Sherlock: The Worst Episode From Every Season

Sherlock may have been a great show, but not every episode of the series was a great one.

Sherlock The Blind Banker
BBC

BBC's Sherlock is often considered by many as one of the greatest TV series of all time and for good reason. Starring Benedict Cumberbatch as Sherlock Holmes and Martin Freeman as John Watson, the series gave us terrific writing and incredible directing, all elevated by fantastic performances from its talented cast, particularly Benedict Cumberbatch as the title character.

The show was smart, unpredictable, and even occasionally funny, making for a fun and entertaining experience with every season. From the first season, many viewers were very much along for the ride to see where this modern retelling of Sherlock Holmes would go. While a 5th season is still a possibility, the series hasn't had a new episode in more than 4 years, leaving the state of its future uncertain.

However, while there's no denying that Sherlock has certainly earned its critical acclaim and dedicated fanbase, not every episode in the series was a winner. Like every great TV series, some episodes of Sherlock shined and others faltered in comparison, making for underwhelming or even straight-up disappointing episodes. Here are all the worst episodes from every season on Sherlock.

5. Season Four - The Six Thatchers

sherlock the six thatchers
BBC

What a lackluster episode. It's honestly so disappointing to see a once-great show like Sherlock become such a pointless, unfocused, convoluted, rushed, and even an unintentionally goofy mess. This was the show that gave us episodes like A Study in Pink and The Reichenbach Fall, only for the show to eventually give us a show like this. This episode had terrible writing, terrible directing, terrible pacing — all in all, it was just a terrible episode.

For some reason, the writers thought it would be a great idea to center an entire episode around the character Mary Watson, even if we've only known her for one season and quite frankly, don't care for her much at all. It's almost as if the writers were trying to justify that pointless plot twist concerning Mary in the last season, having us wondering, 'Is this show going to be twists for twists' sake?'

Even if you did care about Mary Watson, this episode is so janky, messy, and unstructured, it's hard to get invested in any of the plot points at all. The episode just kind of jumps from scene to scene with barely anything connecting them. There's also very little tension in the episode, which is a problem because, well, it's a Sherlock episode. What is a detective show without tension or thrill?


4. Special - The Abominable Bride

Sherlock The Abominable Bride
BBC

While not part of a season, this special deserves an honorable mention due to the fact that it perfectly highlights what made Sherlock become such a terrible show: the writers trying to do too much in one episode. This episode starts off well enough (and is even fun, in a way) but quickly turns into a chaotic, strained, overdone mess that tries too hard to be clever and interesting to the point where it actually becomes quite boring and, well, silly.

Strangely enough, this episode tries to incorporate both past and present Sherlock into the plot. This episode contributes almost nothing meaningful to the overall series, so why couldn't it have just been a straightforward telling of Sherlock during the Victorian era? It certainly would've made the episode less overstuffed, but even then, the Victorian-era plotline is so terribly written it barely works as a standalone story.

So if it doesn't work as a part of the overall series and it doesn't work as a standalone story, what do we have here? An enormous waste of time, that's what we have. The Abominable Bride certainly deserves compliment for its impressive production work, but aside from that, there's very little in this episode that really justifies its existence.


3. Season Three - The Empty Hearse

Sherlock The Empty Hearse
BBC

The Empty Hearse, a fitting title for an empty episode. This episode had insanely high expectations from everyone before it came out — after all, it would follow The Reichenbach Fall, what many consider the greatest Sherlock episode of all time. Even if you didn't think that, you would still be curious as to how Sherlock managed to fake his own death, making your expectations for this episode still high. Good God, does this episode disappoint.

First off, let's address the big event of this episode: the explanation for Sherlock's fall. There really was so need for this explanation to be stretched to an hour and a half, but that's what we have so at the very least, does the explanation satisfy? Not at all. Plenty of things could've gone wrong during Sherlock's fall (Anderson even points this out), so the writers expect us to suspend too much disbelief in order for this explanation to work. Even if it could work, the answer is just so lazy and uninspired, it's a complete letdown, almost as if the writers wrote themselves into a corner when writing The Reichenbach Fall.

But more than that, The Empty Hearse is just a boring, unfocused, and plotless mess, almost becoming a self-parody of its own self. The show was always funny but that was never the main focus — here, comedy and silliness have taken over, the writers seemingly more interested in dedicating time for jokes rather than the mystery. All in all, The Empty Hearse is a disappointing episode in every possible way.


2. Season Two - The Hounds Of Baskerville

Sherlock The Hounds Of Baskerville
BBC

Had The Hounds of Baskerville been released during any other season, it would not be on this list, but unfortunately for the episode, it shares the same season as A Scandal in Belgravia and The Reichenbach Fall, two fantastic episodes, and this episode just falters in comparison.

Which is a shame, really, because The Hounds of Baskerville is not a bad episode. Far from it, really. It's slick, imaginative, fun, creative, and eventful, making for a terrific modern reworking of one of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's most famous novels. Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman both give superlative performances here and the episode boasts great work both in the writing and directing department, giving viewers plenty of scares and thrills, enough to keep us engaged and entertained.

Still, the episode did disappoint some viewers, some feeling it sorely lacking especially when compared to all the other great episodes of the series. There's also the fact that this episode doesn't really contribute much to the overall plot of the series and works more as a stand-alone episode, which isn't bad, but it definitely puts it on the lower end of the list when it comes to necessary episodes. Still, The Hounds of Baskerville is very much worth the watch, giving us an overall exciting and memorable Sherlock episode.


1. Season One - The Blind Banker

Sherlock The Blind Banker
BBC

While the first 6 episodes of Sherlock are considered the best era of the series, The Blind Banker is definitely the weakest out of all of them. It's dull, lifeless, and uninspired, seemingly dragging on and on throughout its 90-minute runtime, making it tedious to watch and finish. It certainly didn't help that this episode came after A Study in Pink, so many people felt it inferior in comparison as well as the fact that this was only the second episode of the series, meaning Sherlock still had much to do if it wanted to convince us it was truly deserving of the praise it got during its pilot.

Luckily, the show would manage to pull through, giving us great episodes like The Great Game and A Scandal in Belgravia, but The Blind Banker still remains very much the worst episode of both Season 1 and Season 2. There's also the bewildering portrayal of Chinese culture in this episode — The Blind Banker is filled with cheap lazy Chinese stereotypes, making the episode even worse to watch rather than it just being boring.

Really, The Blind Banker is a stale, hollow, and forgettable episode. It doesn't contribute much to the series plot-wise or character development-wise and it's not good enough to stand on its own so this episode just feels like filler — and who wants filler in a series with only 3 episodes per season?


In this post: 
Sherlock
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Writer, visual designer, and The Simpsons fan. Still hasn't finished Super Mario Bros. 3 and probably never will. Rocks at board games, though.