The Mandalorian Series 1 Review: 7 Ups And 2 Downs
How did Disney's first Star Wars TV show hold up?
At a time of peak division between Star Wars fans, The Mandalorian had a serious undertaking on its hands. Could it be one of the first Disney-fronted Star Wars efforts to avoid controversy, or at the very least a divisive response?
Well, for the most part, yes. Jon Favreau and Dave Filoni's The Mandalorian is easily one of the best offerings this franchise has put out, live-action or otherwise. While the new trilogy of films suffers from what feels like more of the same, the show strikes a nerve thanks to its refreshingly grounded direction, endearing characters, and superb action scenes brought on by a terrific ensemble of directors.
Superseding the typical 'Chosen One' storyline, this show's just about one bounty hunter who accepts a job far more complicated than he could've ever expected. Boasting the feel of a western set in the far future, you'd be hard-pressed to find a big-budget sci-fi that scratches that Firefly itch like The Mandalorian.
This feels like a genuinely-realized vision of showrunners with plenty of ideas to spare and it's a promising start to what will hopefully be a creative-driven streak of Disney+ exclusives.
First, let's discuss the negatives...
Downs...
2. The Abundance Of Baby Yoda Close-ups Get Distracting

Now now, Baby Yoda has become the internet's baby at this point, but when you move past the memes and cute gifs, you have a character whose camera time is approximately 95% cute reaction shots. These moments wouldn't be an issue if they weren't so blatant. Similar to how Guardians of the Galaxy 2 did extreme close-ups of Baby Groot to make you admire his cuteness, these moments in the show interrupt whatever's going on to make you go 'aww.'
While there are excellent exceptions like the gags involving him messing around in the background during a scene, the close-up reaction shots read like an executive nudged the director to place it in the middle of the scene. They don't feel all that genuine, which is a shame considering the show was able to establish such a compelling a kinship between Mando and the little green guy.
This is why these moments stand out more than others. They're the moments where the show feels like it's telling you to like him. In a show that succeeds in its ability to earn your admiration, these moments, numerous as they are in each episode, feel like they're forcing that connection.
1. Several Episodes Feel Like Pointless Filler

A huge aspect of what makes The Mandalorian work is its ability to draw you into the dirty, backstabbing-heavy world of bounty hunters. Alongside the engaging overarching plotline involving Baby Yoda and his pursuers, the series' first three episodes are absolutely stellar and give you plenty of incentive to keep watching.
Unfortunately, following that series-best Chapter 3 episode, the show starts to meander. What started as a feasible next step for the story became a standalone arc that only retained one new character out of the dozens introduced and had a tone that felt less urgent than what had at first been promised.
The next episode, Chapter 5, didn't fare much better, as a prominent new character lacked anything endearing or memorable and it featured another story that was only good for an ending tease for the Big Bad. (Unless that character turns out to be someone else.)
Although the follow-up episode was, once again, a standalone separate story, it did serve as a look into Mando's past life, as well as a return to the tone and style that the first episodes had. In any other show, these episodes would be perfectly solid and fine. Here though? They stuck out badly.
Ups...
7. Action Sequences That Are Both Bombastic And Understated

Far removed from the sensory overload space battles and shootouts seen in the central Star Wars movies, Mandalorian's approach to action is refreshingly smaller-scale. If there's a space battle, it's one ship versus another. If it's a shootout, it's contained within a single building, corridor, or contained courtyard. You're never overwhelmed, making the viewing experience so much more enjoyable.
Emphasizing practical effects over VFX spectacle, you get a far greater sense of authenticity within this world and the stakes in each battle. The end result is ultimately something rather immersive, as nothing ever really threatens to take you out of the moment.
The series also resists the urge to revel in those action sequences, never going too bombastic or full Michael Bay-levels of explosions and shouting. Shootouts and bare-knuckle brawls are given proper build-up to build tension before exploding into chaos, something that recent Star Wars offerings have often lacked. Hopefully, the show maintains this style of action going into next season and doesn't feel the need to overdo action for the sake of being 'bigger.'
6. There's Still Plenty Left To Come

While the show has already found an excellent creative groove that has made it a huge hit with even the pickiest fans, it's clear the best may be yet to come.
Whether it's legacy characters that could make an appearance or entirely new personalities to fill out the corners of the show's many worlds, Favreau and company have all the resources necessary to keep the good times rolling.
Add in the introduction of Giancarlos Eposito's stone-faced villain coming in the season's final two episodes, and you also have the potential for a fantastic recurring antagonist.
Who knows what the showrunners have in store for the next season, but there's plenty to get excited about come Fall 2020 when the show returns. Expect some new favorite characters, new locales, and plenty of thrilling action sequences.
5. Jon Favreau And Dave Filoni

Like any of these ambitious undertakings involving beloved IPs, you need great leadership in order to make them work. Thankfully Jon Favreau and Filoni are no strangers to this process and have added another big success to their resume, with Favreau having experience on the creative side of the MCU and Filoni crafting many beloved Star Wars stories in the animated Clone Wars and Rebels shows.
The Mandalorian thrives creatively because it avoids that feeling of having too many cooks in the kitchen, a problem for most blockbuster projects. The show never feels particularly messy or like it's at odds with an overarching story - a criticism frequently levelled at the Sequel Trilogy.
4. There's A Terrific Array Of Directorial Talent

While you may not know the names Deborah Chow and Rick Famiyuwa, you'll feel an immediate need to see more of their work once you see their episodes on The Mandalorian. Nearly every episode of show is led by a different director and you really grow to appreciate the variety of talent put on display.
No matter what episode you're watching, there's a clear sense of authority and perspective throughout every episode's runtime. They successfully buck the trend of most TV shows lacking personality behind the camera.
The trend of allowing numerous directors to take their crack at a Star Wars project is an excellent one that The Mandalorian is perfectly suited for. Here's hoping that next season serves as another proving ground for underrated filmmakers to show off their skills. Oh, and one other fact Star Wars will be happy to hear is that Deborah Chow, the director of the excellent Chapter 3 and 7 episodes, is in charge of the Obi-Wan Disney+ series. Yeah, time to get excited.
3. Ludwig Göransson's Distinct, Moody Score

The show's visuals and production design may be what mainly sells a show's aesthetic, but Ludwig Göransson's musical score, sounding like a samurai revenge flick mixed with an old school western, is what brings the whole thing together. Whether it's being used to add a little sizzle to a badass moment, one-liner or just to immerse you into a particular scene, Göransson hits.
Much like the show's titular character, the score is not in your face or ever fighting for your attention. If you're not paying attention, it sometimes gets lost when the blasters start pew pewing. That said, if you take the time to listen, Göransson's accompaniment elevates so many moments and scenes far more often than you may realize.
It pairs beautifully with the show's retro feel, always working towards heightening the drama and sense of adventure. Although the strong visuals and believable world are what's most often praised for selling a series' authenticity, it's Göransson's music that gives that final pull to keep you hooked.
2. Pedro Pascal's Clint Eastwood-Type Mando

Making a faceless protagonist work is no easy task. Yet through Pascal's expertly-dry line delivery, body language, and the actions his character takes, you're able to connect with him without really seeing his face. Much like 2012's Dredd (minus a visible jawline), the audience is easily able to identify with Mando without getting a real read on him.
The directors and writers also do great work of keeping his character consistent while also selling that mythic cool guy outlaw persona every step of the way. His development as a character is beautifully subtle, allowing his arc to move forward without drawing attention to it. You get glimpses of his tragic backstory and what made him so reserved, but the show allows this to be illustrated through his interactions with people and how he treats them. It's an incredibly refreshing way of giving you a glimpse at a character without spoonfeeding you every detail.
By the season's end, Mando has been clearly influenced by the events of the show and is no longer the lone gunslinger type he once was. Fans can only hope next season offers another sense of rewarding development for everyone's new favorite bounty hunter.
1. The Gritty, Perfectly Realized Tone

Much of the Star Wars fanbase has consistently requested a movie and/or show that takes an extended look into the seedy underbelly of the universe where scum and villainy reigns supreme. Rogue One came close, but it's The Mandalorian which finally achieves that gritty status fans were clamoring for.
Considering Favreau's more comedic background, it was unclear whether the show could maintain a consistent serious tone. Thankfully, both he and Filoni showed the beauty of a gritty tone that refuses to undercut its seriousness, allowing the stakes to feel real and the story to feel worthy of engagement.
There are also appropriate uses of comedy to keep things balanced (like the Force!), but in a way that feels earned and less like a cheap gag. Whatever the time or place in the season, The Mandalorian's tone always feels well-suited and effectively established.
True Or False: The Ultimate Star Wars Film Quiz