Star Trek: Top 10 Original Series Episodes

mirror mirror

In so many ways Star Trek was the Little Series that Could. It took two pilots before Gene Roddenberry€™s €œWagon Train to the stars€ idea was picked up by a network, and even then the series was marred with doubts by the network execs, ever-decreasing budgets, schedule changes, producer changes, threat of cancellation, cancellation, and creative battles enough to fill volumes. And many of those volumes have been written.

When the series entered syndication in the early 1970s, people started to watch. In the end, Star Trek became a billion dollar franchise for Paramount and a cultural phenomenon, thanks largely to a loyal core audience and the power and universality of its storytelling. Long before the Star Trek movies, long before J.J. Abrams, long before €œBeam me up, Scotty€ was a bumper sticker, there was Gene Roddenberry. The creator and producer of the original Star Trek series was a visionary and hands-on executive who spent his nights rewriting scripts and striving to make Trek a powerfully unique vision for the future. But Roddenberry€™s many battles with the studio and the network resulted in his decreased participation over the series€™ three seasons, and as a result the budget and quality of the episodes decreased accordingly. Therefore, in looking at the ten best episodes of the original series, the majority come from season one, when Roddenberry was heavily involved in every aspect of each show. In compiling the list, we considered the power of the storytelling, the impact of each show on the Star Trek canon, its relevance to and influence on science fiction culture then and now and its uniqueness overall. This list omits several favorites, including Journey to Babel and Trouble with the Tribbles, but we only have room for ten, so bear with us.

10. Wolf in the Fold

the wolf

Robert Bloch, author of the novel Psycho, penned the script for this second season show, and it represents one of the series€™ darker adventures. While on shore leave on a peaceful planet, Scotty is accused of the murder of a young exotic dancer. When others are murdered, apparently by Scotty€™s hand, he is put on trial by the Prefect Jaris.

This is a Jack the Ripper story, and makes the list because of it. It€™s a classic murder mystery: a corpse, a murder weapon, suspects with alibis, red herrings, a trial and the surprise reveal of the true murderer at the episode€™s climax, Perry Mason fashion. The only science fiction element that intrudes on the murder mystery genre is when the Enterprise computers are utilized to determine if witnesses are telling the truth. Memorable Line: "In the strict scientific sense, Doctor, we all feed on death. Even vegetarians." - Spock

9. The Menagerie

Menagerie The Menagerie, which won the 1967 Hugo Award for Best Dramatic Presentation, was the only two-part episode of the original Star Trek series. Roddenberry made a wise decision in taking footage from the first (rejected) Star Trek pilot, The Cage, and building a story around it for the regular season run. The end result produced two episodes less than the cost of one, and gave audiences a glimpse into a vision of Star Trek that never made it on the air. Spock kidnaps the invalid former captain of the Enterprise, Christopher Pike, commandeers the ship and sets a course for Talos IV, a forbidden planet. Spock is caught and court-martialed, and during his trial he is able to make his defense through mysterious video transmissions from Talos IV. When Spock€™s motivations are understood, he is vindicated and Pike remains on the forbidden planet to live out his life healthy and whole again. The Cage is cerebral science fiction, which is why it failed as a television pilot. The network wanted more action and adventure. Roddenberry was able to incorporate his central ideas €“ a racially diverse cast, thoughtful and relevant stories €“in the second Star Trek pilot, Where No Man Has Gone Before. The Menagerie established a number of important elements in Star Trek lore: it represented an early (pre-series) adventure of the USS Enterprise; it provided a glimpse into the career of her first captain, Christopher Pike; and it presented a slightly different, semi-emotional portrayal of Spock. Memorable line: "Captain Pike has an illusion, and you have reality. May you find your way as pleasant." - Talosian Keeper, to Kirk

8. Mirror, Mirror

mirror mirror Mirror, Mirror is best known for the €œevil€ Spock, the one with the goatee. There was something about the character, and the way Nimoy portrayed him, that resonated with fans. It€™s fascinating to recognize that Mirror Spock is not that different than good Spock. Both are fiercely logical, pragmatic, yet each proceeds from a radically different world (galaxy?) view. The idea of parallel universes is explored in this episode. The landing crew is transported to the Enterprise of a parallel universe, a universe where each character has a duplicate and the Federation is a force of terror in the galaxy called the Empire. In Mirror, Mirror, Star Trek explored the ideas behind quantum theory and mechanics long before the subject was tackled seriously by physicists. While the mirror universe was revisited again in both Star Trek: Deep Space Nine and Enterprise, many books, television shows and movies have dealt with the idea of parallel realities to the point where it has become a staple of the science fiction genre. Memorable line: "You're a man of integrity in both universes, Mister Spock." - Kirk

7. Space Seed

space seed Space Seed was not only one of the original series€™ best episodes, but it spawned the plot for the 1982 motion picture Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan, considered by many to be the best of the original crew€™s big screen outings. One of the most memorable Trek villains, Khan Noonien Singh, appears in this first season episode and played with a fierce, understated menace by Ricardo Montalban. When the Enterprise encounters a spaceship adrift in space, they discover hibernating humans within. These humans aren't just lost in space€”they€™ve been marooned there for centuries for their crimes against the people of Earth. And of course, like many TOS villains, they take over the Enterprise. Space Seed proffers several classical dramatic themes, including the quest for power and how power can be a seductive force. The episode dealt with the genetic alteration of human beings, a common sci-fi element today, but in the 1960s such a practice was a reference to the atrocities committed by the Third Reich in its quest to purify the Aryan race. The back story to Space Seed mentions the eugenics wars of the 1990s, during which Khan and his army, genetically engineered as superior human beings, attempt to take over the world. Memorable Line: "I signed aboard this ship to practice medicine, not to have my atoms scattered back and forth across space by this gadget." - McCoy

6. Amok Time

trek star When Spock seems on the verge of suffering an emotional breakdown, Kirk and McCoy learn that he is going through pan farr, a physiological condition occurring in Vulcan males every seven years. Spock must return to his home planet and take a wife. In €œAmok Time,€ audiences got a peek at the planet Vulcan for the first time, and the culture and customs of the galaxy€™s most logical race are explored. Much of Trek lore came to be in this episode, particularly as it pertains to Vulcans and their hot, arid planet. Credit is given to Leonard Nimoy himself for developing the Vulcan salute. Amok Time highlights the relationships shared by the series€™ three main characters€”Kirk, Spock and McCoy. While suffering the effects of pan farr, we glimpse Spock€™s human, emotional side: his capacity for anger, his genuine affection for McCoy, and his grief at having killed Captain Kirk. When Kirk turns up alive at the end of the episode, Spock is so overcome with joy that for a brief moment he loses his Vulcan mask altogether. Memorable line: "What they are about to see comes down from the time of the beginning, without change. This is the Vulcan heart. This is the Vulcan soul. This is our way." - T'Pau

5. Balance of Terror

balance of terror

The Enterprise encounters the Romulans in this first season episode that ranks among Trek€™s best.

It€™s been suggested that Roddenberry and writer Paul Schneider gleaned inspiration for this episode from the 1958 film Run Silent, Run Deep, wherein a US submarine commander seeks to destroy a Japanese sub. Mark Leonard (who would later play the role of Sarek, Spock€™s father) is the Romulan commander who has been attacking Earth outposts near the Neutral Zone. The Enterprise engages the Romulans and race to destroy their warship before it can return to its home base. The bulk of the episode is a tense, running battle between two starships, where wits and intuition are more important than might or firepower. Balance of Terror is perhaps the most nautical of the original Star Trek episodes, an element that writer/director Nicholas Meyer was attracted to, an element that he incorporated heavily into Star Trek II. Meyer even went so far as to use the sub warfare idea during in the climactic scene in Star Trek II where Kirk and Kahn engage in a running battle a nebula where their ships€™ instrumentation doesn't function. Balance of Terror also dealt with the issue of racial bigotry, a hot topic at the time and an issue Star Trek would address again and again throughout its three season run. Memorable line: "I wish I were on a long sea voyage somewhere. Not too much deck tennis, no frantic dancing. And no responsibility." - Kirk

4. The Corbomite Maneuver

Corbomite Early in the first season the crew of the Enterprise encounters a €œspace buoy,€ and they destroy it. As the Enterprise continues on they encounters a massive starship called the Fesarius. Its commander, Balok, perceives the Enterprise as hostile and tows the Enterprise away to be destroyed. In this episode we see the development of Kirk€™s character as a commander of a starship, his reliance on Spock€™s logic to help him make life or death decisions, and his friendship with McCoy, who appeals to Kirk€™s compassion and humanity. The Corbomite Maneuver concludes with the Enterprise getting the upper hand in its conflict with the alien Balok, but instead of destroying Balok€™s ship, Kirk reaches out a hand in friendship. The human capacity for compassion is portrayed in many episodes (including Space Seed). The desire to put conflicts aside and foster peace and friendship is not only a hallmark of Star Trek but a bold vision for the future. Memorable line: €œWhat am I, a doctor or a moon shuttle conductor?€ - McCoy

3. Where No Man Has Gone Before

whee

The second pilot made by Gene Roddenberry actually put Star Trek on the air and ranks as one of the best episodes of the original series. And because it was produced as a pilot, great care and attention were taken with the development of the script and the characters.

Sally Kellerman and Gary Lockwood guest-starred in this story about two crew members who develop psychic powers when the Enterprise passes through the great barrier at the edge of the galaxy. Lockwood€™s powers become god-like, and it falls to Captain Kirk to take him out, any way he can. It was the final, climactic fight scene on a lone planet between Lockwood and Kirk that sold the series. What makes this episode important is that it established Spock€™s character as a Vulcan: he eschews emotions and relies wholly on logic. His close friendship with Kirk is fleshed out over a game of chess. And it becomes obvious that, while Kirk relies heavily on Spock€™s wise (and logical) counsel, Kirk is frustrated with Spock€™s inability to see the emotional or human side to a crisis, an aspect of Kirk€™s character that will develop with the addition of Dr. Leonard €œBones€ McCoy during the series€™ regular run. Regular viewers of the show will note the changes made in the characters and cast, crew uniforms and Enterprise sets between the shooting of this second pilot and the production of the regular run. It€™s also interesting to note that the captain€™s name in this one episode appears on a tombstone as James R. Kirk. Memorable line: "Will you try for one moment to feel? At least act like you've got a heart." €“ Kirk, to Spock

2. The Naked Time

naked time When a mysterious disease begins affecting the mental state of the crew of the Enterprise, Kirk loses control of the ship. As it spirals out of orbit and toward the planet below, McCoy must find an antidote and the ship€™s engines need to be restored before they all run out of time. Leonard Nimoy has said he was particularly proud of his work in this episode. When Spock is afflicted with the virus, the struggle between his Vulcan half and human comes to a head. Spock weeps. And from this episode on, throughout the run of the original series, the films, and the J.J. Abrams reboot, Spock€™s inner conflict€”logic versus emotion€”is central to his character. While still early in the series run, The Naked Time established the ability of the Enterprise to travel through time, a device that would be used again in the series and more famously in the 1986 film Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home. Memorable line: "Since the formula worked, we can go back in time, to any planet, any era." €“ Spock

1. The City on the Edge of Forever

City 2 While this list of the €œbest€ episodes from Star Trek€™s original run can be debated until the cows come home, The City on the Edge of Forever is almost universally hailed as the best of the original episodes. Despite years of contentious and often exaggerated back-and-forth about who was responsible for the shooting script (Roddenberry and D.C. Fontana both contributed to the final draft), credited screenwriter Harlan Ellison won Hugo award and Writer€™s Guild awards for this episode. McCoy accidentally injects himself with an overdose of cordazine and in a fit of madness flees to the planet below. Kirk and Spock go after him, discovering an entity called the Guardian of Forever, a gateway to any place and any time. McCoy has traveled into Earth€™s past and somehow changed history. The Guardian tells Kirk, €œAll that you knew is gone.€ Kirk and Spock follow McCoy to 1930s New York. They are trapped in time, and must not only find McCoy, but must set right the historical string of events changed by McCoy in the past in order to restore the future as it had been. The Guardian represents Star Trek€™s first reference to a wormhole in space and time, a plot device now commonplace in the science fiction genre. The City on the Edge of Forever also deals with the butterfly effect, the theory that one tiny event can snowball into a catastrophe that impacts the lives of many. By going back in time and saving the life of a woman named Edith Keeler (Joan Collins) destined to die in a traffic accident, McCoy changes the entire history of the planet Earth from that point forward. The layered, character-driven story is perhaps the primary reason this episode is so beloved. For one, Kirk and Spock€™s fish out of water story, space travelers from the 23rd century trying to survive on Earth of the 1930s, provides some of the series€™ finest comic moments. The episode also questions the necessity of war, and reflects the €œIf you could go back in time and kill Hitler would you do it?€ paradox.

The episode delves deep into the close relationship shared by Kirk and Spock. Even Keeler recognizes this, telling Spock that he belongs at Kirk€™s side, €œas if you've always been there and always will.€

Kirk falls in love with Edith Keeler, and when he realizes that she is the focus of the time paradox, he is unsure whether or not he can let her die and allow history to take its course. There is a romantic tenderness about Kirk€™s relationship with Keeler not seen in his other galactic loves, and the pain on his face when he allows her to be killed is among Shatner€™s most memorable moments in the series. Memorable line: "My friend is obviously Chinese. I see you've noticed the ears. They're actually easy to explain. He caught his head in a mechanical...rice picker." - Kirk, to a policeman

Contributor
Contributor

Not to be confused with the captain of the Enterprise, James Kirk is a writer and film buff who lives in South Carolina.