Star Trek: 10 Best Cardassian Episodes
When it becomes clear what the Cardassians have done, I will be vindicated.
While the Klingons are one of the Federation's oldest enemies and the Romulans are one of the most insidious, there's one that's proved a far deeper thorn to dig out. Not the Borg, not the Ferengi, or the Xindi. A single race has been at the throat of Starfleet more than any other and it's none other than the Cardassians.
The war between the Federation and the Cardassian Union happened off-screen, but we got to see the devastating consequences for the Bajorans and those officers rattled by it. During the latter seasons of Star Trek The Next Generation and all throughout Deep Space Nine, the Cardassians have proved time and again that they're an implacable foe.
They're driven, they're unified (except for certain tailors, of course) and they want to maintain their rule over the space they own. Their threatening presence was even felt in the Delta Quadrant as the starship Voyager had a share of dealings with their influence. Like all true villains, they love an eloquent monologue and a firm hand.
So here are the 10 best outings for the sinister Cardassians.
10. The Wounded
The very first episode that the Cardassians appear in is still gripping, with these brutal, warlike aliens acting as the wronged party. Unfortunately, they have good reason. The captain of the Nebula-class starship Phoenix, Robert Maxwell, has crossed into Cardassian space and has begun targeting and destroying their ships.
Maxwell lost his family to the Cardassians during the recent wars and Picard believes that he's out for vengeance, as does Gul Macet, a Cardassian officer who is sent to deal with the situation. Picard then discovers that Chief Miles O'Brien served with Captain Maxwell during the wars, serving on Setlik III and on the Rutledge.
When the Enterprise manages to track down the Phoenix, Maxwell insists that his actions are justified because the Cardassians are transporting weapons to their outer stations. O'Brien finally manages to convince Maxwell to stand down in order to avoid further bloodshed and the Enterprise escorts the Phoenix back out of Cardassian space. As Gul Macet and his crew are ready to leave, Picard warns him that Maxwell's concerns were justified and that tensions between the Union and the Federation are far from over.
How right he would proved to be.
Interestingly, Gul Macet was played by Marc Alaimo, who had previously played the Romulan Commander Tebok in The Neutral Zone and a French poker player in Time's Arrow. He would then go on to star as Gul Dukat (one of the most prominent Cardassian characters of all) in Deep Space Nine. He had facial hair in this episode, which was never used again for any Cardassian and their uniforms were redesigned after this first appearance.
9. Cardassians
A second season episode of Deep Space Nine, Cardassians is the story of an abandoned child who is being manipulated into a political weapon by that most sly of operators, Gul Dukat. When a Bajoran man with a Cardassian child appears on DS9, Garak takes an interest. The boy takes an immediate dislike to Garak and bites him on the hand. Garak and Dr. Bashir decide to investigate, finding that the boy is the son of a prominent Cardassian politician, Kotan Pa'Dar.
It seems that Gul Dukat had manoeuvred this boy, Rugal, into position when the Cardassians withdrew from Bajor, leaving him as an orphan. Rugal was then to be used to humiliate Kotan Pa'Dar, who is a fierce political rival to Dukat's own ambitions. Bashir and Garak manage to expose the plot and Sisko, elected to decide the boy's fate, returns Rugal to his original parents. Also in this episode, Rugal stays temporarily with the O'Brien's, which leads to Chief Miles having to rexamine his prejudices towards Rugal's people.
The Cardassians are shown to be violent and oppressive in the past, but this episode also highlights just how manipulative and cunning they can be.
8. Second Skin
Major Kira awakes in a darkened room to find herself on Cardassia and much worse than that, a Cardassian herself. She is informed by Legate Tekeny Ghemor that she is his daughter, an Obsidion Order sleeper agent called Iliana. Kira furiously rejects this, she knows who she is and she is no Cardassian. The problem is, she becomes unsure of her own memories when she watches a video of herself, as Iliana, speaking before her supposed sleeper-mission.
Representing the Obsidian Order (and thus the true villain of the piece) is Entek, who is seeking to manipulate Legate Ghemor into exposing his links to the Cardassian dissidents. The dissidents believe quite rightly that the Obsidian Order and Central Command have too much control over the lives of the average Cardassian, that they live dangerously close to a police state. Entek believes that by exposing Legate Ghemor's weakness, his love for his missing daughter, he can drag the Legate out into the street and expose him as a traitor.
Fortunately for Kira and the Legate, the cunning tailor Garak still has a few contacts on Cardassia and helps Commander Sisko and Odo to foil the plot. Entek is killed, Kira is returned home and to her previous self. She and Legate Ghemor remain friends, with the old man determined that his daughter must still be out there.
Much as with the Roman Empire and many medieval courts, Cardassia is shown here to be riven with intrigue and political manoeuvring to rival even the Romulans. The Obsidian Order is hinted at being the real power on Cardassia.
7. In Purgatory's Shadow/By Inferno's Light
The two-part of In Purgatory's Shadow and By Inferno's Light (when the Dominion War begin in earnest), this episode shows Gul Dukat plunging the Cardassian Union into its alliance with The Dominion. At the start of this two-parter, Dukat was a disgraced renegade operating out of a battered old ship, but by its conclusion, he is the supreme ruler of Cardassia, appointed by the Dominion. Almost everything that Dukat has ever wanted now lies within his grasp and there's little anyone can do about it.
While the Federation and the Klingons scramble on how to act in the face of this new threat, they are joined by the Romulans and they have to deal with a Changeling imposter having replaced one of the core crew. But the real story here lies with Worf, Martok, Garak and Enabram Tain. They have been kept prisoner in a Jem'Hadar facility and they must both warn the station of the imposter as well as facilitate their own escape. Garak and Tain finally have a moment of father and son, then Garak must confront his claustrophobia.
In the end it doesn't come to all-out war just yet, but Dukat has signalled to Captain Sisko that he intends to capture Deep Space Nine and the Wormhole, for the Cardassians serve the Dominion now. This state of affairs would go on until the very end of the war, when the weary Cardassian people would throw off the shackles of the Dominion and pay a dear price for it.
6. Lower Decks
No, not the animated series, the seventh-season Next Generation Episode that the animated series is named after. In this episode, young Bajoran officer Sito Jaxa (previously seen alongside Wesley Crusher and Nick 'totally not Tom Paris' Locarno in the episode The First Duty) is given a mission. This mission is to accompany a Cardassian-turned-Federation agent, Joret, back into Cardassian space. The two share an uncomfortable shuttle ride as they discuss the past history between their two species, then the mission is to get underway.
Throughout the course of this episode, Sito Jaxa and her fellow ensign Sam Lavelle have been competing for the same promotion, but neither is sure of what to expect. The senior Enterprise staff are distant and occasionally secretive, making both Sito and Lavelle uncertain. In the end, Sito does not return from her mission. Federation intelligence suggests that she was killed and the crew are stricken with grief for the loss.
Easily one of the most moving and thoughtful episodes of The Next Generation, Lower Decks remains an episode not just about the nature of the Federation's relationship with the Cardassians, but of its own failings and calculated risks.
5. Nothing Human
Voyager naturally didn't have many dealings with the Cardassians, seeing as how they were hundreds of thousands of light-years away. But one episode rung true on the nature of this species, Nothing Human. In this episode, B'Elanna Torres is attacked by a grotesquely huge centipede-like creature and only the work of Dr. Crell Moset can save her. The Doctor thus creates a hologram of him so the two can work together.
The only problem is that Crell Moset was a Cardassian geneticist whose works could be compared unfavourably to those of Josef Mengele. During the Occupation of Bajor, Crell Moest experimented upon Bajoran prisoners in the name of his research. While his ideas do allow for a surgical procedure to allow the separation of the creature and B'Elanna, many amongst the crew (including the barely conscious B'Elanna) are horrified at the inclusion of Moset, with one Bajoran crewman threatening his resignation if Moset is kept active.
Eventually, Captain Janeway orders the Doctor to use Moset's assistance and separate the the creature from B'Elanna, just as the creature's own kind comes looking for it. While B'Elanna is furious at Janeway for overriding her wishes, she is at least alive. The Doctor must weigh up the ethical ramifications of having a recreation of Moset aboard. His knowledge is invaluable, but his methods of obtaining them are grotesque, more so than any centipede-like being.
This episode reminds us that for every Garak and Damar who are decent people deep down, there were still Cardassians like Crell Moset who did not face any kind of punishment for what they did on Bajor.
4. The Wire
Garak is easily the most sympathetic Cardassian that we'll ever meet, despite the misdeeds of his past and those are exactly what this episode is about. While having lunch with Dr. Bashir, Garak's head starts to hurt. Later, he collapses in pain and Bashir strives to find out why. It turns out that Garak has a small device implanted in his brain and it is designed to limit his ability to feel pain, better to resist torture.
Ever since Garak has been exiled to Deep Space Nine, away from his beloved homeworld, he has been using the device more and more. He equates being away from his people as a form of pain until the day he simply left it on. The device was never meant to be used for this long and is now starting to break down in his brain. Bashir tries to find out why Garak is unwilling to go home, to Cardassia, to seek treatment.
Garak weaves three tales about his subordinate, Elim. He tells of how he let Elim die with a shipment of Bajoran prisoners. Then he changes his mind and tells of how Elim turned him in because he refused to interrogate a group of Bajoran children. Then he changes his mind again, telling of how the two of them were both powerful men in the Obsidian Order who betrayed one another.
Eventually, Dr. Bashir tracks own Enabran Tain, former head of the Obsidian Order and obtains the information necessary to save Garak. As he does, he asks what became of Elim. Tain laughs, saying that Elim is Garak's first name.
Garak has always been a mystery and would continue to be so for many years, vexing many on the station with his wiles. Bashir asks him for the truth later on, to which Garak says that everything he's said is true. Especially the lies.
3. Indiscretion
If there was a Cardassian more suited to exploring their culture with than Garak, then it can only be Gul Dukat. Over the years we've seen him manipulate, connive, torture, and kill to get what he wants and this episode is no exception. When Major Kira is contacted by a Bajoran smuggler who claims to have found a long-missing transport ship, she heads out to find it. Unfortunately, it was a Cardassian ship carrying Bajoran prisoners and Gul Dukat insists on accompanying her.
When they find the wreckage, Dukat examines the graves of the bodies they find outside. He is overcome with grief when he finds the body of one of the Bajoran women, whom he says was his mistress. Major Kira, unimpressed, suggests they press on because the number of graves does not equal how many Cardassians and Bajorans should have been on this ship. A short while later they find a mine workings, where both Cardassian and Bajoran are working as slaves for the Breen.
Together, Kira and Dukat liberate the prisoners and find Tora Ziyal amongst them. She is the daughter of Dukat and his Bajoran mistress, a mixed-race Cardassian/Bajoran, someone whose very existence could destroy Dukat's political standing. Dukat is ready to kill her, but Kira stops him and forces him to consider taking responsibility for his actions and his offspring. Dukat eventually relents and takes Ziyal home with him.
While compassion eventually wins out, the fact that Dukat was willing to kill his own child just for her mixed heritage is a damning portrait of Cardassian society.
2. Chain Of Command
One of the most brutal two-part episode of Star Trek ever put to television, Chain of Command sees Captain Picard sent on a covert mission, along with Lt. Worf and Dr. Crusher. They are sent to investigate a potential biological weapon on Cetris III, but fall into a trap laid by the wily Gul Madred (played by veteran David Warner). Worf and Crusher escape, but Picard remains a prisoner. Meanwhile, Captain Jellico is given temporary command of the Enterprise and his style does not go over well with Commander Riker.
In the second part of this story, Picard is subject to intense interrogation and torture by Gul Madred. He is strung up by his arms, he is starved and brutalised. Madred places four lights above himself as he speaks, asking Picard how many there are. Picard says four, because there are four. Madred insists that there are five. He tells Picard that he will see five, or the torture will continue. Picard manages to resist for a while, but eventually Madred tells him that the Enterprise has been destroyed and Picard's resolve erodes.
At the last moment, Picard is released by the Cardassians, as they have failed to take their objective and been outmanoeuvred by Captain Jellico and Commander Riker. Picard is finally allowed to leave, loudly declaring that there are four lights.
When he is returned to his ship, he privately admits to Counsellor Troi that for just a moment, he did see five lights. The torture broke him. This episode again espouses just how brutal and callous the Cardassians can be.
1. Duet
Horrifying and heart-breaking in equal measure, Duet is an example of using the minimum available resources to achieve the absolute maximum effect. Ranked as one of the best episodes ever produced of the entire franchise, Duet is a painful character study into inhumanity, guilt and grief.
Major Kira is told that someone suffering Kalla-Nohra is coming onboard the station. Kira knows that this disease only appeared in a single labour camp and that the conditions there were harsh. Any Bajoran who survived it is someone that she should honour. When she goes to meet this survivor, she finds a Cardassian man, Aamin Marritza.
Incensed and ready to blame him for war-crimes, she has Marritza arrested, but finds that he is not a recorded war-criminal. He insists that he was just a file clerk. When Kira digs deeper, she finds an image or Marritza at that particular camp, but the picture does not identify him as a file clerk, it identifies him as Gul Darhe'el, the Butcher of Gallitep.
Marritza proudly boasts that he is Darhe'el, but Gul Dukat, that ever-present snake, says that this can't be so. He attended Darhe'el's funeral a few years prior. This man Marritza has undergone cosmetic surgery to resemble his former master, then to throw himself on the mercy of the Bajorans so that they would have someone to tear down, someone to vent their anger and hatred at. Marritza was just a file clerk but he knew what was being done at Gallitep and filled him with fear and disgust.
As Major Kira is in the process of letting him go, a random Bajoran man murders him in the street, saying that Marritza being a Cardassian is reason enough. Kira realises that it wasn't, that such hatred will never get anyone anywhere.
Marritza was just a man doing a task but felt a great weight of remorse at what had been done by his state. While he certainly succumbed to the Cardassian pastime of speaking eloquently at great length, he was by no means evil. He felt the evil that his people had done seep into his skin, however and felt he might never be free of it.
The Cardassians had it rough to start with, Gul Madred talked of how harsh and unforgiving their world is, even though Garak longed to return to it. Their passion as a people is for control and order, but one that was also their downfall.