Supergirl Season 4: 6 Ups & 3 Downs From ‘Red Dawn’

Supergirl finally collided with the Red Daughter in the season's penultimate episode.

Supergirl S4 Ups Downs 21
The CW

Contains spoilers from Supergirl Season 4, Episode 21.

Though much of Supergirl's fourth season has been heavily influenced by real world events, a significant portion of it has been inspired by a certain Superman comic book.

After seamlessly tying these differing aspects together through Superman villain Lex Luthor, the show finally pulled the trigger on the Big Bad's master plan as, after nearly a year of anticipation, this week's installment finally saw Kara come face to face with, well, herself.

In many ways, 'Red Dawn' was a quest for meaning. Heartbroken at the realisation that there was another version of her that was trained to be nothing more than a weapon, Kara searched for a way in which she could relate to the Red Daughter. Meanwhile, Alex looked for hidden meaning behind her relationship with her sister (a search that bore some emotional results) while, upon realising that he had been manipulated by Lex, Ben Lockwood sought answers.

The season's penultimate episode, 'Red Dawn' certainly delivered on the long-awaited battle between Supergirl and the Red Daughter, hitting some nice emotional beats in the process. Though it wasn't perfect, it has set the stage for what is shaping up to be a compelling finale.

First, the positives.


Ups...

6. An Unexpected Development For Brainiac-5

Supergirl Brainiac 5 Brainy
The CW

While Brainiac-5 found himself going on one of those emotional journeys that everyone else also seemed to embark on during this episode, his was a little more, well, unnatural. Having decided to tell Nia Nal how he truly felt about her, he accompanied her on a mission so he could do just that. But his capture and torture by the anti-alien brigade awakened a different side to his personality.

Speaking about his deadly ancestors (one of which is the deadly Superman villain Brainiac), Brainy was inadvertently reprogrammed and thus, was able to free himself and continue on with his mission to defeat Lex. The only problem was that he now intended to do so as a stone-cold techno-organic computer, feeling little regard for whoever he put in the firing line to make that happen.

Considering Brainy was becoming more human throughout the season, this was an interesting development - one that proved to be a pleasant surprise, as it created another obstacle for the burgeoning romance between the 12th-level intellect and Nia and could possibly even lead to the introduction of Brainiac himself. Moreover, it could end up foreshadowing the returns of both Mon-El and Winn Schott (both of whom went to the future to fight the original Brainiac).


5. Colonel Haley Chooses A Side

Supergirl Colonel Lauren Haley
The CW

Making an unannounced comeback, Lauren Haley returned to the D.E.O. this week to find Director Alex Danvers with apparent fugitive Supergirl. Though the U.S. Colonel was initially shocked, she quickly threw the rule book out the window and offered to help the Girl of Steel.

Haley has been an interesting character to watch grow all season because, when she arrived, she prided herself on being loyal to the leaders of her country. Now, she finds herself in a situation where those leaders are the enemies and in order to stop them, she has to abandon the approach she knows so well.

Though the significance of her actions in 'Red Dawn' was perhaps a little downplayed (considering how much effort had been put into her character development), it was still great to see her choose the right side and, in the process, help the two people that she inadvertently drove apart.


4. Lockwood's Journey Towards Redemption

Supergirl Agent Liberty Ben Lockwood Sam Witwer
The CW

One character lost in the midst of all the alien-centric madness was the season's original Big Bad, Ben Lockwood.

Upon being confronted by Lena Luthor, he realised that Agent Liberty was nothing more than a pawn in Lex's much grander scheme and that he was now simply a loose end. Naturally, the realisation that his entire cause was essentially built upon a lie weighed rather heavily on him and, in doing so, it reminded viewers of all that he had lost in his quest for peace.

Here, we finally saw Ben Lockwood for who he truly was: a troubled man with good intentions that had been manipulated by an evil far greater than that which he was hunting. However, given his current predicament, we could see him avenge that manipulation by becoming the one loose end that Lex had wished he tied up.

This has seemingly positioned Lockwood for a redemption of sorts and, given how compelling both the writing and Sam Witwer's performance have been over the season, that would undoubtedly add another rich layer to the already-strong storyline and could make Agent Liberty quite the wild card in Supergirl's war with Luthor in the season finale.


3. Supergirl Vs. Red Daughter

Supergirl Vs Red Daughter
The CW

Ever since the Season 3 finale, in which Kara used the Harun-El to split Reign and Sam into two separate entities and inadvertently created another version of herself in the process, fans have been eager to see her go up against her own doppelganger. Well, after almost a year of waiting, they finally got their wish in this week's installment.

In 'Red Dawn', Supergirl discovered that the Red Daughter was obsessed with her real-life identity (Kara Danvers) and, as a result, tracked her to Midvale, where she rescued her adoptive mother Eliza before engaging in an all-out war with herself.

While it was somewhat short-lived, it's hard to deny that the fight exceeded viewers' expectations. With plenty of flips, laser beams, and mid-air combat, the clash of the Supergirls was a visual treat that allowed both versions to showcase what they could do while establishing dominance over each other.

It also deserves credit for having a surprising winner and, though the episode's conclusion unfortunately suggests that this may be the last we see of the Red Daughter (more on that later), it certainly looked like it was setting up a rematch for some point later down the line.

Front row tickets to that one, please.


2. Alex Remembers

Supergirl Alex Danvers Kara
The CW

Let's be honest, Alex's inability to remember Kara's life as Supergirl wore thin pretty quickly.

Originally orchestrated by Alex herself, the D.E.O. Director had J'onn wipe Kara's alien origins from her mind in a bid to protect her from Colonel Haley and, by extension, Agent Liberty. But since then, her lack of knowledge regarding her sister's super activities hasn't added anything of value to the plot and, if anything, has hindered the show by taking away one of its strongest aspects.

With that in mind, it was incredibly fulfilling to see Alex finally remember all that she and Kara had been through together as, thanks to a powerful and moving montage that revisited some of their best moments, her memories came flooding back to her.

The relationship between the Danvers sisters is one of the foundations on which Supergirl was built, so it's good to know that it will no longer be limited by a storyline that had begun to wear out its welcome.


1. Chyler Leigh's Performance

Supergirl Alex Danvers Chyler Leigh
The CW

"Please don't leave me." Alex Danvers pleaded as her super-powered sister lay motionless on the ground below her, unaware of the fact that there probably wasn't a dry eye in any house that just so happened to be tuning into that very episode of Supergirl.

Chyler Leigh put everything she had into that performance, giving viewers her heart and soul as Alex attempted to will Kara back to life. Strong performances are absolutely nothing new for her but this was something else entirely.

From tearfully shaking the Girl of Steel's body to desperately shoving a bunch of grass into her hand and begging for her to siphon the sunlight from it, her performance was raw, tender and incredibly moving and, in all honesty, it was impossible not to join Alex in her quest to save her sister.

Without a doubt, one of the strongest actors in TV today, Leigh has always been one of Supergirl's greatest assets, and she proved that again here by turning an already-emotional moment into a real tearjerker. There was an authenticity in this that we just don't see on many CW shows these days and, quite frankly, it was nothing short of beautiful.

Bravo, Chyler! Bravo indeed.

Now, for the negatives...


Downs...

3. Alex's Dream

Supergirl Alex Danvers Chyler Leigh
The CW

Though the narrative of 'Red Dawn' was primarily focused on the Red Daughter, the emotional core was undoubtedly Alex's journey to regaining her memories of her sister's life as Supergirl. While that played out incredibly well, there was one nagging issue that threatened to undercut the emotional impact of that beautiful scene.

The dream in which Alex had at the beginning of the episode featured younger versions of herself and Kara as they clapped along to a song on the radio, only for the latter to accidentally clap too hard and create a powerful surge of wind - obviously alluding to Kara's super powers. Alex then woke up and was left confused by the dream.

Opening the episode with this scene may have set up its conclusion well but, given that Alex had already overcome her memory issues weeks ago, it was a little too convenient that she just so happened to have another memory flash right now.

If this had played out over a series of episodes, it would have added another thread to the compelling narrative and made this seem a whole lot less predictable. Sadly, it wasn't to be.


2. One Trick Otis

Supergirl Otis Graves
The CW

While Ben Lockwood's desperation for answers contained a lot of engaging scenes, his conversation with Otis Graves was not one of them.

For some reason, Otis, knowing full-well that Lockwood was only a pawn in Lex's plan, didn't seem all that perturbed by the fact that Agent Liberty had stumbled upon his old hideout to ask questions about the mastermind's plans - plans that he wasn't supposed to know about. In fact, Otis was more than happy to spill the beans, telling Lockwood all about Lex's intentions for the U.S. before eventually deciding that it was time to kill him.

While it has been established that Otis isn't all that bright, that's no excuse for his lack of reaction when Lockwood turned up, nor does it explain how he went from playing a game to attempting murder in the space of a few seconds.

As he was nothing more than a thinly-written plot device to further Lockwood's arc, it meant nothing when Agent Liberty killed him. On that note, what was the point in reviving Otis (again!) only to have him die (again!) in the most underwhelming way yet?


1. Red Daughter's Apparent Death

Supergirl Lex Luthor Red Daughter
The CW

Lex's evil plan came to fruition when he thwarted the Kasnian attack (that he orchestrated in the first place). Through the use of his own propaganda, he posed in his own super-suit, holding the "dead body of Supergirl". We, however, as viewers, know that this wasn't actually the Girl of Steel and was, instead, the Red Daughter. Thus, the episode's conclusion posed us with the question: Is the Red Daughter dead?

Given her apparent change-of-heart following her fight with Supergirl when, upon hearing something (likely Lex's attack on Kasnia), she flew off in a hurry, it's unlikely that she hard a part to play in Lex's plan. After all, she doubted Kara's claims over Lex's intentions to use Kasnia and herself, so why would she willingly help him destroy the Kasnian invaders? With that in mind, it's looking like Supergirl's doppelganger may have suffered a dark fate at the hands of Mr. Luthor.

If the Red Daughter is indeed dead, then this can't be seen as anything other than a missed opportunity. While it was established a while ago that Lex was the mastermind behind both her and Ben Lockwood's respective missions (making him the real Big Bad), that shouldn't mean that she's suddenly expendable.

Does this mean that fans of the Superman: Red Son arc had to endure a season full of cameos and teases only for her to be killed off as soon as she became relevant to the main plot? As it stands at the moment, this has made her appear like nothing more than a footnote in Lex's grand plan and, quite frankly, the Red Daughter deserves better.

-

Did you enjoy this week's episode of Supergirl? Tell us in the comment section below.


In this post: 
Supergirl
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.