Shannara TV Show: 8 Things Jon Favreau Should Consider
8. Which Story To Start With?
The rumour, much like the potential WB movie a couple of years back, is that the show will start with Terry Brook's second novel, 'The Elfstones Of Shannara'. The reasons are obvious. It's quite possibly the most exciting of the early novels. It has our heroes chased by all manner of monsters, making for some very exciting sequences. But will it work? Is it the right novel to start with? Let's take a look what I consider the possible contenders. The Sword Of Shannara The very first book published in the saga (though not the first chronologically), I suspect the main reason this never comes up as the main choice is because the overall plot shares similarities with another fantasy story. Lord Of The Rings. (Heard of it?) Our heroes are chased from their sleepy vale by mysterious figures in black, guided by a mysterious druid in a quest to defeat the dark druid Brona even as he threatens to wage war on the Four Lands. Had this been a film adaption, I would have been fine with another story to adapt first. But this is a TV series, so the scope for adaption is very different. It also serves as the original introduction of the Ohmsfords, Allanon's big quest to defeat Brona, a powerful force that betrayed and killed his people and a lot of set up for the motifs that run through each novel. The city of Leah for example. The struggle between the dwarves and gnomes. As an introduction to this world, this surely has to be the best place start? The Elfstones Of Shannara Let's take a look at why this is more obvious choice. The Forbidding is closing and hordes of darkness threaten to sweep across the four lands, starting with the lands of the elves first. Allanon leads a new quest; the elf heroine Amberle and Will, the grandson of 'Sword's main hero Shea to stop the Forbidding from breaking free. Pursued by demons, the most terrifying being a creature known as the Reaper, is a thrilling tale that allows the reader (and viewer) to explore the Four Lands in a quest that is very different to the first novel. First King Of Shannara The prequel to the Shannara trilogy and the origins of the one recurring character from the first trilogy: Allanon. The fall of the Druids. The creation of the mythical Sword Of Shannara. The rise of Brona. If the series wants to start the tale chronologically, then this might be the place to start. The first season would certainly leave audiences with a cliff hanger that the tale of The Sword Of Shannara would have to resolve. The Heritage Of Shannara Unlike the trilogy that preceded it, the 'heritage' story line actually consists of four books. 'Scions', 'Druid', 'Elf Queen' and 'Talismans'. We follow a set of characters across the books, working to save the Four Lands and reunite, all culminating in the final book. If MTV plan to introduce us to characters that can span a number of series...well this is quite possibly the better way to go, though without the story of the original trilogy to go by, it may be a bit confusing...and its good, but not as great as the novels that preceded it.
7. How To Adapt To A New Protagonist Each Series? Make It An Anthology Show
For the majority of Terry Brook's Shannara series, the early ones anyway, each story tends to focus on a new set of heroes, a number of years on from the events of the last book. While this works in the written form, how well will that translate to the screen? Will audiences keep tuning in when the characters they come to love are replaced with new heroes next season? One option is to at least start with the 'heritage' saga as discussed on the previous page, but again writers will face that same problem as soon as that story line is done. Another option is to alter the characters so that they play out the story lines of other books. (Personally I think this is a bad idea). A better way to go would be treat each season the same way as the books. Make each season an anthology story, set in the Four Lands. This can work. Though a very different show, American Horror Story showed that this can be successful. It also gives the writers a get out clause should a season not be as successful as the last. A fresh start each year with a new set of characters. Later trilogies that focus on the same characters through each book, should the series get that far of course, could likely be condensed into one series too, allowing for the writers to focus on multiple stories set in this world. However, in terms of those early novels, there is one central character that links each story. And takes me onto my next point...
6. Allanon. Get Him Right

5. Follow The Books Exactly Or Forge Their Own Path?

4. Target The Right Audience, Find The Right Tone For The Show...

3. Incorporate The Word & Void Trilogy?
What is interesting about the premise of the world presented in the Shannara novels, is that it is in fact a post-apocalyptic world, where magic has come into effect; races like dwarves have been created out of humanity living underground for centuries. In the early Shannara novels it is little more than implied that our world as we know existed prior to the Four Lands. In fact it is probably Walker Boh's journey in the second book in the 'Heritage' series 'The Druid Of Shannara' that begins to play on this story line, taking our hero to what is obviously a decimated city from our near future, the first blend of technology with the magic that inhabits this world. Terry Brook's 'The Word & Void' trilogy is quite different; set instead in Illinois in the US of our time, where the two heroes John and Nest encounter magic. Obviously such an adaption would be massively different from the Shannara novels; it is only in the 'Genesis of Shannara' trilogy, written many years later, that links the events of The Word & Void' to the original Shannara trilogy by focusing on the apocalyptic 'Great Wars'. Now I can't imagine that 'The Word & Void' would come into play any time soon. There are many shows out there already that focus on the mix of real world and supernatural. Haven. Buffy The Vampire Slayer before it. And of course Supernatural itself, currently in its ninth season. But should the Shannara series be successful, bringing a Lord of The Rings-style high fantasy to television screens, then the Word & Void could serve as an interesting and very accessible prequel spin-off series, linking both eras together.
2. Learn From Other Fantasy Adaptions
I've already discussed this at some length, so this really is a summary of all the points I have made before. Think about why Game of Thrones endures while Legend Of The Seeker didn't make it past two seasons. Think about where fantasy has been successfully incorporated into other shows; Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Merlin, even Doctor Who. And look at films too. Why did the Harry Potter series do so well while the Chronicles Of Narnia series didn't have the same measure of success? Harry Potter did particularly well when it didn't focus so heavily on adapting every element of the source material. The same can be said for the Lord Of The Rings trilogy. Tom Bombadil wasn't needed, whereas Smeagol / Gollum was given much greater depth. The makers of the Shannara TV series shouldn't go into this blind. Fantasy has finally had the resurgence it needed thanks to the ability of film makers to faithfully adapt beloved sequences to screen, have the effects to do the stories justice and treat the source material seriously. Let's hope Shannara learns from both the mistakes and the failures if it is to endure.
1. Have An End Game
This is key. The makers of Game Of Thrones have it; they already know George RR Martin's vision for how his series ends. Legend Of The Seeker went season to season, picking up one book at a time. And that is how I imagine the Shannara series will be too. One book per year. Three seasons if they focus on the original Shannara trilogy. (Four if they went for the Heritage series instead). The fact is, there are a lot of books in the saga, and only now, almost forty years after The Sword Of Shannara was published, is Terry Brooks looking to conclude his saga. Still, with 28 books (7 trilogies, 1 quadrilogy, a duology and one prequel) it is foolish to think that we will ever see all these stories adapted for screen. Honestly I think we'll get the original trilogy if it does well, maybe the Heritage series beyond that...any more, well it depends if the later books can be condensed. Still, there needs to be a plan. Each novel in the original trilogy is set years apart, with a separate group of protagonists, but really these are as much Allanon's story as theirs. A plan needs to be laid out as to where each potential end will be. The last thing you want to do is invest two, three, maybe four years in a story line or character, only for the show to be cancelled before you get that final resolution. Knowing what can serve as a series finale is essential. Supernatural, while slightly different, certainly had that it its first five years...which is why it seemed to meander for the next two, until season eight picked up again. A five year plan is always good. Look at Babylon 5. (If you ignore the whole telepath colony story line). Too many shows have been cancelled without the finale it deserved. Shannara should have that end in mind; to be honest, so should ever cult show. A final card to play if the calling card comes earlier than expected. I want a beginning, a middle and an end. Let's hope with Jon Faverau working on this, it gets the start it needs to be successful. Because we always need more fantasy on our screens. Just as long as it is done right!