The Exact Moment The Simpsons Lost Us
Turns out that the downfall of America's first family was never about the jokes...
The Simpsons never quite managed the feat of getting a US president, sitting or otherwise, to appear on the show.
That’s an important fact to remember because from its early mega hit popularity onwards, the series has gotten close. The UK’s then-Prime Minister Tony Blair appeared in 2003, Nixon, Reagan, Carter, and Ford turned down Krusty Gets Cancelled (though only Reagan responded), and in 1992 George H.W Bush claimed during a Washington speech that “we need a nation closer to the Waltons than the Simpsons.”
The series was a cultural juggernaut at the height of its popularity. In the decades since its relevance has waned, The Simpsons has become perhaps the only thing more powerful than a phenomenon. With 684 episodes, 34 Emmys, and Time Magazine’s deserved title of the 20th century’s greatest TV series, The Simpsons is an institution.
So, who needs the president?
Well, The Simpsons certainly didn’t in its golden age, whatever about its current incarnation.
At the height of its popularity and what critical and fan consensus agree was the show’s golden age (seasons two through twelve, give or take), the animated family sitcom was a force to be reckoned with.
Subversive, warm-hearted, silly, sharp, ingeniously clever, gleefully dumb, and always preternaturally original, the show was best described by critics Alan Sepinwall and Matt Zoller Seitz in TV: The Book (shout out to YouTuber Patrick Willems’ superb Simpsons video for sourcing this quote): “The Simpsons is… ambitious, intimate, classical, experimental, hip, corny, and altogether free in its conviction that the imagination should go where it wants.”
Wherever there was an established norm, whether it was in comedy, storytelling, or character, The Simpsons were there to subvert it. The episode Homer’s Phobia, controversial in its day, provides an example of this.
This episode depicted homophobia not from the perspective of a gay character affected by it (something American mainstream prime time television was far from offering), but instead from our loveable American everyman. The protagonist of the show, the audience insertion persona, was depicted as an unapologetic homophobe, and viewers were expected to follow Homer’s journey to acceptance via the episode’s always charming guest star John Waters.
In the nineties, the aftermath of the AIDS crisis cast a long shadow over American culture, and few shows even attempted to discuss LGBT themes. Those that did mostly offered “don’t discriminate” platitudes.
In contrast, The Simpsons expected viewers to interrogate their unconscious prejudices by showing that even the absurd hero of a surreal cartoon needed to learn, grow, and change sometimes. It’s a hilarious episode which masks a poignant message in genuinely inventive and funny comedy, something viewers haven’t seen from the show in a long, long time.
So what happened?
[Continued on Page 2]
How To Write Comedy
A lot of pop culture analysts have attempted to pinpoint the moment when The Simpsons began its long fall from grace, and many of the culprits will be familiar to fans of the show.
The Principal and the Pauper is infamous for disregarding series continuity in favour of a cheap laugh and a sensationalist plot, but the show never cared for internal consistency all that much. Saddlesore Galactica is highlighted as an example of the show no longer trying to hide its recycled plots, but Bart’s bizarre adventure with a secret society of race-fixing jockeys is actually nothing like Lisa’s moving coming-of-age story when she briefly owned a pony.
The commonly cited culprit Homer Vs Dignity comes closer to the cause, though not for the reasons some commentators claim.
The thing is, the downfall of The Simpsons isn’t rooted in its approach to comedy writing.
Yes, there were a few lightning-in-a-bottle years where every episode was filled with killer gags, but the show’s style nowadays isn’t far from that tone of comedy. The scattershot humour of the series combines everything from highbrow satire, to parody, to sight gags, to gross-out jokes, to slapstick, to typical sitcom character comedy, shifting modes multiple times in a single scene.
This anarchic approach and frenetic pace has stayed in place since it began in the show’s third season standout Homer at the Bat.
The Simpsons lost us not because of any comedic misstep, though there were many, as outlined in the individual episode examples listed above. Instead, the moment that The Simpsons lost us was when it went from being a countercultural phenomenon that mocked those in power, to being another platform devoted to cheerleading them.
[Continued On Page 3]
What Does The Simpsons Have To Say?
The episode Homer Vs Dignity sees the beloved everyman become a “prank monkey” for Mr Burns, a job which entails publicly embarrassing himself in exchange for extra pay. It’s a mean-spirited and dark instalment of the show which most viewers deride, but it’s one which signals a significant shift in the show’s approach to authority.
For The Simpsons’ first ten seasons or so, Mr Burns is unapologetically portrayed as a villain. A heartless, hateful tyrant, he’s a broad parody of the tragic billionaire embodied in fiction by Charles Foster Kane. This factory owner isn’t good-hearted but tragically corrupted, he’s an out-and-out bastard whose humanity has been worn away by years of over-the-top greed.
Whilst The Simpsons as a rule abhorred realism and certainly was no Malcolm in the Middle or even Bob’s Burgers in terms of centring a working class perspective, the stakes of the series when it came to work were always recognizable.
From its first episode wherein Homer can’t afford Christmas presents for his kids, the show famous for taking nothing seriously took the hard financial realities of life in America seriously. This wasn’t Modern Family, where money flows constantly and comfortably, its attendant woes never affecting the lives of its characters. Look throughout the series best-loved episodes and you’ll find countless moments, from the loss of Lisa’s pony to Homer’s “do it for her” collage, which underline the struggle that everyday Americans contend with thanks to the Mr Burns of the world.
Fast forward to Homer Vs Dignity, where Homer is in financial dire straits at the episode's beginning and gets out of paying at a restaurant... By playing in their mariachi band. He needs extra money because he's "too dumb" to budget, and within a few minutes of screen time has amassed so much extra cash that he feels compelled to give it to a good cause.
The boss/worker divide between Homer and Burns lasts a mere few minutes before the characters are essentially on equal footing and money is once again no object to the usually hard-up Homer. The episode’s plot falls flat not only because it’s unfunny, but because the stakes have changed from “Homer hates his boss, but has to work to feed his family” to “if The Simpsons run out of money, it'll turn up via some deus ex machina”.
[Continued On Page 4]
It Stopped Being The Underdog
This lack of a power imbalance throws off the show’s attempts at satire, as it no longer appears comfortable criticizing those in positions of authority and instead settles for sucking up to them.
Despite the politics of its creators, the satire of The Simpsons strived to be bipartisan, with one famous scene summarising the two American political parties Republicans and Democrats with the taglines “We’re Just Plain Evil” and “We Hate Life and Ourselves”, respectively.
This unapologetic cynicism grounded the myriad perspectives of the show’s writers. Whilst Bill Oakley and Mike Reiss may have appeared on leftist podcast Chapo Trap House, their co-writer Jon Swartzelder is a libertarian conservative, and many more of the show’s writers are liberals. Their collective disdain for authority and those in power is less rooted in a specific ideology and more in the show’s own values.
Despite Mr. Bush’s complaints, the right to have a home of one’s own, a way to can support your family, and a community around you without having to rely on one rich overlord is a pretty classic American value.
The show’s enduring popularity came from The Simpsons’ implicit position as the underdog. When Bart becomes famous in “Bart Gets Famous”, success turns to ashes in his mouth as it’s hollow and empty without family and friends around. When the family meet pop icon Michael Jackson, they’re not in awe of his fame and success. Instead, he’s a tragic, troubled figure who helps Homer out of a tight spot and becomes his friend.
When they meet Lady Gaga in a critically abhorred episode years later…
Homer Vs Dignity and its depiction of the employee and his employer as almost-instant equals isn’t the moment that derailed The Simpsons. That came earlier, and it came in an episode which unlike most of the instalments singled out as the show’s downfall, is actually pretty funny.
[Continued On Page 5]
Celebrity For Celebrity's Sake
Season ten’s fifth episode, When You Dish Upon A Star, follows Homer’s accidental discovery of Kim Basinger, Alec Baldwin, and Ron Howard (all playing themselves) holidaying on the remote outskirts of Springfield.
Although Homer initially convinces the trio to allow him to be their assistant, he soon blabs about their presence to the townspeople and falls out of favour with them. By the episode’s end, Homer has a court order banning him from being within 500 miles of any living or dead celebrity, whilst for Baldwin, Basinger, and Howard it’s back home to Hollywood where happy days are here again (sorry).
It’s a silly, funny premise, and one which Bart After Dark writer Richard Appel wrings some inspired laughs out of (Homer’s thwarted screenplay idea about a “killer robot driving instructor and his best friend, a talking pie” is a stand-out). It’s also an episode which operates on two assumptions: that viewers know who the celebrities in question are, and that they empathise with these celebrities as much as Homer.
Fabulously wealthy, powerful guest stars were nothing new on The Simpsons, but the show’s only mention of George HW Bush portrayed the president as a cranky, embarrassingly out-of-touch curmudgeon, whilst Bill Clinton’s appearance had him grin and admit “hey, I’m a pretty lousy president.”
The show was unafraid of pot shots and unimpressed with power, quick to side with the often ignorant and small-minded but genuinely well-meaning family, rather than an attention-grabbing guest star.
When Marge became a police officer she was not only horrified by the endemic corruption throughout the force, but had no answer when Lisa asked “but aren’t the police a protective force that maintains the status quo for the wealthy elite?”
In contrast, when billionaire emerald mine heir Elon Musk appeared on the series in 2015, the show rolled out the red carpet and fawned, never referencing any of his professional and personal scandals and controversies.
[Continued On Page 6]
Conclusion
In its prime, the show didn’t pull in megawatt guest stars like Danny DeVito and Michael Jackson in order to capitalize on their fame. Instead the series saw them play interesting, original characters which commented on their respective public images. Even brief, one-joke cameos served to subvert the perception of artists and public personalities, rather than reinforce it for them (and their managers).
Look at Cypress Hill, the hard-edged rap outfit who The Simpsons left collaborating with an orchestra, or the Red Hot Chili Peppers, a controversial rock group who cheerfully acquiesced to family-friendly censorship in their appearance on the show.
The show excelled at forcing people whose job consisted of maintaining an image to dismiss it, twist it, or outright flip it for fun. The Simpsons wasn’t impressed by power and hated authority, because its central family were normal everyday people.
Fast forward through the show’s increasing fame and its cultural import, and the cause of its downfall is clear. The Simpsons lost us the moment the show become as in love with attention, as desperate for approval, and as shamelessly willing to change itself for others as the celebrities who it once mocked.
Watch Next
The Simpsons Celebrity Guest Star Quiz - How Many Do You Remember?