Star Trek: 10 Things You Didn't Know About Julian Bashir
Sorting the truth from the even truer lies for Star Trek's dearest doctor on the frontier.
Not unlike Deep Space Nine itself when it first aired, Julian Bashir was an unusual addition to the franchise. Somewhat of an oddity in the pantheon of Star Trek doctors, he was young, inexperienced, and fresh out of Starfleet Medical, but already possessed of enough brash self-assuredness not to have chosen from amongst any of the litany of "cushy" jobs available to him after graduation. Instead, he had decided to grace the frontier, i.e. the Station, with his healing presence, because that's where 'heroes were made'. Even his best friend "hated" him when they first met.
If, as O'Brien also noted in the pair's memorable merry exchange in Explorers, Julian was not "an in-between kind of guy," then everyone grew to love him — and some maybe "a bit more" than others — as time went on, a testament to the writers and producers who were determined not to squander the immense talents, and all-round likeability, of actor Alexander Siddig.
Bashir was always already a gifted doctor, too. He proved that on countless occasions, not the least of which was on the battlefields of two wars — Klingon and Dominion. It was the worst of times; it was the best of times. Even the OG spoiler of a genetic secret couldn't hamper the admiration of his friends and colleagues, and nor could Luther Sloan crash the party for long. Then, there were those stuff-of-legend lunches with the (former) spy… tailor… tinker… let's just settle on Garak. Here, my dear doctor, the lies really are just another way of telling the plain and simple truth.
10. Siddig For Sisko?
Not yet on a twenty-six-hour day, Alexander Siddig (aka Siddig El Fadil) already had less time to prepare for his audition. Then, as he related in The Fifty-Year Mission: The Next 25 Years, the process was even more speedy. His agent had called with a short, but effective, message: "It's Wednesday night, off you go. It's Star Trek, you've got this scene. Do a good job. See you later".
From casting documents released via TrekDocs on Twitter, it would seem that Siddig's first audition for Star Trek was, in fact, on a Thursday morning — 9:30, 23rd July at Twickenham Studios in London. Not knowing there was a new Trek show in the works, Siddig thought he was going up for a part in Star Trek: The Next Generation, perhaps as "Deanna Troi's brother". As Siddig then recalled in The Making of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, he also turned up to the audition sporting a black eye, having been punched in the face by an overzealous, and over-drunk, 'fan' on the London Underground the night before.
That didn't seem to deter producers, however. In fact, as further detailed in The Making of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, Rick Berman himself had sought out Siddig in the first place, after being impressed by his performance as King Faisil in A Dangerous Man: Lawrence After Arabia. Berman had initially wanted Siddig for the part of Commander Sisko, but upon learning that the actor was only in his mid-twenties (appearing older in A Dangerous Man), Berman asked if he would audition for Doctor Bashir, at that point called 'Doctor Amoros,' instead.
9. Amoros, Julian Amoros
Before Bashir, and indeed before Alexander Siddig, there was Amoros, Julian Amoros. Julian was not quite the "blank canvas" Siddig auditioned for, as the actor put it in the Star Trek: Deep Space Nine DVD extra Crew Dossier — Julian Bashir, but there were plenty of differences (and similarities) between the characterisation of Amoros and the Bashir that made it to screen.
In the 12 June 1992 draft of the Star Trek: Deep Space Nine series bible, "DR. JULIAN AMOROS" is, as per Bashir, a "human, male, mid-twenties," but, unlike Bashir, Amoros already held the rank of Lieutenant Commander. Akin to Bashir once more, Amoros is described as "naïve," with "gung-ho expectations" about his first assignment out of the Academy, an assignment he'd chosen over "the cushy job" he could have taken at Starfleet Medical.
Quite unlike Bashir, however, Amoros was "charming and cocky all at the same time," or as writer Robert Hewitt Wolfe stated in The Fifty-Year Mission, he was "a little more suave, with a little more in the way of personal skills […], [not] as prone to shoving his foot completely into his mouth". In the June bible, Amoros also "like[d] to go to the phaser firing range to practice with O'Brien". Definitely not! Although, then again, I suppose that is basically a high-tech version of darts!
Amoros became Bashir after producers had met Siddig (in L.A.), and it was the actor's interpretation of the character that then served to re-shape Bashir's personality. As Siddig himself put it in the Crew Dossier DVD extra, "I could play him as someone who was genuinely freaked out by arriving in space, as I was genuinely freaked out by arriving in Los Angeles".
8. Ganglions In A Twist
For anyone taking them, medical finals probably do feel like life and death, though Doctor Bashir was embellishing just a little all the same in his attempts to win over a Bajoran woman at the start of Q-Less. His dramatic recounting might have culminated in the dizzying last-second inspiration of "pericardial membrane," but it was a prior mix-up — "preganglionic fibre" for "postganglionic nerve" (Oh, if I had a penny!) — that had cost Bashir the top graduating spot of 'Valedictorian' for second place 'Salutatorian' instead.
In the very first drafts of the Star Trek: Deep Space Nine bible, the then "DR. JULIAN AMOROS" is said to have "graduated second in his class," but no particular reason is provided. By the time of the revised bible of 10 September 1992, as given in The Making of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, Amoros had become Bashir and the preganglionic/postganglionic explanation for missing out on that farewell speech at graduation had been added.
There was always something eminently odd, however, about the mistake in the first place. Lethean Altovar put it best in Distant Voices when he said to Bashir, "But pre-ganglionic fibres and post-ganglionic nerves aren't anything alike. Any first-year student could tell them apart". According to the Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Companion, that line was actually included by episode co-writer Robert Hewitt Wolfe as a nod to his wife Celeste. A "pre-vet" at the time, Celeste had pointed out that, for pre- and post-ganglionic fibres and nerves, "no one [in the medical field] would make such a mistake".
In Distant Voices, it was implied that Bashir deliberately got the question wrong merely because he didn't want the pressure of being Valedictorian. Later, ganglions and nerve fibres would connect — recognisably this time — into something much bigger.
7. Adigeon Prime Your Neurons
The doctoring of Doctor Bashir's genome began life as the B-plot of a pitch by freelance writer Jimmy Diggs. It had Dr. Lewis (or Louis) Zimmerman and the new 'Long-term Medical Hologram (LMH)' with Bashir as template, but according to the Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Companion, writers struggled at first to find the core element of the story, now the A of the episode, but not yet of Adigeon Prime. As René Echevarria stated, "There needed to be some big secret that Zimmerman uncovers, and we couldn't, for the life of us, think what it would be".
As the Deep Space Nine Companion goes on to note, there were still a lot of unanswered questions about Bashir's past, even by season five. He had chosen triage over tennis, but was he good enough to go pro at the sport in the first place, or did he drop the racket just to please his parents? Bashir had been very mysterious about them too. In Homefront, O'Brien practically offered up his folks' place in Dublin as a holiday home to Odo, but Bashir didn't seem to want anyone dropping in on his relations. Finally, of course, there was the matter of those damned ganglions.
The Eugenics Wars-inspired Eureka moment of an answer apparently came from then supervising producer and writer Ronald D. Moore, who, in a "bolt of inspiration," asked, "What if Bashir had been genetically engineered?" The rest was the retroactive of "accelerated critical neural pathway formation" on the titular planet. In an early draft of Doctor Bashir, I Presume, only O'Brien and Zimmerman would have found out the truth about Bashir, the former then blackmailing the latter to keep it quiet. Alexander Siddig opposed the idea, however, not wanting to act the rest of the series with the heavy burden of such a secret.
6. Shouldering The Subtext
For a character like Garak, the only limit to subtext was the number of intricately woven lies the galaxy would permit. As for Bashir, you could always read his emotions like a book — just not one of Shoggoth's Enigma Tales. When the would-be Cardassian tailor and the "thoughtful young man" first met in Past Prologue, the in-between-the-lines was written all over their faces, and then carefully placed on the Doctor's shoulders.
If we can read anything queer into Garak/Bashir at all, it's because the actors rather boldly chose to play it that way. When asked by Ira Steven Behr what Garak really thought of Bashir in What We Left Behind, Andrew Robinson gave the following reply:
At first, he [Garak] just wanted to have sex with him. That's absolutely clear. That's all he wanted from him. […] But then it really got complicated, especially when Garak's addiction and despair began to surface. He needed someone to share it with.
In an interview all the way back in 2000, Robinson revealed that he had "planned Garak not as homosexual or heterosexual but omnisexual". Much later, in 2022, he told The Shuttlepod Show that "they [the producers, we assume]" had "no idea" that's what he had had in mind, but that the moment hands were put on shoulders, Alexander Siddig "picked it [the subtext] right up".
In an interview for The Beat in April this year (2024), Siddig confirmed that he did, indeed, play Bashir's first meeting with Garak that way, stating,
I became visibly flustered. That was entirely my choice. It wasn't written in the script. So, I set off in that direction right from the get-go.
In the same interview, Siddig also noted that he tries to infuse a little "implied homosexuality" into most of his 'written as straight' characters, "probably because I'm not quite straight myself and that's probably perfect".
5. Case Of Loving You
The 'Garashir' ship had sailed long before anyone could climb aboard. There was more chance of Quark donating his entire estate to charity than there was of any real romantic or sexual pairing between Garak and Bashir during the run of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. Producer Ira Steven Behr might well have claimed in What We Left Behind that, after The Wire, "We should have had Garak come out to Bashir as a gay Cardassian," and then go from there with the relationship, but the 'should' in that sentence is doing all the heavy-lifting, and Behr's later "probably not" is decidedly the operative where the studio was concerned.
Bashir was pretty unlucky in love throughout most of the series. Leeta stayed around for the longest, but whatever medical ethics had to say about Sarina, and Melora, moreover, was over in an episode. There was one person, one entity, towards whom Bashir made every effort at an overture, but, as Alexander Siddig put it in What We Left Behind:
Julian Bashir was too immature. […] I was punching above my weight when I was on the same stage with Terry [Farrell]. Jadzia had no need for Bashir.
With Jadzia's untimely death, and the arrival of new Dax host Ezri, things changed. As Siddig concluded, "[Ezri] seemed to need Bashir as much as Bashir needed her".
Although not canon, These Days, the first episode of the four-part online miniseries Alone Together: A DS9 Companion, written by Matthew Campbell and starring the remotely separated Alexander Siddig and Andrew Robinson, continued the story of Bashir and Dax's relationship. In it, we discover that Ezri had died 10 years prior, after which point Dax had been transferred into new host Kairn. Both he, Kairn, and Bashir tried to carry on their relationship. "I had never really considered being in love with another man," Bashir tells Garak, "but it was Dax". Unfortunately, the Symbiosis Commission didn't quite see things the same way.
4. Bullseye Bromance
Familiarity breeds contempt, as the saying goes. Or, perhaps in this case, the best of friendships are, in fact, built on an undercurrent of loathing. Much like a lot of the audience, Miles O'Brien couldn't bear to be around Bashir at first. In The Storyteller, the Chief had to be practically ordered to sit in the same shuttle as the Doctor. It was then the multitude of life and death — mostly death — situations thrust upon them which solidified, and at times tested, the duo's most unique, most endearing relationship.
The bromance might never have begun, however. According to producer Ira Steven Behr in The Fifty-Year Mission: The Next 25 Years, the studio returned with all kinds of suggestions after season one, one of which was that they "put rockets on the station so it could go off and have adventures," and another was that they say goodbye to Bashir. Whilst Behr never knew the studio's exact reasoning, he notes that, "I just felt that they felt the character was an irritant in some way. Which I guess is another way of saying he got on O'Brien's nerves". Everyone was unanimous in refusing both ideas: "The space station was no and getting rid of Bashir was no," concluded Behr.
It was O'Brien's near demise in Armageddon Game, an episode originally slated to feature Dax over the Chief, that truly marked the beginnings of the "bond that can never be broken" between the two men, for the writers and the actors alike. Alexander Siddig regularly cites the episode as a pivotal moment for the pair, the "crux of the relationship" as he put it in Crew Dossier — Julian Bashir.
Of course, Bashir and O'Brien went on to be known for their legions of holosuite adventures, but they also notably played darts — a game introduced for them in Prophet Motive. According to Robert Hewitt Wolfe in the DVD extra Crew Dossier — Miles O'Brien, the pair could have ended up playing pool instead, until writers found out that they wanted to do that on Star Trek: Voyager.
3. Is Kukalaka Helping?
If the character of Doctor Bashir wasn't well received in the beginning, then it was, in part, because he was written in to that unamiable corner. As Alexander Siddig stated in The Making of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, "There was a definite proviso from the production office to make Bashir naïve and arrogant". Far from avoiding such a challenge, however, Siddig embraced it, deciding to play Bashir at the start as "completely imperfect in almost every aspect".
Back when the cost of complaining was the effort of a letter, the studio received hundreds of them in disapproval of "Bashir's personality," as further related in The Making of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. Some of the press at the time certainly didn't seem to disagree. One article in the Philadelphia Daily News from December 1993 simply went with the title "Bashir's A Pain, But Actor Loves Him".
In Crew Dossier — Julian Bashir, Ira Steven Behr acknowledged the initial fan resistance to the "too wet-behind-the-ears" Bashir but noted the determination to change perceptions. "We [were] going to make this character great because Sid is a great actor," Behr concluded. In a 2023 interview with The CloneStar Podcast, Siddig credited the episode Our Man Bashir for changing fans' minds, fans who had "openly vilified" Bashir only the week before.
Whether or not Kukalaka — Doctor Bashir's 'first patient' and teddy bear — made Julian appear like more of a grown-up is another matter, but it did help bring him down to Earth/Bajor and provided for some excellent comedy in In The Cards. Besides, we're all allowed to nourish our inner child. Only those 'Soulless Minions of Orthodoxy' would say otherwise.
2. Now, Who Wants Sandwiches?
Yes, he killed everyone on the Yukon and tried to create a supernova that would have destroyed the entire Bajoran star system — Deep Space 9 and the fleet along with it — but at least the changeling masquerading as Bashir had the otherwise good manners to bring snacks to his work-weary 'colleagues'. "A gentleman and a scholar," in O'Brien's words, none the wiser that his best friend had been replaced by polymorphic goo (no offence, Odo).
It was around the point of the sandwiches in In Purgatory's Shadow that we, the audience, found out that Bashir had been in a Dominion internment centre on an asteroid somewhere in the Gamma Quadrant since at least before the uniform change. In a manner similar to Bashir's genetic status, the changeling 'big reveal' wasn't planned much, if at all, in advance. As Robert Hewitt Wolfe stated in The Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Companion:
We thought, 'Okay, we've got prisoners of the Dominion, but we need a surprise. Something we don't expect. And suddenly we learn that Bashir's a prisoner too. He's been replaced on the station.'
Naturally, the news came as quite the surprise to Alexander Siddig, too, who noted in the DS9 Companion:
Apparently, I'd been a changeling for the previous three or four shows […] But I didn't know until the last minute. […] What a shock!
For reference, see the look on Changeling Bashir's face when the Defiant swoops in in By Inferno's Light.
1. Buttered Scones And Tea
There are two things you should never ask anyone in the UK if you plan on living: 'Is it "scone" to rhyme with "cone" or "scone" to rhyme with "gone,"' and, 'Does the jam or the cream go on first?' Why we are so obsessed over the minutiae of this one baked good is a mystery, although they are delicious. However you say it, Doctor Bashir happened to be partial to a scone, too.
I doubt that its pronunciation ('to rhyme with gone' for Bashir) was part of the test for Section 31, and in any case, in Inquisition, the Doctor got a plateful of gagh in place of his order of hot buttered scones, moba jam, and red leaf tea. Whilst the holographic Worf was presumably tucking in, Sloan and company continued the interrogation-turned-recruitment-pitch.
Although basically ordered by Captain Sisko to play along next time, Bashir never really did get the chance to act out his holosuite spy fantasy in the real world. Bashir did remain absolute in his admonition of the clandestine organisation and paragraph of the Starfleet Charter, nonetheless, even if he and O'Brien would later go to some extreme… lengths to try to get at some of Section 31's secrets.
In the hypothetical of the season eight opener devised and discussed by former Star Trek: Deep Space Nine writers and producers in What We Left Behind, Bashir was a member of Section 31 by 2395, if not "running the goddamn thing," at least to Robert Hewitt Wolfe's mind. A common theme, perhaps. In Alone Together: A DS9 Companion, set about 25 years after the end of the Dominion War, Bashir is also "coordinating the activities of Section 31". He's probably settled the great scone debates, too!