South Park: Every Main Character Ranked Worst To Best

We are going to make our own list, just like the girls!

South Park
Comedy Central

South Park is an animation staple in the TV industry, as there are very few shows that rival the longevity and general quality of this series. While it has undoubtedly seen a slump in the past few seasons, it still has plenty of character and remains funny thanks to its outstanding cast.

Defining the "main" roles within this series is an increasingly difficult task throughout the development of the show, as side characters often end up growing into far more relevant positions. Thanks to this, the four leading figures of Stan, Kyle, Eric and Kenny no longer have a monopoly on being considered the show's mains.

However, to allow for this list to remain practical, it will only be including the primary children characters, to be able to explore them all thoroughly. This is a show about the children of South Park after all, and there are many notable presences.

Therefore characters like Randy Marsh and Mr Garrison won't make an appearance, but still, deserve to be heralded as some of the best.

With that all said and done, here are the main characters of South Park ranked from worst to best.

12. Timmy Burch

timmy south park
Comedy Central

Timmy's introduction gave Trey Parker and Matt Stone a chance to open up options of discussing disability in the guise of comedy. To do so has meant that they've featured surprisingly compelling moments and opened up many narrative avenues. Thankfully they don't mistreat Timmy, as the other kids all like him, and he seems to be an incredibly happy chap, making him irresistibly fun to watch.

With that being said, he ranks lowest thanks to the fact that the setup of his character inherently means that the joke gets old. He can only say the word Timmy, and whilst it is funny for a surprisingly long time, the joke grows a little stale. From there, he becomes more of a character, with motives and usefulness, but the limited speech choices become troublesome.

He will always feel like a lesser character since they decided to limit the amount of vocal interaction that he could have with the rest of the cast.


11. Clyde Donnavan

Clyde Donnavan South Park
Comedy Central

Clyde is easily one of the dullest and most mundane looking characters in the show, but that weirdly ends up being a major contributing factor to what makes him such a funny presence. He has a surprisingly vapid personality that appears consistently and makes him easily fitting for whatever purpose he is needed for.

He is vain and often arrogant but also weak and childish. This ultimately makes him a swiss army knife kind of role that can be slotted into any storyline that needs additional numbers or a blank slate to work with. This may make him sound like an irrelevant and unimportant role, but that strangely becomes part of what makes him so charming.

He is however still restricted by this lack of personality, and while we have seen that he is one of the more popular kids - The List being a strong example of this - he often tends to be ignored and left in the background.


10. Token Black

Token Black
Comedy Central

Token is another role who seemed to be introduced purely for the sake of a one-note joke. However, eventually, his character not only evolves but becomes a rather interesting presence within the show, as he has some great moments of self-awareness and acts as a brilliant insight into the toxic behaviour of the rest of the cast - particularly Cartman.

Additionally, his families wealth means that there are many directions to go in with him, frequently leading to hilarious segments. A particular highlight has to be his involvement in the Fractured But Whole game as he hosts the base for Coon and Friends rival superhero troupe The Freedom Pals. Thanks to his rich family, his basement is far more superior to Cartman's, and thus becomes a great source of disdain for The Coon.

However, Token falls low on the list more out of the fact that he doesn't seem to have a strong personality. While other roles in the show can easily be defined by their actions, voices and character traits, Token tends to fall behind as underdeveloped.


9. Tweek Tweak

Tweek Tweak
Comedy Central

Tweek ends up being far more of a fun and integral presence in the show than what you would initially expect when first meeting him. The paranoid and always jittery young boy is much more than the simple joke he is initially presented to be, as he brings a lot of personality to the cast thanks to his well-defined mannerisms.

His constant fear and nervousness lead to many storyline choices that ultimately give him a decent purpose. While he isn't often amusing thanks to the fact that his character lacks nuance, he at least presents something very out of the ordinary.

It would be a sin not to discuss the Tweek x Craig storyline which sees them become the town's first gay couple and utterly shoots him and Craig Tucker (who we will get to later) into relevance, saving his character from being an unimportant side attraction. This is not only a really funny narrative, but has some surprisingly heartfelt moments.

He falls low again because while he has some development, he mostly exists as his base character and changes very little.


8. Craig Tucker

Craig Tucker South Park
Comedy Central

Craig combines a few elements mentioned in the previous entries but adds a bit more of a specific presence to improve upon them. The introduction of this character was incredibly funny as he was essentially a glorified cameo that became a personality-filled part of the show.

Craig first appears as a random kid that is sat outside of the counsellor's office every time that we cut away to it. This makes you very curious as to what he's always doing there, and the first time he speaks, you understand why.

The character is hilarious thanks to his dry and sarcastic delivery, and lack of care about anything. His first scene sees him flip his middle finger up to Mr Mackey and this would go on to become a defining trait for him.

He stands out because he has a unique vocal tone that is always flat and dry but is held back again by his lack of relevance. However, alongside his loving partnership with Tweek and other moments - like his involvement in the Peruvian Flute Pandemic episodes - he is a little more developed than others.


7. Jimmy Valner

South Park Jimmy
Comedy Central

When Jimmy is introduced in the episode "Cripple Fight" it is merely for the purpose of being an antagonistic foil to Timmy. However, he not only goes on to become much more but even turns into one of the best characters in the show.

Jimmy is incredibly loveable as he seems to seek laughter from everyone, and his love of stand-up comedy gives him this very endearing edge.

There is a lot of humour inspired by Jimmy's delivery of jokes and his speech impediment, with his stutter often impeding his comic timing. But whilst these kind of moments are present, it never seems to be told in an entirely mean-spirited way, as Jimmy is often shown to be confident and happy in what he does and how he does it.

There is a sense of popularity to Jimmy as well that helps him to become one of the better characters, as all of the other children love him, making it easy to feel the same. He only ranks in the middle thanks to the fact that he is not always a principal member of the cast.


6. Wendy Testaburger

wendy south park
Comedy Central

As with many of the other side characters in the show, Wendy started as a somewhat underdeveloped and non-specific part added for the sake of a romantic angle. However, she goes on to become so much more and arguably is one of the closest roles outside of the main four to being a leading character.

Wendy often acts as the voice of reason within the class and has strong, opinionated views about plenty of different issues. This isn't played as her being a nuisance, as the show makes it clear that she is one of the more thoughtful and intelligent children, thus making her political leanings the desired direction.

However, she also has plenty of flaws and humour that helps her to stand apart from simply being someone who scrutinises the other's behaviour. Wendy can be full of rage even going so far as to have fought Cartman before in the fantastic episode "Breast Cancer Show Ever". She can also be vain, sarcastic and surprisingly mean-spirited, which also gives her a unique identity.

Wendy is far more than just the girlfriend of a lead and has proved that time and time again.


5. Kyle Broflowski

South Park Kyle
Comedy Central

We now step into the territory of the traditional four leading men (or boys) of the South Park series, and Kyle sadly falls to the lower echelon. Kyle has an incredibly important role in the show, which makes up for his somewhat undefined characteristics. He is one of the main plot drivers and traditionally the one who finds meaning in the children's adventures.

"You know what? I've learned something today". It is easy to get frustrated whenever these words are spoken, followed by a monologue about the point of the episode. Still, this is a big part of what makes the show work, as the moral learnings of the children give the more nonsensical and abrasive humour a purpose for existing, and Kyle is the embodiment of this.

He is indeed shown to have plenty of flaws and is prone to bouts of aggression, cynicism and immorality. Still, he exists as one of the moral compasses of the show, and thankfully has the comedy chops to pull off such a role without being too boring.

Ultimately, he is integral, but it's no surprise that Trey Parker and Matt Stone thought about killing him off because of his similarities to Stan.


4. Stan Marsh

South Park You're Getting Old Stan
Comedy Central

Speaking of, Stan Marsh is considered by the creators to be incredibly similar to Kyle and having the same position in the show as the moral compass. But this statement is a disservice to the unique characteristics he brings to the table that contrast the rest of the characters.

Stan is evidently shown to be the most vapid member of the cast, as he often allows his own vanity to take over his motives and actions. The fact that people seem to herald him as the leading figure of the school and all around decent guy clearly goes to his head at many points, leading to some excellent comedy - as seen in the episode "Butterballs".

He is not as clearly defined as other cast members, but Stan is by no means an underdeveloped character as he has had some of the most significant changes and moments within the show. His life with Tegridy farms and general relationship with his irresponsible father has given him this nihilistic edge that has a unique place in the town of South Park.


3. Kenny McCormick

South Park Kenny
Comedy Central

Kenny does very little in regards to narrative or comedy in the show, excluding the motif of his persistent deaths and resurrections. This alongside the joke that you cannot make out any of what he says ultimately should make him an underdeveloped character who ranks far lower on the list, but he is almost at the pinnacle thanks to a collection of reasons.

Firstly, if you were to show images of the characters to audience members who've never seen South Park, they likely would still recognise Kenny, not by name but by look. His orange parker and covered face are an iconic part of the show and have even gone on to be a visible part of popular culture.

In addition to this, he has plenty of character traits outside of his non-speaking and constant deaths. Kenny is shown to be impulsive and a pleasure seeker, he takes drugs at times, seems to be the most lustful kid and generally acts in a far less decent way than others.

Finally, he has had some of the more heartfelt moments within the series, with a specific example being his relationship with his sister.

All of this comes together to make him one of the best and most memorable aspects of South Park.


2. Eric Cartman

South Park Eric Cartman
Comedy Central

This deplorable villain of a child is a massive part of what makes the show so fantastic, and thus he was always going to be one of the highest-ranked mains. Eric Cartman is a nightmare child, and would even make Damien from The Omen a little intimidated. Still, his mean spirited jokes and general prejudices are fantastic bridges for narratives and comedy moments.

He is a character that you love to hate, as his acts are deplorable, but give you a chance to laugh at some taboo subjects. Trey Parker and Matt Stone ingeniously crafted the role to be the character that accumulates the majority of the risqué humour, and thus he can often act as the focal point for the more dangerous moments without souring any of the other characters.

In addition to this, Eric has a wonderful connection to wordplay comedy. His constant mispronunciations such as the classic "respect my authoritah!" makes him hilarious to listen to, and combined with the general voice performance from Trey Parker makes him one of the funniest characters.

As the series anti-protagonist, he is integral to the show's identity and does a great job of it.


1. Butters Stotch

South Park The Butters Show
ViacomCBS Domestic Media Networks

Butters is easily the best child character in the show, even though he isn't part of the big four. His climb from being a background character, to a small supporting, to finally a leading position proves how popular he is not only amongst fans but the creators themselves.

In a town as crude and offensive as South Park, Butters is the one child who doesn't seem to get it. His adorable innocence and naivety often get him into many problems, and ultimately makes him a perfect subject for manipulation. His constant dismissal and abuse gives him this endearing quality where you want to see him finally get the respect that he deserves.

Leopold "Butters" Stotch always finds the silver lining, no matter how much abuse gets thrown his way. This upbeat and optimistic attitude not only makes him incredibly funny but allows him to stand out thoroughly well amongst the general pessimism of the rest of the characters.

He ranks as number one for being the funniest, most unique and loveable character.


In this post: 
South Park
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Michael is my name, overanalysing comedy is my game! Anime, wrestling, TV, movies and video games all live in my head rent free!