Red Dwarf: The Promised Land Review - 6 Ups & 2 Downs
The Red Dwarf lads return for their feature debut...

Red Dwarf is the special kind of TV show that has survived things other TV shows can never recover from, and a lot of that is down to just how loved the franchise is.
For 32 years the dwarfers have delivered a classic mix of mind-boggling, creative science fiction adventures with witty British comedy. Everyone involved in the production's commitment and passion for the show has also kept the wheels turning, as fans and the cast just want more of what the series brings to the table
Finally, after decades of waiting, fans are treated to a full-fledged film following the crew on yet another space adventure, only this time on a much grander scale.
The crew discovers the fleet of cats we last heard from in series 1, and discover they are now led by a tyrannical ruler who kills anyone not willing to worship him as a God.
The good news is that it's not complete Smeg, and fans will be overjoyed at just how good the final product is. From the writing to the bump up in scale it all delivers what you'd expect from a Sci-fi comedy movie starring Lister, Rimmer, The Cat and Kryten.
No spoilers ahead for this one, but before we get into what the movie does well there are a couple of stumbles it does make along the way.
First let's look at the negatives...
Downs
2. The Horrible TV Show Broadcast

Despite the excellent visual quality, improved camera work, and overall bigger budget sheen, for some insane reason, the entire film was broadcast in the most irritating fashion.
The film actually opens with a classic Red Dwarf intro that spoils some of the biggest moments of the film off the bat. We're shown exploding objects, characters and some big visual jokes that basically ruin a lot of the plot.
It sticks out terribly and feels weird as the film already has introductory titles directly before, explaining the plot of the cat people for viewers who aren't fans. This leaves the film awkwardly opening for newcomers and then suddenly catering to fans.
Constant commercial breaks every 10 minutes also frustratingly broke up the film as each big reveal was met with a title card and a cut to black. Understandably adverts cannot be avoided on TV, but the film's pacing was set by these breaks rather than as its own thing so it is worrying how this will transition to home-media when watching it at home.
The inclusion of a laugh track is also puzzling as the last time the boys did a special it didn't include one. Maybe the fan backlash to series 7 and Back to Earth not having audience members cackling in the background swayed them to include it, but it's still odd to have in a feature-length movie.
If it's a movie, just let it be a movie. Hopefully, these issues are ironed out for the home release.
1. The Villain's Defeat Is Super Abrupt

Red Dwarf is remarkably consistent with their bad guys, and one of the best surprises of the film is how great the villain of the piece, Rodon, is.
He doesn't actually get many big jokes or even things to do but bark out his lines, but the committed performance of Ray Fearon completely sold him to the audience and he dominates every scene he appears in through sheer presence.
So it's a real shame such a great character goes out with such a wet fart of an end.
There's not any great showdown or a creative way the crew outsmart him. No spoilers here, but it comes down to a very brief, and overly silly, end that doesn't even make a lot of sense when you sit and think about it.
Considering how great villains such as Legion, the Inquisitor or even Hudson-10 were all taken out in a memorable way that involved some ingenious scheme from the crew, this was a rapid, unsatisfying end to the threat that was the glorious cat leader.
These were the only mild niggles in an otherwise great product, however, and here is everything the film does right.
And now to the positives...
Ups
6. It's The Best Red Dwarf In Years

Fans can breathe a sigh of relief as this is the tightest script the boys have been in since the mid-90s.
There have been flickers of the past highs in seasons X to XII, but it always seemed creator Doug Naylor was struggling to fit his ambitious stories into the 30-minute runtime of a TV show.
In The Promised Land he finally has room to breathe and there is plenty of laughs, action and emotional moments that flow nicely into one another with some terrific pacing. It seems there is always something new or exciting to discover in every scene.
There are some occasions guaranteed to go down as classic Red Dwarf moments, all the witty one-liners you could ask for and the crew all feel truer to their classic portrayals of the characters.
A trademark of Red Dwarf is the characters getting personality changes and here is no exception with Kryten not going for a servicing meaning his usual intelligence can't ex Machina the boys out of a tight spot, and the much-hyped super-Rimmer is a standout hit.
The later years of the show have never truly managed to live up to its prime run, but this special manages to capture that glory yet again.
5. The Stunning Visuals

It was billed as a special with the budget of a series and it sure looks it.
The crystal clear 4K resolution features much more ambitious camerawork, with sweeping shots gliding effortlessly through the crisp corridors of the Dwarf. Then we're treated to the beautiful wide vistas of the desert moon that hosts a massive chase scene. Everything looks fantastic.
Props also have to be given to the production design with each ship having a distinct look and color palette, and dripping with small details.
The many explosions looking suitably epic, and some of the action scenes being pulled off rival some films with a much bigger budget. The reliance on models and more practical work over CGI has worked wonders for the show in the past, and here it shines brighter than ever.
The shot of Starbug half-buried in the desert with the sun fading in the background is some of the most beautiful cinematography the show's ever pulled off and makes sure fans are treated to all the curious sights of space in the best way possible.
You'd be forgiven for forgetting this is a made-for-TV film.
4. The Comedy Is On Point

From the very first big gag of the cat people being shown to use giant catflaps instead of doors, the special contains some of the funniest material the crew has had to work within forever.
There's a lot of great character moments, including Rimmer becoming an all-powerful diamond-light hologram, and the Cat discovering there are selfish people in the world that garner huge laughs.
Norman Lovett completely steals the show in a hilarious sequence where he has to save the stranded crew that feels like something ripped straight out of series 1. Kryten also manages to grab many crowd-pleasing points, including his first uninhibited use of a swear word.
There area few gags that feel like they belong in a mediocre 80s sitcom, but they are few and far between and for the entirety of the runtime almost every punchline manages to hit the mark.
Red Dwarf has produced some true belly-laugh gags in it's past, this special definitely adds a few more into the mix.
3. The Fan Service Is High, But Not Obnoxious

It's clear The Promised Land is a 90-minute love-letter to the show, as every single second of it seemingly has some easter egg to the show's past, but it all feels completely in keeping with the narrative at hand and they never steal the spotlight from the film itself.
It's all subtle and diehard fans are going to have an absolute ball with all the tasteful callbacks to the series past. It would have been so easy to make the super-hero Rimmer his alter-ego Ace or have the cat people still be fighting over what color their holy hats were going to be, but they sensibly hold back and don't get in the way of the story being its own entity.
Making sure each reference isn't forced in for the sake of pleasing fans hasn't been the series strongest aspect, but this is one where they have clearly learned to reign it in.
Be it Rimmer stating he always has a pen, a space core directive being quoted or Lister parading in a Hawaiian shirt from series 1, it's all carefully chosen to ensure it's in no way constantly winking to the audience.
Every fan assuredly squealed in delight when the legendary Omm song was quietly snuck in, one of Kryten's most famous gadgets returned and Cat referenced one of his most famous scenes from season 3.
2. The Performances Are Great

There has been much criticism that while the actors are clearly having fun, the characters just don't seem the same anymore and come across as caricatures of their past selves than how they used to be.
However, everyone here brings their A-game to deliver arguably some of their best work. Craig Charles' understated and mature take on the aging David Lister allows him to showcase his growth from a young waster, while still being a freewheeling space bum.
Chris Barrie tones down his usually over-the-top portrayal of Rimmer that dominated Series X to XII and manages to channel some of the emotion and contemplation the character went through in the earlier series.
Kryten and The Cat are as reliable as ever, with Danny John-Jule's portrayal of the Cat completely perfected now, and just his facial expressions are enough to ring laughs out of a scene.
The villain steals every scene he is in, the boys are all on fire and Norman Lovett's return shows he hasn't missed a step as Holly. All the side-characters do a great job as the loony cat people worshipping Lister as their God too.
The step-up to film clearly got everyone involved motivated to step-up their acting chops.
1. It's A Satisfying End To The Series

Red Dwarf first aired on 15th of February 1988, almost 2 years before The Simpsons, and there was much talk about this being one last final hurrah for the longest-running sitcom of all time.
If that's true, then everyone can hold their heads high as it truly sends off the show on a high note. The movie not only answered the long-standing fate of the 2nd Ark of the cat people, but it delivered on a lot of the things fans wanted to see.
The characters all have a moment to shine, revealing some new aspects to them as well as ending a few long-standing arcs too. There isn't a single one who comes off as being left out and the narrative does a great job of ensuring everyone has some role to play in this last big adventure.
Allowing Lister and Rimmer to finally understand their complex relationship and share a tender moment felt like genuine acceptance from two characters that had been at each other's throats for decades.
It wraps up a lot of loose threads and connects back to the beginning of the series beautifully. If this truly is the end for the show then fans couldn't have asked for much better of a finale.
What did you think of Red Dwarf: The Promised Land?