Sherlock: 10 Best Moments From Series Three

From a selection more extensive than Magnussen's Mind Palace...

On New Year's Day, one of the most highly-anticipated television events of recent years finally arrived as Sherlock returned for a third series and once again entertained, mesmerised and baffled the nation (and later the world). These three new adventures for the Hat Detective and his faithful friend, John Watson (no longer a bachelor), provided the outstanding drama, direction and performances that we have grown accustomed to but also, integrally, moved the show forward; introducing new characters, reinforcing the old ones and turning the show into a big old guessing game more than ever, meaning that we were never sure of quite what would happen next. From a selection more extensive than Magnussen's Mind Palace, here are the top ten best moments from the latest series of Sherlock. Well, what are you waiting for? The read is on!

10. Sherlock is Dying... - His Last Bow

Sherlock Is Dying

Two of the most intriguing additions made to Series Three were the further explorations of Sherlock's head, in the many Mind Palace scenes the series gave us and, unexpectedly, the tantalising hints at what made Sherlock the (super)man he is today. These two elements are demonstrated no better than in the tense scene when Sherlock is fighting to survive after being shot. Articulating the lightning-quick thought processes going on in his mind, the scene gives us Sherlock taking advice from an imaginary Molly, Anderson and a berating Mycroft on how he should fall, thinking of his childhood dog, Redbeard, to prevent him going into shock and facing a straight-jacketed Moriarty for information on how to stop the pain. Yes, Sherlock did get weirder this year. Letting us journey with Sherlock through his own mind plus a surprise appearance from his nemesis (they could only pull that off once!) would be enough to make this scene memorable but what sets it even higher is the flashes of the past. The inclusion of Redbeard the dog, with all the implications that has for why Sherlock's repressed his emotions (it's said the dog was put down) and, also, the glimpses of a young Sherlock played by co-creator Steven Moffat's son, Louis, make for a fascinating scene in which we see through the cracks in Holmes' hard shell.

9. The Face Of An Old Friend - The Empty Hearse

One of the most important scenes in the series is the moment in opener 'The Empty Hearse' where Sherlock - after letting his best friend believe he was dead for two years - finally reappears to John. Posing as a French waiter, Sherlock sneaks up on him in a restaurant - nearly resulting in giving John a heart attack and definitely resulting in him getting a sore face. Both actors are sublime here, with particular praise going to Martin Freeman for a restrained performance that makes the moment all the more emotional. This scene also shows just how inhuman Sherlock can be. He really doesn't understand the profound effect his 'dying' had on his friend, assuming that in no time at all they would be back in Baker Street, solving crimes. Instead, John has not only moved on from their old flat, he's also got himself a new partner - romantically, that is, in the form of Mary Morstan. Here, Sherlock really starts to realise the world doesn't revolve around Sherlock Holmes. This, arguably, is the major theme of this series, encapsulated here in this funny and heartbreaking moment.

8. Sherlock Holmes Has A Girlfriend?! - His Last Vow

One of the last things anyone expected from Series Three was a girlfriend for Sherlock but in 'His Last Vow' John and the audience were dumbfounded to discover that Sherlock Holmes - the man who finds all sentiment abhorrent to his calculating cranium - was in a relationship with Janine, the bridesmaid from John's wedding. Sherlock, you rascal! Except of course, this was not the case and Sherlock (or 'Sherl' as his ersatz girlfriend called him) was just using Janine to get into her boss' - Charles Augustus Magnussen - office. While none of us really believed things were as they seemed, it's great fun to see Sherlock trying out this whole other persona and John's incredulity at the bizarre situation ('YOU have a girlfriend?' 'Yes, I'm going out with Janine. I would have thought that was fairly obvious') makes the scene ten times more hilarious. Speaking of hilarious...

7. Drunk Sherlock - The Sign of Three

A stag do hosted by Sherlock Holmes was a notion harder to swallow than Derren Brown being involved with Sherlock's death, but that's what we were treated to in the mid-series party 'The Sign of Three.' Going for a pub crawl covering every street where they've found a corpse (one presumes that's a lot), Sherlock and John quickly get... Baskervilled. Benedict Cumberbatch's Sherlock intoxicated in any way is funny (we got a glimpse of it before when he was drugged in 'A Scandal in Belgravia') but the situation is taken further when the pair are called out on a case! The drunken deductions (personal favourites include 'deaded' and 'sleeeeep') are a highlight as is Sherlock's flailing 'cluing for looks.' By inverting such iconic elements of the show this scene could almost be a parody from a sketch show yet it actually is the finest example of the surprisingly numerous comic moments that this series produced.

6. Who Leaves A Wedding Early? - The Sign of Three

After an episode packed to the rafters with humour (from the drunk scene to Sherlock's distaste for wedding telegrams), 'The Sign of Three' ends at the other end of the Sherlock scale with a sombre shot which serves to remind us what sort of man Sherlock is. Through delivering his best man speech, sort-of flirting with Janine and diagnosing Mary as pregnant, Sherlock seems to be enjoying himself at the Watson's wedding - until he slips away quietly while the guests party. The reason this scene is so significant is that the episode is all about showing the more human side to Holmes. Surely there is no other social occasion that would be more repulsive to the pure, cold reason Sherlock holds above all things than a wedding and yet he almost fits in, with his more alien attributes (as shown before) played for laughs. However, here we are reminded that Sherlock is an outsider. Referring to Mrs Hudson's question from earlier in the episode, who leaves a wedding early? The answer is Sherlock Holmes.

5. Showdown At Appledore - His Last Vow

You could fill this entire list with Magnussen's scenes from 'His Last Vow', but his villainy is best shown here. All seems lost for Sherlock and John as they have failed to nail anything on Magnussen. Knowing he holds all the power, Magnussen proceeds to flick John's face for fun. There is nothing they can do to stop him.

Charles Augustus Magnussen is a terrific villain, played to palpable perfection by Lars Mikkelsen, who treads the line between being thoroughly detestable, downright disgusting and obsessively watchable. As a media mogul with power over the entire Western World, he's a chillingly believable creation given outlandish traits, like a lack of understanding of personal space and toiletry hygiene. He's more than an equal for Moriarty, actually outwitting Sherlock (unless there's another reveal to come) - causing the detective to resort to something other than his brain to slay the dragon. Shooting him dead. This scene, the climax of the series, is incredibly tense, with drama pulsing right through it. Forcing Sherlock to use such menial means proves Magnussen a memorable villain and provides one of the series' great moments.

4. Anderson's Theory - The Empty Hearse

The opening few minutes of the series form one of the most audacious scenes ever in Sherlock. Recapping the fall from St Bart's at the end of Series Two, we find out that thanks to a lookalike mask being placed on Moriarty's corpse, a quick bungee jump and the aid of illusionist Derren Brown, Sherlock survived. Except, of course, it's all a load of cobblers. Despite the increasingly ridiculous and plausibility-stretching methods on show, this scene has us fooled into thinking that we were wrong to mock some of the more outlandish theories on the internet - 'it was a mask, after all?!' - and it's not until Derren Brown hypnotises Watson that we cotton on to the fact that this may not be the truth. Though perhaps the little too cinematic but triumphant window-crash and quick snog off Molly should have told us.. It is of course only an idea of Anderson, now part of the metafictional Sherlock fan group, 'The Empty Hearse.' However, despite playing us all for saps, this scene is impossible not to love. Who knows it might even be how he did it, as it's not completely clarified which of the solutions shown is the real one. Still, I'm guessing it wasn't the Sherlock/Moriarty eloping one. Sorry, certain sections of Tumblr.

3. Sherlock's Best Man Speech - The Sign Of Three

Another of the grand themes of Series Three is the relationship between John and Sherlock. While John revealed just how much Sherlock meant to him in the here-come-the-waterworks scene in 'The Reichenbach Fall', this series gave us Sherlock's own declaration of love for his friend - in his heartfelt and humorous best man speech. While the entire thing is a series of vignettes that lasts half the episode, the core of the speech is Sherlock's touching words about his own ridiculousness being redeemed by 'the bravest and kindest and wisest human being ever had the good fortune of knowing' and calling himself and Mary 'the people that love most of all in this world.' These frank, very human sentiments act as a testament to how far Sherlock has come since 'A Study in Pink.' That man would never have been so caring and courteous to a (fellow?) human being - let alone speak aloud his feelings for him. As such, this scene makes for a fascinating study in the development of the character and therefore one of the stand-out moments in the series.

2. Liar - His Last Vow

One of the great twists of Series Three was the true identity of Mrs Mary Watson. Discovered by Sherlock in Magnussen's office, it turns out that she's an assassin! Perhaps the most worrisome aspect of this series was the inclusion of Mary Morstan as Watson's wife - surely she would ruin all the fun of Sherlock and John's dynamic duo? Thankfully, this was not the case as Mary proved a fantastic character. Ably played by Martin Freeman's real-life partner Amanda Abbington, Mary was a level-headed woman who encouraged her husband's involvement with Sherlock without butting in. It was of course a massive surprise, then, when we found out that John had fallen in love with a psychopath - again. With all the clues hidden in plain sight despite no one guessing it, this scene is a real coffee-spluttering moment and also a great example of the level of intelligent and exciting storytelling that Sherlock delivers. But there was a bigger twist coming...

1. Did You Miss Me? - His Last Vow

Two years ago, millions of viewers were themselves turned into amateur sleuths when Sherlock shuffled off this mortal coil to go to that big Baker Street in the sky - only to reappear moments later. At the end of Series Three, Messrs Moffat and Gatiss have produced this reaction again as it was revealed, in a shock turning point, that Moriarty also survived! Probably. Possibly. I dunno. Coming straight out of left field (or should that be east wind?), this was the twist to top all twists. While there were definite clues on show for how Sherlock faked his death, Moriarty shot himself in the head - surely a jump onto an inflatable mattress wouldn't fix that? So, Moriarty, did we miss you? We certainly did! But now we'll miss Sherlock for the intervening months or years until the next series arrives to no doubt provide another bulging bunch of fantastic moments. Do you agree? Or did a different moment blow away the rest of TV for you like an angry detective would a Napoleon of Blackmail? Have your say below!

Contributor
Contributor

Spewing words on the internet daily. You can also read my stuff at StarburstMagazine.Com, WeGotThisCovered and TheQuiz.Com.