Sherlock: 10 "Mouthwatering Ideas" For Upcoming One-Off Special

One such story involving a jewel and a goose...

News broke a couple of weeks ago about the prospect of the BBC hit series Sherlock returning for a one-off special, possibly later this year. After co-creator Mark Gatiss announced with much doom and gloom that Series 4 wouldn't air until early-2016, star Martin Freeman spoke about Gatiss and fellow co-creator Steven Moffat having a "fantastic, really mouthwatering idea" for a one-off story. For Sherlock fans like myself, the disappointment of having to wait even longer for Series 4 is balanced tantalisingly by the myriad opportunities that a one-off episode throws up. It's an opportunity to keep fans on board while teasing where Series 4 will eventually go, much like the mini-episode 'Many Happy Returns' did before Series 3 began. It's also possible that such an episode could be used to address some of the criticisms of Series 3 (though it's unlikely that they'll take up any of my recommendations). Here, then, are ten succinct possibilities for what a one-off special of Sherlock might entail. Some of these suggestions are on the fanciful or speculative side, but considering how little we have to go on, that's hardly surprising. We'll begin with a story involving a jewel and a goose...

10. A Christmas Special Based On The Blue Carbuncle

This and the following entry both presume that a one-off episode is intended as a Christmas special. With Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman both having stage commitments in 2015, it's likely that a Christmas special would have to be shot later this year. Assuming for the moment that this is possible, The Blue Carbuncle is the ideal choice for an one-off episode with a festive flavour - despite fellow WhatCulture! writer Joe Gardner advising against it back in January. The series has already borrowed from The Blue Carbuncle, with the Christmas setting of parts of A Scandal in Belgravia and the hat-based deductions of Sherlock and Mycroft in The Empty Hearse. But there is still a lot of potential in the story, particularly surrounding Holmes' capacity for mercy (or lack thereof). It would certainly be a test of the show's character, especially for those who felt that parts of Series 3 were too frothy and not case-focussed enough (people like me, for instance).

9. A Christmas Special Based On A Non-Canon Christmas Story

Under Steven Moffat, the Doctor Who Christmas specials have often been reworkings of classic Christmas stories. Some of them are good (A Christmas Carol), some of them are bad (The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe), but they remain an integral part of the modern Doctor Who experience. While Gatiss and Moffat have openly said that every Holmes adaptation can be considered canon (and therefore can be borrowed from), it would be interesting to see how they would deal with branching out from the Doyle universe. There is a lot of humour to be mined from the contrast between traditionally sentimental Christmas stories and Sherlock himself, who once described sentiment as "a chemical defect found in the losing side." There's no need to slavishly follow the story of, say, A Christmas Carol, just as the series currently cherry-picks from many different stories for a given episode. But with a good idea at the heart of it, we could have a Christmas special as hilarious and subversive as Blackadder's Christmas Carol.

8. A Sherlock-Lite Episode

Since its revival in 2005, Doctor Who has often been filmed with two episodes being shot simultaneously. This has resulted in the 'Doctor-lite' episodes, in which the Doctor or his companions don't drive the main story, allowing the actors to work on other episodes. While the quality of these stories vary from the excellent (Blink) to the excremental (Love and Monsters), it would be interesting to see whether the same structure would work on Moffat's other show. Before you dismiss the notion as impossible, it is not without precedent in the Holmes canon. In The Hound of the Baskervilles, Holmes is absent for long periods of time, with the story being led by Dr. Watson's investigations on Dartmoor. With John being increasingly aware of Sherlock's methods and "tricks", he deserves another opportunity to try them out, either on his own or with Mary. The only downside is that if a Sherlock-lite episode turns out to be good (and I mean Blink levels of good), it will only increase the pressure on the writers to make more episodes.

7. The Reappearance Of Irene Adler

Sherlock's treatment of Irene Adler is one of the most contentious aspects of the show's history. While many bought into the logic of making her a dominatix, using her sexual empowerment and mind games to confound Sherlock's deductions, others felt that Moffat's writing robbed the character of agency, reducing her to a victim who needed rescuing at the end. Depending on which side you fall down on, bringing her back is a great opportunity, either to fix old mistakes or to explore new territory. We already know from The Sign of Three that Holmes still thinks about 'The Woman', however disatisfying that brief appearance may have been. We also have no idea what became of her after Sherlock saved her in Pakistan. Perhaps she could be the one behind Moriarty's message? Or she has been recruited by Mycroft as a new way of keeping tabs on "brother mine"? There are so many possibilities here, and Lara Pulver is so charismatic in the part that it would be a shame if we never see her again.

6. A Real-Time Story (Sherlock Meets 24)

24 is now back on our screens, reminding us all how revolutionary its real-time approach seemed when it first aired in 2001. Several TV shows have copied the format since for individual episodes, including Doctor Who for the episode 42 and The Simpsons in its parody, 24 Minutes. Considering how modern and tech-savvy Sherlock is, it would be fascinating to see what a real-time episode would look like. The series has already toyed with ticking-clock puzzles in The Great Game, but these were puzzles that lasted multiple hours and could be intercut with other plot points. By giving Sherlock a case with a very specific timeframe, it would test his powers of deduction to the limit and show how much the slow pace of other people's lives truly gets in his way and on his nerves. Additionally, it would provide some compensation for fans who felt that the climax of The Empty Hearse (involving the bomb under Parliament) was not built-up or executed properly.

5. The Watsons' Baby

It's clear that the Watsons' baby will feature at some point in future episodes of Sherlock. With Mary being heavily pregnant by the ending of His Last Vow, there's no way that Gatiss and Moffat can get away with stringing out the pregnancy for a whole series (or longer, like Bonnie in Family Guy). Doing it in the context of a one-off episode is a good way of getting it out of the way while establishing its narrative significance. The baby raises all kinds of questions about the future direction of the show. How will it affect the dynamic between Sherlock and John (particularly if Sherlock is made its godfather)? Will the baby make the Watsons more of a target, with Sherlock having to devote more time to protecting them rather than solving crimes? Most interestingly of all: will the writers break canon, knowing that Mary dies (off-page) in the original stories? Surely not even Moffat would be cruel enough to have her die in childbirth... would he?

4. An Older Holmes And Watson

Gatiss and Moffat have often talked about making a lot of episodes of Sherlock over a long period of time, with the main actors eventually growing into the age at which their characters are normally portrayed (i.e. late-40s to early-50s). Assuming that everyone's schedules stay as jam-packed as they are currently, it's fair to assume that we may not get there, unless the show is revived many years down the line. In this case, a one-off episode looking into the future wouldn't be a bad thing. The series has pointed towards Holmes' retirement before, with a passing hint in His Last Vow to beehives on the Sussex Downs. And prosthetics are now sophisticated enough to turn even the most youthful of actors into wrinkly old codgers; Moffat did it with Matt Smith in The Time of the Doctor to pretty good effect. Finally, it would be a good way to present some of the weaker Holmes stories from the later parts of the canon, such as the utterly silly The Lion's Mane. Can we really see a young Sherlock Holmes taking on a murderous jellyfish?

3. Sherlock Working For The Government

Sherlock's relationship with the British government is a testy one, epitomised by the banter between him and Mycroft. While Mycroft is always keen to bring his loose cannon of a brother inside the tent, Sherlock sees his brother as unambitious and constantly pokes fun at him: in A Scandal in Belgravia he refers to him as "the Queen" and turns up at Buckingham Palace in nothing but a sheet. But with Moriarty seemingly back, Sherlock may end up working directly for the British government, and that would make for a great story. On top of the conflict this situation would produce between the Holmes brothers, this would be an opportunity for Gatiss and Moffat to draw on the many cases in which Holmes dabbled in politics. The Naval Treaty, The Second Stain and His Last Bow are all really good stories which (excepting the last example) haven't been explored in detail so far. It might also give an insight into Mycroft's comments in His Last Vow about the undercover assignment in Easter Europe and "what happened to the other one"...

2. A Doctor Who Crossover

Wholock Now that Matt Smith has hung up his bow tie, we won't ever get to see a crossover between Sherlock and his Doctor - or 'Wholock', as it's known on YouTube. Because of Moffat's involvement in both series, comparisons between Doctor Who and Sherlock are ever-present, as are speculations as to what might happen if their worlds collided. While a five-minute skit for Children in Need would slake the appetite of many a fan, a full-length episode would put the matter to bed forever. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q3bGYljQ5Uw Of all the entries on this list, a Doctor Who crossover is the most distant hope. Moffat has said on separate occasions that the two characters inhabit very different universes, and that if they did meet, they would probably would just stand around bickering. On the other hand, Moffat has openly acknowledged the influence that Doyle's stories had on the characterisation of the First Doctor, and even let Smith pose as Sherlock Holmes during The Snowmen. Plus, seeing Benedict Cumberbatch and Peter Capaldi go toe-to-toe really would be something.

1. The Valley Of Fear

Moriarty 1

So far, three of Doyle's four Holmes novels have been at least partially adapted for the series: A Study in Scarlet became A Study in Pink, The Hound of the Baskervilles became The Hounds of Baskerville, and The Sign of Four became The Sign of Three. That only leaves The Valley of Fear, and considering the pattern, you'd think it would be best to leave that until Series 4. In fact, doing it as a one-off might be the best way to go.

Some of The Valley of Fear has been tackled before: its most famous line ("Dear me, Mr. Holmes, dear me!") became Moriarty's text to Mycroft in A Scandal in Belgravia. But it does mark the first appearance (chronologically) of Moriarty, giving the writers a means to answer the cliffhanger at the end of Series 3. If Moriarty is truly dead, it can be dealt with in a self-contained manner and we'll see no more of Jim, except in Sherlock's mind palace. If he isn't, and is casting the same manipulative shadow that he does in the novel, it would be the perfect set-up for a dark and gripping Series 4.

Disagree with my choices? Think there's something even better that Gatiss and Moffat could do? Drop me a comment below.

Contributor
Contributor

Freelance copywriter, film buff, community radio presenter. Former host of The Movie Hour podcast (http://www.lionheartradio.com/ and click 'Interviews'), currently presenting on Phonic FM in Exeter (http://www.phonic.fm/). Other loves include theatre, music and test cricket.