Obi-Wan Kenobi Part I & II Review: 7 Ups & 2 Downs

Ewan McGregor returns to a Galaxy Far, Far Away with heavy baggage and scores to settle.

Obi-Wan Kenobi
Disney

Seventeen years after the harrowing events of Revenge of the Sith, and exactly forty-five years after the release of A New Hope, Obi-Wan Kenobi has finally returned to live-action form with his own TV miniseries. And though we're only two episodes in, the results of his return have already been very impressive.

Starring Ewan McGregor, the series takes place between the fall of the Republic and the events of A New Hope, and finds Kenobi cut off from the Force and living in exile on Tatooine, before being suddenly thrust into a mission of grave importance.

Nostalgic, surprising and chilling, Obi-Wan Kenobi's first two episodes have been a welcome return to classic Star Wars, adding effective depth to the drama of the Skywalker Saga whilst exploring the trauma and confliction of its title character, who's far from the man he once was.

With that in mind, from the impressive new characters to the slight flaws holding it back from greatness, here are 7 Ups and 2 Downs from the first two episodes of Obi-Wan Kenobi. Be warned, though: This review contains major spoilers.

DOWNS...

9. The Grand Inquisitor Is Thoroughly Wasted

Obi-Wan Kenobi The Grand Inquisitor
Disney+

One of the biggest talking points of the Obi-Wan Kenobi trailer came from its inclusion of the Grand Inquisitor, the powerful Jedi hunter first encountered in Star Wars Rebels. His appearance hinted at a major role throughout the show.

Unfortunately, this hasn't yet come to pass. Though Rupert Friend is adequately chilling in the role, the Grand Inquisitor acts as nothing more than an expository red herring, in place to signal the arrival of the show's real villain, the Third Sister.

Based on the trailers, it's possible to say we've not seen the last of him, despite his apparent death, but even so his role so far has been painfully underwhelming, and highlights just how many key characters have been reduced to walking plot points.

Along with Friend, Jimmy Smit's return as Bail Organa seems only to exist to set Kenobi's latest mission in motion, and Joel Egerton's fleeting appearance as Owen Lars was basically what we saw in the trailer.

It's early doors, of course, so there's a chance these characters come back in a big way that actually allows them to be a three dimensional person, but so far there's a lot of promise left unrealised.


8. It Takes A While Getting To Obi-Wan

Obi-Wan Kenobi Part II Organa
Disney+

Whilst Part II spends a lot more time focussed on Obi-Wan and his turmoil, Part I features the haunted Jedi a lot less than expected, instead shifting focus to other major characters spread throughout the galaxy.

Much of this early focus comes from Bail Organa, his wife Breha, and their adopted daughter, Princess Leia. These scenes allow audiences to see what Leia was like as a child, and how she lived before the destruction of her planet, but they also hinder the story in a big way.

With sprinklings of unwanted politics and overdrawn exposition explaining how rebellious Leia is, none of it's entirely bad, just overburdened and unnecessary.

The same can be said of the Inquisitors, who burst onto the scene in a menacing way, but are subsequently given nothing to do except set-up coming conflicts with heavy dialogue and frustratingly little action.

Ultimately, almost everything outside of Obi-Wan himself feels thin and tacked-on to set up the coming drama with little subtly. There are bright spots in there, but these kind of edges definitely need smoothed out in coming episodes.

Now, onto the positives.


UPS...


7. Both Episodes Are Genuinely Surprising

Obi-Wan Kenobi Part I Leia
Disney+

Perhaps the most remarkable thing about Obi-Wan Kenobi so far comes from how genuinely unpredictable it's been.

Though the trailer and first episode build-up hinted at the series being focussed on Obi-Wan and his attempts to protect Luke, the show effectively pulls the rug to reveal Leia as the focal point of the Jedi's latest adventure.

This unexpected relationship has its flaws - in A New Hope, Leia's message for aid hints she's never met Obi-Wan - but it also adds great depth to Obi-Wan's journey, and how he's still so loyal to his fallen apprentice.

Speaking of which, Part II's ending surely deserves to go down as one of the Star Wars franchise's most shocking moments, as the Third Sister reveals that Anakin Skywalker is still alive, shaking Obi-Wan to the core before cutting to a ravaged Darth Vader breathing heavily in a bacta tank.

The unexpected relationship between Obi-Wan and Leia, mixed with Vader's stunning return and some elegant cameos from Anthony Daniels' C-3P0 and Tamuera Morrison as an old clone trooper, help both episodes stay wonderfully fresh.

And if that last twist is to believed, the show's got plenty more tricks up its sleeve.


6. A New Villain Promises Big Things

Obi-Wan Kenobi Part II Reva & Owen
Disney+

Although some more time with the Grand Inquisitor would have been great to see, Obi-Wan's new foe Reva - the Third Sister - has already proven to be an exceptional addition to the fold.

Played by The Queen Gambit's Moses Ingram, Reva's single-minded desire to hunt down Obi-Wan is gripping from the off, painting her as a dangerous adversary whose past is sure to be explored deeply down the line.

At the moment, we know she used to be a Jedi before her mind was twisted by the Empire, and that her reckless abandon has made her come to blows with her own superiors. Her obsessiveness hints at a tragic backstory, most likely linked to Part I's opening flashback to the younglings escaping Order 66.

The potential is there to make Reva yet another haunted villain who's backstory adds more compelling strands to the evilness of the Empire, but also to explore an unseen part of Obi-Wan's post-Purge life.

Fingers crossed the show doesn't drop the ball.


5. The Thrilling Action

Obi-Wan Kenobi Part II
Disney+

For most of their run, Parts I and II feature little action, with the vast majority of the conflict being psychological and internalised.

That being said, the action we do get to see is fantastic. Fast-paced, brilliantly choreographed, and aided by Natalie Holt's atmospheric score, it's at once tense and high stakes, and effectively explores how Obi-Wan is cut off from the Force and down to using a blaster to fight.

The fact that Obi-Wan is less powerful makes each fight sequence feel genuinely threatening, as he's more easily hurt and uncomfortably out of his element.

It's great to see the series use its action to add something to the story, and even greater to see it's found a way to make Obi-Wan feel like he's in actual danger, despite the fact he's obviously making it out of the show alive.

And now that he's retrieved his lightsaber and tapped back into the Force to save Leia, the action's only going to get better. Especially with so many villains on his tail.


4. Ewan McGregor Is Brilliant

Obi-Wan Kenobi Part I Ewan McGregor
Disney+

Coming as a shock to absolutely no one, Ewan McGregor has already emerged from Obi-Wan Kenobi as its greatest strength, slipping back into his most famous role with the ease of a Jedi.

It's great, nostalgic fun to have McGregor back in the franchise, but it's even better to see how willing he is - even at this early stage in the game - to challenge himself with a deeper performance than the prequels ever allowed.

Playing a broken man haunted by his survival and plagued by visions of the friend he believes he failed, McGregor has barely touched the surface of Obi-Wan's mental anguish, but has already captured great tragedy within the Jedi's heart. There's even a brief but heartbreaking reference to Duchess Satine, his deceased love interest.

Don't let that description confuse you, though: This is still McGregor's Obi-Wan, so there's plenty of humour and playfulness scattered around to counteract his pain.

It's just that, in these first two episodes, the much more serious performance of Alec Guinness is already starting to show itself, and McGregor seems more than ready to explore Obi-Wan's darker side.


3. The Supporting Cast Almost Steal The Show

Obi-Wan Kenobi Part I Reva/Third Sister
Lucasfilm

As great as McGregor is as Obi-Wan Kenobi, there are moments throughout the first two episodes where he's almost overshadowed by his exceptional co-stars.

Though Rupert Friend is, as noted, underused, he still manages to emerge from his scenes as an intimidating force of evil and moral corruption. Likewise, Jimmy Smits just about overcomes the script's insistence on making him a walking piece of exposition by capturing the loving father within the serious politician.

Elsewhere, Moses Ingram is fantastic as Reva, a woman controlled by her own thirst for vengeance and power, but noticeably hiding something deep and sad under her villainous façade, and Kumail Nanjiani adds much needed humour as conflicted con artist Haja Estree.

Other supporting stars such as Joel Egerton and Fast & Furious's Sung Kang are also on solid form, though the true scene-stealer of the series at this point is surely Vivien Lyra Blair, who plays a young Princess Leia with such ferocity, humour, and innocence that one wonders how happy Carrie Fisher would've been watching her.

It's a sweet performance, far beyond her years, and promises big things for Blair's future. Like the rest of the cast, she's giving it all and making waves.


2. It's Intimate & Character-Driven

Obi-Wan Kenobi Part I
Disney+

There's a lot that can be said for Part I and II of Obi-Wan Kenobi and their ability to tell both a sweeping story across several different planets whilst maintaining their primary focus on character.

For all its beautiful set design and special effects, the main takeaway from the first two episodes has been how committed showrunner Deborah Chow is to telling an unseen part of Obi-Wan's story, by tapping into the Jedi's grief, dwindling hope, and perseverance.

It's a brilliant character study, first isolating him as a lonely exile and then throwing him head-first into a mission only he can complete.

The glimpses into the psyche of Leia and Reva also prove that the show - like all Star Wars - works best when it moves away from mindless spectacle and actively invests in the personalities at its centre.

Given the richness of Obi-Wan's backstory and the overwhelming tragedy of his life, the series has a great opportunity to ensure he remains one of the most compelling Star Wars characters. Parts I and II offer the perfect foundation.

Speaking of which...


1. It's A VERY Strong Start

Obi-Wan Kenobi Part II
Disney+

Overall, the best thing that can be said about Obi-Wan Kenobi's first two episodes is that they form a near-perfect start to a show that, should it maintain or even surpass this quality going forward, could go down as the finest live-action Star Wars show.

Creating a rich and vibrant world in which the Empire rules and the Jedi are no more, the series has already tapped into the complexities of a galaxy ruined by war, and has introduced half a dozens compelling characters with great stories to tell in the process.

It's easy to see these episodes as mere set-up for bigger things to come, but it's hard to argue with what they achieve, despite some brief flaws, in their own right. It's complex, mature, and adventurous in a way that manages to pay homage to the original trilogy, the prequels, and even The Clone Wars all at once.

With McGregor on top form, Hayden Christensen returning as Darth Vader, and new villains and anti-heroes lurking in every shadow, Obi-Wan Kenobi is off to an astonishingly good start. Hopefully things get even better from here.


Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/