Sherlock: 10 Most Outrageous Fan Theories

Moriarty's not dead because we haven't even met him yet...

With a show as popular - and rarely on - as Sherlock, the internet is always buzzing with speculation about where it will go next when it eventually returns.

One of the biggest reactions to a TV episode in recent years happened after the finale of series two, The Reichenbach Fall, when Sherlock jumped from a rooftop and promptly returned from the dead. For two years, fans came up with endless theories about how the detective faked his death - varying wildly in believability - until series three revealed the actual answer. Such was the depth to which fans dissected the episodes that the explanation in the show actually felt less developed than some of those fans had made up.

And that spirit has carried on in this long gap between series three and four, as fans wonder what will happen next to Sherlock and John, how Mary's pregnancy will turn out and if Moriarty really has returned.

Here are some of the craziest fan theories about Sherlock, those that the detective himself would surely criticise for their huge leaps of logic and questionable deductive ability.

10. Mrs Holmes Is Moriarty

I'm not sure the nuts and bolts of how this would work were considered when this theory was dreamt up, but if Mummy Holmes turned out to be her own son's nemesis it would certainly be one hell of a twist!

This seemingly-random theory does have some basis in the show. Famously, the Napoleon of Crime is a Professor of Mathematics in the original Conan Doyle stories - something that has not been carried over onto Sherlock with Andrew Scott's not-very-professorial Jim Moriarty.

However, in His Last Vow, we learn that Sherlock's mother is a genius mathematician who wrote a book called The Dynamics of Combustion. In the original stories, Moriarty was the one to author a book called The Dynamics of an Asteroid.

Coincidence? Some sections of the fandom don't seem to think so.


9. Janine Is Moriarty's Sister

Janine was Sherlock's temporary girlfriend in His Last Vow, who he heartlessly dated - and even got engaged to - to get close to her boss, the evil media mogul Charles Augustus Magnussen. But is her boss actually another Sherlock big bad and did she have her own agenda in her relationship with Sherlock? Some fans seem to think so...

The word is that Janine is actually the sister of the recently-resurrected Moriarty. Assuming he really is still alive but wanted to wait in the shadows for a little longer, the theory goes that he set his sister up as Magnussen's PA and purposely maneuvered Sherlock to kill Magnussen so that he could take over his huge business, to relaunch himself in the world. And perhaps he encouraged Janine to date Sherlock to mess with his enemy's heart, as he promised to do back in series one.

Of course, the only evidence in the show that these characters are related is that they are both Irish!


8. Sherlock Was An MI6 Agent

Sherlock Holmes Mycroft
BBC

Over the three Sherlock series we have gathered vague hints about the backstory of Sherlock and Mycroft's fractured relationship and this seemingly crazy theory offers a possible explanation for their problems - Sherlock was actually a secret agent! The name's Holmes. Sherlock Holmes.

According to the theory, Mycroft - as is heavily hinted during the series - is the head of the British secret service (like M in James Bond, geddit?) and at some point in the past hired his brother as one of his agents. It then states that the alluded to third Holmes brother was also an agent but met some terrible fate on the field. This trauma caused Sherlock to quit the job and become a private detective, and brought about the rift between the two remaining brothers.

And speaking of the third Holmes brother...


7. Tom Hiddleston Is The Third Holmes Brother

Sherlock fans have been wired about the idea of meeting Holmes Boy No. 3 since his mention in His Last Vow - and only one man could fit the role, according to the internet. None other than Tom Hiddleston.

This is perhaps less of a fan theory and more of a communal wishful thinking but the thought goes that Hiddleston's brother would be named Sherrinford - a character from the wider world of Sherlock Holmes. Although he doesn't appear in Conan Doyle's stories, other writers have created this extra sibling - who is even smarter than his brothers!

The idea has reached co-creator and Mycroft actor Mark Gatiss, who has said that Hiddleston would be amazing on the show and that he would have a word with him about appearing on the series. Fans can influence such things as casting decisions nowadays so, who knows, this one could actually happen.

Even if it's not Hiddleston, it seems likely we'll we seeing the third Holmes brother in Series 4, with 'Sherrinford' one of the tease words the creators offered for the upcoming run.


6. The Explanation Of Sherlock's Death Isn't Real

After all the speculation over Sherlock's fake death, the series had fun with people's huge interest in the answer by teasing us with two comic versions - Derren Brown hypnotizing John, and Sherlock and Moriarty eloping - before giving us the real answer. Or did they?

Some fans believe that the final explanation is no more real than the first two and is in fact from John's imagination. This would explain why the more obvious clues are picked up on - no offence, John! - such as the rubber ball and Sherlock's double.

Naturally, John - who still admires his best friend but is angry at being abandoned - imagined a scenario where Sherlock was in complete control of all eventualities without a thought as to the friends he would hurt by faking his death. Which we know isn't strictly true, as Sherlock seems to genuinely fear for their lives when Moriarty threatens John, Lestrade and Mrs Hudson in The Reichenbach Fall.

This theory might well be on to something - or it might be fans just not liking the explanation we were given.


5. Baby Watson Will Die

At the end of series three, the Watsons are expecting a little girl (who they will not be calling Sherlock). But surely Sherlock and John's partnership - and therefore the show - is properly over if he has a child to look after? Unless...

Yes, fans fear Sherlock will go incredibly dark next series and that Baby Watson won't last long. The theory goes that the baby will die in the fourth series finale, at the hands of Moriarty who has actually had previous dealings with Mary (see more later). This would liken him to Rumpelstiltskin, the fairytale trickster who threatened to steal a woman's baby, which ties in to the many allusions to Grimm's fairy tales in The Reichenbach Fall.

This seems like an outrageous idea as, while it is often shocking, Sherlock has never been so nasty before. Yet Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss have promised that the next series will be "dark." But they wouldn't really kill off the innocent child of our beloved John... would they?


4. Mary Works For Moriarty

As just mentioned, many fans believe there are still revelations to come about Mary's murky past - including the fact that she either did or still does work for Moriarty.

The idea goes that she is Sherlock's version of Colonel Moran, Moriarty's right-hand man in Doyle's story The Empty House - the tale that The Empty Hearse, the episode that introduced Mary, was based on. The theory is backed up by the similarity of Mary's maiden name - Morstan - to that of Moran. Some think Mary is running from this past while others believe she is still in Moriarty's employ, and that he planted her with John to destroy Sherlock's world from the inside.

This one was reignited by the idea apparently being hinted at in an unlikely source - the official Sherlock colouring book. On one page, Mary's wedding ring can be spotted in an illustration of the pool scene from The Great Game, in other words the place Sherlock first meets Moriarty. Pulling at straws or really on to something - you decide.


3. Andrew Scott Is Not Moriarty

BBC

Moriarty is the character who apparently captures fans' imaginations the most as many of these theories revolve around him. Yet, to quote that paraphrased meme, what if we told you that we haven't even met the real Moriarty yet?

This idea is based on the fact that Doyle's Moriarty is a figure who loves to work in the shadows, only revealing himself to Sherlock when it was absolutely necessary - which is in sharp contrast to Scott's Jokerish version who is known worldwide as the Criminal of the Century! According to the theory, Scott is an actor hired by Moriarty to play him, similar to the Richard Brook storyline in The Reichenbach Fall.

Another idea, so that we can continue to have Scott as Moriarty, is that the character we have seen him play previously was the real Moriarty's twin brother. This might seem far-fetched but it is based on the fact that, in the Doyle stories, Moriarty has a brother also called James (Doyle had seemingly forgotten that he had used the name before). So the idea that there are two Moriartys is actually canon already.


2. The Johnlock Conspiracy

Despite all the weird and wonderful fan theories out there, one of the most widely believed and circulated is the so-called Johnlock Conspiracy. Followers of TJLC at it's known are sure that it is the intention of showrunners Moffat and Gatiss to make Sherlock and John a romantic item by the end of the series. But, wait, don't roll those eyes just yet. This theory isn't just fan-fiction but has been devised through in-depth scene and script analyses - with perhaps a dollop of wishful thinking.

Although the writers have always asserted that there is no homoerotic tension between the pair, some fans believe that the story of Sherlock and John employs too many narrative and filmic techniques that frame them as a couple for the pair to be just good friends. Examples include the reference to the classic romantic ending of Casablanca in His Last Vow, and how there are secret hearts hidden in many of their scenes together. A big one comes from A Scandal In Belgravia when Irene Adler mentions how both her and John are attracted to Sherlock, despite them being generally interested in the opposite sex (a comment that John does not correct).


1. Various Theories On How Moriarty Returns

Maxresdefault 22

Is he back or not? It's a question no one - not even Sherlock - has the answer to yet, with the question most recently being asked in the Series 4 teaser trailer.

Ever since the 'Did you miss me?' video appeared in Series 3, theories and counter-theories have abounded about how a return might work.

One is that Moriarty faked his death, using a real gun but with an empty chamber, and hiding a blood packet in his collar for added effect. Another theory suggests that Sherlock was in on it, with the pair of rivals having an agreement about faking their deaths, as a test to see who can do it more convincingly. There's also the idea that the 'miss me?' screen was faked, either by Mycroft, or some other organisation, or that Moriarty isn't one person, but an entire underground network. Maybe he's really just Sherlock and everything, including us, exists in the mind-palace.

Do you think any of these theories hold any water? Or are they just the work of over-enthusiastic fans? Leave your thoughts in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

Spewing words on the internet daily. You can also read my stuff at StarburstMagazine.Com, WeGotThisCovered and TheQuiz.Com.