The Sopranos: Every Season Ranked Worst To Best
The highs and lows of the modern mob masterpiece.
Choosing your favourite season of The Sopranos is like picking your favourite child. Each collection of episodes is magnificent and special in its own way, offering something slightly different while adding to the overarching narrative at the same time (the child analogy falls apart a bit here).
The show evolved majorly over its eight year run, and while David Chase’s vision is a clear one throughout, the scale and ambition of the show in its early days is totally different to the series we end up with for that still much-debated finale.
That’s all to say that your favourite season of The Sopranos will be influenced by your own genre tastes, whether you prefer something in the lineage of exciting gangster cinema or something with a wider scope and a heavy, occasionally oblique outlook. The show covered many genres and styles - there’s something for everyone in there.
By no means is any series of The Sopranos bad, but if pressed to make a decision, here’s how we’d rank the seven seasons (accounting for season six’s midway split), which range in quality from very, very good to genuine telly perfection.
7. Season One
Our introduction to Tony Soprano and co. is an extremely confident one. We open with our initial hook - a mobster walks into a psychiatrist’s office - and from there build on Tony’s double life as a philandering mafioso and family man (key to Tony’s character development - he’s always trying to be a good dad, something nearly every heavy drama would crib).
The major characters are set up beautifully, and from day one James Gandolfini and Edie Falco prove to be two of the finest TV actors in history. Christopher, Uncle Junior, Tony’s troublesome mom Livia - the core is established from the off.
It’s not for a while, though, that The Sopranos explores its deep bench. Paulie and Sil are there, but given minimal depth. Dr Melfi will go on to become much more interesting too. Indeed, one of the reasons The Sopranos maintains and even improves over time is Chase’s ability to delve so far into each of his characters, some of which are more archetypes at this point.
Season one is also far more of a standard gangster story. Beyond the psychiatry and family stuff, this is Tony’s rise to power. It’s thrilling stuff, particularly at the end, but the show has barely begun to flex at this point.
6. Season Three
There’s loads to like in season three, particularly surrounding Ralphie Cifaretto - a truly horrible yet often funny character (“University”, a Ralphie spotlight, is breathtaking TV) - and the increased importance of the New York mob, who’ll go on to become ever more important.
It also boasts “Pine Barrens”, a strong contender for the best episode of anything ever, and the season in general is a good showcase for Christopher, whose professional success is beset by personal problems.
Season three’s lowly position is due in large part to slightly repetitive elements. Ralphie is a great foil to Tony - but we’ve seen this before in his tangles with Junior and Richie in seasons one and two respectively. It lacks the pace of season one and the great overarching story of two.
Worse still is Meadow’s love life, which takes up far too much time. Her relationships first with Noah (an insufferable character - deliberately, but still), later with Jackie Aprile jr, are good for a few laughs but aren’t what most folks watch The Sopranos for to say the least.
5. Season Six B
The end of The Sopranos was about as momentous as TV gets, and while the ending is still a sore spot for many fans, for most, it didn’t disappoint. Wrapping up the saga of Tony Soprano was an immense job, and David Chase et al stuck the landing in a tense run of nine episodes that tied up some loose ends and left others fiendishly dangling.
Most everything in the show is wrapped up just right, with characters like Christopher, AJ, and Paulie getting endings that aren’t necessarily conclusive, but feel just right.
While The Sopranos doesn’t fold under pressure like some major shows at the final stretch, though, that sense of finality isn’t always for the best. The early stretch of the run does retread the same ground a couple of times in its attempts to hammer home just how low Tony has finally sunk, and if we’re being honest, the final clash with the New York mob wasn’t the grandstand finish we might have hoped for.
The Sopranos does everything it can to de-sensationalise the mob, and that leads to a final season that’s if not anticlimactic then certainly bleak.
4. Season Five
The Hollywood years. Sopranos S5 combines the high octane action of season one with the increased depth and maturity that comes from five years’ worth of crafting these brilliant characters. It’s a particularly streamlined season, with the focus throughout being on growing tension between NJ and NYC.
The presence of Steve Buscemi is a little jarring for some, a big name actor invading TV land, but as ever, he’s brilliant, and fits right in, his Tony Blundetto offering a bizarro-Soprano, and his season long arc a lovely tragedy.
After the emotional heft and drama of season four, there are some fanservice elements to this season, which at times seems to cater to the Sopranos fans who are in it for the gangster action rather than ruminations on modern America, but the season boasts some of the best examples of the form.
It’s also the high point for the great Drea de Matteo, who is given increasingly more screentime as Adriana, mob wife turned reluctant FBI informant. Her arc here is heartbreaking, stomach churning, totally inevitable, but some of the best acting the show ever boasted.
3. Season Six A
It should be noted up top that one particular arc in season six is among the show’s least interesting. Erstwhile side character Vito Spatafore’s homosexuality and subsequent life on the run has the makings of an interesting angle, but the sudden escalation of the character’s status and the slow pace of the story makes this something of a miss.
Aside from that, though, season six(a) is a fascinatingly inventive, often confrontational installment for the show. It starts with “Members Only”, a hall of fame episode that sees Tony get shot. From there, the season sees Tony grapple with his conscience and mortality, and attempting in his own way to become a better man.
A big theme of The Sopranos is whether people are capable of true change, and to that end season six is a dark one, seeing the likes of Christopher and Vito, along with Tony, unable to escape from themselves.
The heavy use of dream sequences and relatively slowburn intensity of this run won’t be for everyone, but it’s a testament to The Sopranos’ evolution that a season like this is just as fitting as the previous season’s gangster goodness.
2. Season Four
Season four contains a bit of everything. There’s comedy from Ralphie, who starts a ludicrously ill fated relationship with Tony’s sister Janice and continues to be a major pain. There’s an alternative romantic lead in the dashing Furio Dante, Napolitano mobster and ponytail wearer.
Adriana’s arc kicks up a notch, Uncle Junior emerges as the low key best character on the whole show, and Christopher’s heroin addiction leads to an intervention in one of the finest TV scenes ever committed to film. Really, though, this season is owned by Tony and Carmela. Gandolfini and Franco were four years in at this point, but they’d never explored their characters - more specifically, their marriage - like they do here.
Much of the feature length finale is given over to the two heavyweight actors (both winning Emmys for the episode) as years and decades of marital discontent come to the fore. It’s pure lived in drama, intense and gripping but never overplayed.
Season four sees the show step away from the Tony vs [temporary thorn in his side] structure, and ushers in the second movement of the series: Tony vs himself.
1. Season Two
For all of four’s thespian majesty and six(a)’s incredible scope, there’s little arguing with the sheer concentration and focus of season two. The primary thrust of this season: Tony’s best friend, Big Pussy, has turned FBI informant, and eventually Tony’s going to find out.
The season is bookended by two near-wordless sequences: the first, a table setting montage to “It Was A Very Good Year”, illustrating where the Soprano family and crew had ended up since last year’s coup. The last, a long held shot of waves way out to sea, the tranquil image a contrast to the violence wrought by Tony across 13 episodes.
Tony’s real evolution begins here. In season one he’s a brutish but capable and ultimately somewhat likeable mobster. Here, we see his true form: an endlessly destructive entity, incapable of causing anything but total ruination to anything that enters his orbit.
David Chase and his team would become ever more ambitious as the years passed, but season two strikes such a sweet spot, a honed, exciting, pacy plot alongside clear signs that this show was to be far, far more than another gangster drama.
How Much Do You Know About The Sopranos?