more her opposite?
Megan Fox came to town as Reagan, something of a temporary Jess replacement, and was a cold, hard business woman who didn't really fit in with the show's vibe at all.
Apart from being a replacement for Jess in terms of a fourth occupant of apartment 4D, she also became the main love interest for Nick for a while. In reality, she wasn't a good fit for either purpose, and though she did eventually ease into the quirkiness of the group, she mainly just highlighted how much the show needed and missed Zooey Deschanel.
Perhaps however, the most damning evidence for why Reagan falls dead last on this list is that she couldn't even be bothered to read the Pepperwood Chronicles!
8. Robby
Robby is the only character on this list who was never a member of the core group, but as he as appeared in more episodes than Reagan, it seemed unfair to leave him out. He certainly made an impression during his time on screen.
Originally brought in as Cece's rebound from her casual relationship with Schmidt, as just about the exact opposite of New Girl's resident douchebag, Robby was an utter ray of sunshine every time he appeared on screen. Even when his teeth were shattered in a freak weightlifting accident, he was still smiling.
Though he never quite worked with Cece, and they were never going to stay together, Robby had a new lease of life when he started dating Jess. They were far better of a match, and we got to learn more about his incredible life, from playing bass on a Santana album, to saving Elon Musk's life and having a PBS documentary about him.
His story on New Girl came to something of an unsavory end as it was revealed that he and Jess were actually related, but had he appeared in more episodes, he may well have ended up further along on this list.
7. Aly
As soon as New Girl started, there was almost immediate sexual tension between Nick and Jess, and Schmidt and Cece. These were two on and off couples that were made for each other from the start, but it took a little while longer for someone to come into Winston's life in the same manner.
After the likes of Shelby and Rhonda left Winny the Bish out of luck in the love department, he joined the LAPD and found his soul mate in his partner, Aly.
Straight away, in spite of Nick and Coach's concerns, Aly proved that she was a certified badass, a great cop, and wasn't about to take crap from anyone. Her relationship with Tripp kept her from pursuing anything deeper with Winston originally, but she finally realised what a great guy she had right in front of her, and was the best thing that ever happened to him.
Like several other characters in New Girl, it took Aly a while to get used to the weirdness of the group, but once she embraced it, she was bringing them to her bedroom for a bizarre ceremony of naming her son's godparents like it was a normal thing to do.
6. Coach
After appearing in the pilot episode of New Girl, Damon Wayans Jr. was replaced by Lamorne Morris for the series moving forward. It wasn't until season three that Coach returned to apartment 4D to take up a major recurring role in the series.
With Coach came his own brand of strangely intense humour that was essentially centred around sports, masculinity, and the inability to speak to or be friends with women. However, this was balanced well with the same kind of weird energy that typically gelled the group together throughout the years.
He initially had no interest in being friends with Jess, who he genuinely thought was called Jebecca, but as the series went on he became a lot more tolerable. However, fans can certainly be glad they got Winston for the first few seasons instead.
He properly entered the series late, and he left early, as he moved to New York to be with his girlfriend May on the East Coast. This only gave fans two full seasons of Coach, and though he was slightly more one dimensional than many of the other main characters, more time throughout the series may well have changed this.
5. Cece
Is there a character on New Girl that went through more of a transformation from the first episode to the last than Cece Parekh? Though not one of the main group that actually lived in apartment 4D, Hannah Simone's character did appear in every single episode, and was virtually unrecognisable by the end of season seven.
To begin with she was a shallow model who was only interested in dating idiots who were no good for her, and hiding her relationship with Schimdt for the sake of her own pride and ego. She thought she was better than him, but thankfully, she changed her mind about a lot of things.
When she started working with Nick at the bar she was given another dimension, before starting Cece's boys and becoming a mother to Ruth. Instead of only thinking of herself, she became a far more rounded character and person.
Her friendship with Jess is beautiful throughout the entire series, however it can't be understated how important it was that she end up with Schmidt. Kyle, Robby, Coach, and Shivrang were all wrong for her, there was only ever one person that was going to make her happy and allow her to flourish into the person she became.
4. Winston
Cece went through quite a transformation for the better throughout the years, and while Winston went through arguably as big of a transformation of his character, quite how good it was is up for debate.
After missing the pilot episode, Winston moved in as the basketball superstar who was way cooler than any of the people he shared the loft with. Over time however, he became goofier and goofier, and though he joined the police force, making a huge positive step in his life in the process, he was one of the dumbest characters on the entire show.
He was usually oblivious to the things going on around him, he simply didn't know how to work a good prank despite believing he was a master, and his relationship with Ferguson was questionable at best. However, having said that, his heart was easily the biggest in the entire show, sharing it with everyone in the loft.
As he seemed to grow denser and denser, his sense of ego disappeared, and he was able to just have fun and be happy with his friends. Who didn't love seeing a classic Cece-Winston mess around?
3. Nick
Nick Miller was once described by Cece as the illest of the ill, while Jess simply said that he never did anything. As far as those two statements go, the latter is certainly the most accurate, at least for the majority of the show.
He was a grumpy old man trapped inside a relatively young man's body, he dropped out of law school to become a bartender, his credit score was so low he was laughed out of the mobile phone store, and he never trusted either the internet, or computers in general.
However, in spite of all this, of all the mistrust and the social skill trouble, Nick still managed to be one of the most lovable characters in the entire show. He clicked perfectly with Jess, and once he realised that Reagan wasn't the one for him, he finally allowed himself to be happy with her.
There were a lot of times before he got together with Jess, and even when they were together the first time around, where Nick actually showed how cruel he could be. However, this was definitely a minority, and most of the time, his relationship with Jess and bromance with Schmidt were always highlights of just about every episode of the show.
2. Schmidt
Many people will have swear jars in their homes, where they can throw a bit of money every time they say something they shouldn't as something of a punishment. Apartment 4D however, exclusively for the benefit of Schmidt, had a douchebag jar, to punish him for saying some of the most cringeworthy things imaginable.
In theory, Schmidt should not be a likeable character. Aside from being one of the biggest douches in the show, with the exception of Benjamin, he is incredibly money driven, arrogant, and looks down on just about everyone around him.
However, in a similar way that, on paper, Nick shouldn't be as lovable as he is, Schmidt is one of the most popular characters in New Girl history. He isn't ashamed of his douchey tendencies, and even leans in to them with hair chutney, a binder with pictures of him modeling his own suits, and personalised condoms, and we love him for it.
As the only male in an otherwise female office, and being overweight throughout his childhood, there were some insecurities that he battled through, and even though he spent his entire life building from his fat teenage years to being a huge professional success, he gave it all up to spend more time with his daughter. What could possibly be better than a good, devoted father?
1. Jess
Every main character on New Girl, with the exception of Reagan, has been wonderfully written, had a fine balance between humour and heart, and brought joy to fans for years. However, there is only one Jessica Day, and no one else can really even come close to her.
Without Jess, there is no show. Even with Nick, Schmidt, and Coach, who would have wanted to see what went on in apartment 4D without Jess? It was her coming into their lives that made the story worth telling, as her uncompromising and unapologetic optimism eventually won everybody over.
The humour in New Girl is typically based around awkwardness, weirdness, and downright goofiness. Is there anyone who defines that more than Jess? If you're not sure of the answer, go and watch her trying to seduce Paul Genzlinger, or impress millennials with her Urkel impression.
It is simply impossible not to love Jessica Day. Even cold hearted grumps like Nick Miller, Remy the superintendent, and the guy who pulled a gun on her in a car park are impervious to the charms of her smile.