Riverdale Season 3 Premiere: 5 Ups & 3 Downs From 'Labor Day'
Riverdale is back. And so is its magic.
Contains spoilers from Riverdale Season 3, Episode 1.
It might've been a long hot summer for the residents of the eponymous town, but for Archie Andrews the cold is beginning to set in as the young man faces a future behind bars in the third season premiere of Riverdale.
Hiram Lodge's horrid plan to rid Archie from both his and his daughter's life was set in motion during last season's finale, and Labor Day wastes little time in throwing us in at the deep end. The summer has past, and now Archie faces the consequences of his decision to betray Hiram. With his mom fighting his corner in court, the red-headed protagonist is given a chance to enjoy one last weekend with his best friends while the jury deliberates over his fate.
Elsewhere, Jughead faces a few trials and tribulations of his own as new king of the Serpents, and things go from bad to worse when an old enemy rears her ugly head. The Coopers are trying their best to move on from the events of last season, which proves difficult for Betty - especially due to her sister Polly's meddling behaviour.
For those that managed to stick with the show after the extremely disappointing second season, your faith might just be rewarded, because Labor Day is a vast improvement on what came before.
Ups...
5. The Time-Jump
Time-jumps are more often than not problematic in network television series'. While their purpose is clear, the use of such a convention can often result in the loss of important events. As a result, the writers then have to find alternative ways to deliver this information and catch the audience up on what's been happening. It all tends to get very messy.
Riverdale, however, surprisingly manages to avoid such a mess. Archie's arrest in the second season finale was shocking to say the least, and having the opportunity to see some of the fallout might've been appreciated, but given the outcome of the trial, it's much better to have not witnessed it.
If the showrunners were intent on sending Archie to prison, then seeing anything that came before the trial would have been a big waste of time. They made the right call in cutting to the chase and, let's face it, this is something they should do more often given how ridiculously drawn out Season 2 was.
4. Archie & Jughead's Friendship
One of the several reasons the second season was such a slog was the fact that former best mates Archie and Jughead were consistently at each other's throats. For some reason, the writers seemed hell-bent on separating the iconic duo, and due to this, much of the show's signature charm was lost.
Labor Day is a step in the right direction, as it not only establishes the new status quo for the narrative moving forward, but also reinforces that Archie and Jughead's friendship couldn't be stronger. The thought of losing his best friend has brought Jug closer to Archie once more.
The Labour Day subplot provides for a much-welcomed break from the darker storylines, and ultimately reminds us of why we fell in love with Riverdale in the first place. The murders and twists are great, but it's the characters and their bonds that keep us tuning in each week, and seeing said characters having fun for the first time in months is the ideal way to the re-launch the series.
3. Veronica's Character Development
When Veronica first showed up in the town of Riverdale, she promised to leave her privileged rich girl persona behind in New York, as she hoped of starting afresh. However, when Hiram Lodge showed up in the second season, Veronica reverted to her former self, once again became what one could only describe as her father's daughter. Mind you, the writing wasn't particularly strong enough to justify such a dramatic change in her character, but at this stage, that's beside the point.
Throughout the lengthy storyline of the previous season, Veronica got in deeper and deeper with her father, and couldn't see what was right in front of her the whole time. If Labor Day proved anything, it's that Veronica is no longer infatuated with her dad. In fact, she's the complete opposite. Knowing that it's his fault Archie is on trial, Veronica not only calls out Hiram, but disowns him entirely. The writers have finally redeemed the character, making her someone that we want to cheer for once more. It's about time.
2. The New Mystery (And Jughead's Connection To It)
Riverdale is bursting at the seams with storylines as it is, what with Archie's imprisonment, Veronica's vendetta against her father and Jughead taking over his father's mantle, but the show simply wouldn't be complete without a new mystery for our protagonists (and us, for that matter) to become engrossed in. The show is built on storylines of this nature. 'Who Killed Jason Blossom?' and 'Who Is The Black Hood?' provided rather compelling narrative arcs for the previous two seasons, and the mysterious Gargoyle King looks to be at the centre of Season 3.
Dilton and Ben are involved somehow, and Jughead discovers the two boys engaging in some sort of satanic ritual in the woods. The writers are keeping their cards very close to their chest in regards to this storyline, which leaves us with plenty of room to speculate. Involving Jughead is very clever on the writer's part, because the character is the show's best mystery solver and, as interesting as the Serpents storyline is, it's great to see him doing what he does best once more.
Perhaps it's too early for a theory, but the almost religious connotations associated with this Gargoyle King could possibly link this plot thread to the Coopers' new psychiatrist, Edgar.
1. The Significant Improvement In Writing Quality
While the first season of Riverdale was universally acclaimed, it didn't take long for the sheen to wear off. The increased episode count and plot contrivances made the bloated second season a failure, and ruined the magic created during the show's first year. Labor Day not only recaptures said magic, but it also marks a significant improvement in the writing quality.
The plotting is well executed throughout, and the decision to keep viewers waiting to find out the result of Archie's trial is pretty clever. What's more, the characters are once again realising the gravity of their actions and experiences, something that was non-existent the whole way through last season. The storylines are also much more interesting this year, with Alice and Polly's indoctrination offering something new. It feels fresh again.
Downs...
3. The Unnecessary Exposition
In spite of the fact that Riverdale is accompanied with a 'previously on' segment, the writers have a habit of using dialogue to remind viewers of previous events. While there have been significant improvements in the standard of the show, this particular problem is still as rife as ever. As always, the writing department make a decent effort to hide the exposition, but it unfortunately still sticks out like a sore thumb. No amount of padding will make the re-delivery of this information natural, because people don't speak like this in real life.
It's also worth mentioning that, in this day and age, casual viewing is almost entirely a thing of the past, which means that the majority of the audience will have seen most of (if not every) episode of the show to date. Therefore, they don't need to keep being reminded of what happened before and, even if they did, isn't that's what the 'previously on' segment is in aid of?
2. The Return Of Penny Peabody
Riverdale has had its fair share of antagonists over the years, but none are as frustrating as Penny Peabody. The villainous attorney has caused more than enough havoc for Jughead and the Serpents, but the young leader has proven time and again that he won't ever give up on his friends and family. That's the difference between the two characters: Jughead has something to fight for, whereas Penny comes across as a bit one-dimensional. We know absolutely nothing about her, and she appears to have no desire other than to cause trouble, which doesn't make her a very terrifying foe.
Her return doesn't bode well for the season, because despite the fact that she's simply not a great character, this storyline has been explored multiple times already - within the same season. Bringing her back for yet another turf war won't provide anything new for the series.
1. Archie The Martyr
While Archie is the protagonist of the show, he's more often than not been Riverdale's most infuriating character. He's easily led and on occasion he's not even likeable - which he doesn't have to be, but it does make rooting for him a little difficult. At the end of the day, Archie's outrageous behaviour during the second season is what got him into this mess, and although he did make great strides in redeeming himself in both this episode and the previous one, he's still not very good at making judgments.
The character is aware of his shortcomings, and he's making every effort to atone for his sins, but choosing prison as a way of redemption is yet another reason to be frustrated with him. He's not guilty of murder and he knows this, and yet he's choosing to go down for it. Perhaps he did it to ensure his family don't have to go through another trial, but surely he realises that his loved ones would rather endure a few more court dates than have their son go to jail?
Oh Archie, when will you learn?
What did you make of Labor Day? Tell us your thoughts in the comment section below.