Red Dwarf: Every Series Ranked From Worst To Best

From smeg to not-so-smeg, this is the definitive list of all the Red Dwarf series.

Red Dwarf
Dave

Red Dwarf is nearly 30 years old. That is quite an achievement for a TV show that isn't a soap opera, a Saturday night football highlights show, or Doctor Who. It's even more of an achievement for a geeky little sci-fi sitcom, that some BBC executives didn't have faith in making it past even one series.

How exactly have the Dwarfers made it this far? In part, it's because of a solid, and loyal, fan-base who've stuck with the show through the highs, the lows, and the cancellations. But it's also because of the staying power of most of the cast and writing team. Despite some changes over the years, the same four actors, and one co-creator, have remained as a core part of this long-lasting Red Dwarf journey.

It's been one smeg of a journey too. 67 episodes in total across 11 series, with series 12 now landing on Dave. And whilst not every episode, or even series have worked, they've never drifted far enough away from the Red Dwarf ethos to make fans abandon Starbug and ditch the show.

As we await the next step of their clueless trek across the stars, let's start-up the Holly Hop Drive and fly backwards in time to see which were the best, and worst, Red Dwarf series.

11. Red Dwarf: Back To Earth

Red Dwarf Back To Earth
Dave

Whilst largely successful in ratings (which resulted in series 10 being commissioned), Back to Earth was by far the worst series in the show's history. The critical failing of Back to Earth was the largely self-indulgent plot, which saw the Dwarfers transported to real-life Earth and come to realise that their existence was just a work of fiction. Hilarious meta-gags and fourth-wall breaking did not follow.

Because on paper, such an idea might seem interesting and fun. But in reality, it was a laboured affair that simply didn't translate to the screen. At best, it's a cloying fan-made tribute to the show. At worst, it's a cringe-inducing three episodes of poor jokes, hammy acting, and sub-standard writing. And let's not get us started with one of the worst Blade Runner homages in the history of Blade Runner homages; even a hardened replicant would feel embarrassment at this a particular attempt at a parody.

In essence then, Back to Earth is the total smeghead of the whole Red Dwarf canon.


10. Red Dwarf VIII

Red Dwarf VIII
BBC

This was very much the "difficult" series of Red Dwarf. With an audience backlash to the perceived failures of series seven (which actually isn't all that bad, more of that later), series eight attempted to take the show back to its roots. And whilst bringing a live studio audience back into the equation was a good idea, the storylines were not.

The decision to resurrect the entire crew of Red Dwarf was the biggest failing of this series. Suddenly, the whole essence of the show - four losers left alone in space - became lost in a nonsensical, and unnecessary, story arc. Perhaps after so many series Doug Naylor became bored of the show's structure, and he wanted to freshen it up. But as he's now learned with more recent series, the structure was fine the way it was.

Most episodes of series eight became entirely forgettable, and are hardly worth revisiting. Worst too, the series would end on a bizarre cliffhanger which to date, has yet to be resolved.


9. Red Dwarf X

Red Dwarf X
Dave

Back to Earth may have been the first shot at reviving Red Dwarf on Dave, but it was series ten when the show spiritually came back. Gone was the attempt at creating an overlong cinematic story, and back was self-contained half-hour sitcom episodes This represented the true resurrection of Red Dwarf, and whilst it may not have been the stablest of returns, it was still a welcome one.

The biggest danger that series ten faced was a lurch too far towards nostalgia. The show couldn't feel like it was just an attempt to cash-in on the rose-tinted memories of fans, it needed to offer something new. Thankfully, Doug Naylor was not planning on restructuring the show's principle setup (as seen in series eight). Instead, we see the main cast return to do what they do best: slob around space and insult each other. Hey, if it ain't broke, don't fix it.

This series is a mixed bag of old jokes and receding hairlines, but it was the finale, 'The Beginning', that proved the biggest highlight. A smart, funny episode that would've been a worthwhile conclusion to the Red Dwarf saga. If the show hadn't been recommissioned, that is.


8. Red Dwarf XI

Red Dwarf XI
Dave

Whilst it's still nowhere near as good as the early years, series eleven admirably continued to build on the familiar groundwork that was laid out in series ten. In fact, series eleven even managed to improve upon the show's revival on Dave with some impressive episodes.

'Officer Rimmer' and 'Samsara' were the most notable highlights of this series. In the former, there were some neat callbacks to the original series when Rimmer finally achieves his seemingly impossible quest to become an officer. With a new bio-printer in his hands, he proceeds to create an officer's club full of duplicate Rimmers. In a neat subversion of previous Rimmer-filled episodes though, the original Arnold actually gets on with his newly-printed twins. Marvelous!

'Samsara' plays out like a spiritual sequel to classic episodes 'Justice' and 'Marooned'. Again, the episode is at its best when it plays off riffs from the early years of the show. By reversing the ideas found in 'Justice' - this time, doing bad things meant good things happened as a result - the Dwarfers suddenly had free reign to act like smegheads to each other. Which is exactly what you want to see in a good Red Dwarf episode.


7. Red Dwarf VII

Red Dwarf VII
BBC

With no studio audience and higher production values, series seven was derided as being the end of Red Dwarf. The moment when the show jumped the shark, and abandoned the cheapness and charm that made people fall in love with it in the first place.

What made things worse for this series was that co-creator from day one, Rob Grant, was no longer on board. With the writing partnership of Grant and Naylor broken, new blood was brought into the writer's room and this was not immediately successful. The series also suffered from Chris Barrie's departure from the show, who left to star in new god-awful football sitcom, A Prince Among Men (good move, Chris, good move).

But despite the flaws and missteps, series seven is not the dud everyone remembers it to be. There's some excellent character pieces to be found here; Lister's realisation of his paradoxical existence, Rimmer's rebirth as a hero, and Kryten's unfortunate discovery about his own creation.

This was a series all about redemption and perhaps then, it's now time it was redeemed in the eyes of some of its critics.


6. Red Dwarf VI

Red Dwarf VI
BBC

Series six is a pure game of two halves. You can split the series right down the middle, with one half proving a tasty treat and the other half you're better off spitting out.

Let's get the bad stuff out the way first. So, 'Psirens', 'Emohawk' and 'Rimmerworld' aren't terrible. But they're all average at best. They're passable attempts at making a standard episode of Red Dwarf, each feeling like lazy rehashes of concepts and ideas that were done much better in previous series. They fail to offer anything new, and ultimately, they fall a bit flat in comparison.

However, 'Leigon', 'Out Of Time' and 'Gunmen Of The Apocalypse', stand out. All of them are witty takes on well-horned sci-fi concepts. 'Gunmen...' would take this to the next level though. It was an episode that gained international acclaim for its clever concept. It had some brilliant comedic acting (Chris Barrie, in particular, kills it as "Dangerous" Dan McGraw), and an engaging, sometimes touching, story. It's rightly up there as one of the best Red Dwarf episodes in the show's history.


5. Red Dwarf V

Red Dwarf V
BBC

The fifth series saw series director from day one, Ed Bye, departing the show. His unique vision for Red Dwarf would get lost in the process as Grant and Naylor attempted to take over direction after Bye's replacement, Juliet May, left production halfway through shooting. Triumph was created out of this crisis though, as series five ended up a great one.

Like series six, half the episodes of this run weren't exactly classics. But once again, some dynamite episodes saved the day. We had a psychotic Rimmer (and Mr. Flibble) in ' Quarantine'. And in 'Back To Reality', Red Dwarf delivered one of its finest sci-fi stories ever. A complex study of characters, depression, and life itself. With hints of philosophy and Timothy Spall added for good measure, all wrapped up in a funny 30 minute sitcom. It was an incredible piece of television.

And whilst series five may have been the series that began the full transition for the show in becoming a more gag-orientated sitcom, it still showed audiences that Red Dwarf could do more than just jokes. It's all in the microdot...


4. Red Dwarf I

Red Dwarf I
BBC

"They're dead, Dave." This is how it all began in 'The End'. A senile computer called Holly informing the barely human Dave Lister, that he was now the last human alive. It was a thing of beauty, and felt like a call-back - and a worthy successor - to the excellent TV adaptation of Douglas Adams' A Hitchhiker's Guide To The Galaxy.

Yes, it feels more dated today, but the first series is still the perfect genre-bending introduction to the original crew of Red Dwarf (minus Kryten). With low budgets, each episode played out like 30-minute stage productions. They offered disturbing, early insights into the fragile psychosis of the two lead characters (well, Rimmer mostly).

And with 'Future Echoes', only the second episode of the show, it proved that Grant and Naylor had no issues in creating stories which would be complex and heavily reliant on sci-fi elements. This was late eighties British television here, yet here we had a show willing to throw out traditional ideas and offer something wholly new and creative on our screens. And more importantly, something funny too.


3. Red Dwarf II

Red Dwarf II
BBC

Before Starbug, there was the Blue Midget. A small ship that opened its doors in the second series of Red Dwarf. Because the biggest problem Grant and Naylor faced with the show in series one, was the setting of Red Dwarf itself. It was a gigantic ship that restricted the characters, and so, it was time to set them free.

This proved a successful move for the show, as it now meant much more exploration of the deep dark recess of space for the Dwarfers. Which meant new characters were more easily found too, and one such character was Kryten. The android made his first appearance in this series, except he was played by David Ross. The "Classic Kryten" in the form of Robert Llewellyn would takeover the role in series three and beyond.

This was the series that offered the vast potential of the Red Dwarf universe. Although still primarily a Lister/Rimmer double-act, series two gave prominence in Red Dwarf to Norman Lovett's senile super-computer Holly in the excellent 'Queeg' ("We're talking jape of the decade. We are talking April, May, June, July and August fool..").

And again, it was a series that wasn't just about the laughs. 'Thanks For The Memory' was borderline an emotional drama at times. One where the audience, much like Lister does in the episode, actually start to feel sorry for Arnold J. Rimmer.


2. Red Dwarf IV

Red Dwarf IV
BBC

By 1991, when series four was broadcast, Red Dwarf was at the height of its popularity. The show had truly metamorphosed into the juggernaut comedy show we've come to love, but it was still not afraid to wear its heart on its sleeve.

Episodes like 'Camille', despite silly in nature, offered more emotional tunnels into characters like Kryten. Although we had the introduction of silicon heaven for our favourite subservient mechanoid in the previous series, Camille offered an unexpected shot at romance for Kryten. Albeit, with a big green alien blob. But hey, love's blind.

But it was episodes like 'White Hole' ("So, what is it?"), 'Justice', and the brilliant anti-war piece, 'Meltdown' (which the BBC refused to show on TV during the first Gulf War), that cemented this series into classic territory. We even had our first glimpse of the alternate, better version of Rimmer in 'Dimension Jump' ("Smoke me a kipper...").

The introduction of "Ace" Rimmer was like a un-wanted mirror for Arnold, one which he believed was there to accentuate his failings. But the twist that "Ace" was the one who had the more difficult upbringing than the smeghead version of Rimmer was pure genius.


1. Red Dwarf III

Red Dwarf III
BBC

Series three was the high-point of Red Dwarf. Grant and Naylor were now in full control of the show's production. This meant that out went the drab looking sets of the first two series, and in came a much more exciting and colourful look to the show. This was the Dwarf style that we would come to associate with the show. And with Kryten becoming a full member of the crew, we now had the core Dwarfer team.

None of these changes would've mattered though if the episodes hadn't delivered. And they did, in spades. Character development excelled this series, with the Lister/Rimmer dynamic explored in great depth in the classic bottle episode of 'Marooned'. And 'The Last Day' went even further, by introducing alien concepts such as life and death into Kryten's weirdly-shaped head.

Sci-fi elements would blossom too (along with the budgets) in the inventive 'Backwards','Bodyswap' and the introduction of the shape-shifting, emotion-sucking creature of 'Polymorph'. And we'd get glimpses of how things might've been if only Rimmer had invented the Tension Sheet in 'Timeslides'. A tragic what-if episode, if you equate success with large pots of money. Which of course, Rimmer does.

Red Dwarf III was a leap for the show that was now fully heading into hyper-drive. It was the moment when Red Dwarf became not just a show you liked, but a show you loved.

Agree with this ranking? Share your own down in the comments.


In this post: 
Red Dwarf
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Writer. Proud owner of a 1950-2000 Grays Sports Almanac. Has never created a dystopian alternate timeline (yet).