The Boys Season 3 Review: 8 Ups & 2 Downs
The Boys delivers its best season yet, despite some inescapable flaws.
For the third season running, Eric Kripke's blistering superhero drama The Boys has proven to be one of the most compelling shows currently on air, brilliantly satirising the overdone superhero subgenre whilst creating a thrilling and timely story around its deeply flawed protagonists and villains.
With its heavy-hitting themes of identity, political extremism, and corruption, as well as its ridiculous humour and relentless action, The Boys' third season is surely the show's best instalment yet, bursting with sharp social observations and some of the best acting performances of the year.
Following the titular Boys as they race to find themselves and cause more damage to the reputation of the evil Homelander and his remaining allies, the season suffers from a slightly convoluted narrative, but easily overshadows its shortcomings with frequently inspired writing and brilliant shocks.
With that in mind -- from the flaws holding it back from perfection to the timeliness of its drama and the success of its ensemble cast -- here are 8 Ups and 2 Downs from the third season of The Boys. Be warned, though: This review will contain some major spoilers.
DOWNS...
10. It's Occasionally Overstuffed & Rushed Through
Though it's mostly a massive step-up from previous seasons, The Boys' third chapter is also the show's messiest and over-eager, packing its eight episodes with a handful of major subplots that could have done with more room to breathe.
Though the season's biggest developments are handled with ample consistency and great pace -- from Homelander's deteriorating mental state to The Boys' struggles to remain as a functioning team -- many of the smaller plotlines are not so lucky, and despite their potential are often rushed out and underused.
Most notably, the third episode, "Barbary Coast," struggles to balance its abundance of flashbacks and present-day drama, making each new twist feel oddly muted and underdeveloped, because it doesn't focus on them long enough for them to really matter.
In other cases, many promising plotlines are introduced only to be flippantly brushed aside without any lasting impact, such as the death of eager newcomer Supersonic, Homelander's attempts to make Starlight his PR girlfriend, and The Boys' all-too-brief and handwaved trip to Russia.
None of these developments are entirely awful, but there's a sense watching each episode that the season could've done with a major trim and tighter focus.
9. There Are Too Many Characters
The main reason that this season feels so busy is because there's simply too many characters for the writers to successfully juggle with equal focus and depth.
For the most part, the season has some of the best character development of the series (which we'll get to), but because there are so many people spread across so many different locations, it also leaves several great players by the wayside.
Queen Maeve, for example, despite her otherwise compelling growth, is often kept at arms length from the action around her, and Frenchie and Kimiko are only briefly affiliated with The Boys before they go on their own, smaller misadventure. Others such as A-Train, The Deep, and Victoria remain complex, but barely make a dent.
The biggest victims of this are probably Vought CEO Stan Edgar, who makes for a brilliant foil to Homelander before he's thwarted and never seen again, and silent assassin Black Noir, who's given more focus but dies before leaving much of a mark.
The season's most dominant personalities -- Homelander, Butcher, Starlight, Hughie, and Mother's Milk -- are handled with much more care, and whilst no one is entirely betrayed by the overstuffed writing, there are still plenty who deserved more time to shine, if only to improve the season's pace.
UPS...
8. The Boys Level The Playing Field
As teased in the trailers, one of the season's big twists came in the form of Queen Maeve giving Billy Butcher some temporary Compound V (the controversial drug used to give supes their powers) so he can stand a chance fighting Homelander and unstable newcomer Soldier Boy.
Of course, this new weapon has its startling downsides, not only leaving Butcher with irreparable brain damage, but also leading to a conflicted Hughie taking the drug in an attempt to finally be of use on the battlefield.
This leads to some brilliant development from both broken men, but more than anything it allows the writers the chance to inject more action to the drama. On more than one occasion, Butcher and Hughie come to blows with Homelander, and are -- with some help -- able to give him a run for his money.
Up until this season, most of the war between Homelander and The Boys had been psychological and threatening rather than physical, but Compound V has finally given the team chance to bring the fight to their enemies, and even put Homelander on edge.
7. The Brutal Action
As noted, the introduction of The Boys' powers have lead to some brilliant twists and long-awaited character confrontations, and whilst the more subtle drama remains of high quality, this season has been at its best when hitting audiences with action.
With thrilling choreography and emotional depth, season three's action sequences consist of fights between Homelander and Soldier Boy, Homelander and Butcher, and -- because he's finally been backed into a corner -- Homelander and Maeve. Even timid everyman Hughie has got in on the action, which has made for a great change.
Considering it's a show about superheroes coming to blows, the violence has been very brief until this season, and season three has made the most of the emotional turmoil and rich character development of its stars to make the action both necessary and shocking in equal measure.
The Boys has always been gratuitous, and whilst the increased action is far from pretty this time around -- there's lots of blood and plenty of nasty deaths -- it also feels vital to the next phase of the series' central war.
Going forward, it promises to only get more shocking and inventive. Speaking of which...
6. Herogasm Takes The Series To New Heights
Perhaps the biggest talking point about this season of The Boys was the fact that, before the premiere, showrunner and writer Eric Kripke announced he'd be adapting the controversial storyline Herogasm to the screen, and pushing the series to new heights of WTF depravity.
Herogasm, which is basically an annual supe orgy, really shouldn't have worked on the small screen, and yet thanks to Kripke's desire to shock his audiences but also deliver a compelling story, it easily emerges as the best episode of the season and the show.
Darkly amusing and ludicrously crude, the episode is surely one of the most mature episodes of TV ever aired, but cleverly counters its shock value with a clash for the ages, in which Homelander is trapped by Butcher, Hughie and Soldier Boy and is finally put on his back foot after years of being seemingly unstoppable.
It's a brilliant display of storytelling, perfectly balancing The Boys' insane humour with its intelligent character clashes and gasp-inducing cliffhangers.
Whether it's Mother's Milk being covered in supe semen (seriously), Homelander fleeing in anger, or Starlight telling the world how evil Homelander is, Herogasm is an episode that deserved to talked about for a long time as a major turning point in the show's overarching drama.
5. The Incredibly Timely Themes
The Boys has never been one to shy away from current events or making political statements, but season three's worldview has been more blunt -- admittedly, it can be too blunt in parts -- and powerful than previous seasons'.
This is the season where Homelander finally snaps and shows the world his true face, becoming an icon to radicalised right-wingers who are empowered by his no-bullsh*t persona, public speaking, and claims that he's the only person in the media who's willing to "tell the truth."
Kripke has been clear that Homelander's new image is meant to mirror Donald Trump's influence of American politics (hilariously angering conservative viewers who somehow missed the memo they were watching a show that mocked them), and that shines through the entire series.
Homelander's use of social media and news stations to gaslight his opponents and control his fans is just the tip of the iceberg, though. A-Train also gets a powerful subplot wherein he confronts a white supe who's over-policing Black neighbours (whilst saying "All lives matter"), which causes him to confront his own mistakes.
As I've said, some of these themes are a touch too heavy-handed in parts, but in a way that's part of their charm; this is a show that's never shied away from the big issues, and season three pulls no punches.
4. The Rich Character Development
Despite the fact it's juggling over a dozen prominent characters and several hard-hitting themes, The Boys' writing this season has still delivered the goods in the character department, with even the most side-lined players getting their fair share of compelling development.
The best development definitely comes from Homelander, who's finally snapped and allowed his true self to come out, and Butcher, who's desire for revenge have caused him to become almost suicidal in his attempts to achieve his goals.
Elsewhere, Hughie's increasing anxiety and fragile masculinity force him to come to terms with his life and his surprisingly stable relationship with Starlight. Starlight herself, meanwhile, emerges as the show's true MVP, almost single-handedly ruining the reputations of Vought and Homelander.
Other supporting players such as a morally conflicted A-Train, a pathetically weak The Deep, a battle-ready Queen Maeve, and conniving senator and supervillain Victoria Neuman, are a bit too removed from the drama at times, but are still given ample opportunity to reach new levels of powerlessness and tragedy.
Even Black Noir, the show's silent enigma, finally gets some horribly tragic backstory, even if it leads to his unfairly rushed death in the finale.
3. The Flawless Ensemble Cast
Of course, none of this rich character development would be possible without the show's flawless ensemble, who each give their best performances yet in a season that constantly challenges them.
True standouts this time around include Karl Urban as a bitter, haunted Butcher, Erin Moriarty as a woman who sticks her middle finger up to a cruel, male-dominated world, and the consistently underrated Laz Alonso as Mother's Milk, who spends this season followed by family tragedy and blinded by loss.
This season also introduces Supernatural's Jensen Ackles as Soldier Boy, a Captain America-like hero whose fame, sadism, and narcissistic tendencies are surpassed only by Homelander, and he's clearly having a great time playing a darkly amusing monster.
As great as the main cast are, though, a lot of credit deserves to go to show's more side-lined stars, who despite feeling out-of-the-loop still colour the season with absorbing performances impossible to hate.
Karen Fukuhara and Tomer Capon continue to be utterly heartrending as Kimiko and Frenchie, Chace Crawford's horribly slimy portrayal of The Deep remains an absolute masterclass in pitiful awkwardness, and Colby Minifie's hilarious portrayal of conflicted Vought boss Ashley steals the show whenever she's around.
It's a brilliant ensemble, and there should be no doubt The Boys is one of the best acted shows currently on-air.
2. Antony Starr Steals The Show
As phenomenal as everyone else is this season, though, no one holds a candle to the irreplaceable Antony Starr, who for the third season running continues to give one of the most fascinating performances on TV.
As Homelander, Starr's ability to come across as both genuinely terrifying and painfully pathetic is unmatched, painting the so-called "hero" as a perfect image of fragility, greed, and rage. Starr manages to make his truly insane, but still finds a way to find the broken human within the monster.
The most impressive thing about Starr's performance comes from his facial expressions, which in a single twitch capture every ounce of Homelander's terror, anger, and increasing insanity.
Everyone has missed out on major award recognition for their work in The Boys so far, but if the Emmys and Golden Globes know what's good for them, they should really be seeking Starr out for some nominations. It's a monumental achievement.
1. It's The Best Season Yet
Despite some brief writing flaws, The Boys' third instalment is unquestionably its best season yet.
Thanks to Kripke and his team's fantastic writing, the stunning work of its ensemble cast, and the brilliantly high stakes of the drama, the season captures everything that's made The Boys' such a hit perfectly, and throws a series of momentous new twists, characters, and rule changes into the mix for good measure.
The high bar its set proves yet again that the series is only getting better with time, and thanks to the cliffhangers it's left in place -- from Billy Butcher's impending death, young Ryan siding with Homelander, and Neuman preparing to take the role of Vice President -- season four has the potential to continue this trend.
There are few shows as daring and intelligent on TV at the moment, and The Boys seems to just be getting started. Now to eagerly await the new season, which should hopefully air in the summer of next year.