Sherlock Season 4 Finale: 13 Dumbest Moments From 'The Final Problem'
This isn't torture, this is vivisection.
After two years of waiting for a new run of Sherlock to come around, just like that it's gone again. And this time perhaps for good.
Was it worth the wait? Well, no. Although Series 4 provided some good moments and interesting ideas, mostly in second episode The Lying Detective, it largely continued the show's downward curve.
Moving further away from the well-written, super intelligent detective show it started out as, it's gone further into Tumblr-baiting, fan-servicing, Bond-esque nonsense, and all of that was encapsulated in the finale, The Final Problem.
Picking up after last week's twist-within-twist-within-twist cliffhanger, the episode puts the focus on Sherlock's sister Eurus, their relationship (or lack thereof, and why), and begins a dangerous game that encompasses a little girl on a plane, Sherlock's dead dog, and, of course, the 'return' of Jim Moriarty.
What it resulted in was, sadly, a complete, incoherent mess of an episode. From the horror film opening to the very end, these are the dumbest moments from what may be the last ever Sherlock episode.
13. Shrugging Off John Being Shot
Aside from the reveal that the woman Sherlock spent the night with, and the one John met on the bus, and his new therapist, were ALL Eurus, The Lying Detective ended on the cliffhanger of John potentially being shot.
Of course, the show wasn't going to kill him off at this point, but it was going to be interesting to see how he got out of the situation. Was he rescued? Did he overpower her? Did he get shot, just not fatally?
Well, the last one was technically correct. It's revealed that Watson was shot, only with a tranquilliser dart, and then the whole situation is hand-waved away just like that. It was a sloppy resolution, but set the tone for what was to come.
12. 221BlownUp
This one can be split into two parts. The first is the way that the drone makes it into 221B Baker Street, controlled from afar. Not only has the drone successfully been piloted into the flat, but it's also a motion-censored one - but of course - meaning they can't move without detonating it, and just have to stand around and stare in horror as it slowly makes its way towards them.
Naturally, then, they have to move. John and Sherlock go out the window, Mycroft down the stairs, and while they survive the iconic location goes up in flames, accompanied by a shot of Sherlock and Watson leaping from the flames, like something out of a straight-to-DVD action movie. Sherlock it ain't.
11. Eurus And Moriarty's Dance
After all the teases, Moriarty finally made a real return this week. Andrew Scott made a glorious entrance, soundtracked by Queen's I Want To Break Free, except it was quickly revealed this was five years earlier.
Scott's presence was enough for that to work, but not so much what came after. Even ignoring the fact Mycroft allowed a major criminal and his dangerous sister to have an unmonitored conversation, we then got to the meeting of Moriarty and Eurus. At which point they, erm, danced against the glass.
Maybe Moffat and Gatiss have been watching The OA recently, but this was f**king weird.
10. Sherlock Can't Tell There's No Glass
Speaking of the glass, by the time Sherlock makes his way to Sherrinford the case containing Eurus has gone.
That's weird enough, but believable within the framework of Eurus making everyone do all of her bidding (though why she then stays there, even though she's technically free, I don't know).
However, while it may still look like there's a glass case, it's then revealed that it has actually gone. It's a stretch that anyone in that room wouldn't notice, but Sherlock? One of the greatest, most perceptive minds in the entire world, couldn't tell there was no glass? Come on.
9. Mycroft Is A Complete Idiot
Mycroft has managed to work his way right to the very top level of government (in some shadowy form, anyway), which is particularly impressive when you consider he's a bit of an idiot - or so this episode makes out.
However, here we see that his monitoring of Eurus has been a total failure, that he allowed her a private audience with Moriarty (with predictably disastrous results), that he lied to his parents and Sherlock about Eurus for years, and then had her return to Sherrinford, the 'secure' facility she was more than capable of breaking out of before.
For the smart Holmes brother, that's a hell of a lot of oversights and mistakes. And all this despite his remarkably young rise, which saw him know where his sister - still a child - was being held even when his parents didn't.
8. The Fake Tombstones
In the flashback scenes of Sherlock's childhood with Eurus, we see that he was fascinated by the tombstones. The reason was they had the incorrect dates on, an architectural joke that amused him no end.
Except this was no joke or even flaw from the people engraving the stones, but the work of... yep, Eurus. As it turns out, she was the one who changed the numbers (yeah, a child engraved tombstones, but that's not even the worst bit), all to leave a message for Sherlock to find, which would be a clue to figuring out a song and notice her, forgetting he's about five, and this means he doesn't figure it it out for another 30 years or so. Brilliant.
7. "I Love You"
One of the big criticisms of Sherlock since Season 3 is the way it's seemingly pandered to sections of its audience, creating not scenes but moments that purely exist to be gif'd and reposted thousands of times on Tumblr.
While a few such moments occurred here, none were more obvious than his conversation with Molly, whom he must get to say "I love you."
You really have to feel for Molly in this moment, with the show just abusing her even more than they have done. While she's mostly been treated as completely disposable, this goes into emotional torture. And then, of course, it's all pretty much forgotten about.
6. Everything On The Plane
The episode started not with Sherlock and Watson, or even Eurus, but a young girl waking on a plane, discovering everyone else was unconscious, and she was headed towards disaster.
From there, this strand of the story gave Sherlock, Watson, and Mycroft impetus, the main problem they had to solve. It was often distracting from the more centralised elements anyway, but then it was revealed that - woah! - there was no girl on the plane.
Instead, it was Eurus all along, pretending to be the child, effective her own version of a 'mind palace' - a way of visualising her mental state. It just, well, didn't really make any sense. From her mimicking the girl to phoning herself with the voice of Moriarty, right down to its resolution, which was that she needed a hug from the brother she'd long wanted to kill.
5. The Game Relies On Sherlock Breaking The Rules
Almost the entirety of Sherlock's time at Sherrinford plays like a sequel to Saw rather than an episode of Sherlock, with Eurus in the role of Jigsaw. She pushes them into increasingly dangerous games, pitting them against each other and forcing them to kill.
It all culminates in a scene where Sherlock is forced to choose between killing Mycroft or Watson. This itself leads to one pretty good moment (Mycroft's 'performance'), and one daft one (Watson agreeing he should be the one to die, forgetting he has a daughter already without a mother).
But the crux is, what if Sherlock really had gone through with it? If he'd shot one of them, then the entire endpoint of Eurus game wouldn't have worked. It required him breaking the rules. Which, sure, maybe she knew that's exactly what he'd do. Or maybe the writers just don't have a clue what they're doing anymore.
4. Watson Is Chained Up... Until He Isn't
Moving the action to the old Holmes home (which is maybe where Eurus was based all along, unless she really did orchestrate them all being transported there), and in what we learn is a mirroring of what Eurus did to Redbeard, poor old John Watson is stuck down a well.
The water is rising, there are bones on the floor, and he's chained up. This would make any potential escape or rescue seemingly problematic. But not for Watson, apparently. When Sherlock has found Eurus and talked her round, a rope is thrown down the well, and Watson climbs out no problem - with no reference to the chains he was previously bound by. Good trick, that.
3. Eurus Can Somehow Control Everyone
How did Eurus manage to break free of her super high secure facility? It's an interesting question, given it's an island and she's under constant surveillance and on total lockdown.
The answer is that she can control anyone she meets.
Oh, right, of course. How, exactly?
She just can. Don't ask questions.
It's through this apparent superpower that Eurus can brainwash the entire prison staff into letting her come and go as she please - presumably with transport to London thrown in for good measure - and remove the glass case she's contained in, as well as set up the entire game she lays out for Sherlock.
2. And She F**king Killed A Child And No One Really Cares
A lot can be traced back to Redbeard, who was, we're led to believe, Sherlock's dog. In this episode, it's presented as the beginning of him wiping Eurus from his mind, since she was the one to kill the poor doggo.
Fear not, though, for Eurus - as villainous as she may seem - did not actually kill the unfortunate canine. Phew!
Oh, what's that? Redbeard wasn't actually a dog. He was a child. And, yep, she did kill him. Those were his bones in the well.
Oh well, that's fine, as long as she didn't actually kill the dog.
1. The End Montage
After Watson's rescued, Eurus is shipped back off to Sherrinford, and Mycroft tells his parents the truth, the show sets about completely resetting the status quo.
One last video from Mary - who foresaw such events, or at least similar, taking place - tells the pair to do what they do best, so we're treated to a zippy montage of 221B being restored, and Sherlock and Watson solving all manner of crimes.
It all reverts back to a happier time, as if none of the baggage exists between Watson and Sherlock, and oh there's Mary, as if the whole "I love you" thing didn't happen. Everything's just rosy.
Perhaps even more annoying, though, is that in pressing this reset button, the writers demonstrate in a brief montage they do know what the show is supposed to be like. They've just got their heads too far up their own ars*s to write it.
What did you make of The Final Problem, and S4 as a whole? Share your thoughts down in the comments.