The Single Biggest Mistake Every Doctor Who Series Has Made
What can the new season of Doctor Who learn from its predecessors?
Some Doctor Who series are more popular than others. But none of them are perfect.
Though overall episode quality is subjective, there’s always something that certain fans take issue with, from unconvincing monsters to controversial writing choices.
In most cases these misfires only affect individual stories and can be easily overlooked, but some cast much larger shadows over the series they appear in.
More often than not it’s a case of the show taking a step outside its comfort zone and paying the price, from adopting new formats to drastically changing the characterisation of the Doctor.
There are also fudged openings, where it took a little too long for things to get settled, and underwhelming finales, where ambitious storylines ultimately didn’t stick the landing.
With a new series (or season, as we're calling them these days) on the horizon, there’s never been a better time to look back at past mistakes. So what are the worst crimes committed by every series of the revived era?
13. Series 1: Misjudged Comedy
For the most part, Series 1 was a triumph. RTD knew how important this was and so threw the kitchen sink at it, and it shows.
There’s gripping drama, like the Doctor’s confrontation with the ‘Metaltron’ Dalek, or his dinner date with Margaret. There’s rich emotion – no episode is more tragic than Father’s Day, but honourable mention must go to the Doctor’s Time War trauma. And of course, there are scares. “Are you my mummy?”.
There’s also comedy – some of which lands, and some of which doesn’t.
For every genuinely funny gag (the Doctor being oblivious to the London Eye in Rose, or his “happy medium” line in The Unquiet Dead), there’s a burping bin and a farting alien.
Sure, a large part of the show’s audience is children, and younger viewers probably enjoyed these moments of goofy humour. But in hindsight they seem misjudged.
The mission statement of the 2005 revival was to prove that Doctor Who deserved to be taken seriously. Including a slapstick burp in your first episode somewhat clashes with that goal. Similarly, Aliens of London/World War Three is remembered as a silly story rather than a sharp satire, all thanks to the Slitheen’s flatulence.
Unsurprisingly, there were far fewer moments like these thereafter.
12. Series 2: Fudging The Opener
Series 2 is a strange beast. As the second series of Doctor Who’s revival but the first to feature the Tenth Doctor, it’s both a second chapter and a first chapter – a continuation and a fresh start.
Though David Tennant had already been launched on Christmas Day, it’s definitely possible for that first series to be a successful jumping-on point too (as we’re hopefully about to see with Ncuti Gatwa). However, Series 2 isn’t exactly proof-of-concept.
Despite some fan-pleasing elements (the return of Cassandra and the Face of Boe) and a fantastic location in the New New York hospital, New Earth is a lame series opener. It does nothing to really hook new viewers, or set up the rest of the series. And it feels too familiar, with the Tenth Doctor/Rose pairing having already been established (and already becoming slightly unbearable). The Doctor and Rose aren't even the Doctor and Rose for half of it, which seems like such an obvious misstep for the series premiere.
The production team weren’t even 100% sure which episode to put first, with Tooth and Claw and The Girl in the Fireplace both considered. Neither would have worked particularly well, but what we got wasn’t much better.
11. Series 3: The ‘Rebound’ Doctor
The early years of the revived series did lots to develop the Doctor as a character. Series 1 made him a war survivor. Series 2 made him a romantic hero. And Series 3 made him… a bit of an arse?
It’s understandable that the Doctor would still be reeling from the loss of Rose when his next companion came along, but the writers leant way too far into the Doctor’s ‘rebound’ characterisation, and his frosty attitude towards Martha just comes across as unnecessary.
It’s a double-edged sword, since the Doctor’s mistreatment of Martha is what allows her to come into her own. Indeed, episodes like Human Nature/The Family of Blood use her unrequited love to interesting effect.
And then you have scenes that play it for laughs, like the Doctor and Martha sharing a bed in The Shakespeare Code, or the whole “one more trip” thing in the first half of the series.
Yes, the Doctor is an alien with questionable social skills. But the idea that he could remain totally ignorant of Martha’s advances is ridiculous, stretching plausibility to the point of farce. It’s painful to watch.
10. Series 4: Underdeveloping The Doctor And Donna
Series 4 is one of the modern era’s strongest, without a doubt. The show’s popularity was at an all-time high, with one of its best-ever Doctor/companion pairings, some of its most memorable monsters, and a truly epic finale.
To be frank, it was difficult to think of a mistake the series made. So, we've settled on something that was there, but in too short supply: the Doctor and Donna.
That might seem like a strange thing to say. After all, the indomitable duo are present in all thirteen episodes. But they don’t always get lots to do together.
There are only four stories where it’s just the Doctor and Donna all the way through (Partners in Crime, The Fires of Pompeii, Planet of the Ood, and The Unicorn and the Wasp).
Every other story either features returning companions (Martha in the middle of the series, then absolutely everyone in the finale), is Doctor or companion-lite (Midnight and Turn Left), or splits the Doctor and Donna up for a prolonged period (as is the case in the second half of every two-parter).
The result was that, while they had a fun relationship, it was never really developed beyond 'mates having a laugh'. You could argue that's a positive, but it would've been nice to see a bit more nuance as well. Why can't we have our cake and eat it too?
9. Series 5: The New Paradigm Daleks
Series 5 was the freshest Doctor Who had been since 2005, with a host of updates, redesigns, and revisions. But not all of them went down well.
Fans could take a new Doctor, a new companion, a new TARDIS, a new sonic screwdriver, a new title sequence, and a new arrangement of the theme tune. But the new Daleks were a mess.
Sure, these Skaro Skittles weren’t universally hated, but they also weren’t universally loved. Fans were quick to make fun of their bulkier proportions and colour-coded liveries. When the universe’s deadliest aliens are being compared to Teletubbies, you know you’re in trouble.
So strong was the backlash that the New Paradigm Daleks were retired almost immediately. Some efforts were made to improve the props, with the bulky back section removed and a more metallic colour scheme. But it was too little too late, and the bronze design was reinstated.
No-one has dared to update the Daleks since, with models like the Reconnaissance Scout and Defence Drone presented as one-offs rather than the new status quo.
With a new era dawning, will the Daleks be redesigned again? If so, we can only hope they’re received better this time round.
8. Series 6: Weak Finale
Series 6 could have been remembered as one of Doctor Who’s best.
The first half of the series gets a lot right. There’s an incredible two-part opener, a sense of dread throughout, and some of the show’s most unsettling monsters in the form of the Silence and Gangers. It all built to a dazzling mid-series finale, with a cliffhanger that was both satisfying and yet left you chomping at the bit to see what was next.
And while Let’s Kill Hitler might not be the most convincing premiere, the series’ second half has its fair share of quality, including all-time greats like The Girl Who Waited and The God Complex.
Everything was resting on the finale… which, sadly, didn’t quite stick the landing.
There’s a nice sentiment behind The Wedding of River Song, with River’s bid to save the Doctor a metaphor for the devotion of the show’s fans. But at one part long it's way too overstuffed. And in the end, the resolution to the Doctor’s ‘death’ was very underwhelming, not least because the 'Previously On' segment heavily signposted that the Teselecta would be involved.
Just think how much the perception of Series 6 would improve if The Wedding of River Song was on par with The Pandorica Opens/The Big Bang.
7. Series 7: Ditching Two-Parters
Following the heavily serialised structure of Series 6, Steven Moffat went the other way for Series 7.
Multi-part stories were out, and standalone adventures were in. ‘Blockbuster’ was the buzzword, with the show exploring more genres than ever before. The episodes even got their own movie-style posters.
As a strategy to drum up week-to-week excitement while simultaneously silencing complaints about convoluted storylines, it seemed sound. But in hindsight, doing away with two-part stories wasn’t the best idea.
Every story now had to be crammed into a 45-minute runtime, even if they demanded longer. As a result, some episodes felt extremely rushed, with The Power of Three the most notorious example. The story of the ‘Slow Invasion’ would've been a perfect two-parter, with the moment the cubes reveal themselves serving as the cliffhanger.
The same is true of the series finales. Just imagine how much grander The Angels Take Manhattan and The Name of the Doctor would've been if they had more room to breathe.
Ditching two-part stories led to far too many mediocre and forgettable stories, and it's no surprises Series 7 is easily Matt Smith's weakest run on the show.
6. Series 8: Misjudging Capaldi’s Introduction
From Ben and Polly all the way through to Rose, every companion who has straddled two Doctors has been sceptical of the new incarnation to begin with. But they always come around eventually.
The one example where the bad feeling didn’t dissipate immediately, and instead continued well into the series, is Series 8.
The Twelfth Doctor is easily the most unlikable since the Sixth (at least, to begin with). And his rocky relationship with Clara in Series 8 is unlike anything else in the revived series, before or since.
On the one hand, the decision to go hard with this uneasy dynamic is commendable, and made for some great character drama. But looking back, making the Twelfth Doctor such a stark contrast to the Eleventh perhaps wasn’t the wisest decision. Average ratings dropping by over a million in Series 9 indicated that something about the Series 8 Doctor didn't quite click with audiences.
Add to this the fact that Matt Smith cameos at the end of his first episode (a device which neatly establishes that the Doctor is still the same person, but ultimately just makes you miss the old guy), and Capaldi’s introduction really didn't do him any favours.
5. Series 9: No Missy In The Finale
Series 9 had a different kind of story arc, with the various “hybrids” mentioned through the series an allusion to the Doctor and Clara’s toxic relationship rather than anything literal.
It’s much more abstract than usual, and has grown in appreciation in recent years.
Less forgivable is the decision to bring the Doctor and Clara’s story to a close without the person who orchestrated their friendship in the first place: Missy.
Missy wasn’t physically present at the Doctor and Clara’s beginning, with that crucial phone call taking place offscreen. But when she finally reveals herself as “the woman in the shop”, who not only put the Doctor and Clara together but kept them together, it’s clear that she has bigger plans for the pair.
The rampage that the Doctor goes on in Hell Bent is the closest thing we get to a realisation of these plans. So why is Missy not there watching, even from the sidelines? It’s especially puzzling when you consider that she was present in the series opener.
Having Missy back for the finale would've neatly bookended both Series 9 and Clara’s time in the TARDIS. She feels conspicuous by her absence.
4. Series 10: Spoiling John Simm’s Return
By the time Series 10 aired, Doctor Who had been back on our screens for over ten years. As such, the show was beginning to look to its more recent past for inspiration.
In 2015 alone, the Shadow Proclamation, the red Supreme Dalek, Julian Bleach, and Alex Kingston all returned. But the biggest surprise of all would come in 2017, when Mr Razor was revealed to be John Simm’s Master. Dun dun duuuuuuun!
Except, it wasn't a surprise at all.
At the press screening for The Pilot, a trailer was shown containing Simm, on the condition that the assembled journalists would keep quiet… which The Sun took as an invitation to leak the story almost immediately. Even if the news hadn’t been leaked, it would still have been confirmed well in advance in the 'Coming Soon' trailer attached to the end of the first episode.
With ratings dipping from Series 9, holding the reveal back until the moment itself would've been a vital injection of hype, giving the BBC a whole week before The Doctor Falls to drum up promotion.
The fact that they chose to spoil one of the show’s most shocking moments instead is baffling.
3. Series 11: Being Too Standalone
During the Moffat era, there was a perception that Doctor Who had become too complicated. Consequently, the BBC was keen to make the Thirteenth Doctor’s adventures completely standalone.
The idea was that you could watch Series 11 without any knowledge of what had come before. The same was true of the episodes themselves, with the only real throughline being the developing relationships between the fam.
Series 11 certainly achieved this, but at a cost. It went too far, and Doctor Who lost the identity it had spent 13 years creating.
Pre-existing elements don't automatically alienate new viewers if implemented correctly. It's not even like all the new, original stuff was any good – when the highlight of your series is the bloody Pting, you know you've messed up somewhere. World-building also suffered, with a weak attempt to bring things full circle with Tim Shaw, and... oh, that's it. Not to mention several awful episodes like The Ghost Monument and The Tsuranga Conundrum.
A back-to-basics approach to entice new viewers isn't a bad idea on paper, but Series 11 lacked identity and cohesion. A failed experiment that unsurprisingly was abandoned the following year.
2. Series 12: Too Much Filler
We can already hear you asking, "What about the Timeless Child?!", and while we aren't fans of it either, Series 12 would still have problems if you take it out. And frankly, we're sick of talking about it.
With more of an arc than Series 11 and some actual acknowledgement of Doctor Who history, Series 12 did a much better job of keeping fans engaged.
The decision to open the series with a two-parter, close it with a loose trilogy, and have a game-changing tentpole story slap-bang in the middle created a greater sense of momentum, and of one developing story.
These instalments account for 60% of Series 12’s episode count. Add in Can You Hear Me?, which lays groundwork for Ryan’s imminent exit, and you have seven episodes that are essential viewing.
Unfortunately, the same can’t be said of the remaining three, which are almost completely pointless.
Sure, there’s the odd reference to the ongoing arc here and there (like the Skithra Queen's “Have you ever seen a dead planet?” in Nikola Tesla’s Night of Terror), but they feel more like hangovers from Series 11, and they kill the momentum of the series.
Add to that the fact that Orphan 55 and Praxeus are true abominations, and the series would've been better off without them.
1. Series 13: Too Many Story Threads
Faced with the challenge of how to make Doctor Who during COVID, Chris Chibnall returned to his Broadchurch roots, opting for a story that was completely serialised.
Marketed as an epic six-part saga, Series 13 raised the stakes, with a universe-spanning central mystery, multiple story threads, and the show’s first proper ensemble cast in years.
But was there perhaps too much going on?
Case in point: Kate Stewart. Nice as it was to see her again in Survivors of the Flux, introducing her so late in the game (and with so many characters already on the board), meant that there wasn’t room for her to do anything in The Vanquishers. After six years away it was hugely underwhelming.
Likewise, waiting until the finale to wrap up basically every story thread wasn’t wise, and teasing revelations about the Doctor’s past then not delivering was disingenuous.
There's a point in The Vanquishers where almost every hero character (including two Doctors) is stood in the TARDIS, idly watching on as the Doctor explains the plan. It really does serve as the perfect metaphor for Flux's primary failing.