The Flash: Ranking Every Season From Worst To Best

Which of The Flash's six seasons made it to the finish line?

The Flash Season 2 promo
The CW

The Flash has become a staple of television over the past decade, quickly eclipsing its own parent show to become the most popular superhero series on television today.

A vehicle for DC Comics' Scarlet Speedster, it gave longtime fans of Barry Allen the chance to see him light up the small screen for the first time in decades, while also giving Arrow fans the chance to experience another new layer of the ever-growing Arrowverse. And what an ambitious layer it turned out to be.

Grant Gustin's leather-clad hero has been tearing up the pavement of Central City for over five years now and though there have been some roadblocks along the way, that hasn't stopped The CW series from amassing a loyal fanbase devoted to both the characters and the adventures they embark on each and every week.

Six seasons in, Barry and Team Flash have practically seen it all. Or maybe not as the show will return for a seventh at the beginning of next year. And with that in mind, let's take this hiatus period to reflect on all of its seasons thus far and ultimately see how they stack up against each other.

6. Season 4

The Flash Barry Allen
The CW

With the exception of Supergirl, it seems like every Arrowverse show is doomed to have a pretty poor fourth season. That's right, unfortunately even The Flash couldn't outrun destiny this time.

Following in its predecessor's footsteps, the show produced a third season that was both promising and problematic before trying far too hard to distance itself from it and producing a much worse follow-up in the process. Though not even remotely as low as Arrow's fourth offering, The Flash Season 4 still made a lot of the same mistakes as it attempted to channel some of what made the show such a success in the first place - only to unwittingly mistake its glorious light-heartedness for something that was much too corny.

Wally West's replacement with Ralph Dibny sparked controversy while Clifford DeVoe's overpowered nature resulted in a lot of depressingly repetitive episodes. Speaking of which, his reliance on the newly-established bus metas resulted in a deeply convoluted plan that provided the show with the means to produce an endless supply of villain-of-the-week episodes - each one devoted to a specific bus meta. And that, more than anything, made the season an absolute slog to get through.

There is one silver lining in the phenomenal 'Enter Flashtime' - which is one of the show's greatest hours - but not even that was enough to elevate this one from last place.


5. Season 5

The Flash Season 5 Barry Allen Nora West Allen
The CW

The fifth season is, by and large, an improvement over Season 4 but it wasn't able to stop itself from falling victim to a number of the same issues that plagued it.

Though Nora West-Allen's arrival spiced the dynamic up nicely, she quickly became a crutch that the writers relied on over and over again and that plot device grew wearisome early with the confrontational West-Allen daughter refusing to learn from her mistakes. The resulting episodes grew repetitive while the the narrative got thinner.

Speaking of repetitive, however, nothing was more annoying than the incredibly dull Cicada - who showed up, mumbled a few 'This Ends Now's before retreating at the first sign of defeat. And to make matters worse, Team Flash allowed it to happen every single time.

There was some promise in there with the Nora stuff and Thawne's return reinvigorated things late in the game, resulting in a finale that might just be The Flash's single best episode in years, but all the good was undercut by the shortcomings of the primary storylines.


4. Season 3

The Flash Savitar
The CW

Of all the evil speedsters The Flash has adapted, the Savitar debacle proved to be the weakest because, yet again, the length of the season undercut what the writers were trying to do.

Barry's battle with his evil futuristic time remnant was excellent in theory, and there are few words to describe the goosebump-inducing moment in which his troubled reflection revealed himself, but a season full of plot holes, convoluted time travel logic and too many on-the-nose 'I am the Future Flash' teases hindered what could have been the best narrative the show ever tackled.

Other things that held the season back were the confusing Dr. Alchemy subplot, the main narrative's damsel-in-distress treatment of Iris West and the swift wrapping up of the iconic Flashpoint storyline.

However, the season also produced some cracking episodes, the Savitar arc remained compelling the whole way throughout and it all came together in one of the show's better finales. And without a lot of the middling stuff, it could have been a great season - perhaps even better than the second.

In hindsight, it's easy to see why the show relied so heavily on evil speedsters because, in spite of Savitar's shortcomings, the arc was still head and shoulders above almost everything that came after it. And parts of it were so good, in fact, that it almost placed above this next entry...


3. Season 6

The Flash Season 6 Caitlin Snow
The CW

After two lacklustre offerings, The Flash found a way to bounce back in its sixth season and it all has to do with new showrunner Eric Wallace's different approach.

Learning from previous mistakes, the writers adapted to the extensive episode count by splitting the show into two mini 'graphic novels' instead. This resulted in Team Flash battling not one but two Big Bads throughout the season, as they went up against Bloodwork across the first seven episodes while battling the mysteries of Black Hole and Mirror Master in the back half. And to top it all off, both narratives bookened the long-teased Crisis On Infinite Earths - which served as this season's Arrowverse crossover.

They say less is more, but The Flash came up with a unique method of giving us less and more. There were more major threats than ever before, yes, but shorter narratives resulted in far less time-wasting and filler episodes - and this ultimately made the season a much smoother watch than many of its predecessors.

It's a shame that this ended up being the season cut short by a few episodes, because the show was really going places, delving into its characters in a more powerful manner, for the first time in a long time. That said, it means it gets to bask in these compelling narratives for a little longer at the beginning of Season 7... and that really ain't so bad.


2. Season 2

The Flash Season 2 Race
The CW

It's hard to imagine where the Arrowverse would be without the second season of The Flash. A year of television that gave life to the multiverse, it expanded The CW's growing universe of heroes exponentially and brought forth one of the show's most compelling arcs.

Barry's emotional grapples with his inability to allow himself to be happy felt like an authentic progression of his emotional journey, but it also broke new ground for a character that had been put through the wringer more times than he would care to count - something that enhanced his struggles with his inability to defeat Zoom.

Speaking of Zoom, he proved to be a worthy successor to Thawne in that he was far more terrifying in appearance and every bit as formidable in approach. And the saga that the two speedsters embarked on strengthened the Arrowverse as a whole, introducing us to parallel dimensions and the Speed Force itself.

Did certain story beats mirror the first season? Yes, but it didn't matter because the show managed to adapt the Arrowerse's successful formula a second time and still managed to remain fresh while doing so. And after all, this was essentially the Earth-2 doppelganger of the show's maiden voyage, and it was a pretty damn worthy one at that.


1. Season 1

The Flash Reverse Flash Barry
The CW

'Perfection' is a word used so much in today's day and age that it's almost become something of a cliché. The truth is that, while virtually everything is capable of greatness, perfection is a hard standard to reach. And yet this writer can't help but think that the Arrowverse has never come as close to perfection as the debut installment of The Flash.

Drastically different to what worked for Arrow, The Flash adopted a more optimistic and light-hearted tone, placing an emphasis on family and making each adventure feel as fun as the golden age of superhero television from the '60s and '70s. But those colourful adventures were merely a backdrop for the compelling narrative at its heart, as The Man In The Yellow Suit saga was without question the best piece of epic storytelling that the Arrowverse - and indeed, The CW - has ever produced.

Carried by a star-making turn from Grant Gustin, The Flash's debut offering was a comic book come to life in all the right ways. And as introductions go, this was nothing short of phenomenal - kicking The Flash off on such a high that none of its follow-up seasons - or Arrowverse seasons in general - ever came close to matching the grandeur of it.

-

Which season of The Flash is your favorite? Tell us in the comment section below.


The Flash Quiz: How Well Do You Remember Season 6?

The Flash The Void
The CW

1. On Which Date Did The Flash Season 6 Premiere?

In this post: 
The-Flash
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.