Pros And Cons Of Binge Watching TV
The landscape of television has changed inordinately since the launch of Netflix, HBO GO, and other streaming entities (not to mention the initial release of television as DVD boxsets). Thanks to those mentioned, someone who missed the run of Lost can now watch all 6 seasons at their leisure, or can catch-up on Breaking Bad before the final season airs on August 11th. Netflixs decision to make a whole season available at once of their original programming was controversial and groundbreaking. When House of Cards premiered in January, viewers were able to watch it as quickly or slowly as they chose. The term binge watching has been floating around more and more and the conversation is intriguing. Is it better to binge watch shows vs. the traditional format of one episode a week? Here Im going to examine three pros and three cons of marathoning a series.
Pro The Novel Argument When talking about binge watching, its best applied when talking about serialized television. There are plenty of shows out there whose storylines, plot, development, and execution can be viewed as novelistic. David Simons The Wire is a great example. Simon often argues when viewers say that nothing happens in the first few episodes that if you read Moby Dick the first few chapters have the same nothing happened aspect. After all, you wouldnt read a chapter of a novel one-per-week style; you would read the whole book in the closest time frame that your schedule allows. Simon and Mad Mens Matthew Weiner have argued that episodes shouldnt be reviewed individually because the viewer doesnt know the pay-offs in the big picture. Its hard to say that nothing happens if you dont understand how the whole picture should be viewed. Con The Water Cooler Effect Each spring when Game of Thrones comes back on the air, I have a shared experience with millions of people each Sunday night. When Monday morning rolls around there are countless fans discussing and theorizing based off the shared experience we all had the night before. Shows built around suspense and mystery, like Homeland or Orphan Black, have an extra thrill because the week in between episodes causes us to spend hours thinking, discussing, blogging, and frequenting message boards until we know what is really in store. When watching The Sopranos or The Wire on DVD, it was hard to share my excitement when something amazing happened, because most people aren't caught up in those worlds at the same time.
Pro Payoffs Referring back to Simon and Weiners beef with episode reviews, when you watch a show all at once you get the payoff much sooner. When writers drop little Easter eggs or crumbs in episode one, when you get to episode twelve or thirteen days later (rather than months) the picture is clearer than it was, and its easier to appreciate the episodes as a piece of the puzzle rather than filler. For example, this past season of Boardwalk Empire had a slow start, focusing on plot lines involving Chalky Whites daughters boyfriend, the medical student, and then was seemingly abandoned for a chunk of the season, only to be brought back in a big manner. Having watched the season in one week (opposed to 12), I was less inclined to moan through the slower episodes because I knew the reward was coming. Con Spoilers (And yes, this paragraph may contain spoilersnotably for Showtimes Dexter) If you choose to sit on a show until you can stream the whole series or get the DVD set, you are subject to major spoilers. This is especially true if youre a pop-culture junky. Obviously, its wise to avoid message boards and even Wikipedia pages for spoilers (even IMDBs number of episodes an actor appears in has spoiled a show before), but shows reference other shows and aren't concerned if you havent caught-up on Game of Thrones or Dexter yet. Coming in late to a show can take the air out of a few gasps fans had during their week-to-week viewings. Even noticing Julie Benz was on No Ordinary Family during Dexters fifth season could connect the dots.
Pro You Have To Unless you want to miss out on some of the greatest shows of all time, youre going to have to binge watch. Unless you have the most extreme discipline and watch 86 episodes of The Sopranos over 86 weeks, but I have a feeling the writing and sheer addiction wouldn't allow that. The reality is, as much as I want TV to be the only thing I do, its not. People have to delegate time to television and that means that some shows slip through the cracks. Almost all of my favorite shows I either watched in its entirety post-live run, or I caught up on multiple seasons in order to watch its next season air live. Con The Emotional Connection of Years Dedication Thanks to Netflix and some miracle, I was able to watch all six seasons of Lost in a shade over three weeks. A lot of friends of mine had spent six years on the same journey and cite the show as having them gotten through a lot of tough times. Fans that saw the show during its run on ABC were on a six year adventure, and have a special bond with Lost. It was frustrating and rewarding for them and Ill never have that same experience with that show (and summers of not knowing, which Im glad I didn't have). What do you think?