Ranking Every HBO Drama Series From Worst To Best

HBO's long form output, from duds to dynamite.

Succession HBO
HBO

For the best part of a quarter century, HBO has been the undisputed chief of quality drama. Near-single handedly ushering in the so-called Golden Age Of TV, then maintaining it through the choppy waters of strikes, financial crises, and the spectre of streaming, HBO has reshaped the world of long form drama, and continues to produce some of the greatest stuff on the small screen.

Their dramatic department covers every genre you could imagine, from crime to fantasy to thrillers, mega budget epics, lush period pieces, and smaller, more intimate depictions of family strife and complex characters. And in doing so, they’ve lured ever-bigger actors to the world of telly, with huge Hollywood stars accepting that the juicer parts can be found outside of cinemas.

That’s not to say everything they touch turns to gold, mind - as we’ll see, they’ve had plenty of yawners, misfires, and outright duds, though they’ve more than made up for it with the good stuff. From the works they’d rather sweep under the carpet to the bonafide, all-time classic shows, here’s how HBO’s episodic drama stacks up.

Also as a note: limited series like The Young Pope and Sharp Objects aren't counted here - they're worthy of their own list.

39. The Newsroom

The Newsroom Will McAvoy speech
HBO

Aaron Sorkin’s distinct style is a love it or hate it proposition - he writes TV his own way, and if you’re not down with that, he’s got tens of thousands of words for you that will boil your blood. On The Newsroom, though, he reached peak Sorkin, all the smugness and score settling without the wit, drama, or collection of decent characters.

The Newsroom begins by ripping off the film Network (they get away with this by having characters state “This is like that scene from Network”) and only gets more annoying from there. Jeff Daniels plays noble news anchor Will McAvoy, a WASPy boomer who’s always right about everything and doesn’t hesitate to put lessers in their place.

Through McAvoy, Sorkin opines on all the ills he sees in the modern world. There are more embarrassing scenes than you can shake a stick at, peaking with a scene set on a plane during the assassination of Bin Laden that has to be seen to be believed.

None of the characters are at all likeable despite the hard graft of an overqualified cast, and it limps on for three entire seasons. At its worst it’s fun to hatewatch, but for the most part it’s just dull.


38. The Nevers

The Nevers
HBO

The latest from the mind of Joss Whedon, The Nevers is a real mess. Whedon is a high concept guy, and at his best he can juggle a lot of crazy concepts within a tightly structured show with long term vision. In The Nevers, it seems he’s jotted down all the wild ideas he can think of, slotted them into an ugly steampunk setting, and called it a day.

The plot concerns a disparate group in the Victorian era who find themselves imbued with incredible powers thanks to a mysterious extraterrestrial visitation. The set up is part Penny Dreadful, part Heroes, and somewhat lacking in originality, featuring beats and themes that have long been covered by Whedon and others.

They’re not lacking for ideas, and accordingly it’s rarely a boring watch, but the frantic nature makes The Nevers a tough watch. There are shades of Lost or the aforementioned Heroes - it doesn’t feel like a show with a plan.

To make matters worse (or probably: better), Whedon has since recused himself from the show due to the ugly allegations he faces concerning his on-set misogyny and bullying. Whether The Nevers will improve without him or fizzle away remains to be seen.


37. Vinyl

Vinyl TV Show
HBO

Vinyl’s greatest strength was also its ultimate downfall. Here was a glossy drama about the New York rock scene in the ‘70s, produced by two men who’d actually been there: director and aficionado Martin Scorsese, and actual Rolling Stone Mick Jagger. With their expertise, hopes were high.

On the other hand, these guys were 70 years old, and with rose tinted glasses firmly affixed to their heads. Vinyl was the ultimate boomer fantasy, so indebted to the good old days, and frequently featuring cameos from the stars of yesteryear - actors playing the likes of Plant, Lennon, Reed, Bowie - in an attempt to gain cool credentials 40 years after the fact.

Between all that was the bones of a decent show. Bobby Cannavale starred as the record exec trying desperately to keep up with the changing times, and it’s a nuanced, quality performance amongst the overwhelming surface level sheen that makes up most of Vinyl.

HBO quickly commissioned a second season days after Vinyl’s premiere, but changed their mind shortly after the finale. There was something decent in here for sure, but it turned into an incredibly expensive episode of I Love The ‘70s.


36. Industry

Industry HBO
HBO

The cutthroat, brutal world of investment banking seems absolutely ideal for an incisive drama. We’ve seen in the likes of The Wolf Of Wall Street that a financial backdrop, potentially stuffy and impenetrable, can be fascinating and hold mass appeal.

Industry falls somewhat short of that mark, and while no one could reasonably expect it to be on the level of the Scorsese modern classic, it feels at times like the cast of Skins have gone into banking. Somewhere in the production process there was a panic that audiences might not get invested(!) in the banking storylines, and so inject artificial energy by way of superfluous partying scenes just to keep the pace up.

The characters, being young prospective financial players, are by their nature immensely unlikeable, but Industry lacks the nerve to commit to having a bunch of heels as their main players, attempting to generate sympathy for the wealthy, venal, often sinister individuals at its core.

Investing in antiheroes is the name of the game at HBO, but Industry never seems to fully recognise why its characters wouldn’t be likeable.


35. The Outsider

the outsider
HBO

The Outsider was so nearly something genuinely great. Based on a Stephen King novel, showrun by novelist and frequent David Simon collaborator Richard Price, and starring the likes of Ben Mendelsohn, Julianne Nicholson, and Paddy Considine, not only did it sound like quality from the outset but it started off really well.

The opening episode saw Jason Bateman, a Little League coach, arrested for the murder of a young boy. The acting was super, the plot if not amazingly original was certainly captivating, and we settled in for a quality mystery.

But then came the supernatural elements, and layers upon layers of winding mystery. There’s a spooky figure with a blurred face. There are monsters who feed on fear, and spooky patterns pieced together by detective Holly Gibney (a frequently used Stephen King character whose extra sensory skills often provide a neat shortcut to keep plots moving).

There’s loads to like about the show, not least the stellar acting from the whole cast, but it often feels scattershot, unsure of which path to pursue, and to that end, it’s a frustrating watch.


34. Here And Now

Here And Now
HBO

In attempting to make an achingly contemporary drama, Alan Ball instead made a show that, in spite of a high quality cast and selection of solid ideas, was often intensely irritating. Here And Now stars Tim Robbins and Holly Hunter as a married couple with a multiracial adopted family, focussing on all their myriad, zeitgeisty issues.

Ball is at the best of times not a subtle writer, and he’s at his infuriating worst here. There’s no modern hot button issue he doesn’t feel obliged to chuck into his narrative, from sexuality and gender to race relations, identity politics and mental illness. It’s as though he knew from the off he was only going to get one season to play with, and accordingly lobbed everything against the wall at once.

Some of it works - Robbins’ unravelling is handled with empathy and the young cast of often-underrepresented backgrounds do get to tackle issues of genuine import - but the cavalcade of pressing matters often dips into melodrama or stuff happening for the sake of shoehorning in another pressing concern.


33. Rome

Guy Henry Rome
HBO

A glossy but somewhat hollow collaboration between HBO and the BBC had its moments, but often felt like HBO chasing its greatest hits. Antiheroic men, scheming, mysterious women, this was like that dream sequence where Tony Soprano was dressed like a centurion stretched out for two seasons.

That’s a little unfair: Rome’s first season did a great job of taking historical figures and bringing them, and the ancient city, to life. It always looking fantastic, and featured many character actors in rare leading roles, headlined by Trainspotting’s Kevin McKidd as Lucius Vorenus.

Like many shows set in bygone times, it was a little too keen on winks and nods to events about to unfold, most notably in the fate of Julius Caesar, played in scene stealing fashion by Ciarán Hinds for the first season.

The second season quickly went off the rails, with the plot becoming messier and viewers departing in their droves. Rome was always prone to using sex and gore to spice things up; by the end, that’s all that was on offer.


32. K Street

Few networks can boast such consistently bold, daring TV as HBO, and while K Street may not sound as obviously adventurous as much of their output, its format and subject matter were a reasonable risk. Named after the Washington DC thoroughfare that’s a hotbed for political movers and shakers, this Steven Sodebergh-created drama was well observed and realistic sometimes to its detriment.

For those in and around DC, the show was great, accurately presenting their working lives. For others, it could be impenetrable, too insider to latch onto. The show was mostly improvised, which will always come with its own issues of quality control, and what’s more, it was kept bang up to date, referencing recent events on a tight production schedule. Its timeliness was then a boon, but makes it even more difficult to get into nowadays.

K Street is a valiant effort with a great lead turn from Mad Men’s John Slattery, but it can feel more like an experiment than a full fledged TV drama. A great idea, but one perhaps doomed to failure from the off.


31. Maximum Security

HBO’s reputation as the producer of great dramatic content took a huge leap forward with its release of a series set in a violent, dangerous prison. Unfortunately, it’s not this one. 1984’s Maximum Security was in its day a bold and daring programme, but while it paved the way for groundbreaking material, in itself it’s no great shakes.

The series, unsurprisingly, is set in a high risk prison, and accordingly the cast of characters is populated by violent thugs, remorseless criminals, and all sorts of unsavoury so-and-sos. Impressively for its time, this was no moralistic affair; the characters were somewhat fleshed out rather than presented as unredeemable objects of scorn.

There were some fine actors on show here, most notably the superb Jean Smart as the prison psychologist, but the show never quite commits to its grizzled settings. There’s violence beyond what you’d see on network telly, but Maximum Security fails to convey the terror and tension of life in such a dangerous place, thereby spurning a great setting for drama.


30. We Are Who We Are

we are who we are
HBO

Luca Guadagnino’s 2017 film Call Me By Your Name was a surprise smash hit, a romance by turn swooning and melancholic centred around a surprising love connection between two young men in a gorgeous Italian backdrop.

Venturing into TV with We Are Who We Are, Guadagnino and his co-creators try to do the same thing on the small screen with this coming of age story set on a US army base in Italy, but unfortunately the pitfalls it drops into are myriad.

Most notably, instead of scorching performances from Armie Hammer and Timothée Chalamet, the show is staffed with teenagers of varying qualities. None of them are awful and some of them are in fact highly talented actors, but this equates to eight hours of adolescent stropping over various hot button issues.

Indeed its problems are much the same as Here And Now - an effort to do everything all at once, a maximalist show about every single emotion one could feasibly experience. It’s good for a bit but becomes exhausting.


Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)