Star Trek Phase II: The Series That Never Happened

Star_Trek-The-Original-Series After the cancellation of Star Trek: The Original Series, bringing the crew back to our screens was a long a torrid affair that took over a decade. Sure, we had the Animated Series in the early 70's, but the fans wanted live action, and they made this well known at the conventions around that period. The immediate thought was to bring the show to the big screen €“ movies! So Gene Roddenberry teamed up with Paramount Pictures and began to work on his script, tentatively titled Star Trek: The God Thing. Now I don't know what it is with Roddenberry, but for some reason he always seemed to go back to religion, and he tried to do it once more. Paramount didn't like it and so they ended up shopping around for other scripts. After a run in with a famous writer and a studio executive who was obsessed with the Maya Culture resulting in the writer refusing to work on it anymore, the producers finally started work on a film called Star Trek: Planet of the Titans. Now if you remember that the first film was called Star Trek: The Motion Picture, you'd figure that wasn't a good sign. You're right. It wasn't. First Leonard Nimoy wouldn't come back after they used his face as Spock on a beer advert without his permission. Then it seemed that William Shatner's contract wouldn't allow him to come back. Then they released Star Wars. Why is Star Wars significant? Well, you see it was in two different ways. First back during the early years of trying to get a film off the ground, George Lucas enquired about whether the rights to make a Star Trek film was up for purchase. They turned him down, and he went on to create Star Wars instead. Then when Star Wars was released, the executives in charge of the prospective Star Trek film decided to can it. Their reason? Because science fiction fans wouldn't pay to see two science fiction films released within a year or two of each other. Obviously. With that in mind, in 1977 the Paramount executives turned their minds to bringing Star Trek back to television. This was the near birth of Star Trek: Phase II €“ the second live action series in the franchise.

Conception

Uss Enterprise Ncc 1701 A Auf Dem Weg Nach Khitomer

The Original Series was to be set around a five-year mission, something re-referenced at the end of this year's Star Trek Into Darkness. Phase II would have seen a second five-year mission take place, and it would have seen much the same changes as that which eventually went into Star Trek: The Motion Picture. By this I mean that the USS Enterprise would have been re-fit, and the crew would be invigorated by the addition of new crew members. However, this was partly not by design, but by necessity. You see, Leonard Nimoy refused to come back as Spock in a new television series. Two years earlier he'd released his autobiography, I Am Not Spock €“ while the title was misleading (it referred to Nimoy and Spock as being separate entities and recounting his dislike for people being disappointed that he wasn't in fact his character), the merchandising for the character was an irritant for him and he simply did not want to return to television in that guise. So Roddenberry split the role in two. Instead of having a Vulcan first officer who was also the science officer, he instead intended on casting both a first officer and separately a science officer. In addition, there was to new a third new character €“ and you'll probably remember this one €“ it was Lieutenant Ilia, played by Persis Khambatta.

Casting

Lt Ilia

So in addition to Persis Khambatta joining the crew in her role of Ilia, which would later transfer to Star Trek: The Motion Picture, you also had the part of Commander William Decker. This part was never cast during the production phase of Phase II, but the roles were pretty much the same in the later film. You might also know more about how the two were intended to interact by watching Star Trek: The Next Generation. You see, Decker and Ilia later became the basis for Deanna Troi and William Riker (originally Ryker). Although in Troi's case, I don't think they ever planned to shave Marina Sirtis' head. Also, the Kirk/Decker relationship was intended to be something akin to a father/son bond. Plus, although with Number One in The Cage only being referred to as such being the obvious source for Picard later calling Riker the same €“ it was actually the intention that Kirk would call Decker "first" as a nickname. Considering the re-use of the character with regards to the Decker/Ilia relationship, I wouldn't be surprised if this was also the source of Riker's nickname. Xon The third character €“ the science officer €“ didn't cross over properly into the later film as he was replaced by the return of Nimoy. But for Phase II, David Gautreaux was cast as Xon. The character was Vulcan, but unlike Spock, he was intended to be a full-blooded Vulcan. He was also to be much younger than Spock, but a genius. The 1977 writers/directors guide for the show explains the difference between Xon and Spock better than I can:
Xon realizes that the reason that Spock performed so well in his tasks on board the Enterprise was that he was half Human and therefore could understand emotional Human nature. In order to perform as well as Spock, he knows he is going to have to eliminate his Vulcan revulsion at emotional displays. He is, in fact, going to have to reach down within himself and find the emotions that his society has repressed for thousands of years so that he will have some basis for fully understanding his Human associates. What this means is: whereas Spock was engaged in a constant battle with himself to repress his emotions in order to be more Vulcan-like, Xon will be engaged in a constant struggle within himself to release his buried emotions to be more Human-like for the sake of doing a good job, his primary considerations. This will be at least as difficult for him as it was for Spock to maintain his stoic pose. Also, we'll get humor out of Xon trying to simulate laughter, anger, fear, and other Human feelings.

The Pilot: In Thy Image

Star Trek Motion Picture Vger

Originally proposed by Alan Dean Foster, and written at a time when the characters for Phase II weren't clearly known (including references to "Lt. Vulcan" as Xon was yet to be named or cast), In Thy Image was changed and changed until it eventually became Star Trek: The Motion Picture. However, the core elements of the story remained the same, resulting in Foster getting a story credit for the film. This version was intended to be a single episode. Essentially the V'Ger probe became life as a machine intelligence "we of the Wah, servants of the god N'sa" (which was intended to be pronounced "en-sa" so as to not let viewers onto the NASA reference too early. The mission of the vessel was to return to Earth and wipe out all biological containments from the planet. However, in this version of the story there are robot duplicates of dangerous animals, and then duplicates of the crew. It ends up being McCoy who saves the day, as he creates a robot version with a bomb in it, and when the robots return to the Wan vessel, they take the bomb on board. This shows the superiority of organics over technology and the Wan back down. Note that in the treatment there was no "Wan" or "N'sa" reveal. It may have been intended that there would be a later follow up episode. Harold Livingston re-wrote the premise and produced the first script. In his version, elements which are more familiar to The Motion Picture become evident, such as the involvement of the Klingons at the start. The robot version of Ilia is the only one that remains from Foster's version, as we later see it in the film. In this version the Wan is renamed to Vejur and NASA is specifically referenced. The ending is the biggest difference between Livingston's version and the eventual film €“ in the film, both Ilia and Decker are written out. In the Phase II version, they devise a plan where the Enterprise communicates with Vejur and convinces it to spare the citizens of Earth as they are in fact Vejur's creator. Vejur then refuses all further contact with the humans and leaves, after Ilia re-appears on the Enterprise.

Kitumba

Trek Article Klingon

This was intended to be a two part episode, which would have result in some drastic changes to the Klingon race. Essentially the basis for who the Klingons were would have been different €“ because the intention was to make them into samurai. In the same way that the Romulans were meant to be Romans. So with the samurai Klingons, throw out your ideas of Emperor Kahless €“ because they aren't here anymore. In fact throw out the entire planet, there's no such thing as Qo'noS either. In fact, they aren't even Klingons. Confused? You should be. In Kitumba it is established that the race we previously thought were called Klingons €“ but this actually the name of their warrior caste. The cast for science and technology are called the technos, and all others are simply subjects. There is still a High Council, but no Emperor in name, instead that role lies with the Kitumba. But the Kitumba is a spiritual and ceremonial role. Instead, the Warlord of the race has all the power. I said they threw out Qo'noS, didn't I? Well the home planets (yes, planets) of the race are known as Ultar, while an inner planet is the sacred planet for the Kitumba. Neither planet is defended because they believe that their species are undefeatable. So on with the plot, basically, the Enterprise travels deep into Klingon (well I don't what else to call them) space to return the former teacher of the new Kitumba. The teacher defects to prevent all out war between the Klingons and the Federation and the Enterprise crew must try to convince the Kitumba to speak out against attacking the Federation, ending the tradition of non-interference with the Warlord.

Other Episodes

Star Trek The Child

We know the synopsis for the first thirteen episodes of Phase II, and while the majority of them would have been fine, a particular two-part episode called Kitumba would have drastically changed some elements of modern Star Trek. In addition to the pilot itself, you'll recognise two other episodes because they later re-used them for episodes of Star Trek: The Next Generation.

Tomorrow and the Stars

This was a bit of a mish-mash of Original Series ideas. Basically a transporter accident result in Kirk ending up in Pearl Harbour shortly before the Japanese Attack. He falls in love with a married woman, and realises that he can't warn anyone because of the drastic consequences it would have for the Second World War.

The Child

This is the first of our Star Trek: The Next Generation double bill. This one didn't change a great deal, with Troi taking on the Ilia role. The main reason why it's pretty much the same as the Phase II version is because at the time there was a writer's strike on and so they were unable to re-write it. The story was originally pitched by Jaron Summers, but it was Jon Povill who later took on the idea and redeveloped it. In fact the only significant difference other than the crew and the vessel, was that the alien which possessed Ilia was in part of a development life cycle that required the process rather than simply being an inquisitive alien.

Cassandra

A story by Theodore Stugeon, writer of Original Series episodes Amok Time and Shore Leave. It was intended to be a comedy episode. Basically think clumsy Yeoman and a cute cuddly animal. Hijinks! Hijinks!

Practice in Waking

This is essentially a holodeck story before they thought up a holodeck. But replace the holodeck with "directed dreaming" where the same dream is shared by multiple crew members €“ and those crew members get stuck and forget that they're dreaming.

Deadlock

A story of mind control, testing on crew members and the changing of the perceptions of reality. Apparently all perpetrated by Starfleet on its own crew. Or is it?

Other Episodes - Continued

Star Trek Devils Due

Savage Syndrome

This story had some great writers involved in it €“ David Gerrold was one of the ones involved in the original premise and Margaret Armen was involved in the development alongside Alfred Harris. Basically technology overly projects negative emotions on the crew, resulting in them turning on each other. Could have been cheesy, or could have been really good.

Are Unheard Memories Sweet?

The nudity in this episode wouldn't have made it to air, that much is certain. The rest of the premise is that the Enterprise is out of dilithium and is falling into orbit of a planet while an alien race abduct the crew. It was written by Worley Thorne, who was later credited as one of those who re-wrote the teleplay for The Next Generation episode Justice. Not really all that confidence inspiring then.

Devil's Due

A great deal more differences in this episode when it was remade for Star Trek: The Next Generation than The Child. Watch that version of Devil's Due then come back here. I'll wait. Ready? Ok. Now remember that episode but replace Data with the Enterprise computer itself, and hide McCoy in a wall. Confused? I am too €“ not an easy premise to follow. Involves old people de-aging and prophets and all manner of fooey. The Next Generation version took the basic idea and improved it greatly. In fact it amuses me that people say that it was like an episode of The Original Series, because only the "devil" character itself remains the same, pretty much all other characters are different and only a single element of the basic plot remains.

Lord Bobby's Obsession

This story expanded the Star Trek universe with stories about the development of the Britannic Commonwealth, and also added some more to the Klingons (or whatever we should call them) €“ as it turns out they were abducting humans in the 1950s in flying saucers. I wish I was making it up.

To Attain The All

A Norman Spinrad story, so it might have turned out a great deal better than I'm about to describe it. The Enterprise attempts to decipher a solar system sized logic puzzle in order to obtain a cache of advanced knowledge. Coming from the guy who wrote The Doomsday Machine €“ it would have probably been quite good.

The War To End All Wars

Although this was on the drawing board, I doubt it would have ever been shot as originally intended €“ it would have been far too expensive and there is no way it would have fit into a single episode as intended. Kirk comes across a planet where wars involving androids has essentially become a spectator sport. So on the budget list, we have armies of androids, android tanks, massive battle scenes... it wasn't going to happen, was it?

So What Happened To Phase II?

Star Trek Motion Picture Cast

Well much as Star Wars was the cause of Phase II being developed in the first place, it was another science fiction film which ended it. You see, Close Encounters of the Third Kind was released and proved to Paramount executives that science fiction films other than Star Wars could be successful at the box office. At the same time, Phase II was already shooting test shots, costumes had been designed (essentially the same as seen in The Original Series) and sets were built. But it was expensive, and Paramount were feeling the pinch for what was only a television series after all. Personally I think they read the pitch for The War To End All Wars and got scared. So to re-coup their losses on the television series when they decided to cancel it, they sought to make the pilot into a film. Several tweaks later, new costumes made, the return of Leonard Nimoy... and you have Star Trek: The Motion Picture. It's more complicated than that, but you get the idea. A major change they made was to ditch the Phase II costumes and bring in a new one piece uniform in pastel shades... which wasn't for the better. But can probably be glad that we didn't get Phase II. If it wasn't for the films and the success of The Next Generation in syndication then we wouldn't have a franchise today. The Klingons could have become a hopeless mess, and did we really want to take The Original Series into the 1970s anyway? I think the key thing to look at here for illustration is Galactica 1980. That lasted all of ten episodes. I can't imagine that Phase II would have been much more successful. However, if you really want to watch episodes of Phase II then you can now, because there is the fan production Star Trek: Phase II (formerly known as New Voyages). They've done The Child and Kitumba so far. The only difference there is that they have both Spock and Xon, but no Decker or Ilia.

Contributor
Contributor

I'm a pop culture addict. Television, cinema, comics, games - you name it, and I've done it. Or at least read the plot synopsis on Wikipedia.