The Simpsons: 10 Dark Jokes That Took You By Surprise

The Simpsons' more unexpectedly macabre moments.

While ostensibly a family show, The Simpsons has always catered for those who prefer their humour a darker shade of yellow. After all, a running gag about a former children's entertainer tirelessly plotting to kill a ten year old boy is surely the antithesis of 'kid-friendly'. In fact, the more time you spend in Springfield, the more you realise just what a sordid little burg it is. It's a town where corruption creeps like ivy through every corner of power. A town where its young are indifferent, its elderly ignored. A town that lives in constant threat of a nuclear meltdown. Still, think of the comic potential. And so this list is a celebration of the show's more unexpectedly macabre moments (although please note that Treehouse of Horror episodes are excluded here); like the line you can't quite believe you've just heard or the sight gag that sneaks past the censors and heads straight for your subconscious. Put simply, here are the jokes that make you wonder whether to laugh or cry. Enjoy!

10. Bobsled Crash ('Any Given Sundance')

We begin at the Sundance Film Festival, where Lisa's warts-and-all documentary 'Capturing the Simpsons' is due to premiere. Principal Skinner and Superintendent Chalmers, who have tagged along to promote both Lisa and their own 'Chalmskinn' production company, are finding themselves increasingly out of their depth. After being refused entry to an exclusive VIP tent, they are pushed onto a bobsled - which slides downhill and crashes through a Mormon Church. As they emerge from the other side, several brides now inexplicably placed in their laps, Skinner looks at Chalmers and shouts ''This can't be real!'' ''It isn't'' smiles one of the brides,''You crashed and now you're lying unconscious in a snowbank.'' We suddenly cut to reality where, sure enough, the sled has reached an abrupt stop, throwing Skinner and Chalmer's lifeless bodies face down into the snow. As if that weren't bad enough, guest star Jim Jarmusch later appears to announce that he is directing 'Cheaper By The Dozen 3'. The poster shows Steve Martin's character mourning a dozen gravestones arranged in a row.

9. Police Tape Prank ('The Springfield Connection')

Having felt the exhilarating rush that comes from knocking a criminal unconscious with a garbage can lid, Marge develops a newfound taste for justice and so decides to join the Springfield Police force. Although he feels somewhat emasculated by his wife's career move, it does allow Homer the perfect opportunity to perform one of the meanest pranks imaginable. Borrowing Marge's police tape, he tiptoes across the Flanders' driveway (ignoring Lisa's objections) and simply waits for his victim to come home... Ned: Bringing in the sheaves, bringing in the -- Oh, my Lord! Something horrible has happened! Homer: Fooled you, Flanders! Made you think your family was dead. Don't you get it? Ned: Heh. Heh heh... Homer: They're not, though. Ned: Oh? Homer: But you thought they were! We've already seen just how malicious Homer can be (in fact, his anti-Ned agenda in 'When Flanders Failed' is almost relentless) but this verges on pure sadism. Especially as the joke drags on for so long, with Homer simply repeating why it's funny and Flanders trying his best to muster an approving smile. And it's a joke made all the more uncomfortable when we consider the next entry on our list...

8. The Death Of Maude Flanders ('Alone Again, Natura-Diddily')

To Springfield Speedway now; a newly built stock car racetrack where, amongst the excitement, a squad of cheerleaders are shooting free t-shirts into the crowd. To grab their attention, Homer draws a target on his stomach but, just as they fire their cannons towards him, he suddenly spots a bobby pin on the floor and bends to pick it up. The t-shirts miss Homer and instead hit Maude (who, having grown tired of Homer's behaviour, had just returned from the concessions stand), the impact knocking her over the edge of the bleachers and onto the concrete below. Unsurprisingly, the rest of the episode becomes a bit of a downer once we discover that Ned has to raise Rod and Todd by himself. Worse still, Ned can't help but feel that it is all his fault. If only he had gone to buy the hot dogs instead... "Now, now, now'' comes Homer's attempt at consolation, ''Don't beat yourself up. I'm the one who drove her out of her seat. I'm the one who provoked the lethal barrage of t-shirts. I'm the one who parked in the ambulance zone, preventing any possible resuscitation...'' This last part is news to us - and Ned. It may have been just a throwaway line but, nevertheless, it hardly goes some way towards assuaging the fans' fears: did Homer kill Maude?

7. Moe's Terrible, Disturbing Secret ('The Computer Wore Menace Shoes')

If it's dark jokes you're after, this episode really packs 'em in. Under the guise of Mr.X, Homer creates a web page in which he reports on government corruption, local gossip and wild conjecture. It isn't long before Mr. X wins the Pulitzer prize - but only if he reveals his true identity. At first Homer keeps quiet, until he hears that, if unclaimed, the cash award will go to feed starving children. Later, Marge express her concern: ''I'm proud that you won the Pulitzer. But I do feel bad about the starving children'' ''They're with God now'' comes Homer's reassuring reply. One of Mr. X's 'exclusives' claims that flu shots are being used as a form of mind control, which comes as good news to Ned. ''Now aren't you glad we don't believe in inoculations?'' he asks Rod and Todd, who are huddled under a blanket, shivering. ''Yaay!'' they reply, weakly- before Todd reaches out a hand and calls ''Mommy?'' Which wouldn't be so bad had Maude not passed away in the previous season. But it's the following joke that burrows deep into your brain. Not long after his identity has been blown, Homer walks into Moe's - only to find that he is no longer welcome. ''I don't know if I want you in here no more, Homer'' says Moe, ''I've got a lot of secrets I'd prefer to keep clandestine. Uh, terrible, disturbing secrets.'' He then steps over a crack in the floorboard, from which we can see a pair of eyes peeping out and hear a voice- unmistakably that of Hans Moleman- moan ''So hungry''. Just why Moe appears to be keeping Moleman starving in his cellar is unclear; instead it is left to the audience to wonder how a simple sight gag suddenly became so much more sinister...

6. Homer 'Kills' The Krusty Burglar ('Homie The Clown')

Homies There is a character in The Simpsons known as the Estonian Dwarf, a jobbing actor and stuntman who has 'played' Lisa ('Burns' Heir') Milhouse ('Radioactive Man') and, in his most memorable role to date, the Krusty Burglar. It is this last performance to which we draw our attention. As his name suggests, the Krusty Burglar is a mascot whose sole aim, for the purposes of this publicity stunt, is to sneak by and steal oversized styrofoam burgers. As he does so, the crowd of children that have gathered cannot contain their excitement. Unfortunately Homer, who, having recently graduated from clown college is standing in for Krusty, doesn't recognise this as part of the stunt. And so, before anyone can stop him, he tackles the poor fella to the ground and punches him. Repeatedly. ''Stop! Sto-oop!'' sobs one young onlooker, clearly traumatised. ''He's already dee-eaad!'' Thankfully, he isn't. But only, you assume, because The Simpsons would have become a very different show had Homer actually killed an innocent man before a row of crying kids. And so the Krusty Burglar is shown bruised and beaten but, crucially, still conscious. Conscious enough to ask bystanders to check his Medic Alert bracelet, at least. When discussing this scene on the DVD commentary, Matt Groening is noticeably less comfortable than his colleagues; concerned that the joke became too violent. It's certainly one of The Simpsons' more memorable moments, if only for the simple fact that watching a clown beat a dwarf half to death is as hilarious/harrowing as it sounds.

5. Moe's Soulmate ('The Blue And The Gray')

It's Valentine's Day, which of course means overblown romantic gestures for the couples of Springfield and another twenty-four hours of crushing loneliness for Moe. When Homer suggests he attend a seminar on how to pick up women, his spirits seem to lift slightly. ''What have I got to lose?'' says Moe, ''They say for every man on Earth there's one woman.'' And then comes the cruellest cutaway gag in the show's history. The camera zooms out, the world spins and we suddenly cut to a nondescript apartment where a woman who appears to be the female version of Moe stands on a chair and slips a noose around her neck... And, in an instant, Moe's apparent soulmate is snatched away from him (she even shares his proclivity for suicide attempts - talk about compatibility!) and with her goes his only chance at happiness. Worse still, he'll never know.

4. Frank Grimes ('Homer's Enemy')

The concept of this episode sprung from a question in the writers' room: ''What would it be like if you worked with Homer in real life?'' And the short, startling answer is: it would kill you. Frank Grimes is a man for whom life has been a string of tragedies and hard-won victories. A man whose straight-laced professionalism is placed immediately at odds with his colleague's carefree attitude and reckless behaviour. A man who cannot understand how a halfwit like Homer Simpson has an idyllic life while he ''had to struggle for everything he ever got''. A man who, put simply, cannot stand another minute of Homer stealing his sandwiches and calling him ''Grimey''. Ultimately his frustration boils over to the point where, having failed to highlight Homer's stupidity to the rest of the plant, he suddenly breaks out into a crazed impression of his nemesis. And that's when he grabs hold of a pair of high voltage wires... Even in death, Frank Grimes is upstaged by Homer- who calls out (while asleep) ''Change the channel, Marge!'', thus closing the episode with Grimes' coffin being lowered into the ground to the rather unnerving soundtrack of everyone laughing.

3. Brandine's Baby ('To Surveil With Love')

In an effort to prevent a terrorist attack in Springfield, the town is rigged with surveillance cameras, loudspeakers and Ned Flanders' ever-watchful eye. But when Bart finds a blind spot (conveniently located in his back yard), it doesn't take long for that small square to become a safe haven of sin. Here the citizens of Springfield are free to do whatever they want providing, of course, they pay Homer an entry fee. For Brandine Spuckler, the perennially pregnant mother of many, this freedom means being able to smoke and drink as much as she wants. And so, with a long puff on a cigarette and a swig from a bottle of moonshine, she looks down at her belly and proudly declares ''Oh, yeah! That made the kicking stop!'' *shudder*

2. Moe's Professor ('Homer The Moe')

Feeling in need of some inspiration (and no doubt dismayed by how frequently he appears in this list), Moe returns to his bartending alma mater Swigmore University, to be met with some disturbing news from his former professor. Professor: Look at that pond. Why doesn't water sparkle so? I'm dying, Moe. Moe: Is... is there anything I can do? Professor: No, unless you have a cure for cancer. Do you have a cure for cancer? 'Cos that would be great! Moe: I'm sorry, Professor. Professor: Goodbye, Moe. At which point the professor calmly walks into the lake and disappears below the surface. Surprised, Moe calls out to him ''Hey, don't you want to take your shoes off before you go swimming?''. The camera then lingers on Moe's wide-eyed disbelief as it suddenly, erm, sinks in.

1. Banksy's Opening Sequence ('MoneyBART')

For over five hundred episodes the couch gag has undoubtedly become a much-loved staple of The Simpsons. Always short, sometimes stylised and usually slapstick, it draws the opening sequence to a close with a simple or suitably surreal sight gag. Mostly amusing but, given its remarkably short shelf life, forgotten in a flash. And then along came Banksy. When the controversial graffiti artist was commissioned by the show, he is said to have taken inspiration from the fact that most of its animation is done in South Korea. And so here he offers us a glimpse 'behind the scenes', a peek behind the curtain; how the show's merchandise is made and measured in human misery. With the entire sequence shot in a dull grey and soundtracked by the bleakest music you've ever heard, we trudge across the dirty, bone-strewn floor of an Asian sweatshop where, among other atrocities, kittens are shredded to provide the stuffing for Bart dolls, a severed dolphin head is used to fasten boxes and the horn of a frail unicorn- trembling and chained to the wall- is used to poke holes in DVDs. We then zoom out to reveal the factory is contained somewhere within the 20th Century Fox logo, which is now covered in barbed wire and spotted with searchlights. Has there ever been a more daring display of self-destruction from a television show? One minute of relentlessly searing satire and The Simpsons will never be quite the same again. Apparently, around 95% of Banksy's original concept made the final cut. God knows what kind of creature is crawling on that cutting room floor... Like this article? Are they any other Simpsons jokes that have troubled your sleep? Feel free to comment in the box below.

In this post: 
The Simpsons
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshireman (hence the surname). Often spotted sacrificing sleep and sanity for the annual Leeds International Film Festival. For a sample of (fairly) recent film reviews, please visit whatsnottoblog.wordpress.com.