Penny Dreadful Season 2: 10 Public Domain Characters Who Could Appear

With the first season over, who could pop up next season?

ShowtimeShowtimeWe're living in a new golden age of television. With stuff like Breaking Bad, Mad Men, Dexter and The Wire all hitting our screens within the past ten years, the small screen is now just as big an attraction as the big one. Penny Dreadful has continued that trend, with its first season having just wrapped. The second has been announced for 2015, so we can start to speculate the public domain characters who might appear next year. For the uninitiated, the core of the show is Victorian horror. Our ragtag band of protagonists are both original in nature like Vanessa Ives and Ethan Chandler and drawn from famous literary works such as Dr. Frankenstein, Dracula and Dorian Gray. With a warning for a few minor spoilers here for those who haven't watched the entire first season yet, let's put on our speculation caps and guesstimate who could pop up next season. These range from wild guesses to people who already may have links to what's already transpired. We had to knock up a few ground rules for this list. It'd have to be someone who fits the setting, you couldn't have Long John Silver rucking up post-Treasure Island as it would spoil the atmosphere somewhat. Also, they'd have to have a link, even if it's pretty tenuous, to what we've seen already in the first season. Alright then, away we go.

10. Professor Moriarty

movies.stackexchange.comBBCNo, not specifically the Moriarty shown above, but a version of him tailored for the horror setting of Penny Dreadful's Victorian London would be a good fit. It would introduce a more human enemy for the gang to square off against and in a world without Sherlock Holmes (which it would have to be for this to work) how terrifying would the presence of the Napoleon of Crime be? Who could stop him? Of course it'd be tough to try and top the various decent depictions of Moriarty that an inclusion like this would inevitably draw comparisons to. Both Jared Harris' steely confident portrayal and Andrew Scott's chew-the-furniture lunatic approach are either end of the spectrum here. We think Penny Dreadful's version should fall somewhere in the middle, mostly quiet but prone to fits of madness. Perhaps Fringe's John Noble is a good choice?

9. Tom Sawyer

imfdb.org20th Century FoxWe already have our link to the States in the character of Ethan Chandler, so why not introduce Sawyer as an old comrade of Ethan's? We're thinking along the lines of the Tom Sawyer we saw in League Of Extraordinary Gentleman, grown up and out to experience his share of adventure. This personality that Chandler projects to everyone and most of his character arc deals with the fact that those closest to him see through it and realise he's more complicated underneath. Introducing Sawyer as the man Ethan wishes he was could be an interesting dynamic, as well as seeing how Sawyer's more than likely gung ho attitude would be affected by Penny Dreadful's nightmarish Victorian London. Sawyer would have to be a blue eyed square jawed all-American boy, so we're thinking Supernatural's Jared Padalecki would be perfect for the combination of confidence and naivety we'd want for this incarnation.

8. Nikola Tesla

iotaproject.orgwikiNot much is known about Tesla's private life as he was a very private person. What if that was because if he told people what he'd be up to, nobody would believe him? We're picturing Tesla as a contemporary of Dr. Frankenstein. It'd perhaps explain where Frankenstein got a lot of the equipment we see in his lab, especially the stuff that lets him produce electrical currents for reanimation. As Dr. Frankenstein is quite serious most of the time, we'd have Tesla as his lighter hearted contemporary to begin with. Then as he discovers more and more about the nature of Frankenstein's research, he could become the voice of reason, warning Frankenstein of the dangers of playing God. Of course, Tesla wouldn't know about Caliban, at least not until it's too late. We're liking a guest starring role for Ralph Fiennes in the role. A big name actor playing Tesla would automatically lend importance to everything he says. In addition, Fiennes could bestow upon Tesla the level of gravitas needed to play the man supposedly responsible for creating free clean energy before his death took his idea to the grave with him.

7. Billy The Kid

jason.hedrick.blogspot.com20th Century FoxThe most famous gunslinger in the Wild West, the obvious link to the series here is Ethan Chandler. At this point, much of Ethan's past remains unknown, including why it was he sailed to London in the first place. We get an inkling at the end of the first season during its final episode from a couple of men sent to track him down. We can infer from that that he clearly did something considered outside of the law. What if he ran with Billy The Kid's gang? And then maybe Kid, having faked his own death (the recorded historical one) comes after him to either forcibly re-enlist him or get some sort of revenge for a perceived past slight against him. We want a dirtier rougher around the edges portrayal here, Billy should be Ethan's dark reflection. To accomplish that, we like Josh Brolin for the role. The grittiness he'd bring to the show would be tangible.

6. Randolph Carter

havetvargar.deviantart.comPublic DomainH.P. Lovecraft's occult investigator could easily feature in a young incarnation here, perhaps getting his first taste of the dark side that would compel him to undertake the many adventures he will later on go on to have in Lovecraft's stories. Perhaps having him as a young ward for Sir Malcolm Murray would be a good way to introduce him. His plot arc could end after one too many brushes with the other side causes Malcolm to send Carter off home again. The events of the show would act as a gap in Lovecraft's timeline for the character. Thomas Brodie-Sangster (Jojen Reed in Game Of Thrones) would be perfect as the young man with an inquisitive older mind. Also, the character himself would serve as a great gateway character for the audience, something the show is sometimes lacking.

5. Allan Pinkerton

dailyrecord.co.ukPublic DomainThe seeds for this man's appearance have actually already been sewn. In the final episode, the men we see confront Ethan Chandler in the pub introduce themselves as Pinkerton agents, before Ethan brutally slays them. The Pinkerton Detective Agency was a real life outfit based in the U.S. around that time period and they were renowned as being the world's first real private investigation firm. The fact that two agents would board a ship and pursue their prey overseas means Chandler must be a very important collar for them. Perhaps important enough to have the head of the agency, Allan Pinkerton himself, investigate when the men he sent turn up dead. We like Mad Men and Sherlock Holmes star Jared Harris in this role, Pinkerton as a determined bounty hunter trying to catch Chandler who is technically in the wrong.

4. Countess Elizabeth Bathory

mnn.comPublic DomainWe've had Dracula as a somewhat unseen primary antagonist thus far, having stolen away Mina and triggering the plot of the first season. So why not include the other prominent vampire myth? Countess Bathory was a Hungarian countess during the late 16th and early 17th century who was imprisoned for murdering hundreds of young girls and supposedly bathing in and drinking their blood. Comparable to the legend of Vlad The Impaler, on whom Dracula was based, Bathory would make another fantastic antagonist to the group to have to deal with. Whether she's allied with Dracula or possibly some sort of rivals (warring vampire clans could make things more interesting) she'd definitely fit in with the gothic sex appeal the show has going for it. Having played her once in the film Bathory: Countess Of Blood, we'd have Anna Friel reprise the role here in the series, perhaps playing her as some sort of vampiric royalty.

3. Dr. Jekyll/Mr. Hyde

gbdh.sadiron.comWarner Bros. PicturesAs far as cautionary tales go, this one fits the time period and makes a hell of a lot of sense. The theme of our group of heroes all having dark secrets they keep from one another is recurrent in the series, from Dr. Frankenstein's creation to Chandler's apparent lycanthropy. Perhaps Dr. Jekyll could be bought in as a replacement for the late Van Helsing but be forced to keep his arrogant evil side a secret in fear that his new employers would dutifully exterminate him. Maybe even have him responsible for the as-yet unsolved Ripper-esque murders that Chandler seem to think he may have committed. We'd also ensure our Mr Hyde is unlike the usual portrayal, like the one in the picture above. In an unlikely comparison, think The Nutty Professor here: Hyde would actually be super smooth and socially adept with the ladies, but obviously a completely deranged nutcase underneath. Jekyll, in contrast, would be quiet, unassuming and maybe even a little less physically attractive. The balance of learned man and deranged psychopath would need a talented hand, especially as the actor would be essentially playing two parts. The man for the job is our eyes is Toby Kebbell, one of the most underrated actors on the planet. He could easily pull off both the timid nature of Jekyll and the cocksure swagger of Hyde.

2. Spring Heeled Jack

spookyisles.comPublic DomainOne of the oldest persisting myths straight out of Victorian London, Spring Heeled Jack was supposedly this phantom figure who was sighted several times in and around London during the Victorian period. He was characterized by his demonic appearance and his ability to leap great heights and distances. Stories like this are fodder for Penny Dreadful, Spring Heeled Jack often being the focus of actual penny dreadful books at the time. Other than the sightings, not a lot is known about him, leaving the TV show some creative license when it comes to characterization and motive. We'd have him as a sort of renegade Batman-like figure with misunderstood goals. Perhaps the people he attacked were reprehensible people themselves, maybe cut-throats or crooked noblemen. Perhaps he is out for revenge against the upper classes for something that happened to him. If you're thinking of an actor to portray Penny Dreadful's answer to Batman, it'd have to be Jason Statham. He's an unusual choice for a more dramatic series, but he got to stretch his acting legs and give a good performance in the film Mockingbird. We're thinking that a similar portrayal here would work wonders.

1. Cthulhu

entropiaplanets.comPublic DomainBack to H.P. Lovecraft for our last entry and our pick is easily his most famous creation. Cthulhu is one of The Great Old Ones, a pantheon of gods who existed before the dawn of mankind. He sleeps beneath the sea in an ancient underwater city known as R'lyeh and has legions of worshippers who have foretold of his reawakening. During the last few episode of this season, Vanessa Ives, and subsequently Ethan Chandler, was possessed by some sort of malevolent unknown force. During Vanessa's conversation with it when it's inside Ethan, she identifies it as Satan. But what if she was wrong? What if instead, Chandler was the mouthpiece for the Dreaded Old One who sleeps beneath the sea? It'd be a nice twist and a way to introduce a little Lovecraftian mythos into the proceedings, especially if you have our previous suggestion of a young Randolph Carter present. Obviously, Cthulhu wouldn't be played by any one person, but if you're going to give him a proper voice at some point, mo-cap and voice actor extraordinaire Andy Serkis is the way to go here. So, Penny Dreadful fans? Agree? Disagree? Maybe you can think of a better actor/actress for these roles? Click on that comment box below and let us know!

Contributor

Just a jolly ol' pop culture nerd living just outside London in England. I dabble in a little bit of everything but specialise in wrestling, gaming and comic books.