The Simpsons: 10 Worst Guest Stars Ever

Being on the Simpsons is a sign that you've made it - but it doesn't always work out.

The Simpsons is known for having had great guest stars over the years, continually snagging some of the biggest names in the entertainment industry (and elsewhere) and having them turn up on the show both as cameos and at times as actual characters. In the early years you had Kelsey Grammer, Michael Jackson, Dustin Hoffman, James Earl Jones, Elizabeth Taylor, Phil Hartman, George Takei, Ringo Starr, Jon Lovitz, and many others. There were musical guests like The Red Hot Chilli Peppers, Aerosmith, The Smashing Pumpkins, and Sonic Youth. In more recent seasons guest stars have included Daniel Radcliffe, Max Von Sydow, Zach Galifianakis, Seth Rogen, Patrick Stewart, Edward Norton, Bryan Cranston, Benedict Cumberbatch, Gordon Ramsay, Neil Gaiman, Michael Cera, Jeremy Irons, Cheech and Chong, Alyson Hannigan, Jodie Foster, Sacha Baron Cohen and, again, many others. Many, many others. There have literally been hundreds of guest stars on The Simpsons over the years, which is not surprising given the show has produced over 500 episodes to date. What is surprising is how they have managed to continually attract relevant celebrities, despite the claims that the show is past its prime. However, not all of these guest stars have panned out the way the show no doubt hoped. Some frankly have fallen flat, especially those making cameos for the sake of just being there. Guest stars playing actual roles tend to fare a little bit better, but they're not immune - sometimes the writing staff just lets them down. It's often no fault of their own - but here are the ten worst guest stars from the history of The Simpsons.

10. Conan O'Brien

Episode: Season 5, "Bart Gets Famous" Hold back the outrage for just a moment. Yes, Conan is awesome. Yes, he was a huge part of the early Simspons, and his episodes were some of the best. We love the guy. However, we can't help but think that Conan could have been given a better role for his cameo in season five's "Bart Gets Famous" - you know, the one where Bart becomes the "I Didn't Do It" kid on Krusty's show. It's a classic episode, and it features Bart at one point appearing on Conan's Late Night with Conan O'Brien. Funny thing, the part was written before Conan even knew he was getting the Late Night role (though he had already auditioned to take over from David Letterman). It was cute, but over quick, and not as funny as it could have been. Frankly, O'Brien could have been better utilized, even if "only I get to do the dance" was amusing.

9. Kid Rock

Episode: Season 11, "Kill the Alligator and Run" Kid Rock's cameo appearance in Season 11's "Kill the Alligator and Run" marks a turning point as far as guest stars on The Simpsons go: for the first time, the show went with someone more trendy than actually relevant. In the very same episode, Diedrich Bader does a fantastic job portraying the voice of the sheriff in a Florida town where Homer joins the Spring Break festivities - then attempts to extend them. Kid Rock, however, seemed out of place (at the time, he was still living off "Bawitdaba" fame, well before "All Summer Long" revived his career). The inclusion of Rock and his pals (including the late Joe C.) was just... lame. It didn't work, wasn't funny, and was the low point of the episode. "Kill the Alligator and Run" gets a lot of heat as one of the "worst" Simpsons episodes, but outside of Rock's participation, we rather enjoy it. The "no listening, you hear me?" line from the Cool Hand Luke-inspired Boss character, the family becoming hill-billies, Bader's performance - there's a lot to like, and it's a shame the Kid Rock cameo fell so flat. The Houston Press listed Rock as one of the five worst musical guests of all time on the show.

8. Martin Sheen

Episode: Season 9, "The Principal and the Pauper" Martin Sheen is a fantastic actor with a distinct voice who is good in just about anything. Apocalypse Now. The West Wing. The Dead Zone. Catch-22. JFK. Spawn. The Departed. And then there's his turn as "the real Seymour Skinner" on The Simpsons, in one of the most disliked episodes of all time, "The Principal and the Pauper." To be fair to Sheen, this really isn't his fault. He took his guest starring role, and delivered his lines as written. Sadly, the writers came up with such an awful storyline that there was really no saving the episode (in our opinion, though it has its defenders), and what could have been a classic guest star up there with Dustin Hoffman was wasted on a horrible plot twist that was almost completely ignored in later years.

7. U2

Episode: Season 9, "Trash of the Titans" As far as musical guest stars on The Simpsons go, U2 was something of a bomb, despite the fact that at the time, their career was still pretty much at its peak. And despite the fact that aside from this cameo, the episode was otherwise a classic. "Trash of the Titans" sees Homer running for head of Springfield's sanitation department, winning by making all sorts of wild claims and getting under the skin of the straight-laced Ray Patterson (played perfectly by Steve Martin). It featured the classic "The Garbage Man" song, a parody of "The Candy Man." U2 had actually requested to be on the show, and the producers obliged, but pretty much just wrote them in as happening to be playing Springfield. Homer interrupting their show as part of his campaign for sanitation commissioner is humorous but a one-note joke, and Bono's enthusiasm ("Hold on folks. The man's talking about waste management, that effects the whole damn planet!") is corny even as it pokes fun at the star's social leanings, and the only real funny moment from the band is when the rest of the group consider going to Moe's for a pint, but won't let Adam Clayton join.

6. R.E.M.

Episode: Season 13, "Homer the Moe" Another musical bust. The "Shiny Happy People" singers appeared on The Simpsons in season 13 (that was 2001), just as their career was really hitting its slump. The band requested that former drummer Bill Berry not be animated for the appearance, so the likeness of a session drummer was used - making us wonder how amicable Berry's departure really was (Berry had quit the band and become a farmer). Seems there might have been some hard feelings lingering, as the band was never the same as a three-piece. This is another stale guest appearance in an otherwise stellar episode. After Moe's club is rebranded "M" by a design consultant, and becomes too high end, Homer opens a bar in his garage - and manages to have R.E.M. play. Any band could have been inserted into the episode and it wouldn't have mattered, in fact almost any rock act would have made more sense, as R.E.M. were anything but a beer-friendly band. The end of the episode has the band sitting down with the Simpson family for Thanksgiving dinner, featuring a Tofurkey (a missed opportunity to bring back the "You don't win friends with salad" song).

5. Elvis Stojko

Episode: Season 18, "Kill Gill Vols. 1 & 2" Who? Why? Elvis Stojko is a Canadian world champion figure skater, winner of two Olympic silver medals, and probably not known to many outside of his home country, or figure skating fans. He retired from the sport the same year this episode aired, and the decision to include him of all people as a guest star is absolutely baffling. When Michelle Kwan turned up on the show, she was a little more relevant. Despite the family taking in "Krusty's Kristmas on Ice" (a Christmas show put on by a Jewish clown), you likely would have had to explain to a few viewers just who the hell Stojko was. From context, sure, he's a figure skater - but why would we care? He was well past relevancy at that point. If you think we're being a little hard on Stojko, well, maybe we are. Season 18 as a whole was one of the worst for guest stars who were a little past their expiry date, completely irrelevant, or simply misused. Others included pseudo-celebrity and TV personality Dr. Phil, rapper Ludacris (rappers never really fare well on The Simpsons), Ted Nugent, Metallica, Fran Drescher, Ronaldo, James Patterson (writer of the Alex Cross series who has frequently worked with ghost writers), etc.

4. The Williams Sisters

Episode: Season 12, Tennis the Menace Season 12's "Tennis the Menace" sees the Simpson family get a tennis court, and wow does it fall flat. Season 12 was the harbinger for the show's troubled teen years, and this was a particular low point. The entire episode can be summed up in a single word: "forgettable." Or perhaps we could just go with "meh." The Williams sisters, Venus and Serena, were of course at the top of the tennis world at the time, so including them fit, but it was almost as if the production staff said "well, we've done baseball to death, and our fair share of football, we even did a hockey episode, so what sport is next?" The better answer would have been basketball, but Yao Ming and LeBron James didn't make it onto the show for a couple more seasons (and were really afterthoughts). In any case, the whole thing seemed unnecessary.

3. Lady Gaga

Episode: Season 23, "Lisa Goes Gaga" The fact that Lady Gaga had an entire episode dedicated to her is absolutely mind-boggling. It's not that she's not talented; we loved her in Machete Kills. It's not that she's not relevant, either - when this episode came out, it was the height of her popularity. And we're not opposed to pop stars being on the show: Katy Perry's live action appearance was fantastic. However, it was just too much Gaga, too over the top, too garish. The only joke that really worked was the obligatory meat dress joke, and given how telegraphed and expected it was, when that's your best, it's not a good sign. In a lot of cases, guest stars on The Simpsons are underutilized. In this case, it was way too much Gaga.

2. Michael Moore

Episode: Season 15, "The President Wore Pearls" The Simpsons rarely gets political. And other than the Treehouse of Horror that sees Kang and Kodos pull an "Invasion of the Body Snatchers" on Bill Clinton and Bob Dole, and "Politically Inept with Homer Simpson," it usually falls flat when it does (though the opening of "Treehouse of Horror XIV" which sees Homer's votes for Obama continually going to McCain on a voting machine was a keeper). So with Michael Moore turning up in Season 15's "The President Wore Pearls" the show wisely tried to avoid being directly political, but really, it was still there. Moore had overstayed his welcome in the public eye by that point: his fantastic documentaries "Roger and Me" (looking at the auto industry and its impact on his hometown of Flint, Michigan), and its follow-up, "Pets or Meat," were eye-opening, and "Bowling for Columbine" crucial to the debate around the school shooting, others like it, and gun control. "Farenheight 9/11" wound up caught in a maelstrom of partisan politics in the U.S., and pretty much everything Moore did from there on out was divisive. Which would be fine in other settings, but on a show like The Simpsons, the aim should always be for funny, and Moore showing up just wasn't. It was simply "hey there's Michael Moore, he's that political documentary guy who chastised the president at an awards show, remember him?"

1. N'SYNC

Episode: Season 12, "New Kids on the Blecch" Bart and his friends form a boy band. That's an easy pitch for an episode, right? Unfortunately, it just wasn't very good. Boy bands have never been "cool" and should never be what The Simpsons' aspires to be. We all know the life of a boy band by now: they have a big hit or two, are loved by tweens, then fall apart, and one or two members, maybe, make it in solo careers. For reference, see New Kids on the Block, N'Sync, Backstreet Boys, and heck it'll probably happen to One Direction soon if it hasn't already. Boy bands are always very dated products of their time, so going back and watching this episode, you almost feel embarrassed by how bad N'SYNC's guest spot was, even though Justin Timberlake has turned out to be a pretty decent talent, able to poke fun at himself and excel at comedic roles like his spot in Bad Teacher. The entire episode was a mess, and even the homage to Mad Magazine couldn't save it. Plus it had the bizarre plotline where the Navy is behind Bart's whole boy band in order to subliminally recruit new members. Overall, terrible, and N'SYNC's atrociously trendy guest spot was its low point. Any we missed? Add them below!

Contributor
Contributor

Primarily covering the sport of MMA from Ontario, Canada, Jay Anderson has been writing for various publications covering sports, technology, and pop culture since 2001. Jay holds an Honours Bachelor of Arts degree in English from the University of Guelph, and a Certificate in Leadership Skills from Humber College.