The Umbrella Academy Season 2 Review: 8 Ups & 2 Downs

A thrilling, hilarious, improved second season.

The Umbrella Academy
Netflix

Netflix's The Umbrella Academy kicked off last year with an acclaimed if slightly uneven debut season, offering up an appealingly irreverent twist on typical superhero TV, despite some pacing and storytelling issues.

It's a sure pleasure to report, then, that season two remedies most of the prior season's nagging issues, while delivering a terrifically entertaining story which sees the superhero siblings scattered across the early 1960s as they attempt to prevent a new apocalyptic threat.

Taking a potentially familiar end-of-the-world narrative and adorning it with a slew of gleefully inventive time travel shenanigans, it's sure to leave fans of the first season impressed by the uptick in both its character work and off-the-wall storytelling.

Though the second season doesn't pull an immediate 180 for those left cold by what came before, it nevertheless feels like a mostly superior follow-up which changes just enough while further emphasising everything that worked about the first year.

If you're feeling starved of quality superhero media right now, fear not because the drought is most certainly over. But first, here's what season two didn't quite get right...


Downs...

2. Not All Subplots Are Created Equal

The Umbrella Academy Vanya Ellen Page
Netflix

With the siblings being spread across 1960s Texas, it follows that the majority of them are separated into their own distinct subplots when the season kicks off.

Though most of these plots are either poignant or hilarious - or in the case of Klaus (Robert Sheehan) reinventing himself as a bohemian cult leader, both - not all of them totally hit the mark.

The notable weak links are Luther (Tom Hopper) becoming a hulking bodyguard for a certain famous figure from American history, and Vanya (Ellen Page) being rendered an amnesiac for a huge chunk of the season.

Though Vanya's uneasy romance with the unhappily married Sissy (Marin Ireland) is a welcome dose of queer representation on-screen, it too often devolves into turgid melodrama, largely as a result of that pesky, convenient amnesia plot.

The season also occasionally strains to tie all of the heroes' stories together, occasionally resulting in the overarching narrative feeling a touch contrived.

None of this is a deal-breaker by any means, but it's a shame that some of the ancillary plots weren't a little more inspired.


1. The Messy Time Travel Logic

The Umbrella Academy
Netflix

Without getting into the weeds here, you're sure to be left nursing a migraine if you actually try to keep track of every last beat of this season's dizzying time travel story.

Though the basics are easy enough to digest - the family is attempting to prevent a nuclear war linked to the assassination of John F. Kennedy - it doesn't take long for Five's (Aidan Gallagher) time-hopping plan to become messy and convoluted.

This is of course an inherent part of most time travel stories, though with little attempt made here to acknowledge how silly it all becomes, one's left to presume it's supposed to be cleverly labyrinthine rather than self-consciously ridiculous.

While this is in no way a season worth switching your brain off throughout - because it's wonderfully creative and clever for the most part - you're likely to enjoy yourself more the less you think about the time travel mechanics in any specific way.

But The Umbrella Academy season two is for the most part exactly what you'd hope for. Here's everything it gets right...


Ups...

8. It's Better Than The First Season In (Almost) Every Way

The Umbrella Academy
Netflix

There's always the worry that a second season will simply fail to recapture the charm of the first or end up feeling a tad stale, but that thankfully isn't the case at all here.

If season two perhaps lacks the immediate, unexpected wow factor of its predecessor, in almost every other respect it is a sure improvement. For starters, it's funnier, it's far more heartfelt and affecting, and the action sequences feel decidedly more stylish.

But beyond all that it addresses a number of the fundamental issues people had with season one: tonally it feels a lot more consistent despite its constant flirtation between light and dark.

The pacing is also hugely improved, as it truly feels like each of the season's ten episodes actually need to exist in order to tell this story.

Some fans may lament the general absence of season one fan favourites Hazel (Cameron Britton) and Cha-Cha (Mary J. Blige), but by and large it's clear that creator Steve Blackman has listened to his critics.


7. The INCREDIBLE Cast

The Umbrella Academy Vanya Ellen Page
Netflix

Even with its issues, season one was propped up at all times by the efforts of an incredible ensemble cast. The chemistry between the leads kept things engaging even in the show's weaker moments, and that's truer this time around.

All of the actors feel decidedly more confident in their parts this year, allowing them to deepen their respective characters and deliver more affecting, meaningful banter with their screen siblings.

There are obvious standouts - Robert Sheehan is once again magnificent as the tortured yet delightfully charming Klaus, who spends the season seeking spiritual redemption and struggling to come to terms with his prior losses.

But the show-stealer just might be, again, Aidan Gallagher, whose mind-bogglingly impressive performance as Five continues to suggest a wisdom far beyond his years - as is necessary for the character, a middle-aged man trapped in a boy's body, to work.

Yet everyone gives it their all, even Page, who despite being saddled in such an unconvincing B-plot for much of the season, imbues it with every drop of feeling possible.

Season two simply confirms how impeccably cast the ensemble truly is. Bravo.


6. It's Full Of Surprises

The Umbrella Academy Five
Netflix

The unpredictability of the central time travel narrative ensures season two is jam-packed with unexpected story twists and turns, as well as the surprise return of more than a few characters.

If the central end-of-the-world plot seems familiar, it's really just a leaping-off point for the season to explore so many other avenues for both its story and characters.

To that end, it ventures off in a number of totally left-field directions, yet crucially without ever feeling like it's trying too hard to get one over on audiences.

But just when you think you know where things are going, another spanner gets thrown in the works or another familiar face shows up totally out of nowhere.


5. Lila Is A Vital New Addition To The Cast

The Umbrella Academy Lila
Netflix

Several new cast members join the roster this year, though none more memorably than Ritu Arya as Lila, a young woman who ends up committed to an insane asylum along with Diego (David CastaƱeda) at the start of the season.

And while it's not much of a spoiler to say that romance blooms between the two, Lila is thankfully so much more than a mere replacement love interest for Diego.

Lila has a significant role in the season far beyond anything allowed to be revealed in this review, and thanks to Arya's deliciously sarcastic rendition, she quickly becomes one of the entire series' most appealing characters.

Disrupting an established ensemble with a quirky new character is always risky, but here it pays off dividends.


4. The Thrilling Action Sequences

The Umbrella Academy
Netflix

Though season one was certainly stylish from top to bottom, the overall vision for the series' aesthetic feels more consistent and confident this time around.

Beyond there being a larger number of action sequences this year, they're all shot through with a greater sense of artistry and technical wizardry.

Sweeping camerawork and tight, motivated editing combine with the sheer diversity of the fight scenes to ensure that most of them feel totally distinct from one another.

And even when the show lets loose with the nutty VFX, it avoids ever getting too cartoony or janky-looking for its own good.

There's a generally grounded quality to most of the action, inherently absurd though much of it is, which keeps it from ever ditching its profound sense of stakes.


3. The Sharp Character Development & World-Building

The Umbrella Academy
Netflix

Juggling such a sizable ensemble is never easy, and while so many shows end up slowly transforming their characters into caricatures as they progress, The Umbrella Academy's second season has actually made them even more human.

This is particularly true for Klaus, who embarks on a major "spirit quest" over the course of the season, while the spectral family member Ben (Justin H. Min) gets a majorly expanded role, and perhaps most affectingly Allison (Emmy Raver-Lampman) has to deal with living as a black woman in the deeply intolerant cesspool of 1960s America.

Rather than use its time travel gimmickry for shallow nostalgia, a clear attempt is made to engage with social issues of the era and then use it to strengthen the depictions of the central heroes.


2. All The Awesome Music

The Umbrella Academy
Netflix

Season one received considerable praise for its soundtrack, particularly the instantly viral use of Tiffany's "I Think We're Alone Now" for that dance scene, and season two follows its lead exceptionally well.

Though it's fair to say that the second season perhaps overdoes it slightly with the jukebox musical selections, they are for the most part a canny selection of pop-rock hits, used either for comedic effect or to spruce up an action sequence.

It's better not to spoil the music you'll hear this season - especially as a couple of them are massively unexpected - but know that the soundtrack only further enhances the show's deliriously entertaining style and tone.


1. The Fantastic Setup For Season 3

The Umbrella Academy
Netflix

No spoilers here, but the season ends with quite the electric, enticing hook for season three, which Netflix will presumably confirm plans for in the coming weeks, as was the case with season one.

Though it's easy to appreciate how a show like this could struggle to come up with inventive ways to keep things chugging along, season two's final scene certainly sets the stage in a mysterious and amusingly off-the-wall way.

In addition to present global circumstances likely delaying production on the third season - which may not end up releasing until early 2022 - this tantalising setup is sure to leave fans desperate for more.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.