The Mandalorian 2.8 Review - 6 Ups And 3 Downs From Chapter 16

Season 2 of The Mandalorian ends (mostly) on a high, but with a few niggling questions unanswered.

Mandalorian Chapter 16 Dark Trooper
Lucasfilm

It's finally here. Season 2 of The Mandalorian finally came to a close with Chapter 16, with Jon Favreau once again handling writing duties and Peyton Reed returning to direct. Having spent the week living in fear of something bad happening - given Star Wars likes to do that with its sequels' endings - I can certainly say it kept me in suspense. (And fear - that's important too.)

Chapter 16, or The Rescue, starts with Din and Cara Dune intercepting Doctor Pershing before they recruit Bo-Katan and Koska Reeves to add to their rescue party. The band make it to Gideon's light cruiser (well... duh), and the end result is a mostly satisfying conclusion to The Mandalorian's second season - one that packs an emotional wallop at that.

But there were a few things here and there that left quite a lot to be desired, and it means the sophomore season ends on a slightly weird note. Those looking for a definitive and satisfying conclusion will be pleased, but between some dodgy action, weird characterisations and a slightly dissonant note to end on, this isn't quite the home run that previous episodes set up.

It's still a strong chapter overall, but one that's also potentially a little too self indulgent.

MAJOR SPOILERS AHEAD!


Ups...

6. Seeing All The Mandalorians Together Is Ridiculously Cool

The Mandalorian Chapter 16
Lucasfilm

Although it's a bit weird that Axe Woves is literally... nowhere to be found (as is Greef Karga, weirdly) it was pretty great to see all our favourite Mandalorians on the same screen - even if they didn't get on all that well.

The episode on a whole was pretty light on comedy, but seeing Boba and Din step into this backwater canteen and do the classic Western staredown together was very amusing. We also get to see the Gauntlet again - the iconic Mandalorian starfighters seen in The Clone Wars and Rebels - which is nice, but the main attraction is seeing all the characters interacting with one another.

There's that classic factional tension that has dominated Mandalorian history since... forever, and while it is interesting to see that conflict, I do kind of think Bo-Katan's characterisation in this episode was really off. It's one thing to admonish Boba Fett's conduct as a Mandalorian for willingly collaborating with the Empire, but to mock him for being a clone? That felt weirdly out of step with her previous depictions - especially when she liberated Mandalore for the first time thanks to a battalion of clone troopers.

Either way, it was great to see them all together - even if Boba does exit stage left prematurely shortly afterwards.


5. Boba Fett Doing Boba Fett Stuff

The Mandalorian Boba Fett Slave I
Lucasfilm

What was once the obligatory "Grogu Doing Grogu Things" entry has now become the "Boba Fett appreciation zone". But what can I say? It's just great to have Temuera Morrison back doing Boba Fett stuff.

While he doesn't deploy his seismic charges this time around, he does get to show off his skills in the Slave I, and it was pretty funny seeing him toy with all those TIE Fighters for the sake of providing the infiltration team's cover, only to then just turn around and blow them to smithereens like they were nothing.

Morrison's Boba has been a revelation this season, and the best part - thanks to the post-credits sequence - is that there's more of him to come.


4. The Darktroopers Are TERRIFYING

Mandalorian Chapter 16 Darktroopers
Lucasfilm

The Darktroopers are every bit as terrifying as you remember them from the old Jedi Knight games, and maybe even a little bit more.

They have to be deep cooled so as to not waste power, which leads to a great race against time where we see Din try and get to the control panel to lock them in as they're being powered up.

One trooper manages to get out though and proceeds to give Din the thrashing of a lifetime. (Seriously, is Din okay? That has to have left a big concussion.) Thankfully he uses the Beskar spear and manages to take it down before blasting the rest out of the airlock. But even so, the Dark troopers are right on up there with the most fearsome weapons we've seen in the Empire's arsenal.

Who knew mixing Terminator with Star Wars would be such a good combo?


3. Din Duelling Gideon

The Mandalorian Chapter 16 Din Djarin Gideon
Lucasfilm

Yeah we all knew it was coming, but it definitely lived up to the hype.

Din makes his way to rescue Grogu and who else is there but Moff Gideon? I LOVE the exchange the two share here. Gideon looks like he's going to bargain with Din; he can have Grogu so long as Gideon gets to keep his Darksaber, as in Gideon's own words, he has all he needs from the Child.

It's great to see that Din doesn't care about the Saber at all. He isn't drawn to the power it brings and just wants to rescue his space wizard son.

Of course, Gideon takes the opportunity to double cross Din, leading to the duel with the Beskar spear and the sequence overall is really clever. It's not a duel we're really used to and seeing Gideon wield that thing like a maniac as opposed to a master swordsman exemplifies what makes this confrontation so great: neither Din nor Gideon are used to wielding either of these weapons, which leads to a frantic struggle and not an elegant duel to the death.


2. Luke Skywalker's Rogue One Moment

The Mandalorian Chapter 16 Luke Skywalker
Lucasfilm

Ever since Grogu reached out into the void on Tython's seeing stone, fans had been speculating as to who could answer his call. In reality, there was only ever going to be one Jedi who could reply, and they make one heck of an entrance in Chapter 16.

Just when everyone thinks all hope is lost, with the Darktroopers once again on the scene and ready to pummel the blast doors and make it to the bridge, an X-Wing shows up and you can tell from Grogu's reaction that it's the Jedi he reached out to earlier in the season.

No other Jedi flies an X-Wing, so of course, it had to be Luke Skywalker - and boy does he get time to shine. Decked out in all black and brandishing his iconic green lightsaber, Luke makes quick work of the Darktroopers in a direct and clear homage to Vader's hallway massacre at the end of Rogue One.

Having dispatched all the troopers, Luke emerges onto the bridge and removes his hood, revealing a digitally de-aged Mark Hamill. It's always great to see Hamill back in Star Wars (or anything for that matter - bless him), and while yes the technology does veer ever so slightly into the uncanny valley, Luke's return is still a clear highlight.

... for the most part.


1. The Book Of Boba Fett

The Mandalorian Boba Fett Fennec Shand Jabba's Palace
Lucasfilm

I'll get to the fallout of Luke's appearance in just a second, but for now, let's all bask in the warm glow of this wonderful shot.

Aaaaaahhh. How lovely.

After Chapter 16 ripped all our hearts out of our chests with Grogu choosing to go with Luke Skywalker rather than stay with Din, we're treated to a lovely little post-credits sequence involving Boba Fett. Fennec Shand does her best Boushh impression, killing the Gamorrean guards near the staircase entrance, before the camera pans to reveal that none other than Bib Fortuna (the Twi'lek underling to Jabba in Episode VI) is sat in Jabba's throne.

Enter Boba, who enters shortly after and guns down Bib. He then proceeds to sit down in the throne himself (all the while Fennec helps herself to some fancy Star Wars drink), with his theme playing overhead. A quick fade to black later, and we're given a title: The Book of Boba Fett, another Star Wars spin-off series releasing in December 2021.

What else can you say? I doubt I'm the only one who's been won over by Boba this year, and besides, seeing more of Ming-Na Wen's Fennec isn't a bad thing either. Only time will tell what the character is getting up to on Tatooine, but expect the series to delve deeper into the character's backstory and motivations, which were mostly kept at arm's length for Season 2.


Downs...

3. Is This Really How It Ends For Grogu?

The Mandalorian Grogu Chapter 16 Luke Skywalker
Lucasfilm

Putting genuine criticism aside for just one second, I think we can all agree that seeing Din say goodbye to Grogu was pretty heartbreaking, and in that sense, it may merit a down. It's totally fair to call this a great ending for Grogu in that he's learned to get over his attachment if that's how you've interpreted it, but at the very least, seeing space dad lose space wizard son is a pretty sad note to end on.

As for my overall feelings on Grogu going off with Luke to the Jedi Temple? They're not too great. Look, we all knew this could probably happen, and at this point in the Star Wars canon it's not too sad a note to end on. However, we are burdened with the knowledge of foresight and we know that Luke's experiment with the temple does not go well at all. In the moment it might make for an emotionally happy farewell seeing Grogu vibing with R2, but then you remember, "oh yeah... this all goes terribly!"

Will we see Grogu again? Honestly, I don't know. The little fella already survived one temple massacre so there's nothing to say he couldn't do the same again, but there's an element of tragedy to this ending that I'm - and probably even The Mandalorian itself is, actually - struggling to reconcile with.

The Mandalorian Chapter 16 Din Djarin Grogu
Lucasfilm

The core of this show was always between Din and Grogu, and while I know we have SO MUCH left to resolve with the Darksaber, and Bo-Katan and Mandalore and whatever else, I feel like Din will be missing a part of himself from now on. That may add something to his character, but this ending is still incredibly bittersweet, and slightly bizarre given the episode ignores the tragedy of it all.

Pedro Pascal is phenomenal when he has to say goodbye to little Grogu - and I'm sure there'll be many viewers who will be just as torn up about it as Din himself is. In plenty of ways it feels like classic Star Wars, and even a fitting end for the pair's journey; Grogu has learned something about attachment and Din has learned more about what it means to be a Mandalorian.

But this also feels like a backwards step. We're still treating attachment like it's something a Jedi should fear, and not that that idea itself is part of what led to the Order's collapse twice over. Unfortunately, the episode seem so caught up in slicing Imp droids to pieces, that it never even considers interrogating that idea.


2. The Hit Or Miss Action (And Some Niggling Questions)

The Mandalorian Chapter 16
Lucasfilm

There was something almost imperceptibly off about Chapter 16. I mentioned in my review for Chapter 12 that The Mandalorian has sometimes strayed into repetitive territory with its action - that being lots of generic ducking and shooting in classic Imperial corridors. Peyton Reed does add in some flourishes here or there, but the part where Bo-Katan, Fennec, Cara Dune and Koska Reeves are storming the base felt very bland compared to the other sequences we've seen in previous chapters.

Does it matter too much when we get Luke massacring Dark troopers and Din duelling Moff Gideon? Not particularly. But there are still ways of making these sequences feel more frenetic and engaging.

Lastly, to wrangle another gripe with the episode into this entry, it did feel ever so slightly rushed. Greef Karga and Axe Woves have weirdly disappeared for one, but there's still some confusion over Gideon's plot and why he wanted the Child. Chapters 12 and 16 heavily imply that it's related to Snoke and Palpatine, but the specifics of the plot are cast aside here.

In Chapter 14, after Grogu is abducted, Gideon ends his interrogation of The Child by telling his subordinates to inform Doctor Pershing that they have their "donor". Pershing himself is en route to Gideon's light cruiser in this episode, but the Moff reveals to Din that he has all he needs from Grogu. So, why was Pershing necessary? Where was Gideon travelling to? There's a chance Gideon was bluffing, but he was prepared to shoot Grogu at the end. Granted he was aware he'd all but lost by that point, but these still feel like questions that should've been resolved by now.


1. Bo-Katan's Characterisation Was Really Off (And Contradicts Rebels)

Mandalorian Chapter 16 Bo Katan Darksaber
Lucasfilm

We're living in unprecedented times for Star Wars. The Mandalorian Season 2 has been the first property to really utilise the expanded canon effectively, drawing in key characters from the beloved Clone Wars and Rebels cartoons and other literature to great effect.

One of the big highlights has been Katee Sackhoff's Bo-Katan Kryze, but her behaviour in the Season 2 finale seems totally at odds with what we know about the character. In The Clone Wars and Rebels, Lady Bo was a reluctant leader. She didn't win the Darksaber by defeating its previous wielder in combat - she was given it by Sabine Wren.

Bo-Katan was initially reluctant to accept the weapon from Sabine (who technically earned the right to wield it after besting Gar Saxon in a duel), but did so aware she was the right person for the job. She wanted to unite Mandalore against the Empire, and she had the experience and acumen to make it happen.

Which is why it's so weird that she's hung up about Din defeating Gideon and not herself. She'd previously accepted the saber from an old ally before, so why not now? Has Bo-Katan been corrupted by the weapon's power? Or is she just really insecure that she's the only one to wield it without defeating its previous owner in combat? We still don't know the circumstances of how it came into Gideon's possession, but this feels like something she should've gotten over a LONG time ago.

No doubt the third season of The Mandalorian will address this in due time, but her portrayal here was really jarring, and something that'll no doubt leave fans of Star Wars Rebels all too confused.


Watch Next


Star Wars: You'll Never Get 100% On This Mandalorian Quiz

The Mandalorian
Lucasfilm

1. Who Created The Show?

Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.