The Mandalorian: Ranking Every Episode From Worst To Best

The best and worst of the galaxy's newest bounty hunter...

The Mandalorian Poster
Disney+

Over the last few weeks, The Mandalorian took the world by storm.

Many were unsure of what exactly to expect from the first-ever live-action Star Wars television series, especially given its placement as Disney+'s big opening-day draw but within days, the show had cemented itself as not only a viable and genuine piece of the overarching Star Wars mythos but also a bona fide phenomenon in its own right.

With the first season of the show now over, and several months to kill before we get the second season in fall of 2020, it's time to take a look back at all eight of the episodes and see where they stand.

From good to bad to everything in-between, let's reminisce about where The Mandalorian faltered and where it soared to heights we didn't dare even dream it could have reached.

8. Chapter 1: The Mandalorian

Mandalorian Doorway
Disney+

Things got off to a pretty rocky start.

Everything about this first episode just doesn't *quite* work. From the opening scene, its tone feels kind of all over the place, essentially just being a sequence of unconnected scenes held together solely by a steady stream of references to all things Star Wars.

It also doesn't help matters that the timing and editing of the episode just feel consistently offbeat. With Filoni making the transition from animated to live-action in his directing, you can feel some of the finer nuances slipping through the cracks. As a result, set pieces such as the final shootout of the episode don't really land. It's a Frankenstein's monster of an episode, stitched together in a wholly unnatural way.

The reveal of Baby Yoda and the subsequent final shot are truly incredible, but you have to slog through an episode of filler to get there.


7. Chapter 4: Sanctuary

Mandalorian Cara Dune Gina Carano
Lucasfilm

Directed by Bryce Dallas Howard, this episode is classic Star Wars storytelling, even if it is a twinge too generic for its own good.

With a plot ripped straight from the handbook of Kurosawa's Seven Samurai, this episode chronicles the adventures of Mando and Baby Yoda as they help save some locals from a gang of invading marauders. It sports some great Baby Yoda moments (this is the episode that gave the internet the sipping tea meme, so there's that), introduces us to Gina Carano's Cara Dune, and features a stellar final action setpiece that sees Howard treating an AT-ST like the star of its own monster movie.

Sadly, the character beats here for Mando himself feels a bit stilted and phoned in, doing little more than scratching the surface. The idea of Mando suddenly taking settling down as a serious option feels a bit out of left-field, so the would-be tragic ending of him realizing he and Baby Yoda have to go on the run doesn't really have any emotional heft to it.

But it sure is a fun episode.


6. Chapter 5: The Gunslinger

Mandalorian Razor Crest
Lucasfilm

Filoni's second turn in the director's chair of the season is a vast improvement over the first.

He's clearly worked through the kinks of translating his vision into live-action and the resulting product is a much more confident and nuanced episode. The opening dogfight sequence immediately puts any doubts to rest, Filoni is the real deal, whether he be dealing with animation or live-action. Later setpieces such as Mando and Calican's nighttime ambush of Fennec Shand are also handled with incredible precision and care, hitting all the right beats.

It's also worth noting that this episode is the only one written by Filoni and it shows; what could have easily been simply nostalgia-fodder becomes a subversive and intriguing examination of the post-Empire galaxy. Mos Eisley is no longer the hive of scum and villainy it once was. Droids bartend, the booths are empty, and the only bounty hunter insight is a wanna-be who's just trying to make a name for himself.

An interesting and unique episode.


5. Chapter 6: The Prisoner

Mandalorian Image
Lucasfilm

Rick Famuyiwa's second turn at-bat directing never quite reaches the euphoric heights of his first episode, but it's still one hell of a ride.

Essentially acting as a standalone bottle episode which digs into Mando's past, this is pretty much a straight prison-break-gone-wrong story just set in the Star Wars universe. But thanks to Famuyiwa's stellar direction, it also happens to feature some of the very best action sequences in the entire season. The setpieces early on in the episode that sees Mando singlehandedly taking out several of the New Republic security droids is thrillingly constructed, utilizing tension and suspense masterfully to build from simple setups to incredibly satisfying payoffs.

Famuyiwa and Christopher Yost's script also features one of the strongest arcs for Mando in the entire season. Leaning in on his penchant for murder leading up to this episode as a character flaw he must overcome is a brilliant choice and it makes it that much more compelling to see him having to learn from his mistakes here and make smarter choices for his and Baby Yoda's future.


4. Chapter 7: The Reckoning

Mandalorian I Have Spoken
Disney+

In the second-to-last episode of the season, Deborah Chow returns to the director's chair and once again delivers a slam dunk.

This episode has just about everything you could possibly want from The Mandalorian; great Baby Yoda gags (see: Baby Yoda nearly crashing the ship), great action (see: the fireside shootout with Mynocks), and the payoff of seeing returning characters all coming together and interacting with one another.

This episode also earns a special place all its own for giving Werner Herzog his juiciest dialogue of the season, as he absolutely chews the scenery while waxing philosophical about the state of the post-Empire galaxy. As if that wasn't enough, it also features him giving the instantly all-timer line delivery of "we will be very quiet".

By the time Moff Gideon is introduced and guns down the entirety of Herzog's crew, cornering our heroes and kidnapping Baby Yoda, the episode has worked its way up to classic territory.


3. Chapter 2: The Child

Mandalorian Baby Yoda
Disney+

If the first episode was a mild misfire, then this episode was just shy of a miracle.

With its true objective purely in view following the Baby Yoda reveal at the end of Chapter 1, the show was finally free to really show its cards and show them it did. Directed by Rick Famuyiwa, this episode set a tone and pace that the rest of the season would follow to great success. The first several minutes of the episode play out in complete silence as Mando and Baby Yoda march across the barren wasteland, and yet it is utterly captivating to watch thanks to Famuyiwa's inspired direction.

The episode is full of thrilling and impressive setpieces (the Jawasandcrawler chase scene is straight out of Mad Max: Fury Road and the showdown with the Mudhorn has delightful callbacks to one of the best moments of Attack of the Clones) but where Famuyiwa really excels is in capturing the early blossoming of the relationship between Mando and Baby Yoda. It's the thread that would make the show such a phenomenon and its only so captivating because of how intensely focused on building it through dynamic motion and emotion Famuyiwa was here.


2. Chapter 3: The Sin

Mandalorian Imperial Remnant
Lucasfilm

Deborah Chow's first episode as a director is a barn-burning delight, delivering hugely satisfying action setpieces, tons of pathos-driven affecting storytelling, and inspired character beats and payoffs that work like gangbusters.

Following the enlightening success of Chapter 2, it was absolutely stunning to see Chow building on the groundwork Famuyiwa had laid in such remarkable form. Again, the unlikely relationship between Mando and Baby Yoda is the show's most valuable asset and it is what makes this episode so incredibly compelling. Seeing Mando have to pass the point of no return, and make a choice that marks genuine change within himself, all in the name of saving Baby Yoda is delightful.

The subsequent action sequence of him storming the safehouse and murdering a whole bunch of stormtroopers is just the icing on top of the cake. And then, as if all of that wasn't enough, it also delivers the extra bonus payoff of all of the Mandalorians showing up to help save the day, jetpacks, miniguns, and all.

It is unbelievably awesome and the show at its very finest.


1. Chapter 8: Redemption

Mandalorian IG
Disney+

Somewhat unbelievably, The Mandalorian managed to save the best for last, with a season finale that is an emotionally satisfying joyride from beginning to end.

This is the first and only episode of the season directed by Taikia Waititi, and its as if Waititi shoved every once of his love for Star Wars into this thing because it's practically oozing charm from every orifice. From the side-splitting opening of the two scout troopers abusing Baby Yoda only to get utterly destroyed by IG-11, to the shootout between our heroes and Moff Gideon's firing squad, to Baby Yoda using the force to stop a flame thrower, to Emily Swallow's The Armorer getting to whoop some ass, to the final showdown between Mando and a TIE fighter, this thing kicks from beginning to end.

It is consistently surprising, featuring both the funniest (see: Baby Yoda riding on a speeder bike with IG-11) and most emotionally devastating moments (see: The Mandalorian covert being mostly killed off or Mando's genuine growth and sadness at IG-11's sacrifice) and feels quintessentially Star Wars.

By the time it reaches its final moments, with Mando and Baby Yoda blasting off to find Baby Yoda's homeworld and Moff Gideon slicing his way out of his TIE Fighter with a Darksaber, it guarantees the wait for Season 2 is going to be an arduous few months.


Contributor
Contributor

A film enthusiast and writer, who'll explain to you why Jingle All The Way is a classic any day of the week.