Supernatural: Every Major Villain Ranked Worst To Best
Sam and Dean have faced their fair share of fierce foes.
Supernatural's legacy is 15 seasons strong and, as such, is full of memorable villains.
Some started out good then turned bad, some vice versa, and some were just always rotten to the core. Whatever their intentions, these individuals decided to mess with the wrong pair of hunters.
Sam and Dean have been blasted through plenty of near-death (and in some cases actual death) situations. The poor duo has been up against everything from angels, demons, and just about everything in between. But as much as fans love the two Winchester brothers, a show is only as good as its antagonist.
Thankfully, Supernatural has plenty to choose from but for this list, we'll be looking at only the major villains (or Big Bads) that made an appearance. That means no individual monsters, demons, or other beasties despite how cool the hellhounds were.
This list will take into account each of the major villains' powers, impact on the story, as well as fan reception.
14. Dick Roman
You all knew this one was coming. As his namesake suggests, Dick Roman was a bit of a... well you know.
The real Dick Roman was one of America's wealthiest men before being taken over by the leader of the Leviathans.
Unfortunately for Dick, his time in the spotlight was around the same time as Castiel's turn to the dark side. This entire section of Supernatural history was by far one of its weakest storylines and having a "man in a suit" as one of the major villains didn't help.
Ultimately, Dick was an utterly forgettable and quite frankly bland addition to the villains' roster. Dick was also one of the least charismatic villains the show had to offer, leaving Season 7 of Supernatural at the very bottom of many fans tier list.
13. The Darkness/Amara
Amara, also known as "The Darkness" (sadly not the band) was a reoccurring character that debuted in season 10.
However, fans did not take to her one bit, especially after her obsession with Dean. Amara was supposed to be the be-all, end-all of things, acting as the antithesis to God. She was a being of pure darkness yet she never really presented much of a threat.
It was clear that her character was purely invented to try and up the stakes but her presence as a villain was lacklustre at best. This especially stung since her big bad predecessor, Rowena, was a stand out for the show.
Her off and on relationship with Sam, Dean, and God often made her motives questionable. Ultimately, she could never be taken seriously as the all-powerful villain the show pushed her towards being.
12. Castiel
Supernatural has a bad habit of turning their heroes evil for a brief stint.
Both Sam and Dean at some points have been possessed or turned against one another through some devilish means. However, their loyal angel companion was always there to help bring them back and keep them on the right path.
Castiel had always been the sort of goofball of the trio so seeing him attempt to play the bad boy was comical at best. The sudden and brutal execution of his brother, Raphael, was an especially grim moment given how moral and just Cas had been in the past.
The excuse that Cas was acting for the greater good does not excuse his behaviour towards the others and his sudden shift in personality.
11. The Four Horseman
The Four Horseman had been teased throughout the show long before their eventual appearance.
Sam and Dean had already become well acquainted with one of the riders, Death, who had become a fan favourite. Perhaps it was the incredible performance of Death that made the other three seem so disappointing in comparison.
None of the horsemen really presented much of a threat despite how terrifying Death could be at times. Each horseman only lasted a single episode before having their rings removed and their physical form reverted.
The threat presented by the individuals boiled down to a few towns being inconvenienced as they were defeated just as quickly as they had arrived.
The three deserved much more screentime at the very least and ended up feeling like a time-waster until the boys could make their way to Lucifer.
10. Raphael
Raphael only ranks so low on this list due to how lacklustre their appearance was in comparison to the other archangels.
Initially, Raphael had an excellent build-up with the scene of Dean using him to frighten Lillith into fleeing. Not only that but one of their first real appearances shows him utterly obliterating Castiel.
After this Raphael is largely left in the background, during his brief stint as ruler of Heaven the angels are thrust into chaos. Since all of this is left off-screen it left a lot to be desired with the whole angel civil war plotline.
Raphael would return once more to assist Crowley in defeating a power-hungry Castiel. The alliance is short-lived as Castiel seemed to hold a grudge and used his new god-like power to burst Raphael like a balloon.
9. Abaddon
Abaddon was one of the last remaining demons that genuinely presented some kind of threat to the Winchester brothers.
Originally thought to have been killed, she travelled through time and began wreaking havoc in what was then the modern-day. Her tenacity and vicious love for killing was only matched by her dark sense of humour. Even when up against Dean and co. she enjoyed their seemingly futile attempts at fighting her.
Abaddon has been shot, stabbed, and decapitated but still managed to bounce back proving she was worthy of the Knight of Hell title. Her cocky demeanour and quite frankly total disregard for caution ended with Dean finally piercing her with the First Blade while branded with the Mark of Cain.
It was a fun experience to watch a demon genuinely enjoy their work, however sadistic it was.
8. Rowena
As a refreshing departure from the typical angels and demons of the show, Rowena brought something new to the table.
Supernatural often tackled a lot of biblical themes and entities so it was refreshing to see a villain vastly different from the others. She was still connected to the show's typical heaven and hell skirmish by having her as the mother of Crowley.
Not only was her story exciting and engaging, but Ruth Connell also did a great job of conveying the character's wit, charm, and at times malevolence.
Rowena started off as an exceptional villain before inevitably joining the Winchester brothers. Her loyalty was always in question, however, as she seemed to back the most powerful party as a form of self-preservation.
Her long run in the show is sadly put to an end when she sacrifices her life to drag demons back into hell along with her.
7. Metatron
What Metatron lacks in physical intimidation he more than makes up for in terms of raw power.
Not many angels, or even archangels, have even come close to possessing the kind of power that Metatron has had. As one of God's most trusted lackeys, he acted as the Scribe of God which essentially God's glorified secretary.
Since Metatron wasn't even an archangel like some of the other Big Bads on this list he can often be overlooked. However, not many others can boast that they too called down all of the angels and then became the ruler of heaven itself.
Metatron also wears the honourary villain badge of successfully killing one of the Winchester brothers. After being thrown in angel prison, Metatron acts as a sort of weird angelic Hannibal Lector when the boys need him to remove Dean's Mark of Cain.
6. Crowley
What show is complete without an on-again-off-again frenemy like Crowley?
As one of the longest-running characters of the show, Crowley has been one of the teams greatest villains and associates. The character stood out thanks to his conniving and manipulating ways, often double-crossing or outsmarting the Winchester's at every turn.
Like his mother, Crowley was a mostly selfish being that cared predominantly about keeping himself safe. This often meant him switching sides or striking deals whenever the situation called for it.
Crowley managed to work his way from lowly demon to King of the Crossroads and eventually to the King of Hell himself. After Sam cures Crowley of his demonic urges, the anti-hero realises that all of his goals stemmed from a need to be loved.
He finally manages to prove himself a faithful friend when he gives his own life to seal Lucifer away in another dimension.
5. Lilith
Horror fans know that there is nothing more terrifying than a child.
During Lillith's first few appearances she chose to take the form of a young girl as she sought to free her father, Lucifer. As the oldest demon ever created she had undying loyalty to her creator and went as far as to baiting Sam into killing her. With her death, the final seal containing Lucifer was broken.
Lillith was a prime example of a sadistic and downright cruel individual who revelled in the torture of others.
Her later appearances were a little lacklustre as she was swiftly eviscerated by the Archangel Michael following her resurrection. However, her appearances in the earlier seasons definitely left a lasting impression as she led the armies of hell in a rampage across Earth.
4. Michael (Alternate Reality)
Michael was always one of the most dangerous archangels rivalled only by Lucifer.
This becomes even more so apparent when an alternate version of him, from the Apocalypse World, winds up in Sam and Dean's timeline.
Similar to the original Michael, Dean was a natural host for this angel of war when the two teamed up to put an end to Lucifer once and for all. This proved to be a trick as after they finally killed Lucifer, Michael sought to completely take over Dean as a vessel.
This version of Michael also has one of the most impressive list of kills of any villain, mainly due to the violent takeover of his own world. Apocalypse Michael has managed to defeat Gabriel, Lillith, Anna, numerous hunters, and Lucifer (twice!).
Though Michael was eventually defeated by Lucifer's son, Jack, he proved to be arguably the most powerful angel that Team Free Will ever had or ever would face.
3. God
Throughout the show the Winchesters faced varying levels of angels and demons, it only made sense to end with God himself.
Known commonly as his vessel "Chuck", God had played a major role through the entirety of the show whether it was due to their absence or meddling. As it turns out, God had been trying to get Dean and Sam to kill each other for some time, allowing demons and other entities to run amock to do the dirty work for him.
Much like the old biblical tales, Chuck is a vengeful and merciless God. Any and all hardships that befell the Winchesters was caused either directly or indirectly by Chuck. This was all due to Chuck's plan of creating a good "story" as a sort of metacommentary from the showrunners.
In the end, God even offers up multiple ending for Sam and Dean to choose from with the two refusing and choosing their own destiny for once.
2. Azazel
The Big Bad that started it all, Azazel (or simply Yellow Eyes) kicked off the entire series we now know and love.
Azazel was tasked with finding a worthy vessel for Lucifer's eventual return, which eventually would lead him to the Winchester/Campbell family.
Old Yellow Eyes previously made a deal with Mary to save John, Sam and Dean's father. But when it came time to collect and begin the process of turning Sam, Mary tried to stop him, resulting in her death and kickstarting the decades-long vendetta between Azazel and the Winchesters.
Originally thought to be the overarching villain, the long-awaited victory against Azazel is short-lived and only the beginning of Sam and Dean's problems.
Without Azazel, there would be no Supernatural, and the boys would never have become the badass demonslayers they are today.
1. Lucifer
Without a shadow of a doubt, Lucifer has by far caused the most pain and destruction all throughout the show.
Many of those already mentioned on this list were either in servitude or at least created by Lucifer. Without him, there would be no demons for the Winchesters to have fought against.
Even Azazel was only acting under orders. Lucifer has killed countless angels, hunters, demons, and even gods from other pantheons.
So much build-up was centred around the return of Lucifer from his cage and it more than paid off. The soulless Sam storyline, the involvement of Michael and Gabriel, sending the Four Horseman, all of these moments became some of the shows greatest arcs.
Lucifer may not have been the final big bad of the series but he remains the most influential villain.
Watch Next
Supernatural Quotes Quiz: Which Character Said What?