Star Trek: Picard - 7 Ups & 2 Downs From Stardust City Rag

Engaged, finally.

Star Trek Picard
CBS

Hello. I'll get straight to the point here, this was the best episode of Star Trek: Picard so far. Not a perfect episode of course, but whatever bars the show has set thus far were either reached, surpassed, or outright smashed through. We had gore, sacrifice, comedy, emotion, shocks, history, deaths, horror, a phaser fight in a nightclub, and one of the best exchanges in Star Trek history. What the hell else were we tuning in for?

For a show that's undoubtedly lost viewers already because of it's slow pace and it's obsession with the future over the present, this felt like the week that everything finally clicked into gear. No more crews to be assembled, no more stages to be set, just one man and his mission to save a young woman he's never met. Possibly even the entire Galaxy while he's at it.

This week our adventurers finally arrive at Freecloud. There they hope to find Bruce Maddox, an estranged family, and a way to finally reach Dhaj's sister. As we enter the second-half of the season there's still a lot to get through, but what delights would we get this week...


Downs...

2. Aren't We Forgetting Something...

Picard Soji Narek
CBS

Now, this might just be me, but I've got this vague recollection of there being some other story going on in this show?

Something about a girl who's maybe an android? Or maybe she's not? And she's on this Borg cube somewhere and people keep wigging out when they see her? Also she's sleeping with this guy who might also be sleeping with his sister who's a Romulan but also she's not and she's a human sometimes? Her name was Destroyer... something?

I must have just imagined it though. Either that or that show's producers have completely forgotten about it. Which is a shame because it's now been two weeks since the scene with her and the former drone and, despite that being one of the most tantalising reveals in the show so far, we've learned nothing more about it.


1. Remember Elnor?

Picard Elnor
CBS

Now, this might just be me, but I've got this vague recollection of there being some interesting new character introduced last week?

Something about a young Romulan boy who grew up with a sect of warrior nuns? Who's incredibly skilled with a sword and cleaved the head off a man after delivering a killer line like "choose to live"? He's got all sorts of pent up angst and an unresolved abandonment complex because of Picard? His name was... "now you listen here" or something?

I must have just imagined him though. Either that or that show's producers have completely forgotten about him. Which is a shame because they apparently replaced him with a dork in a jacket who apparently can't deduce meaning or intent from normal people talking. Also he doesn't take his sword on dangerous away missions, for some reason.


Ups...

7. Eye, Borg

Picard Icheb
CBS

Star Trek: Picard has put a lot of effort into making this feel like no other Star Trek show you've seen before. Everyone's swearing, everyone's shagging, and former Starfleet officers even get pop-up adverts for drug dens. But our opening scene this week took things to another level entirely.

Not since the opening scenes of Star Trek: First Contact has the franchise veered so stylistically into body horror, but seeing poor Icheb have his eye viscerally ripped from its socket will have shocked virtually everyone watching. This was something straight out of a slasher flick, and carried more weight in its execution than any f-bombing Admiral.


6. Jeri Ryan

Seven of Nine
CBS

It took me an entire night to sleep on this point but, when the realisation finally arrived, it hit me like a bolt of lighting. There was something... 'off' about Jeri Ryan's performance this week, and to an extent that it didn't really feel like you were actually watching Seven of Nine. The way she speaks, the way she carries herself, it just didn't quite feel right.

As jarring as it is though, of course it doesn't feel right. Here is a woman who has reclaimed so much more of her humanity than she managed in the few years we saw her on Voyager, that the version of her were used to is little more than a distant - and likely painful - memory. We're watching a huge evolution in this performance, and Ryan deserves credit for managing to pull it off while still dipping back into the Seven of old when required.


5. In Orbit

Star Trek Picard
CBS

Think I've made this point in previous weeks but the work being done to flesh out the individual stories of the supporting cast has been one of the show's most consistent plus points. Every week feels like a new chapter in Picard's story, but by dedicating just a few minutes (or even just one scene) to the rest of the crew we're fleshing out their stories really well.

This week saw Rios in awe of his Borg crewmates, Raffi desperately attempting to reconnect with her estranged son and, in the process, showing us more about what she's been through since the Synth attack on Mars and, as for Agnes... bloody hell. First we learn that she and Maddox were actually lovers, before the closing scene pushes us into the business end of the story.


4. Easter Eggs

Star Trek Picard
CBS

This could be an entire article itself (and indeed it will be) but the amount of Easter Eggs and clever references hidden in this episode were a golden gift from heaven to bigtime Star Trek nerds. They ranged from the subtle to the blatant, from the huge to the hidden, and it'll likely be weeks until they're all fully uncovered.

A few quick highlights if you've not read the full article yet. Quark getting namedropped and apparently franchising out his bar, Maddox drinking Tranya from The Original Series, The Breen, The Neutral Zone, Picard's old Bolian barber from the Enterprise-D, the USS Voyager and, best of all, Seven of Nine being caught off-guard at the use of her human name, Annika.


3. Patrick Stewart

This scene, and the performance that went with it, should not have worked.

Posing as Borg-trafficking rogues, Picard, Elnor, Seven and Rico beam down to Freecloud to try and spring Bruce Maddox from his underworld captors. Presumably not convinced that Jean-Luc could master the subterfuge with a soft English accent he, instead, goes full am-dram, campy... I don't even know the word... french... i... fied(?) pantomime villain and you have never seen a man having more fun with a role.

It should, as I've said, absolutely not have worked. It should have detracted from the tension in the scene or the emotion of the reveals but, in Patrick Stewart's hands it's the shows first, real Show Your Non-Star Trek Friends moment. It's daft, enjoyable TV, and a welcome break from the intensity of the show thus far.


2. This Scene Alone

Picard Seven of Nine
CBS

When Star Trek: Picard finishes we're going to have years of debating whether or not it was a worthy addition to the canon. Being such a departure from the show we hold so dear it's destined to divide fans across the spectrum, and will likely have words like "misunderstood" or "misguided" hanging around its neck. That said though, wherever you end up in that particular conversation, we're all going to agree that it was worth it all for this one, small scene.

Taking her leave from her new crewmates, Seven stops to ask Picard a question. She drops the tough-girl persona, and plays the part almost identically to how she portrayed it in Voyager. Everything, from the delivery of her lines, the pronunciation of her words, and the skittish hesitation to meet his gaze, is perfectly done.

After they brought you back from your time in the Collective. Do you honestly feel that you regained your humanity?... Yes.All of it?... No.

She steps onto the transporter pad as the theme from Star Trek: Voyager rises in the background, and this show's most iconic moment (and probably one of the best scenes in any Trek show ever) is born.


1. The Plot Really Thickens

Star Trek Picard
CBS

For all the complaints about Picard taking ages to actually get going, about it being far more obsessed with the story it's going to tell, rather than the one it is telling, this episode finally put that to bed. We're here now, in the midst of this fascinating story, and we're traveling at warp speed. Maddox has served his role, we know where Soji is, the conspiracy around the Synth attacks is coming to the fore, and Agnes has made her move.

It was undeniably a slow start, but with all the pieces in place now there's the perfect amount of time left to run through it all. The probable pacing of the last few episodes feels genuinely exciting, and the stories they've crafted for them are each fascinating in their own right. What does Agnes know? How does it connect to Mars? How does it connect to Soji? Is the Federation responsible? Tune in next week to find out.


Managing Editor
Managing Editor

WhatCulture's Managing Editor and Chief Reporter | Previously seen in Vice, Esquire, FourFourTwo, Sabotage Times, Loaded, The Set Pieces, and Mundial Magazine