The Sopranos: 10 Greatest Ever Episodes
As The Sopranos turns 20, let's look back on the finest episodes of one of the all-time greats.
“It's good to be in something from the ground floor. I came too late for that and I know. But lately, I'm getting the feeling that I came in at the end. The best is over.” - Tony Soprano, The Sopranos pilot.
First airing way back in early 1999 (20 years ago today, in fact), many agree that The Sopranos ushered in a golden age of television, paving the way for such modern classics as Breaking Bad, Game Of Thrones, and many others. With the rise of Netflix and Amazon, legions of couch potatoes have a wider choice of quality TV than ever before, all at our grubby fingertips. We’ve never had it so good.
However, over ten years since David Chase’s epic mob drama ended, there’s a nagging feeling that the best really is over. True, we’ve had some great shows since, but for my money nothing has come close to the impact of The Sopranos. The show boasted bold storytelling, a strong cast and of course, James Gandolfini’s unforgettable performance as the complex, tormented father and mafia boss that doomed everything he touched. These are just some of the elements that place it head and shoulders above all the other pretenders to its throne.*
Cunnilingus and psychiatry brought us to this. In honour of this television behemoth, let’s count down the ten greatest episodes of The Sopranos.
*Disclaimer: for sake of argument, let’s just pretend The Wire never existed. Capiche?
10. The Test Dream
Kicking off our list is perhaps the show’s most off-kilter episode. Coming towards the end of the fifth season, The Test Dream may not have had the full-throttle spills, thrills and kills that other episodes did, yet it remains one of the show’s most memorable offerings. It begins with Tony checking in at the Plaza Hotel, where he enjoys some lavish room service and the services of a prostitute - a rather quiet evening in by his standards. He falls asleep, and we are taken on a surreal journey into the big man’s psyche through a twenty minute dream sequence.
The show had given us a window into Tony’s dreams before (as we will see later in this article), but never to this depth. It’s fair to say Tony had a lot on his plate at this point of the series - there was the breakdown of his marriage to Carmela, ongoing tensions with the New York family, and his erratic cousin Tony Blundetto becoming an ever-growing liability. These anxieties filter into his dream - at one point his teeth fall out, which according to the dream dictionary, symbolises a loss of power. The audience is used to watching Tony vocalise his problems in Dr Melfi’s office - here we are seeing how he deals with them internally, and it makes for compelling viewing.
The Test Dream perhaps comes closer than any other film or TV series in depicting the messy absurdity of dreams. The cinematography is suitably quirky, with characters talking directly to the camera and a memorable visual when, after Tony is being nagged by Carmela to get dressed, he points to a television that is showing him doing just that. Likewise the cameo of Annette Bening (complete with Tony’s goofy reaction) perfectly captures the randomness of dreams. In a lesser show this type of storytelling would feel like a gimmick - not here. Indeed, Tony’s dream foreshadows at least a couple of key events that would affect the direction The Sopranos would go (more on that later). The Test Dream is a unique achievement that lingers long in the memory.
9. All Due Respect
If The Test Dream was an experimental episode of The Sopranos, then All Due Respect is a fairly straight-forward offering by the show’s standards. It ultimately boils down to Tony having to make a crucial decision - his cousin Tony Blundetto’s foolhardy actions have led to the psychotic Phil Leotardo demanding retribution for his brother’s death. It’s up to Tony to choose between letting his beloved cousin live, or risking a bloody, unwinnable war with New York.
A major theme of the show’s fifth season was that old adage - it's lonely at the top. As the season finale, All Due Respect highlights just how isolated Tony Soprano has become. In a comical scene, his old ally Paulie complains how he “never comes round no more.” He has no choice to reconcile with Carmela because every other woman he truly wants (particularly Dr Melfi) has seen through his sh*t. When Tony finally blows his cousin’s face off, he kills the one friend that he could relate with on a human level, and didn’t just suck up to him because he was the boss.
The final scenes are fitting, with Tony fleeing from the FBI alone, like a wounded bear, through the icy forests of New Jersey. After being kicked out of his house at the beginning of the season, he ends it with his wife welcoming him back inside. He has come full circle, yet we know how much it has cost him just to get back to where he started. All Due Respect ties up an excellent run of episodes, while at the same time craftily setting the stage for the show’s apocalyptic final season.
8. College
Going way back to the show’s first season, College first aired at a time when many viewers were just beginning to recognise the mob drama’s genius. Perhaps the main hook of the show is the duality of Tony Soprano - he is a fearsome, hulking mafia boss, yet also a family man who genuinely wants the best for his children. College shows what happens when his home life and business collide, with explosive results.
Tony begins the episode in “devoted father” mode, taking his daughter Meadow on a tour of colleges in Maine. On the road, he stumbles upon Febby Petrulio, a former wise-guy who has since turned FBI informant. And so begins a balancing act between keeping his daughter happy and hunting down the rat. The juxtaposition between an innocent college tour and the brutality of Tony’s work life is striking.
The show had started strongly, but College was undoubtedly the show’s finest hour up to that point. Indeed, the simple cat-and-mouse plot allows it to work as a great standalone short film, and could potentially serve as the perfect gateway drug to series newcomers. It’s also important in that it cemented the Tony Soprano character - here’s a man that we’re simultaneously disgusted by (this episode marked his first on-screen murder) yet we can’t help but love. It was a moral dilemma every viewer faced, and would keep us glued to the show for the next eight years.
7. Sopranos Home Movies
It’s fair to say The Sopranos has its share of brutal deaths and some gruesome violence - Downton Abbey it ain’t. Yet what separates the show from its many imitators was how it captured life’s more quiet, more understated moments. The premise of Sopranos Home Movies is basically two married couples on a weekend away in upstate New York to celebrate Tony’s birthday. They eat home-cooked meals, drink wine and play board games. Imagine that in an episode of Sons of Anarchy.
Ultimately this is an episode about what it means to be a Soprano. During a drunken Monopoly game, Tony and his sister Janice take some unwelcome trips down memory lane. Janice recalls the time their father shot a bullet through their mother’s beehive hairdo. This rankles Tony, who responds in typical fashion by referring to his dear sister’s younger days performing sexual favours to men under the boardwalk. The tension escalates until Bobby, defending his wife’s honour, smacks Tony with a sucker punch and the two have an almighty brawl there and then in the living room. It's one of the best fight scenes in the show - the green Monopoly house that sticks to Tony’s face is an especially wonderful touch.
Perhaps this episode’s most influential character is none other than Livia Soprano, and she doesn’t even appear on screen. Indeed, the matriarch of the Soprano family had been dead since the third season. However, it is clear that she continues to haunt Tony, the part of his past that he can’t get away from. Like his mother, he wants to bring everyone down to his miserable level - a desire that manifests itself most extremely with his treatment of Bobby. Bobby is a good a man as exists in The Sopranos universe, which of course Tony cannot abide, and so decides to take him down a peg by ordering him to get his hands dirty and commit his first whacking. The final shot of Bobby, back from carrying out the hit, holding his daughter out to the lake is perhaps the most devastating of the entire series.
6. Funhouse
Like The Test Dream, the season two finale Funhouse also delves into Tony’s dreams, on this occasion coming amidst a severe case of food poisoning. One of the subplots of the second season centred on Tony’s growing suspicions about his long-time friend Pussy Bonpensiero. The audience knows that Big Pussy (that nickname never gets old) has been ratting his fellow wiseguys out to the FBI as an informant, but up to this point Tony had not followed it up. Until, that is, Pussy reveals the truth to Tony. In his dream. In the form of a dead fish.
Few other shows could get away with this as a key plot device. But in the world of The Sopranos, it works. Tony has clearly suspected the truth for a while, but doesn’t want to believe one of his closest buddies could be a rat, so he banishes the very idea to his subconscious while he deals with other business. Deep down however, he knows a man in his position cannot afford to shy away from the hard truths. Therefore he has to make a decision, leading to a wonderfully tense scene aboard Tony’s yacht, where Tony, Paulie and Silvio prepare to kill a man they’ve been through so much with.
Before Pussy is whacked, he manically tries to weasel out of what is coming to him, proposing outlandish situations to Tony where he could stay alive and everything all be OK. Eventually though, he accepts his fate - there’s a sad sense of inevitability about it all. As the fish imitating Pussy tells Tony in the dream sequence - “f**k of a way for it all to end”. Luckily for us, it wasn’t the end of the show, but Funhouse most certainly signalled the end of the good times for Tony and his crew. If the first two seasons represent the show’s first era, Funhouse was the moment where the series would take a darker turn, and the inevitability of death would become more and more clear.
5. The Second Coming
As the series marched towards its end, Tony became an increasingly monstrous character who would stop at nothing to stay at the top. By the time the final few episodes rolled round, perhaps the only semblance of humanity he had left was his love for his children. Yet, as The Second Coming proves, he’s far from being a model dad.
As the quintessential broody teenager, A.J. Soprano has never been the most popular character amongst fans. However, not even the most hardened A.J. hater could fail to be moved by his tragic suicide attempt. In one of the most harrowing scenes of the entire series, Tony arrives home to find his son thrashing around pathetically in the pool, a cement block dragging him down to a watery grave. The performances of both actors are staggering here, particularly James Gandolfini’s delivery of “Come on, baby” as a father desperately clutches his crying son. In the most emotional of circumstances, Tony seems to have found his heart.
However, it all feels too late. When Phil Leotardo’s crony Coco drunkenly leers at Meadow, he reacts in the only way he knows how - with extreme violence, dishing out the most brutal curb-stomp this side of American History X. Phil obviously wants to retaliate, and the war between New Jersey and Brooklyn is finally set in motion. In the W.B. Yeats poem from which the episode takes its name, the narrator describes how “things fall apart”. For Tony, things are falling apart fast, and what’s worse - he is the architect of his own downfall.
4. Whitecaps
The Sopranos featured some savage fights during the course of its run, but none were quite as hard-hitting as the domestic showdown between Tony and Carmela in the fourth season finale Whitecaps, which led to the couple’s separation that would last for most of the next season. For four years audiences had witnessed the many flaws in the Sopranos marriage - namely Tony’s continuing affairs and Carmela’s willingness to brush over her husband’s indiscretions in order to maintain her luxurious lifestyle. In Whitecaps this doomed marriage comes crashing down in spectacular fashion.
The straw that breaks the camel’s back is when Tony’s ex-goomah calls the house and informs Carmela not only about Tony’s history with her, but that he’s recently been sleeping with her cousin Svetlana. Tony returns home to find Carmela launching his things out onto the front yard, and the two have an explosive confrontation that has been coming their entire marriage. Like any lasting married couple, they know how to cut each other deep, slugging one another with some unwelcome home truths. The outstanding performances of Gandolfini and particularly Edie Falco turn this into jaw-dropping drama that no other show has really come close to.
The destruction of the Sopranos marriage is made all the more powerful by the fact that, at the beginning of the episode, we see them at their happiest. Tony has just bought Carmela a house on the Jersey Shore, and the two celebrate with a romantic dance on the beach. As much as we might want them to end up happily ever after by the end of the episode, we know this just can’t happen. And so, by the final scene, Tony walks out of his house, seemingly for good, into the night. Perhaps no episode of any show has so unflinchingly depicted the breakdown of a marriage in all its ugliness, and that’s why Whitecaps makes this list.
3. Whoever Did This
Ah, Ralphie Cifaretto. Played by the ever-brilliant Joe Pantalino, old Ralphie was perhaps the most repugnant character in the series’ entire run. Which, for a show based on some pretty terrible people , is no mean feat. In perhaps the show’s most disturbing sequence, he beat well-meaning stripper Tracee to death in a parking lot. In Whoever Did This we see a human side to this heinous man when his son is critically injured in a bow-and-arrow accident. Tony himself even imparts some genuine sympathy to a man he despises. But when a stable fire leads to the death of Tony’s beloved racehorse Pie-O-My, Ralphie is the prime suspect - and his time is up.
But really, Whoever Did This is not about Ralphie - indeed, his murder comes thirty minutes into the episode. This is about Tony making one misguided decision (killing a made man over a horse) and then having to deal with those consequences. And boy, does he deal with them - over the latter half of the episode we watch as he and a doped-up Christopher spend the day decapitating and dismembering Ralphie’s corpse. Anyone who says the show glamourised violence needs to watch this sequence - it’s as sickening and nasty as it gets.
In the final shot of the episode, an exhausted Tony staggers out from the darkness of the Bada Bing club and into the blinding sunlight, before the screen goes white and it cuts to the credits. As an audience, we feel just as drained as Tony does, and the end of the episode feels like abruptly waking up from a long nightmare. However, whereas we can turn off the television and go about our lives, Whoever Did This is a stark reminder that the nightmare Tony is living is one he can never escape from.
2. Pine Barrens
“Captain or no captain, right now we’re just two assholes lost in the woods.” - Christopher Moltisanti.
Pine Barrens is perhaps the single most famous episode of the show, and for good reason. The premise is simple - Paulie and Christopher are making a routine collection from a Russian named Valery, which goes wrong and ends up with the man in the boot of Paulie’s car. As they prepare to bury the corpse in the snowy New Jersey woodland, they discover a slight problem - the Russian isn’t dead, and flees into the forest, forcing the two mobsters to pursue him. Out of their comfort zone, the macho bravado of Christopher and Paulie soon fades into hysterical panic - and it makes for gloriously entertaining viewing.
This episode is overflowing with great dialogue and moments of throwaway humour; from Paulie educating Christopher on the Cuban Missile Crisis (“That was real? I saw that movie, I thought it was bullsh*t.”) to the image of the two men shivering in an abandoned van, desperately tearing open old ketchup packets for sustenance. There’s some wonderful moments elsewhere too, such as the reveal of Bobby sporting his full hunting gear, much to Tony’s amusement. Pine Barrens is an example of a standalone episode you can watch at any time, for no other reason that it’s a hugely entertaining hour of television.
But away from the gags and the quotable lines, there’s a more serious matter at the heart of Pine Barrens. At the mercy of Mother Nature, Paulie and Christopher discover that the concepts of rank and status they hold so dear don’t really matter when you’re lost, freezing your nuts off and pathetically gobbling on packets of ketchup. This is the hard truth that Tony himself is coming to at this point of the series - how valuable is his power really if all it brings him is misery? When it comes down to it, maybe we’re all just assholes in the woods.
1. Long Term Parking
As this article has touched on, the sad reality at the core of The Sopranos was that everyone who came into Tony Soprano’s orbit was eventually doomed, thanks to his sociopathic behaviour and mounting paranoia. Of all the characters in the show, Christopher and Adriana were the most tragic victims of this. As Christopher declares in this season five episode: “That’s the guy, Adriana. My Uncle Tony, the guy I’m going to hell for.”
Adriana had been working as a reluctant informant for the FBI since the third season, and up to this episode had been growing more anxious about being found out. When a murder goes down at her club, the Crazy Horse, the feds request that she wears a wire to help them investigate. At breaking point, she reveals to Christopher she’s a mole and begs him to run away with her. This scene isn’t an easy watch, but it’s a masterclass in both acting and writing - Christopher goes from brutal violence (almost strangling his girlfriend to death) to embracing Adriana in impassioned regret, all in the space of a few minutes. Christopher, apparently calmed down, leaves to clear his head and Adriana begins packing for their exodus. Maybe, just maybe - everything might turn out OK for this tragic couple.
Except, in the Sopranos universe, it’s never that easy. Adriana gets a call from Tony, who tells her Christopher is in hospital after a suicide attempt. Silvio picks her up, and after an unbearably tense car ride, it becomes clear that Tony’s right-hand man isn’t taking her to a hospital. They drive to the woods and thus begins arguably the most hard-hitting scene of the entire series. Sil drags a hysterical Adriana out of the car, she begs for her life, we hear the shots ring out and the camera cuts to the rustling leaves of the trees. In a rarity for the series the actual violence happens, but it remains the most shocking death of The Sopranos and the lasting image of the show’s finest hour.
Agree with this list? Which episode do you think is the best? Share your thoughts down in the comments.