Stranger Things Season 3 Review: 6 Ups & 6 Downs

The third time isn't quite the charm.

Stranger Things Season 3
Netflix

The day has finally arrived! Season 3 of Stranger Things is streaming now on Netflix - some 20 months after the slightly divisive second season dropped - amid hope from fans that it'll serve as a major return to form for the smash hit sci-fi series.

Is that the case? Well, yes and no. Reviews have been pretty consistently positive out of the gate so far, and in several ways Stranger Things 3 builds on a rocky second season, best of all reducing the episode order to eight and forgetting that infamous Chicago detour ever happened.

But it's also fair to say that this is far from the triumphant return to the first season's prevailing quality fans may be hoping for.

Scripting issues abound throughout season three, and overall there's an unshakeable feeling that the Duffer brothers have perhaps grown a tad complacent due to the show's success.

Everything feels so ordinary this time around, even in its better moments. As such, the inevitable fourth season should probably be the last, before the show risks comprising itself with a genuinely bad or undeniably perfunctory batch of episodes...


Downs...

6. The Plot Is Pretty Dull

Stranger Things Season 3
Netflix

The supernatural hooey that comprises Stranger Things' narrative has always been its weakest suit and taken a backseat to the characters, the world-building and the exuberant style.

That's perhaps no truer this time around, though, with a central monster plot involving Russians and Hawkins' nifty new mall that never really inspires the audience to get particularly invested.

Cribbing from countless popular sci-fi films throughout, there's little true creativity or inventiveness here, while the central kids are too often portioned off into their own under-cooked subplots.

This is especially true for Jonathan (Charlie Heaton), who gets virtually nothing to do for the entire season, and Nancy (Natalia Dyer), who spends way too long shoehorned into a tiresome breadcrumb-following plot where she's reinvented as a chintzy Lois Lane knock-off.

Though the surrounding style and performances certainly help prop the lacklustre story up, it's a genuine shame that so much talent and craft is wasted on thoroughly generic sci-fi tosh.


5. Too. Much. Romance.

Stranger Things Season 3.jpg
Netflix

Even for the standards of TV shows revolving around teenagers, there are just way too many romantic subplots crammed into these eight episodes.

In the first half of the season in particular, as many characters as possible are paired-off into predictable couplings that, bar a single exception, lead exactly where you expect they will.

Forced love stories rarely make for compelling drama, and that's absolutely true in this case. Even Eleven (Millie Bobby Brown) and Mike's (Finn Wolfhard) love-in just feels like it's eating up precious time that could be spent exploring literally anything else.

At best, the prolonged devotion to the heroes' love lives is a failed attempt at character development, and at worst it's a soapy attempt to pad out a malnourished central plot.

Sadly, Hollywood will seemingly be forever convinced that audiences won't identify with characters unless they're constantly falling for the nearest person in earshot. Not good.


4. The Wildly Uneven Pacing

Stranger Things Season 3
Netflix

The pacing of this season is totally all over the place, and while the eight episode length ensures it never reaches The Defenders level of exhausting, those first few episodes do take their sweet time to actually do much of consequence.

The first half as a whole feels sluggish, honestly, while the back-four episodes then feel overly rushed, resulting in a hurried sprint all the way to the finish line.

There's much to be said for a show that knows when to pump the brakes and when to ramp things up, but this season seems to have it all wrong: it stands still when you want it to move, and it hits warp speed when you want it to breathe a little.


3. Nostalgia Is A Substitute For Substance (Again)

Stranger Things Season 3
Netflix

One of the most consistent complaints about Stranger Things ever since its inception has been its over-indulgence in nostalgia-bait, leaning heavily on 1980s pop-culture hallmarks to score easy points with audiences.

Sadly season three commits probably the most consistently egregious set of offences in this regard, invoking 1980s sound and imagery to frequently pandering levels.

First and foremost, not since Suicide Squad has a media product so lazily used classic pop songs to convey a feeling or mood.

It's rare for more than 10 minutes to go by, especially in the season's first half, without the show pulling a hamfisted pop lick out of its sizeable jukebox, and it's ultimately more groan-worthy than charming.

In visual terms, there's a cringe-worthy recurring gag that pays awkward tribute to The Terminator, a sequence that lazily invokes Back to the Future, and an embarrassing nod to The Neverending Story that's sure to be talked about until season four is finally with us.

Ultimately, these nods will work fine enough for many, but it's hard to escape the feeling the creators are talking down to audiences and using nostalgia as not only a crutch but a substitute for quality storytelling.


2. The Lack Of Compelling Character Development

Stranger Things Hopper David Harbour.jpg
Netflix

Perhaps the biggest disappointment throughout the season is the bizarre lack of meaningful character development almost across the board.

When the season begins, Hopper (David Harbour) feels like he's regressed back to his season one self without sufficient justification, almost becoming a caricature in the process, and it's a hole he's never really dug out of during the season.

The aforementioned perfunctory romances are meanwhile often used in place of actual character arcs, while surprisingly little is made of the coming-of-age potential better exploited in the two prior seasons.

Meanwhile, if you were hoping that Cary Elwes and Jake Busey might make valuable contributions this season, their new characters are basically both cartoons who get surprisingly little screen time.

For the most part, the show's characters, both kid and adult, feel stuck in the same gear from the beginning of the season to the end, with desperately little personal growth taking place.


1. The Totally Underwhelming Ending

Stranger Things Season 3
Netflix

No spoilers here, of course, but season three doesn't wrap up in a particularly satisfying way. Neither closing the book on these characters with emotion nor making a compelling case for the guaranteed fourth season, it just...happens and that's pretty much it.

There are certainly moments in the season finale clearly intended to be epic and affecting, yet one can already sense how certain characters will be dug out of the holes they've been left in, so it's tough to get much invested.

It doesn't help that there's a painfully unimaginative mid-credits scene which seems to nod directly towards what's next, and suggests the show is taking the most obvious and thoughtless route possible in order to drag things out for (at least) one more go-around.

So, season three has many flaws, then, but it's also got plenty worth praising. Here's what it gets right...


Ups...

6. The Incredible Production Values

Stranger Things 3 Upside Down
Netflix

The most immediately obvious improvement this season is the major uptick in the show's production values, especially where the CGI is concerned.

While the two prior seasons boasted their fair share of low-fi visual effects, the plentiful monster CGI here looks absolutely incredible, even when watching in 4K, which is quite effective at revealing the limitations of VFX.

Digital effects are used not only for the monster but also some brilliantly grotesque body horror elements throughout, helping evoke a big-budget, cinematic feel rather than a mere superficial gloss.

Elsewhere, from the period production design to the sharp cinematography and thoroughly Lovecraftian creature designs themselves, this is one of the most lavishly produced seasons of sci-fi TV you're likely to see all year.

If prior seasons felt like they were stretching their budgets to breaking point, one suspects Netflix might've spent a little more cash on the details this time around.


5. The Ensemble Cast Kills It Again

Stranger Things Hopper
Netflix

Even when the material falters, there's absolutely no criticism here for anyone in the sizeable cast: everyone tries their absolute damnedest to make it work, and they can't be remotely blamed for the narrative shortcomings.

Especially note-worthy is David Harbour, who pushes back hard against some of Hopper's iffy characterisation and once again proves himself the most talented actor in the room.

More surprising is Dacre Montgomery, who does sublime justice to Billy Hargrove's more central role this season, taking a potentially one-note character and exposing his multi-faceted qualities in unexpected ways.

Everybody else pretty much delivers as expected: the kids knock it out of the park again, especially Millie Bobby Brown, and Winona Ryder once more proves how expertly cast she is as Joyce Byers.

Were the performers not this exceptional, it'd be decidedly tougher to sit through some of the season's duller and more offputting moments.


4. Erica Basically Steals The Show

Stranger Things Erica
Netflix

Lucas' (Caleb McLaughlin) sister Erica (Priah Ferguson) returns this season, and there's a solid argument to be made that she gives the most entertaining performance among the entire cast.

Erica gets a much larger role this time around, even more significant than her screen brother, resulting in her delivering many of the season's best one-liners while also getting stuck in with the central monster plot.

Her brilliantly sassy put-downs represent the season's wittiest dialogue, but without Ferguson's knowing delivery, none of it would land with quite the same impact.

Props to the Duffers for appreciating her potential and absolutely building on it this season, all while making her more than the obnoxious sister archetype: she's actually a relatable human being to boot.


3. There's ONE Brilliant Subversion Of Expectations

Stranger Things Season 3.jpg
Netflix

Though the overwhelming majority of the season plays out as you'll most likely expect, this is one upending of audience expectations that works incredibly well.

Without even hinting at what it might be, know that one of the show's more predictable-seeming plots actually ends up delivering a genuinely surprising pay-off.

Subversion for its own sake obviously isn't enough - just look at the divisive response to Star Wars: The Last Jedi - but here the left-turn makes absolute narrative sense, even if the Duffers made everyone brace themselves for a more generic resolution for most of the season.

You'll know what we're talking about when you see it.


2. Robin Is The Best New Addition

Stranger Things Season 3.jpg
Netflix

Though most of the new cast members sadly aren't served very well, there's one notable addition who instantly becomes one of Stranger Things' most likeable characters.

And that's Robin (Maya Hawke), the girl Steve (Joe Keery) works with at the mall's ice cream shop, Scoops Ahoy.

Between her relaxed chemistry with Steve and deeply sarcastic demeanour, she's a major breath of fresh air, serving as a fine foil for just about everyone she encounters, hero or villain.

It doesn't hurt that she's played by the daughter of Ethan Hawke and Uma Thurman and has the acting chops to match, elevating Robin beyond too-cool-for-school cliches and ensuring she's by turns charming, hilarious and eventually vulnerable.


1. The Terrific Direction & Editing

Stranger Things 3 Eleven
Netflix

In addition to the incredible production values and remarkable acting, Stranger Things' third season is often kept aloft by the behind-the-camera craft, namely the work of not only the Duffer brothers, but also fellow directors Uta Briesewitz and Shawn Levy.

There's a clear consistency across their work here, but it never feels like the filmmakers have been forced to fit into a staid "house style", as is so apparent on most of the Marvel Netflix shows.

There are so many individually incredible shots throughout these eight episodes, not to mention some terrifically sharp cuts between scenes, ensuring that even in its lesser moments, the show has an unmistakable cinematic flair that separates it from its genre brethren.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.