Star Trek: Every Two-Parter Ranked From WORST To BEST
Which Star Trek double episode made you wish away at least the week?
In Star Trek, a two-parter isn't just an excuse not to think of a second title, and sometimes not even that. It is the chance to extend a good story beyond the usual 40 or 20 minutes or so, and leave the audience hanging… "To Be Continued…" or "To Be Concluded Next Week". As Trek fans are currently and keenly aware, almost every iteration, including Strange New Worlds, has used this trick.
Everyone loves a rule, so let's set a few. To count as a two-parter, both episodes must have aired one after the other. That discounts the likes of That Hope is You, Parts 1 & 2, for example. In one fashion or another, both episodes must also have first been broadcast separately. That means no series pilots, no series finales (except one), and no feature lengths like Dark Frontier, The Way of the Warrior, or Flesh and Blood. Finally, we won't be including multi-episode arcs or set-ups for the next season.
Now, who amongst us hasn't done their best rendition of Majel Barrett's computer voice to "Last time on Star Trek…", "And now the conclusion…"? Just me? Well, we'd best get on with it then. In the words of another, also not on this list, "And The Adventure Continues".
42. Terra Firma, Part 1, Terra Firma, Part 2
First on the list, Star Trek: Discovery's third season two-parter is on shakier ground than its title. Terra Firma, Parts 1 & 2 weren't outright bad by any means, but there are 41 double episodes that are better. Life, the Mirror Universe, and Everything, and one in the form of Carl, Guardian of Forever, or it was curtains for Philippa Georgiou.
At the time, Terra Firma was meant as the backdoor (and the big gate) to the ex-Emperor's own spin-off TV show. That was a rocky road to what was Star Trek's first-to-streaming movie. The two-parter's most egregious error was, then, no doubt, that it became 'three-' in what was made of Star Trek: Section 31.
41. Birthright, Part I, Birthright, Part II
Birthright, Parts I & II are fairly forgettable episodes, especially given the competition in the sixth season of Star Trek: The Next Generation. At times, they both border on the tedious. It's not like the Enterprise-D stopped by Deep Space 9 every other Tuesday. Here, there was barely any point that it did, save to get Julian on board.
Most of the two-parter — which really didn't need to be one — was spent in Data's dreams, and then in Worf's 'what Klingon warriors worry about'. Over on Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, they were filming Move Along Home at the same time. It might somehow be preferable just to watch that twice instead!
40. Et in Arcadia Ego, Part 1, Et in Arcadia Ego, Part 2
More Latin is not another copy-and-paste job. In fact, 'Et in Arcadia Ego' is a reminder that, even in paradise, death is ever-present. For Star Trek: Picard's season one finale, the Romulan doomsday of 'Ganmadan' failed to repeat itself. The end of the world (or galaxy) was just the end of Jean-Luc, and the ego death of (a) Data, however fleeting.
The greatest strength of this two-parter is the otherworldly reunion between former captain and former lieutenant commander before Picard 2.0. You'd have to have turned off your emotion chip not to be moved by that. The two-parter's greatest weakness was the self-same duplication, not in ego, but in ships in orbit.
39. Gambit, Part I, Gambit, Part II
'Sacrificing' Captain Picard as merely another pawn in the illicit affairs of the galaxy was a bold move. Naturally, he was never dead in the first place.
The rest of the two-parter wasn't quite as sound, though it was still a lot of fun. The bad guy was as weak as his method of coercion. The bad girl — played by none other than Robin Curtis — was far more entertaining than the 'Stone of Gol' she sought.
That device — a 'psionic resonator' from ancient Vulcan, before the 'Time of Awakening' — was also as odd as Gambit's freeze-frame cliffhanger, the poor man's, The Best of Both Worlds. This was the final season of Star Trek: The Next Generation. Its fourth and fifth episodes could and should have been a lot better. Then again, they could have been Masks.
38. The Vulcan Hello, Battle at the Binary Stars
Yes, we know! We said we weren't doing pilot episodes. In this case, like Michael Burnham, we'll just have to break the rules. Get ready to have your nerves pinched!
The streaming era did things differently from the outset — no main ship, no more Captain Georgiou, and for one, no more Starfleet career (for a bit). The Vulcan Hello and Battle at the Binary Stars weren't the typical treatise for a new series, but, in many respects, more like a classic two-parter with a relatively self-contained plot and a cliffhanger. There was no 'To Be Continued…,' but then, we're still feeling mutinous.
All things considered, this was a solid start for Star Trek: Discovery — a visual feast combined with captivating intrigue. Sadly, we just still haven't recovered from the shock of those Klingons!
37. Storm Front, Storm Front, Part II
As a time traveller, Daniels sure did pick his moments. Just when the crew of the NX-01 thought they were safe after a season-long survival epic, they found themselves flung into another existential crisis for all of time in an alternate 1944. If you thought the Sphere Builders were bad, wait until you've met the "holy mother of…" Na'kuhl!
Storm Front and Storm Front, Part II is a thrilling two-parter that would rank higher on this list, but for its own untimely placement at the start of Star Trek: Enterprise's fourth season, and its rush to wrap up the Temporal Cold War. Like the crew, we, the audience, needed to breathe a little after the Xindi arc.
36. Unimatrix Zero, Unimatrix Zero, Part II
Over the years, Unimatrix Zero has taken more fire than the tactical cube within it. Is it really that bad? No. Is it great? No. Its cliffhanger is also far better than it gets credit. Done and overdone with the Borg, perhaps, but Janeway, Tuvok, and B'Elanna all assimilated? Come on! That was still pretty shocking. Of course, the real cliffhanger was that unrealised rendezvous with Harry.
Unimatrix Zero's greatest strength was also its greatest weakness. The very idea of a resistance movement within the Borg collective unconscious was a good one. Its execution was lacklustre. The romantic relationship at its core failed to convince. Banished to the backends of the Beta Quadrant, Mr Axum was never spoken of again.
35. First First Contact, Grounded
The first of the animated entries on this list was the first to use 'To Be Continued…' since the Star Trek: Enterprise episode Demons (see later on this list). It was also the first time — we assume — that Captain Freeman had been arrested, and accidentally perp-walked, in front of her crew, providing for quite the jaw-dropping cliffhanger to the second season of Star Trek: Lower Decks.
First First Contact ended on an emotional beat. Grounded picked up to pure comedy chaos as various screens (and potted plants) were turned off Beckett Mariner style, all with a view of the 'impractical' Golden Gate Bridge. The episode then did the smorgasbord of Earth hotspots and self-references — from ketracel-white hot gumbo at Sisko's Creole Kitchen to churros in Bozeman and raisins in Modesto.
34. Such Sweet Sorrow, Such Sweet Sorrow, Part 2
Star Trek: Discovery's second season impressed enough that fans demanded a spin-off by way of petition. Before Pike, Spock, and Una could get their own, the Discovery had to be sent off to the 32nd century, and never spoken of again in the 23rd (onwards) under penalty of treason.
If it's a space battle you desire (and why wouldn't you?), a space battle you shall get. 'The Battle Near Xahea' in Such Sweet Sorrow, Part 2 still ranks as one of the best put to Trek, barely skipping a dramatic beat. The mid-point arrival of Po, the Klingons, and sister Siranna was the touch that sealed the deal.
All in all, Such Sweet Sorrow is a visually stunning two-parter, which would have placed higher on this list, but for a few liberties and liabilities with the plot. The unfortunate fact is that Discovery's spore drive was more science fantasy than science fiction, and a canonical contortion, in the first place. Its use did eventually grow on us, not unlike one of its mushrooms. Its non-use for over 900 years was always a fudge though.
33. The Inner Fight, Old Friends, New Planets
How spoiled do you have to be to demand more from a world in which everything is already free? The answer to that question is measured in 'Nick Locarnos'. Dead ringer or not, Locarno was no Tom Paris, barely even a Lieutenant Marseille. He proved that much in the two-part season four finale of Star Trek: Lower Decks.
In fact, only Lower Decks could bring back an obscure, but ultimately memorable, character as the 'big bad' of the season at the end of an episode that owes its pun to another. The Locarno cliffhanger will hold up as one of the most shocking of all time.
Old Friends, New Planets was just as strong. Nova Squadron got a self-promotion to Nova Fleet, and we got to see more through flashbacks of the events surrounding The First Duty. Boimler in command knocked it out the park, and smashed it into the shield grid. And let there be latinum, or it's Genesis for you!