Sherlock Showdown: Benedict Cumberbatch Vs. Robert Downey Jr.

A sociopathic showdown for the modern age: after three seasons on one side and two movies on the other...who's the best Sherlock?

In January, Sherlock Holmes took over the world again as the BBC aired the third season of Sherlock. Millions of people throughout the world watched the new series either as it aired in their country - or maybe through a live stream - to be one of the first to watch it on British time.

No matter the way, it was watched by nearly ten million viewers, and held consistently high ratings throughout the three-episode season. However, now that it€™s February and the hype of the episodes has died down a bit, it€™s time to reflect on what we all just saw on television and think about other adaptations of Sherlock. Obviously, the big one to compare Sherlock BBC to is Elementary, but people forget that there was a Sherlock before these two shows became popular. In the hype that Elementary and BBC Sherlock has brought, we€™ve forgotten the two movies that came before them, starring Robert Downey Jr. as Sherlock and Jude Law as Watson. Since Robert Downey Jr. and Benedict Cumberbatch are favourite actors for many, let€™s take a look at how these two measure up when it comes to being everyone€™s favourite high-functioning sociopath.

5. The Best Deductions

This is obviously a huge part of any Sherlock Holmes retelling: the deduction. It has been said that Sherlock from BBC actually does not deduce, as he does not draw from facts to make a logical reason, he induces using inductive reasoning, because he sees the facts as they are. Either way it doesn€™t really matter, but it is something to think about. This specific category is drawn mostly from the fact that those are two very different ways of receiving information. In the Sherlock Holmes movies, it€™s common to watch the movie not knowing what€™s going on, and then at the end have Robert Downey Jr. explain it to you in an okay British accent. This is exactly where the differences come in. In the movies, Sherlock Holmes takes the audience, and whomever he€™s talking to back through everything that€™s happened, and makes sense of it using things that we most likely missed. In the second series of BBC Sherlock we see this as well, but it isn€™t highlighted as much as it is in the movies. The show focuses more on what Sherlock induces by what he sees when he talks to someone. However, in The Sign of Three, we see that he does in fact deduce what is going on to try to figure out who is attempting to murder someone at John and Mary€™s wedding, using his mind palace to remember what he€™d learned through past experiences. Both actors do this incredibly well, Benedict gives off a better Well, why do I have to explain it? voice, and Robert Downey Jr. has the curse of€sounding like Robert Downey Jr, and never any one else. No matter who he plays, he€™s always Robert Downey Jr. Either in the Iron Man suit or in Victorian-England clothes, etc. Therefore, in terms of the way Sherlock was written, I believe I will give this category to Benedict, despite the fact that there are times where he induces instead of deduces. Also Benedict has the added advantage of doing this multiple times an episode, with writer Steven Moffat€™s inability to stick to one plot line, where Robert Downey Jr.€™s in charge of wrapping up the movie with the deducing of why we€™re all so confused. Best Deduction goes to: BBC Sherlock/Benedict Cumberbatch

4. Their Funniest Moment

This is one of the easiest ones to do. Once again, we€™re faced with two different Sherlocks, two different scenarios because of character portrayal and environment around the character. However, both Sherlocks have had a funny scene or two that will make us chuckle upon remembering. I find that Benedict has his funny moments in quick glances. The way he€™ll deliver a line is where we see most of Benedict€™s comedic moments. It€™s true that the third season of Sherlock delivered more funny moments, but my favourites are still the way he smiles at the painted-on smiley face on the wall before his house blows up, or his words jumbling as he sees Irene for the first time. If I had to pick a favorite funniest moment, it would be in Series Three, Episode Three, where John picks Sherlock up when he€™s undercover, only to reveal that "he's not now!!" The toddler-esque way the line was delivered -and that scene as a whole - was hysterical to me. In the movies there are less people who want Sherlock and John together, most likely because there were just less fangirls there to watch the movies and more people there as fans of the actors or the original series. This eliminated the 'Johnlock' fan-fiction we deal with now in Sherlock and Elementary. This isn€™t to say that there aren€™t moments where we all raised an eyebrow, but that was what Arthur Conan Doyle intended. The point is: there was less of an expectation in the movies, so we got more risks. This includes Robert Downey Jr. in drag, laying with John while he€™s on a train leading to his Honeymoon. This was a hysterical moment for everyone, especially those who only see Robert Downey Jr in the characters he plays, ie: myself. This was also funny because it gave us the atmosphere of John and Sherlock together, on a honeymoon, one in drag, and it wasn€™t fanmade. This was actually happening. These two actors display different ways of showing comedy, Benedict is more subtle while Robert Downey Jr. is more blatant, but because it€™s Robert Downey Jr. in drag... Funniest Moment goes to: Sherlock Movies/Robert Downey Jr.

3. The Most Badass Portrayal

The original idea was €˜most badass line€™ but I€™m shortening it to who is the more badass between the two of them. The answer will probably surprise you. We don€™t see Benedict get physically violent very often in the show. That doesn€™t mean that the character portrayal isn€™t badass. Isn€™t it awesome that he can look at lines of code and decode them in less than a minute? I would think so. The show relies very heavily on making Sherlock a wiz with his mind €“ the rest doesn€™t matter. One of the most badass scenes in BBC Sherlock is what we see on the rooftop with Moriarty. We see a man acknowledge what everyone has said about him, thus making us realise he knows what he€™s capable of. €œI may be on the side of the angels, but don€™t, for a minute, think I€™m one of them.€ This is easily the most badass line and scene in Sherlock thus far, because we saw Sherlock teeter on the line of good versus evil €“ all in an effort to save his friends. The movie however gave us a look at a physically-badass Sherlock. He resorted to physical violence in the movie in the form of recreational fighting. He also used this fighting as a way of fighting off guards and people in his way. While Benedict€™s Sherlock would most likely find a way out, Downey Jr.€™s would fight on sight, just to get past. This does give us a more carnal look to Sherlock, and one that should not be overlooked. This was something that was a part of the novels, in fact in the story The Sign of Four is where it is mentioned. Sir Conan Doyle also mentions facing his adversaries in hand-to-hand combat. So while brainy may be the new sexy... Most Badass Portrayal goes to: Sherlock Movies/Robert Downey Jr.

2. The Reactions To Mary

What many of us were waiting to see in the series that just aired was how Sherlock would react to John dating and marrying Mary Morstan. Many people who were expecting a bad reaction from Sherlock were disappointed, the two seemed to get on as thick as thieves€until Mary shot him of course. That would damper a normal friendship, but still did nothing to Sherlock and Mary. As close as ever. This was far from what people were expecting, and his reaction was far from what the book described. There was never a friendship that took place between Sherlock and John, and she certainly never acted as an intermediary. While no one€™s really complained about how far this particular feature strayed, it€™s definitely a detail that Steven Moffat has ignored. But hey, we all love a good friendship. And season three of Sherlock was all about giving Sherlock friends. Being closer to the novels as a whole, the Downey Jr. Sherlock react in more of a way that we would expect from him. Resentful of John for leaving him, the lifestyle, the solving cases. Not understanding in the least why he would want to get married and be connected to someone, he is the furthest from supporting or even being friends with Mary. In fact, I would go so far to say as in Game of Shadows, when he throws Mary out the train cabin, she€™s lucky Mycroft is there to catch her. However, that was the sentiment that Sir Conan Doyle wanted. It wasn€™t supposed to be about whether or not they were in a romantic relationship, Sherlock did in fact have a dependence on John, which is shown in his dislike of Mary. In fact, one could argue that him disliking Mary would have made him more human than liking her for John€™s sake. But sometimes change is good, and I enjoy a good Sherlock/Mary friendship, and with the dynamic being new and so loved by the fans, I€™ll give credit where credit is due... Best Reaction To Mary goes to: BBC Sherlock/Benedict Cumberbatch.

1. The Best Death

We were all thinking it. In both mediums to tell the story, Sherlock faces an inevitable death. Which one took the cake? BBC Sherlock/Benedict Cumberbatch: If we€™re going by acting, this took the category by a long shot. We had two seasons of robotic Sherlock, before giving John a teary goodbye, and then falling off a building right in front of him. This was the beginning of a new human Sherlock, as he did it to save those who he believed were friends, and making friends he didn€™t even know he€™d have. The only thing that kept TV Sherlock-fans calm was that there was a promise of another season. Beyond the fact that Sherlock Holmes Doesn€™t Die, we knew there would be another season. In the back of everyone€™s mind we all knew; either from word of mouth or knowing the show was popular enough to come back, that Sherlock couldn't die. The television show also comes closer to the book in this specific time because both hero and villain €œdie€, but the movie comes closer, as in they fall into a waterfall, whereas Moriarty shoots himself (or does he?) and then Sherlock falls to his death. Sherlock Movies/Robert Downey Jr.: The one that this had going for it was that they basically had more of a budget to kill Sherlock with. While BBC Sherlock was working on a television show budget, in the movie they could do almost anything they wanted. What did they want? They wanted Sherlock to fall off a train and into the water and down a waterfall. The scene is the same as in the book, where Sir Conan Doyle writes Moriarty and Sherlock€™s death at the waterfall, whereas the television show used the play on words of the waterfall to illustrate a different scenario. The main difference besides the whereabouts between the movie and the book are the facts given on how Sherlock did actually stay alive. In the movie it is said that he used his brother€™s respirator, which he sends to John and then appears camouflaged in John€™s room (another candidate for a funny moment). However in the television show there€™s still debate on whether we were told the truth or not. Because of sheer "How-did-they-do-it?!" and the amazing acting along with it... Best Death goes to: BBC Sherlock/Benedict Cumberbatch. What are other scenarios the two Sherlock€™s faced, and who do you think did it better? Let me know in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

I'm currently attending my local college while trying to figure out who I am. I love Doctor Who, Sherlock, really any BBC show. I've also been told I'm a bit of a nerd. Specifically, a theatre nerd.