South Park: 10 Most Controversial Moments
Who would've thought a cartoon could ruffle so many feathers?
If there's something that's characterised Matt Stone and Trey Parker's notorious animated series, it's controversy. Due to the typical nature of animation, people never really expected that one of the crudest shows on TV would be a cartoon.
Yet, through all of the harsh reactions from critics, parents, and the celebrities that have fallen under Parker and Stone's mockery, the show continues to be consistently lauded by critics and maintains its audience to this day.
That said, it hasn't all been smooth-sailing for the show. Whether it's facing heavy protests from parent groups or even death threats from Middle Eastern groups, these showrunners have been called every name from every kind of person. This makes narrowing down their most controversial decisions and the show's most troubling moments extremely difficult, but let's give it a shot.
This list excludes the South Park video games (which could likely earn high-ranking spots on this list) and instead focuses strictly on the show, with the series' no-holds-barred comedy including 'too soon' jokes, sacrilegious plot lines, and even the occasional spot of racism over its 20+ year history.
10. Lorde Is A 40-Year Old Geologist
A recent example of the media taking South Park a little too seriously is this moment from Season 18. Following the boys' promise of an appearance by Lorde at their party, they're expected to deliver. With no Lorde available, Randy decides to take it upon himself to perform.
What seemed to be just a throwaway gag became something more once a highly-shared article from Spin criticized the show for what they deemed to be an insulting gag. In response, the site actually unintentionally created a massive subplot running through the entirety of the season in which Randy Marsh became Lorde. And due to the new structuring of the episodes where each episode tells a part of a continuous story, this subplot became more relevant than anyone likely expected.
Spin were good sports after the situation, acknowledging that they likely overreacted to what was just a minor sight gag. However, it's not difficult to see how South Park dedicating an entire season to a single article from their site likely was a bit embarrassing, even though the plotline actually yielded plenty of quality (and surprisingly heartfelt) moments at certain points. If there's something to appreciate about SP, it's that strong unpredictability.
9. A Steve Irwin Sore Spot
While there are times where South Park jokes are misinterpreted and received overreactions, they also have jokes that the writers likely knew would upset people. A strong example of this is a quick visual gag from the episode Hell On Earth 2006, where Steve Irwin shows up on-screen (grouped with rows of other dead celebrities) with a stingray hanging from the center of his chest.
This episode aired approximately six weeks following Irwin's passing, so there was some (inevitable) backlash, primarily Irwin fans who felt the joke was unnecessary and distasteful. Even Steve Irwin's widow Terri Irwin voiced her disapproval, stating that she feared her children would one day see the episode.
Each viewer's personal reaction likely depended on just how dark they'd consider their personal sense of humor. It's obvious that Stone and Parker never pull any punches, even when it involves certain tragic events like Irwin's death. And knowing them, they likely knew the reaction they'd get to it, and (without a second thought) kept it in.
8. April Fools Premiere
If there's anything Stone and Parker love doing, it's subverting expectations and getting people worked up. Following a cliffhanger from Season 1 regarding the identity of Cartman's real father, the duo took notice of the Season 2 premiere date (April 1st) and decided to try something different.
Instead of having a suitable second part to close out the Cartman's father storyline, they decided to stick it to critics of the show who stated SP was "nothing but bad animation and fart jokes" by having the entire episode involve just Terrance and Phillip in a storyline of their own.
Critical reaction to the episode was (unsurprisingly) mixed, whereas fan backlash was strong, resulting in thousands of emailed complaint letters. Comedy Central responded by moving up the release date of the season's second episode as a form of reconciliation. Stone and Parker have stated that the episode continues to be their favorite. Knowing them, it doesn't seem far from the truth.
7. Bleeding Mary
Religion is always a slippery slope for any popular show to take on, which would explain why Matt Stone and Trey Parker never shied away from taking it on with the same twisted humor present throughout each episode. After all, you know it's a South Park episode when it involves a statue of the Virgin Mary menstruating.
Everyone in town starts receiving blessings by getting bled on by the statue, including Randy who tries to cure his alcoholism through Mary's holy blood. Needless to say, religious groups and organizations were not exactly fond of the episode's subject matter. Considering that the episode aired on the Eve of the Immaculate Conception (the part of the bible where Mary conceives Jesus), it makes sense why the Catholic organizations attacked the show.
The Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights tried to get the episode completely removed from the Comedy Central schedule and from any DVD box sets, along with an apology they demanded Viacom give. Leading members of the New Zealand Catholic Bishops' Conference and the Council of Christians and Muslims also attempted a takedown of the episode, but to no avail. Crazy enough, this still was far from the worst Stone and Parker got from religious groups.
6. Scientology And Isaac Hayes
Oh, Isaac Hayes, you'd think after years of working on one of the crudest shows ever made, you'd be incapable of being offended. However, it seemed that Hayes was just as susceptible to South Park's comedy as any other group before him.
Although never specifically citing 'Trapped In The Closet' as the main factor behind his departure, the episode's critical view of Scientology made Hayes (a member of the Church of Scientology) upset. The actor was undecided on whether or not to leave the show, but felt he wasn't capable of making the final decision, letting his entourage decide his final departure.
Stone and Parker criticized Hayes heavily, stating the blatant double-standard of their consistent mockery of religion in previous seasons (with Hayes' participation), only for their Scientology episode to tip him over the edge. Chef's final episode 'The Return Of Chef' served as a conclusion for the character, as well as a response to the media who sensationalized Hayes's leaving.
5. 'Ginger Kids' Inspires Real-Life Violence
Look, Cartman may be a hilarious character and certainly a fan favorite, but nobody should ever, ever behave like he does. Adults may understand this, but unfortunately it seems some younger, more impressionable viewers did not.
Following the 'Ginger Kids' episode in which Cartman discriminates against red heads, then leads a rebellion with them, there was a reported incident at Wingfield Academy in Yorkshire where six red-headed students were assaulted in a fashion similar to an idea featured in the episode.
In response, parents of the hurt children launched a Facebook group where they posted pictures of each child's injury. South Park may receive its fair share of criticism, but rarely does it ever motivate action (especially any violent kind) in its viewers. No incident like this has occurred since then, so hopefully this will serve strictly as a cautionary tale rather than a bad omen.
4. Mr. Garrison Teaches Sex Ed
Mr. Garrison has been a consistently-interesting/controversial character because whether he's trying to get fired or simply working through his anger, he's almost always doing something troubling. Not exactly surprising, considering his history with Mr. Slave and his reign as President.
One Garrison moment that certainly garnered reactions from audiences was his demonstration of condom application to the kids in the 'Proper Condom Use' episode. To demonstrate proper technique, he puts a condom in his mouth and places it on a model penis in a (purposely) drawn-out sequence that horrifies the kids.
British satellite channel Sky One refused to air the episode, and while Stone & Parker were able to release it without CC's recommended edits, but reruns did remove the sections where Garrison made any oral contact with his sizable 'model.' Leave it to those two to fight for their right to show a 4th-grade teacher giving oral sex to a model penis.
3. Trapped In The Closet
While South Park was never exactly shy about teasing celebrities in the past, their teasing of Tom Cruise proved to be more of an issue than they likely expected. What starts out as an episode dedicated to poking fun at the rumors following Cruise and his sexuality became something bigger once Scientology got involved.
Stan joins Scientology and is believed to be L. Ron Hubbard, Tom Cruise (along with R. Kelly and John Travolta) coming in and out of the closet, resulting in plenty of controversy and an apparently very upset celebrity. While promoting Mission Impossible 3, Cruise supposedly stated he'd stop all promotions if the episode was shown again on the network. His publicist refuted anything about Cruise's involvement in the situation, but Comedy Central did in fact air the episode 'Chef's Chocolate Salty Balls' at the time 'Trapped in the Closet' was supposed to be rebroadcast.
CC stated the choice was meant to tribute Isaac Hayes (due to his departure from the show), but Stone and Parker believed otherwise. In the end, the episode got nominated for an Emmy and SP continued to poke fun at Tom Cruise, so it's clear that Stone and Parker won in the end.
2. Family Guy And Muhammad
As these last two entries will show you, South Park and its attempts at showing the prophet Muhammad became a messy, stressful series of (mostly unsuccessful) negotiations. Stone and Parker were direct competitors with the show Family Guy and its showrunner Seth MacFarlane back in 2006. Attempting to gain an edge over the other, SP dedicated a two-part storyline that mocked FG while simultaneously stirring the pot with its mentioning of the prophet Muhammad.
While there was no backlash from Seth MacFarlane (who took the show's criticism in-stride), the plot points involving the showing of Muhammad did lead to problems. Originally slated to be Season 10's premiere episode, it was forcibly delayed due to ongoing negotiations with Comedy Central and the whole Muhammad situation. In addition, the two-part nature of the storyline was only made so that Stone and Parker had more time to discuss things with the network.
In the end, 'Cartoon Wars' became more known for its criticism of Family Guy, but the bits of controversy involving the Muslim prophet foreshadowed an eventual problem that would eventually come out in the future.
1. Episode 201
South Park may have never shied away from controversy in the past, but 'Episode 201' represents the peak of trouble the show has ever got in. It angered multiple celebrities and infuriated many Muslim extremist groups who threatened violent retaliation against the network and showrunners, forcing Comedy Central to increase security at their facilities. What caused such harsh reactions? Well, it all came from SP just doing its thing.
An episode involving many of the celebrities South Park has lampooned over the years (with Tom Cruise front and center, because of course), all demanding that they see the Muslim prophet Muhammad. A superhero team of religious figures come to defend the boys and help save the day, including Muhammad himself (albeit with a giant 'CENSORED' bar over his body).
The episode was never rerun on TV, is completely absent from all official streaming sites, and it seems that's unlikely to change anytime soon. This was a moment of extreme censorship Stone and Parker likely never expected to happen, but it's one that everyone involved had no choice but to move on from relatively quickly. Nevertheless, South Park has persevered and is (arguably) better than ever with its latest seasons.
Whether they receive death threats or legal allegations, it seems there's just no stopping Matt Stone and Trey Parker, the fearless leaders of one of the most controversial shows in television history.
What do you think about South Park? Any moments we missed? Let us know in the comments below!