New Star Trek Series: 10 Characters Who Could Be Brought Back
Recently you saw me set out the 10 Rules The New Star Trek Show Must Follow, and now I'm going to suggest who I think could be brought back in that series. We've all got our ideas about who should be in the new Star Trek series, when it gets made (because let's be honest, the franchise makes too much money in the cinema for CBS to continue to avoid creating a new television show). Even the likes of Rolling Stone magazine have suggested that the show returns to its TV roots with a new series featuring the crew of The Next Generation using the same actors no less. But really, if you're going to go that route then why stop at only using those characters? In the same time period you have the characters from both Deep Space Nine and Voyager all of whom would be the perfect age now to play their characters if you set the new series some twelve years after the USS Voyager returned to the Alpha Quadrant. In fact, the only thing we know canon-wise about those characters is that Kathryn Janeway is now an Admiral. These time periods have been covered by the relaunch series of Deep Space Nine and Voyager. There has been some interesting plot points, but the new series shouldn't feel tied to any of them. In fact some, like the death of the Borg, I'd deliberately avoid repeating in the series. This would be similar to what happened with Doctor Who when it had the Virgin New Adventures following the 7th Doctor. You also have the problem of Star Trek: Online, which while it has some great ideas such as the Undine and the gently simmering threat of the Iconians it is likely that any new television series will want to strike out on its own and probably undermine all the plot-lines in STO. But which characters could feasibly transfer to a new series? Would the actors want to return, and furthermore what could we do with them once they're in the show?
Close runners up for the top ten include:
Porthos Because we all know that he's secretly a scout from an immortal alien species that has been observing humanity for centuries in the guise of a Beagle. Sneaky, right? What? That isn't canon? But how else could the dog get a mention in Abram's first Star Trek film? Molly O'Brien/Kirayoshi O'Brien/Naomi Wildman/Miral Paris The kids from Deep Space Nine and Voyager. They're so young in those series that they would be fairly easy to write into any new show post Voyager. Although I'm not sure Scarlett Pomer's face is improved by glueing four Hershey's kisses to her forehead.10. Odo
The last we saw of Odo was him descending into the Great Link on the Founder's homeworld. Now given the importance that they all saw in Odo, it could be expected that he would eventually become what is essentially the Dominion Ambassador to the Federation. After all, he would be the only Founder to have the required balance between what the "solids" want and what is in the best interests of his people. Odo is also probably the easiest character to age out of those that previously wore a great deal of make up. After all, what if the look that the character was trying to achieve all along was exactly how René Auberjonois looks now? Odo has been systematically linked to what could be millions of other Founders, all of which have mastered the imitation of solids a great deal better than he did during the run of Deep Space Nine (barring the Cardassian neck trick, of course). So in order to have Odo appear, I'd simply have Auberjonois in the series without his previous level of make up as the character. This would also have the effect that he could show a greater range of emotion, which would be another example of the level of maturity that Odo has now reached over the time between the end of Deep Space Nine and the new show.
9. Sela
The human/Romulan hybrid of an alternative universe version of Tasha Yar. I wouldn't suggest that the new show should dwell on her past too much as it'll be quite the headache for new viewers. Best just to say that she's pretty much the only Romulan you'll ever pick out in a crowd if they all had their backs turned as she's the only blonde one. But seriously, Sela was awesome. She was a credible threat, who was genuinely sneaky and should have returned for more episodes of The Next Generation. She was pretty much in the same mould as Seska later in Voyager (and as much as I disliked the plotting of the episodes in Voyager during that period, Seska herself was great). Heck, I almost think I would have enjoyed Star Trek: Nemesis if they had done away with all that Picard clone nonsense and just had Sela instead. It would have had the personal element from Star Trek: First Contact that Picard had with the Borg instead of trying to artificially create it. There's a lot wrong with Nemesis, and none of it is Sela's fault. Star Trek: Online has Sela as one of the main antagonists (especially in the Romulan side of the story) and she is voiced by Denise Crosby. Crosby also appeared relatively recently in the Blood and Fire episode of fan series Star Trek: Phase II. Personally, I think if Star Trek came knocking with the Sela role again, she'd be up for it.
8. Q
Quite possible the best antagonists from The Next Generation, and I'm including the Borg in that statement. I think the only reason why he didn't appear in a film was because it would take too much to explain him to viewers who didn't see the television show. Everyone can pretty much understand zombie cyborgs who want to assimilate people plus you can explain the Borg by showing people rather than requiring one of the main characters to explain it by saying "Oh it's Q, he's an omnipotent being that likes to meddle with humans". But you have the time to show him properly in a television series. Plus, he's never appeared in a bad episode. Sure there's the one with the pig like aliens in Napoleonic costumes that was a bit weird. But they killed Wesley Crusher, so even that episode gets a free pass. Having Q in an episode of Star Trek is saying that it'll be average at worse, and usually good. Besides, if you run out of other ideas you can always have the lead character punch him. Q is effectively Loki in Star Trek. Q is ageless. Ish. He has the ability to change his own appearance at a whim. He also now has a son. But John de Lancie is also older. So Q would simply appear older. But how do we explain it? Why would we? It's Q. He doesn't need to explain himself to anyone. Besides John de Lancie is brilliant as an actor and any new series would be lucky to have him.
7. Wesley Crusher
Oh stop it. You all like Wesley. With his annoying habits (like saving the day) and the way he was written as if all the writers secretly wanted to be him... Ok Wesley was not everyone's cup of tea. That's for sure. Just look at the newsgroup alt.wesley.crusher.die.die.die. But we're not talking Wesley Crusher from the first few seasons of Star Trek: The Next Generation here. We're talking the Wesley Crusher that has gone off with the traveller and seen what is out there and has come back to warn Starfleet. He's now played by the Wil Wheaton that we've all seen and loved in the Big Bang Theory. The Wil Wheaton who regrets being a little jerk as Wesley and wants to redeem himself. The Wil Wheaton who should still be annoyed at getting cut from Nemesis. That Wesley Crusher and that Wil Wheaton. As I said, Wesley could come back to warn Starfleet and be stripped of his traveller-like powers in the process. He joins the crew to seek out the enemy that he knows is out there and effectively be the Neelix of the show (in a less chef-like and please, please, please, less irritating way). There would be outcry from the fans, but Wil Wheaton isn't 14 anymore and neither is his character. I think he would be a fantastic addition not only to the show but to the main cast he is after all, a fan of Star Trek now himself.
5 & 6. Worf and Martok
It actually makes pretty good sense to bring back both Worf and Martok. We'll take Martok first he's the Klingon Chancellor last time I checked, so presumably he would still hold that position (although he doesn't in Star Trek: Online). J.G. Hertzler is also playing a character under a bucketload of make up for Star Trek: Renegades, so he might be willing to resume the role of Martok especially as he also still does so at conventions. As for Michael Dorn as Worf... well he wants his own Captain Worf television show. So he wants to come back to the role. As for what role Worf himself would take, well there are a variety of possibilities. Captain is only one of them, as is Ambassador, Admiral, Commodore not to mention where Star Trek: Online places the character. Essentially if you are going to feature the inner workings of the Klingon government in a series set within about 20 years of post-Voyager then both of these characters should be involved.
4. Seven Of Nine
It would be interesting to see what becomes of Seven of Nine when she has spent more time as Annika Hansen than she did as a Borg. As for Jeri Ryan herself, she was recently cast in Ronald D. Moore's Helix. So she's still interested in appearing in science fiction. Jeri Ryan is a fine actress. As Seven she was deliberately wooden at times, and the character didn't really get an expressly long time in which to grow, which is unfortunate as the character filled the Data/Spock brief for the later years of Voyager. Also she was set up randomly with Chakotay at the end of the series, which just seemed baffling at the time so a legitimate romantic interest for her would be interesting. Perhaps she could be involved with our number three choice...
3. Data
Firstly, Brent Spiner has ruled out ever appearing as Data again because he feels that he has aged out of the role. He wanted the character to be killed off in Star Trek: Insurrection and finally got his way in Star Trek: Nemesis. But a backdoor was created to the resurrection of the character, by having his memories transferred to the android B4. Spiner returned as Arik Soong in Enterprise, in some of his best performances. But hear me out. Because the way to alleviate Spiner's concerns about being too old to play Data is to make Data appear older. So why would Data appear older? I'll tell you this love. Now the emotion chip installed on Data was lost with his body, but you can be sure the he and La Forge made many scans of it prior to installing it in Star Trek: Generations after all, it was previously broken and someone had to have fixed it. So they should be able to create a new chip. With that new chip, Data has the ability to love like a human and also feel sentimental and guilt. So in that sort of situation I think all it would take is for Data to enter into a long term relationship. His love begins to age, and after twenty years appears quite older than Data does he realises that this is affecting his relationship and be feels guilty. As seen in the final episode of The Next Generation, Data can change his hair. So why not his skin? Up until now he hasn't had a reason. Love makes people do crazy things, and one of them is to want to grow old with the person that you love. I find the concept of Data aging for that reason quite romantic. But then again I really liked Bicentennial Man. Mind you, you could also take that entire concept and equally apply it to Robert Picardo's The Doctor.
2. Nero
Ok, I take it that this is unlikely due to two major reasons. But hear me out. Firstly, let's address Eric Bana. Sure it's quite unlikely that he would agree to appear on a regular basis on a Star Trek television show. But that's not what I'm suggesting here. I'm suggesting that Nero is the antagonist for the very first episode (a traditional two parter of course) of the new series. He might sign on for such a significant role, especially seeing as we can expect that at least the pilot will get decent ratings. Also if the production was very accommodating to his availability increases the very low likelihood that Bana would appear in the series. But we can hope. As for Nero himself, it would actually be fairly straight forward to explain how he arrives. He arrived in the movie universe by going through a blackhole created by red matter, which also threw him into the past. So a blackhole created by red matter in the movie universe potentially could lead back to the prime universe. Of course the Nerada went back in a much less intact state than it did the first time, but characters in film and TV have survived worse. So Nero would be left back in the prime universe without a ship (although considering the Nerada was converted with Borg technology then who knows what sort of level of regenerative abilities it has) and plotting his revenge especially as in the prime universe, Vulcan is still intact.
1. Charles "Trip" Tucker III
Stop screaming fanboys. Yes, we could bring back Trip. Sure, he wasn't the most popular character from the most popular version of the show. Yes, it would completely wreck the Enterprise relaunch books. But I for one would love to see it, almost as a gift to the fans that the new show doesn't want to be the cruddy version of Enterprise and instead wants to give the viewers what they want. For those that don't know, Trip was killed in the last television episode of a Star Trek series to be shown. He was also given the most pitiful death you've ever seen on television. On a daily basis it seemed that he would get into worse scrapes than he did in that episode, but for some reason he did the equivalent of licking his fingers and deciding to use his body to complete a circuit. Despite him being the best engineer in Starfleet at the time. The books sought to fix this in the non-canon way by having him become a spy on Romulus with his death intending to be a complete cover up. But what if Trip was actually dragged into the future for some Temporal Cold War type thing (because the new series could also answer the question of who Future Guy actually was perhaps it was Trip himself). But bringing him into the future for a series would leave him entirely as a fish out of water, especially if the new series has a ship with transwarp capabilities (which I would suggest if we really wanted it to boldly go where no one has gone before). It would be interesting as he could effectively be that third person perspective on the other characters because he would be stranded out of time, knowing that he could not return as his "death" was ultimately required for the formation of the Federation.