Supernatural Cast: Where Are They Now?

Delving into the careers of those who made Supernatural the phenomenon it was.

Supernatural cast
The CW

Over fifteen years came fifteen seasons of Supernatural, a benchmark for fantasy television dramas. Stemming from the brilliantly creative mind of Eric Kripke, the series proved such a success with viewers that he actually departed the series just one-third of the way through, having concluded its main storyline.

However, Supernatural continued down its profitable path well beyond Eric Kripke's time as showrunner.

On paper, the plot couldn't have been more basic. Two brothers - Sam and Dean Winchester - served as the series' protagonists, chasing all manner of mythical creatures along the way. Naturally, there was a ton more to it, but this served as the core element of the show; the element that was Supernatural's resultant triumph.

Eric Kripke's idea - although with Andrew Dabb and Robert Singer now as showrunners - officially ended on 19 November 2020. 1.38 million viewers tuned in to send the Winchester brothers down the wayward road one final time.

Since then, the main cast, as well as its recurring ensemble, have appeared in a variety of television shows, movies, and even video games, some remaining in the spotlight of other projects, while others faded into near-obscurity...

16. Ruth Connell - Rowena MacLeod

Supernatural Rowena
The CW

Scottish-born theatre actress Ruth Connell starred predominantly as Rowena MacLeod, an immortal witch who is revealed to be the mother of Crowley. Supernatural lore presents her as an abusive mother throughout Crowley's childhood, ultimately abandoning him altogether.

Connell's tenure as Rowena, where she appeared in a combined 33 episodes, made Ruth one of the longest-serving actresses in the show's history. For comparison, Felicia Day is only credited for 11 episodes; Kim Rhodes, meanwhile, starred in 19 episodes of Supernatural.

Having made her final Supernatural appearance in season fifteen's Our Father, Who Aren't In Heaven, Ruth Connell has starred in only three released productions as of this writing. She appeared as Bonnie in the 2020 horror thriller The Cursed Man, and as an unnamed night nurse in an episode of Doom Patrol.

Additionally, the 42-year-old actress provided numerous voices for the 2021 Netflix animation, The Loud House Movie. She starred alongside Asher Bishop and David Tennant, as she voiced the characters of an unnamed car driver and the owner of the chip shoppe, amongst others.

With regards to her upcoming work, Ruth's name is currently linked to three further productions. At present, Connell is in the middle of filming Dead Boy Detectives, an action-adventure comedy penned by Matt Wagner, Neil Gaiman, and Steve Yockey.


15. Rob Benedict - Chuck Shurley

Supernatural Chuck Shurley
The CW

At 51-years-old, the Columbia, Missouri-born Rob Benedict is undoubtedly best known for his time playing Chuck Shurley on Supernatural.

Eventually revealed to be God and, therefore, the series' prime antagonist, Benedict was transcendent in his role. He has 20 episodes credited to his name, concluding in Supernatural's penultimate episode, Inherit The Earth. It's here that he's drained of his power and defeated by Jack Kline.

Benedict went on to star as Fred Collins in the 2021 drama Violet, and as Hunter in an episode of On The Verge. Additionally, Benedict has starred in six episodes of the podcast series Passenger List, credited as Man In Blue Blazer for one episode, James Dennison for two, and Jim for three.

Alongside a stint in NCIS: Hawai'i as Damian Davenport, Rob Benedict has starred in three episodes of the critically-acclaimed Lucifer. All three episodes saw him star as Vincent Le Mec, although one of those episodes also saw Benedict under the alias of Dan Espinoza.

When he's not onscreen, Benedict can also be found hosting a podcast with Richard Speight Jr. entitled Kings Of Con, a reference to his and Speight's ten-episode comedy from 2006-2017. He's also the lead singer and guitarist for Los Angeles indie rock band, Louden Swain.


14. Kim Rhodes - Sheriff Jody Mills

Jody Mills Supernatural
The CW

Like Ruth Connell, Kim Rhodes is one of Supernatural's most tenured actresses. Her role as Sheriff Jody Mills was exquisite, so much so that she was pencilled in for the canned Supernatural spinoff Wayward Sisters.

This, in theory, would have served as a female-oriented Supernatural, spearheaded by herself, Kathryn Newton, and Briana Buckmaster. A sole episode of Supernatural - the tenth episode of season ten - was named Wayward Sisters and featured a group of women, heralded by Sheriffs Jody Mills and Donna Hanscum (Buckmaster), heading off on the most important hunt of their lives.

Since Supernatural's finale, Kim has done very little in terms of acting. She appeared as Woman (Key to Seduction) in 2020's The WOMAN Collection, which was a short comedy-drama anthology designed to examine the concept of love in both a hilarious and abstract manner.

The ex-Suite Life star has also lent her vocal services to the world of video games, doing so in both Vegas Tales and the English dub of Sega's Persona 5 Strikers. She voices Ashley and Mariko Hyodo, respectively.

Moving forward, Kim Rhodes is set to star as Karrie in Strong Enough, a John Foss-directed short drama surrounding an amateur crossfitter. The film is currently in post-production.


13. Felicia Day - Charlie Bradbury

Felicia Day Charlie Bradbury Supernatural
The CW

Charlie Bradbury, played by the incredible Felicia Day, appeared in ten episodes of Supernatural, serving as a much-needed example of Supernatural being an all-inclusive series. Bradbury is the only prominent LGBTQIA+ character to have featured in Supernatural.

The character's sexuality is revealed almost instantaneously. With Charlie working as an IT expert at Richard Roman Enterprises, she informs Sam and Dean of her homosexuality upon being asked to flirt with a male security guard.

Since her time on Supernatural culminated with the third-to-last episode Despair, Felicia has maintained a busy schedule. She voiced Mary Jane Watson in the animated Marvel's Spider-Man television series, first appearing in episode two of the third season.

Other roles for the Hunstville, Alabama native include that of Molly in a single episode of the fantasy-drama Into The Dark, the voice of both Emma and Simi in Glitch Techs, during which she also served as a writing consultant for eight episodes, and, most recently, the voice of the Captain of Emon in The Legend of Vox Machina.

Since 2017, Felicia Day has also played the lead role of Kinga Forrester in Mystery Science Theater 3000: The Return, a revival of the popular sci-fi comedy series originally aired between November 1988 and August 1999.


12. Kathryn Newton - Claire Novak

Supernatural Claire
The CW

The London-born Kathryn Newton broke into the acting business by first starring in 2002's Abbie Down Fast. She was just four-years-old at the time.

It's mind-blowing, then, just how much she's achieved in the two decades since.

Playing Claire Novak, Newton delivered some of her career-best work. She goes through various phases, being a thief, a hunter, and a werewolf, throughout the six episodes of Supernatural she's featured in.

Newton has achieved exponential success ever since. Her role as Millie Kessler, the protagonist of slasher comedy Freaky, aided the film in reaching a higher pedestal during what was a difficult era for the industry. It was refreshing to see how well she worked alongside the always-immaculate Vince Vaughn. Both were nominated in the 1st Critics' Choice Super Awards, with Vaughn ultimately winning in his respective category.

Elsewhere, Kathryn has appeared in Pokemon Detective Pikachu as Lucy Stevens, The Society as Allie Pressman, and Big Little Lies as Abigail Carlson. She'll also play Cassie Lang in the planned 2023 release of Ant-Man And The Wasp: Quantumania and will star in the Zelda Williams-directed Lisa Frankenstein, a release date for which has yet to be confirmed.

Away from the big screen, Newton starred in the music video for Goodbyes, the 2019 hit song from Post Malone.


11. Jim Beaver - Bobby Singer

Supernatural Bobby Singer
The CW

A father figure to Sam and Dean, Jim Beaver's portrayal of Bobby Singer is often trumpeted as one of Supernatural's all-round best cast additions.

Having appeared in 69 episodes of the series, Beaver is originally cast as a family friend of the Winchesters, eventually becoming a focal face of the Supernatural family throughout its entire run. It's this role that put Jim Beaver's name on the map, with much of his fanbase coming directly from Supernatural.

Following the series' end in November 2020, Jim Beaver has kept a busy schedule. The soon-to-be 72-year-old Beaver voiced Theodore Roosevelt in the March 2021 short Teddy, alongside 2020 appearances in Young Sheldon, Blindfire, and Gunfight At Silver Creek as Kenneth, Sergeant Ward, and Phil Macgregor, respectively.

Jim also has a recurring role on hit Amazon Prime original series The Boys, playing the Secretary of Defense Robert A. Singer, and was featured in the recurrent role of former NYPD transit police officer Spencer in B Positive. Sadly, the show was cancelled this past May after just two seasons.

Though it's yet to be released, Jim will play Stace Lamott in the upcoming short drama Liberty, and has been cast as Marcus Carver in Kindling, which is in pre-production.


10. Alexander Calvert - Jack Kline

Jack Kline
The CW

Though he also played Belphegor, Alexander Calvert's biggest claim to fame on Supernatural is for his stupendous work as Jack Kline, the son of Lucifer.

This is the role that put the Canadian actor on the map. Prior to this, the majority of his roles were either one-off appearances in various television series' or straight-to-television movies that remain largely unknown to the common viewer. He did, however, have a reoccurring role as Lonnie Machin on Arrow that lasted a combined five episodes.

As Jack Kline, Calvert delivered a breakthrough performance, rising to prominence for his engaging and believable performances across the 39 episodes he starred in.

It's unfortunate news, then, that Calvert has just one credential to his name post-Supernatural. He'll play Thomas The Cat King in Dead Boy Detectives, also starring fellow Supernatural alum Ruth Connell, which is currently in the middle of production. It's unknown when, exactly, this will air.

Although he doesn't appear to have any other acting gigs lined up at the moment, Alexander Calvert has got a solid Instagram account for his cat, Lord Tyrion, so it's not all bad news for the 31-year-old.


9. Mark Pellegrino - Lucifer

Supernatural Lucifer Castiel
The CW

Mark Pellegrino's portrayal of Lucifer - and therefore Nick, with Lucifer being his primary vessel - brought out some of the best work of Pellegrino's 30-plus year career. That says a lot for an actor who has credits in some of modern television's most successful series', such as Grey's Anatomy, Prison Break, and Chicago P.D.

It was as Lucifer, however, that Mark Pellegrino was first-class.

The 57-year-old Canadian finished up his work as Lucifer the same year as his portrayal of Bill Standall on the hit Netflix series 13 Reasons Why ended. He's lent his hand to just a handful of other projects since; perhaps his most notable role comes by way of the 2021 crime drama American Rust, where he currently plays the role of Virgil Poe.

Pellegrino is also due to play an unnamed grungy man in Strangers In A Strange Land, of which he is also credited as a producer. Starring Leslie Jordan in the main role, the comedy is sitting in post-production.

Outside of acting, Mark also has a hand in American politics, being the co-founder of the American Capitalist Party. More specifically, Pellegrino has declared his political views as being "classical liberalism".


8. Lauren Cohan - Bela Talbot

Supernatural Bela Talbot
The CW

Although Lauren Cohan was only around for Supernatural's early days, her role as Bela Talbot is imperative to the show's early success. She applied her knowledge of the supernatural for her personal gain instead of using it to help others.

Her career has peaked ever since.

Cohan's most respected role post-Supernatural sees her star as Maggie Rhee in The Walking Dead. She started in the role with the 2011 season two episode Bloodletting and remains in the role to this day (bar a brief hiatus owing to a pay dispute), with her character due to run through the eleventh and final season concluding in 2022. She is, however, announced to be continuing this character in The Walking Dead's mini-series spinoff, Isle of the Dead.

Other prominent television roles for Cohan include six episodes as Rose in The Vampire Diaries and thirteen episodes of Whiskey Cavalier as Frankie Trowbridge. On the big screen, Lauren can be found in Batman vs. Superman: Dawn of Justice as Martha Wayne, Mile 22 as Alice Kerr, The Boy as Greta Evans.

Cohan is currently in the process of filming the animated action series Twilight of the Gods, where she has been cast as Inge for at least one episode.


7. Genevieve Padalecki - Ruby

Supernatural Ruby Genevieve Cortese Padalecki
The CW

The character of Ruby, a demon devoted to the return of Lucifer, was played by four separate actresses. Alongside Katie Cassidy, Anna Williams, and Michelle Hewitt-Williams came the star performance of Genevieve Padalecki (then-Cortese).

Genevieve had a total of 13 episodes credited as Ruby between 2008 and 2020, one episode of which saw her starring as herself in season six's The French Mistake. Aired in 2011, this marked Genevieve's final Supernatural appearance until she reprised the role of Ruby for one episode of the final season.

The Californian has since appeared in only a handful of productions since, which included the culmination of her role as Kris Furillo in ABC Family's Wildfire. Genevieve's final episode aired in May 2008, a few weeks away from the exact three-year anniversary of the series' pilot.

Padalecki starred in the 2012 drama Hated, but this - coupled with her aforementioned 2011 appearance as herself in Supernatural - marked her final acting credits for a while, taking time out to care for her and then-Supernatural co-star Jared Padalecki's three children.

Genevieve returned to the screen when she was cast in the recurring role of Emily Walker in the 2021 reboot of Walker, Texas Ranger. The show was renewed for a third season this past March.


6. Mark Sheppard - Crowley

Supernatural Crowley
The CW

Crowley is very easily one of Supernatural's most critically-acclaimed characters. Although this can be put down to the sublime writing provided for him, the vast majority of the character's success can be placed on the grand effort of Mark Sheppard.

First introduced during season five as the son of the aforementioned Rowena MacLeod, Crowley was routinely seen as the prime antagonist of the series, ultimately being the third main character to be killed off after Ruby and Bela Talbot.

Post-Supernatural, Mark hasn't been too busy. He starred in eight episodes of the action-adventure comedy Doom Patrol, in which he portrays Willoughby Kipling, while he also had a recurring role as Richard Johnson on Mania City.

In the 2016 rebooted MacGyver series, Sheppard appeared in one episode as an assassin named Jason Tennant, though he also assumes the identity of a fake Dr Zito, a victim of murder. Intriguingly, in the original MacGyver series, Mark's father, W. Morgan Sheppard, played this role, too.

Away from the screen, the voice of Sheppard can be heard within a DLC pack for Call of Duty: Black Ops Cold War, where the former Crowley voices Roman 'Knight' Grey. He's also currently in the process of filming Walker: Independence, playing an as-of-yet unnamed character.


5. Misha Collins - Castiel

Supernatural Castiel
The CW

Though he's most famous for playing Castiel, the flawless Misha Collins has played numerous other roles across his time on Supernatural, including Jimmy Novak, Leviathan, and even himself, but none will ever compare to that of Cass.

Misha was so popular as Castiel, in fact, that he, Jared Padalecki, and Jensen Ackles won the People's Choice Award for Best TV Bromance in 2014, while he also won the Favourite Sci-Fi/Fantasy TV Actor award the following year, too.

The Boston, Massachusetts actor has kept himself busy, both in and out of the acting realm. He starred as Dylan in the 2021 Amazon Prime original Encounter, while he also hosted Roadfood: Discovery America One Dish At A Time.

In October, Collins wrapped work on the podcast series Bridgewater, in which he played Jeremy Bradshaw for its ten-episode run. Misha Collins also worked as an executive producer on this series, the same role he had for the Roadfood documentary.

As it stands, the former Castiel has been cast as Harvey Dent in The CW's Gotham Knights series, with production on this beginning in Toronto this past April for a planned 2023 release. It's unknown, exactly, how many episodes he will star in.


4. Samantha Smith - Mary Winchester

Supernatural Mary Winchester
The CW

Mary Winchester, played by Samantha Smith, has the honour of being Supernatural's most-recurring female character, appearing in a combined 37 episodes between the series' inception in 2005 until her final appearance in 2019's fourteenth season episode Absence.

Having been killed just six months following the birth of Sam, you instantly got the vibe that she'd do anything to protect her children, regardless of the lack of time they got to spend together. By her last appearance, Mary was finally at peace in heaven, her hunting days behind her. It was a fitting end for Mary, given the story that she crafted.

Since then, Smith has appeared in just two other roles. She played the role of Captain Pamela Shore in an episode of 9-1-1, and most recently starred in an episode of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds, where she portrayed Eldredth.

Samantha Smith's role as Mary Winchester was undoubtedly the most notable of her entire acting career, having initially began her career in the mainstream as a model when she was only a teenager. It was a role in a Super Bowl commercial for HBO that initially put her face out there, leading to one-off appearances in hit shows like Seinfeld, Friends, and NCIS: Los Angeles.


3. Jeffrey Dean Morgan - John Winchester

John Winchester Supernatural
The CW

Jeffrey Dean Morgan is seemingly the perfect fit for these otherworldly shows, considering how he's also well-known for playing Negan Smith in The Walking Dead. This couples nicely with his 13-episode stint as John Winchester.

His regular appearances as the Winchester matriarch concluded in 2008, with just one additional appearance coming over a decade thereafter in season fourteen broadcast Lebanon. The Seattle, Washington native has, however, kept busy.

Morgan's aforementioned role as Negan in The Walking Dead will see him carry the character through to the finale, scheduled to premiere later this year. Following that, Jeffrey is slated to star in the show's spinoff mini-series Isle of the Dead alongside Supernatural alum Lauren Cohan. This is expected to debut in 2023, though when, exactly, is unknown.

The 56-year-old enjoyed a number of movie roles following the conclusion of his routine appearances as John Winchester, starring in Watchmen, Rampage, and The Losers as Edward Blake, Harvey Russell, and Clay, to name but a few.

Regular appearances have followed in the likes of Magic City, where he played Ike Evans, and The Good Wife, which starred him in the role of Jason Crouse. Jeffrey Dean Morgan most recently completed filming of the 2022 thriller Fall, which is now awaiting its release date.


2. Jared Padalecki - Sam Winchester

Supernatural Sam
The CW

There is no Supernatural without Jared Padalecki.

The definition of a perfect casting choice for his leading role as Sam Winchester, the 39-year-old Texan appeared in all 327 episodes of Supernatural. He hunted paranormal creatures, fought demons and angels, and slew all manner of unearthly beasts along the way.

Since the final episode of the hit series aired in November 2020, Padalecki has only appeared in one show, although this is in another starring role. He plays the titular character of Cordell Walker, the same role held by the legendary Chuck Norris for eight years, in Walker. On the productions of both Walker and Walker: Independence, Padalecki also serves as an executive producer, the latter of which he is in the midst of filming.

During his time as a Winchester, Jared also appeared in a number of films, such as Friday The 13th, Cry Wolf, and Christmas Cottage, while also voicing his Supernatural character in a 21-episode animated version of the sci-fi drama.

Outside of his acting duties, Jared Padalecki serves as the owner of the Austin, Texas-based '90s-themed bar Stereotype, which he opened in 2018. In 2015, he also launched his mental health campaign Always Keep Fighting, which aids those suffering with depression, addiction, suicide, and self-harm.


1. Jensen Ackles - Dean Winchester

Supernatural Dean
The CW

Similarly, there is no Supernatural without Jensen Ackles.

Although Ackles is best known for his 15-year portrayal of Dean Winchester, the 44-year-old had already amounted a lucrative career on the small screen. He'd held regular roles in Dark Angel, Dawson's Creek, and Days of our Lives.

In Supernatural, however, Jensen reached new heights as an actor, becoming the face of a sci-fi revolution that will continue imminently. He's slated to rekindle his role as Dean in The Winchesters, the CW-commissioned Supernatural spinoff series.

Elsewhere in the acting résumé of Jensen Ackles, he was the voice behind the titular 'Caped Crusader' in both parts of Batman: The Long Halloween, and played Beau Arlen in two episodes of Hulu's Big Sky. Most notably, Ackles has been featured on the hit Amazon Prime series The Boys.

Like many of his ex-Supernatural co-stars, the Dallas, Texas native has taken on roles behind the scenes as well. He directed a single episode of Walker, which stars both Jared and Genevieve Padalecki, which followed on from him directing six Supernatural broadcasts.

As was to be expected, he'll also serve as an executive producer on The Winchesters. The Supernatural spinoff series was recently confirmed for an 11 October premiere on The CW.


Contributor
Contributor

Can be found raving about the latest IMPACT Wrestling signing, the Saints Row franchise, and King Shark in The Suicide Squad.